≡ Menu

Previously:

The entire NFL had a passer rating of 99.1 in week 15, while averaging 6.91 ANY/A; in other words, the average quarterback this weekend was better than the average performance by Steve Young. So let’s focus on a couple of the rare duds.

A few weeks ago, Ben Roethlisberger was enjoying the high life as the quarterback of the 11-0 Pittsburgh Steelers. But after dropping three straight games, the situation is now ugly in Pittsburgh, and Roethlisberger is a big part of the problem. He is averaging an anemic 5.18 yards per attempt and 8.44 yards per completion over the last month of the season. On Monday Night Football, the Steelers lost to the Bengals in one of the biggest upsets in franchise history. Roethlisberger produced the worst passing performance of week 15: he threw for only 6 first downs on 38 pass attempts (plus 1 sack), making it one of the most anemic Steelers passing attacks of the last two decades.

Meanwhile, in Washington, Dwayne Haskins threw 55 times and somehow still didn’t reach 300 passing yards. It was even uglier through three quarters: he was 25 of 36, but for just 192 yards with only 10 first downs, and 2 interceptions and a sack. And then, somehow, his week got even worse.

The full week 15 passing stats, below.

RkPasserTeamOppResultAttYdTDINT1DSkYdFLAdjY/DBDBVALUE
1Ryan TannehillTENDETW 46-2527273301715016.2128193
2Justin HerbertLACLVRW 30-2732314201618014.3033165
3Josh AllenBUFDENW 48-1940359201917013.2941163
4Kyler MurrayARIPHIW 33-2636406311819113.4337152
5Baker MayfieldCLENYGW 20-6322972016111013.7033145
6Lamar JacksonBALJAXW 40-1422243311310015.1323134
7Tom BradyTAMATLW 31-27453902019325011.6348111
8Matthew StaffordDETTENL 25-4632252101400012.163291
9Matt RyanATLTAML 27-31493563021324010.655270
10Philip RiversINDHOUW 27-2028228201015011.552965
11Mitchell TrubiskyCHIMINW 33-2721202111014011.552249
12Deshaun WatsonHOUINDL 20-27413732017531110.154639
13Jalen HurtsPHIARIL 26-33443383018633010.005034
14Marcus MariotaLVRLACL 27-3028226111100010.392830
15Colt McCoyNYGCLEL 6-203122100101709.50326
16Ryan FinleyCINPITW 27-17138910621109.53153
17Sam DarnoldNYJLARW 23-2031207101121109.2733-1
18Andy DaltonDALSFOW 41-3333209201221709.2035-4
19Kirk CousinsMINCHIL 27-3335271211232208.7938-20
20Cam NewtonNWEMIAL 12-222720900832308.6030-21
21Drew BreesNORKANL 29-323423431101908.6635-23
22Gardner Minshew IIJAXBALL 14-4029226201152118.1234-41
23Tua TagovailoaMIANWEW 22-1226145011021206.3628-83
24Teddy BridgewaterCARGNBL 16-24352580083917.1338-83
25Jared GoffLARNYJL 20-233420921932006.6837-98
26Russell WilsonSEAWASW 20-15271211160005.2227-110
27Patrick MahomesKANNORW 32-2947254301642217.0451-116
28Aaron RodgersGNBCARW 24-162914310854705.2634-138
29Nick MullensSFODALL 33-4136219221221115.2138-156
30Drew LockDENBUFL 19-4832132101031714.7435-160
31Dwayne HaskinsWASSEAL 15-2055295121642605.6659-216
32Ben RoethlisbergerPITCINL 17-273817011611213.2839-235
TotalTotalTotal1095812254154107246289.311167

It was a rough week for the two leading MVP candidates. Patrick Mahomes threw 3 TDs and no interceptions and the Chiefs scored 32 points, which maybe is a sign of how high the Chiefs floor really is with Mahomes. But Kansas City punted 6 times, only the second time that’s happened in the Mahomes era, and the Chiefs averaged a poor 4.6 net yards per pass, the worst performance in any of Kansas City’s last 74 games. Meanwhile, the Packers averaged under 3 net yards per attempt, an extremely rare result for Green Bay over the last 25 years. In fact, it was only the fourth time since Rodgers became a starter that he averaged under 3 net yards per pass attempt for a game. Aaron Rodgers threw for just 8 first downs on 34 dropbacks, one of the worst performances of his career. But no matter: both the Packers and Chiefs rode to relatively easy wins.

The graph below shows the passing differential for each game in week 15.

Mahomes did not play well by his standards, but you might be surprised to see the Chiefs on the negative end of the passing differential. Especially since Drew Brees really struggled for most of the game. He was 7 of 24 for 136 yards with 1 TD, 1 INT, and 1 sack when the game was close; on his final ten passes (which didn’t have a meaningful impact the outcome of the game), he went 8/10 for 98 yards with 2 TDs, 5 first downs, and no sacks. Both quarterbacks threw 3 touchdowns and had a turnover, but Mahomes gained only 7 more yards on 16 more dropbacks. Of course, I’d say Mahomes had the better game — KC went 9/18 on third downs, while the Saints were 1/11 — but I can see why the numbers favored Brees and the Saints.

For Rodgers, his passing stats were only slightly worse than Teddy Bridgewater; of course, the biggest play in the game was a fumble at the 1-yard line by Bridgewater. Bridgewater did not have a good game, but Rodgers had a very bad game: Green Bay punted on 6 out of 10 drives despite the Packers running game having a great day.

The Dolphins are the third team on this list to win with the worse passing game, but the explanation is very simple. Miami won with 250 rushing yards, the 2nd most by any team in a non-overtime game against the Belichick Patriots.

Finally, here are the season rankings for all qualifying quarterbacks. Note that the final row (league average) includes non-qualifying passers.

RkQuarterbackTmAgeAttYdsTDIntSkYdsANY/AValue
1Patrick Mahomes *KAN255444462365221478.51190
2Aaron Rodgers *GNB374773828404181628.661120
3Ryan TannehillTEN324303482315201448.3855
4Deshaun Watson *HOU254724134276442678.02837
5Josh Allen *BUF245114000309251487.55619
6Philip RiversIND39482373522914867.43511
7Derek CarrLVR294453396247201167.41471
8Baker MayfieldCLE254063082258181017.36409
9Drew BreesNOR41332243021411797.55397
10Kirk CousinsMIN3243535692913342177.14347
11Russell Wilson *SEA3249038063713402517320
12Tom BradyTAM4354238863211191286.96315
13Dak PrescottDAL2722218569410667.72306
14Kyler Murray *ARI2349736372611221436.78199
15Matthew StaffordDET324943774239372496.74184
16Justin HerbertLAC2253137812710271716.63131
17Teddy BridgewaterCAR284413360148261656.67128
18Lamar JacksonBAL233322461218291606.5452
19Jared GoffLAR2650937182012201436.4951
20Ryan FitzpatrickMIA38254190912814656.4310
21Matt RyanATL3554740162211362276.45
22Gardner Minshew IIJAX243272259165271476.23-57
23Mitchell TrubiskyCHI262201538146161196.06-81
24Tua TagovailoaMIA22210135992161045.95-101
25Ben RoethlisbergerPIT3855934623010121096.13-149
26Nick MullensSFO2532624371212191395.79-209
27Joe BurrowCIN244042688135322315.72-297
28Andy DaltonDAL332561549116161245.06-365
29Cam NewtonNWE313282381510261525.31-385
30Alex SmithWAS36220142046191224.64-421
31Drew LockDEN2435523301413151075.18-449
32Dwayne HaskinsWAS23213128555181354.44-453
33Nick FolesCHI313111852108181454.7-557
34Daniel JonesNYG23382246289372314.74-694
35Sam DarnoldNYJ23298176769301913.94-807
36Carson WentzPHI2843726201615503263.98-1176
Lg Avg001574711374875734298264946.400

Yes, the league average ANY/A right now is 6.40.

{ 0 comments }