≡ Menu

After twelve weeks, there were still about a dozen teams jockeying for the final four spots. And with Notre Dame’s loss in Palo Alto, we no longer have to ask that pesky Oklahoma/Notre Dame question.

This year seems likely to be the perfect one for a four-team playoff, as the gap between the 4th and 5th most deserving teams — assuming results go as planned next weekend — matches the natural divide from the on-field results.

  • The SEC has one dominant team this year, Alabama. Assuming the Crimson Tide defeat Florida in the SEC Championship Game, Alabama will make the playoff. But the SEC did get a little lucky: if not for Arkansas gaining a first down on an absurd lateral, Ole Miss would have won the SEC West this year. What would the committee do with an 11-2 Mississippi team that beat Bama but lost 38-10 to Florida and by 13 points to Memphis, but won the SEC and beat the Gators in the rematch? Tough to say, but I think we’re all better off that we don’t have to ask that question this year. Assuming Alabama wins, the Tide will finish at 12-1 and very deserving of a playoff spot, while every other SEC team will have at least three losses.
  • The Big 10 had four good teams this year, but it happened to have one of them in the Big 10 West, which may as well have been in Mountain West. With 14 teams and just 8 conference games (the same as the SEC), each team plays one game against the other six teams in its division, and only two games against the teams from the other division. This is how a team like Kentucky can finish with a weak schedule despite “playing in the SEC” — the Wildcats faced Auburn and Mississippi State from the West, the weak SEC East, and a soft nonconference schedule. Iowa had a similar setup, getting Maryland and Indiana from the Big 10 East, the underwhelming Big 10 West, and a pretty easy nonconference schedule (other than Pitt). The difference: Kentucky went 5-7, while Iowa rode this schedule to 12-0. Over in the Big 10 East, Michigan, Ohio State, and Michigan State were the class of the division. They went undefeated against the rest of the East, but Michigan State swept Michigan and Ohio State, albeit in skin-of-teeth fashion: the Spartans never led in either game until the clock hit triple zeroes. Regardless, we now have a great B10 Championship Game, and the winner of Iowa/Michigan State will obviously be a very deserving playoff team. Iowa would be 13-0, and Michigan State would be 12-1 with wins over Ohio State, Michigan, Iowa, and Oregon, with the one loss coming in controversial fashion on a bad call against Nebraska.
  • The Big 12, like the Big 10, had four good teams this year. Unlike the Big 10, all four teams played each other in the conference’s round robin schedule. Oklahoma went 3-0 against Oklahoma State, Baylor, and TCU, which was enough to make up for the Sooners slip against Texas earlier in the year. The Cowboys, Bears, and Horned Frogs all finished 10-2 (assuming TCU beats Texas next weekend), making an 11-1 OU team the clear deserving choice. It doesn’t hurt that Oklahoma also had the most impressive nonconference win of the group, a 31-24 double overtime victory in Tennessee.

  • Notre Dame and BYU could have caused issues, but the two schools finished 10-2 and 9-3, respectively. Injuries hurt both squads, but made the committee’s life much easier. The Pac-12 has failed to produce a 1-loss team: Stanford appears to be the best team in the conference, but the Cardinal lost to Northwestern and to Oregon, effectively eliminating the conference from the playoff discussion unless there are a pair of upsets next weekend. The Cardinal, while very good, also won a pair of games at the final gun, beating Washington State by 2 when the Cougars missed a 43-yard field goal as time expired, and defeating Notre Dame last night by 2 on a 45-yard field goal as the clock ran out.
  • With the Pac-12 out, that leaves the ACC as the final remaining Power 5 conference. And this year, the conference managed to produce two top teams that both went undefeated in conference play. Clemson, of course, finished the regular season 12-0, while North Carolina lost to a bad South Carolina team in week 1, then won its final 11 games. UNC has no notable nonconference wins and managed to avoid both Clemson and Florida State in-conference. The Tar Heels have had an easier schedule than Iowa, so it’s tough to advocate for a 1-loss UNC team, but things will be interesting if UNC can defeat Clemson. But the best-case scenario for fans who want to avoid chaos: Alabama and Clemson cruise to victory next week. That would leave each Power 5 conference champion in the playoff, except the one conference with a 2-loss champion. It doesn’t get simpler than that.

Below are the week 13 SRS ratings. As you see, we do have one team from the ACC, SEC, B10, and B12 in the top four, but only three of those four are the expected playoff teams. Ohio State would likely be a favorite on a neutral field over Michigan State, but given the fact that the two teams have the same record, MSU had the tougher overall schedule, and the Spartans won head-to-head, there’s little argument for the Buckeyes over Michigan State or Iowa.

RkTeamConfDivConf RkGMOVSOSSRSREC
1OklahomaB12B1211220.342.662.911-1
2AlabamaSECSEC-West11218.14361.111-1
3Ohio StateB10B10-East11218.839.558.311-1
4ClemsonACCACC-Atl11216.541.257.712-0
5BaylorB12B1221118.538.256.79-2
6Notre DameIndInd11211.843.755.410-2
7Florida StACCACC-Atl21214.840.655.410-2
8North CarolinaACCACC-Coas31217.637.35511-1
9StanfordP12P12-North11212.441.65410-2
10TCUB12B1231213.74053.610-2
11MississippiSECSEC-West21212.840.653.49-3
12Michigan StB10B10-East21211.341.752.911-1
13MichiganB10B10-East31211.940.752.59-3
14Southern CalP12P12-South2128.943.1528-4
15IowaB10B10-West41213.838.25212-0
16TennesseeSECSEC-East31210.74151.78-4
17NavyAmerAmer-West11114.136.750.99-2
18West VirginiaB12B124118.342.450.77-4
19Oklahoma StB12B1251210.440.250.610-2
20LSUSECSEC-West4116.34450.38-3
21ArkansasSECSEC-West5126.243.349.57-5
22Mississippi StSECSEC-West612940.349.28-4
23HoustonAmerAmer-West21217.831.148.911-1
24UtahP12P12-South3127.740.948.69-3
25WashingtonP12P12-North4128.240.448.66-6
26MemphisAmerAmer-West31212.735.948.59-3
27WisconsinB10B10-West51211.636.948.59-3
28FloridaSECSEC-East7128.839.548.410-2
29Bowling GreenMACMAC-East11213.634.748.39-3
30OregonP12P12-North5126.740.847.59-3
31UCLAP12P12-South6126.54147.58-4
32PittsburghACCACC-Coas4124.343.147.38-4
33ToledoMACMAC-West21113.13447.29-2
34CaliforniaP12P12-North7125.14247.17-5
35Texas A&MSECSEC-West8125.640.946.58-4
36North Carolina StACCACC-Atl5128.237.8467-5
37TempleAmerAmer-East41212.633.345.910-2
38GeorgiaSECSEC-East912837.945.89-3
39LouisvilleACCACC-Atl612441.645.67-5
40Western KentuckyCUSACUSA-East11216.528.845.310-2
41NorthwesternB10B10-West6124.740.645.310-2
42South FloridaAmerAmer-East51210.334.945.18-4
43Virginia TechACCACC-Coas7123.84144.96-6
44Texas TechB12B126122.642.244.97-5
45Brigham YoungIndInd21210.134.644.79-3
46NebraskaB10B10-West7123.540.443.95-7
47Georgia SouthernSunSun11113.830.143.98-3
48Georgia TechACCACC-Coas812-0.143.243.23-9
49Miami FLACCACC-Coas9121.241.8438-4
50Penn StateB10B10-East812241437-5
51AuburnSECSEC-West1012-0.843.242.46-6
52Washington StP12P12-North8123.638.842.48-4
53Arizona StP12P12-South9120.841.642.46-6
54Boise StMWCMWC-Mntn11212.629.442.18-4
55DukeACCACC-Coas10124.436.941.37-5
56Kansas StB12B127110.640.5415-6
57Western MichiganMACMAC-West3125.135.9417-5
58Appalachian StSunSun21115.72540.79-2
59Northern IllinoisMACMAC-West4129.131.440.58-4
60San Diego StMWCMWC-West21213.426.940.39-3
61IllinoisB10B10-West912-241.539.55-7
62IndianaB10B10-East1012-1.340.739.36-6
63Iowa StB12B12812-7.146.239.13-9
64TexasB12B12911-5.344.238.94-7
65ArizonaP12P12-South10120.538.438.96-6
66CincinnatiAmerAmer-East6124.834.138.97-5
67VirginiaACCACC-Coas1112-5.844.338.54-8
68Southern MissCUSACUSA-West21215.52338.59-3
69Central MichiganMACMAC-West5124.733.538.27-5
70Air ForceMWCMWC-Mntn3129.328.8388-4
71MinnesotaB10B10-West1112-4.542.337.85-7
72East CarolinaAmerAmer-East7120.437.337.65-7
73Boston CollegeACCACC-Atl1212-1.438.737.33-9
74MarshallCUSACUSA-East31212.524.436.99-3
75MissouriSECSEC-East1112-3.239.836.65-7
76Utah StMWCMWC-Mntn4122.134.336.46-6
77SyracuseACCACC-Atl1312-5.541.836.34-8
78South CarolinaSECSEC-East1212-5.842.136.33-9
79Louisiana TechCUSACUSA-West4128.627.4368-4
80MarylandB10B10-East1212-9.845.635.93-9
81Arkansas StSunSun3118.726.935.68-3
82Wake ForestACCACC-Atl1412-7.34234.63-9
83ConnecticutAmerAmer-East812-1.435.934.46-6
84VanderbiltSECSEC-East1312-5.539.734.24-8
85Middle Tennessee StCUSACUSA-East512628.134.17-5
86Ohio U.MACMAC-East6123.629.633.38-4
87KentuckySECSEC-East1412-4.137.132.95-7
88TulsaAmerAmer-West912-2.534.532.16-6
89ColoradoP12P12-South1113-4.236.2324-9
90AkronMACMAC-East7122.828.931.87-5
91PurdueB10B10-West1312-11.142.731.62-10
92RutgersB10B10-East1412-7.738.530.84-8
93San José StMWCMWC-West512-0.530.429.95-7
94BuffaloMACMAC-East812-0.829.728.95-7
95TroySunSun411-3.232.128.93-8
96Colorado StMWCMWC-Mntn6122.126.728.87-5
97Oregon StP12P12-North1212-15.642.326.82-10
98New MexicoMWCMWC-Mntn7120.625.726.47-5
99NevadaMWCMWC-West812-1.627.826.26-6
100SMUAmerAmer-West1012-15.740.524.82-10
101UNLVMWCMWC-West912-5.830.424.53-9
102MassachusettsMACMAC-East912-8.832.623.83-9
103Florida Int'lCUSACUSA-East612-1.925.723.85-7
104Georgia StSunSun511-2.625.923.35-6
105Florida AtlanticCUSACUSA-East712-6.529.623.13-9
106Ball StMACMAC-West1012-11.534.322.83-9
107Louisiana-LafayetteSunSun611-3.525.5224-7
108ArmyIndInd311-6.528.5222-9
109TulaneAmerAmer-West1112-1435213-9
110KansasB12B121012-25.34620.70-12
111South AlabamaSunSun711-9.530.120.65-6
112Kent StMACMAC-East1112-10.931.320.33-9
113IdahoSunSun812-10.630.820.24-8
114RiceCUSACUSA-West812-6.426.219.95-7
115Miami OHMACMAC-East1212-11.831.519.63-9
116Texas St-San MarcosSunSun911-9.428.819.43-8
117Texas-San AntonioCUSACUSA-West912-9.628.6193-9
118Fresno StMWCMWC-West1012-13.632.6193-9
119WyomingMWCMWC-Mntn1112-1431.917.92-10
120New Mexico StSunSun1011-13.730.616.93-8
121Hawai`iMWCMWC-West1213-15.231.516.43-10
122Old DominionCUSACUSA-East1012-10.626.515.95-7
123Louisiana-MonroeSunSun1112-14.830.615.81-11
124UTEPCUSACUSA-West1112-1025.415.45-7
125Central FloridaAmerAmer-East1212-20.63615.40-12
126Eastern MichiganMACMAC-West1312-15.630.915.31-11
127North TexasCUSACUSA-West1212-21.533.812.31-11
128UNC-CharlotteCUSACUSA-East1312-15.32711.62-10

This week, Oklahoma and Ohio State recorded two of the five biggest wins of the year. As always, you can view the single-game SRS ratings at this page. Below are the SRS ratings from week 13.

DateTm_ConfPFOppPAH/RW/LDiffMOVOpp_ConfSOSSRS
11-28-2015Oklahoma_B1258Oklahoma St23RoadWin3531B1250.681.6
11-28-2015Ohio State_B1042Michigan13RoadWin2928B1052.580.5
11-28-2015Florida St_ACC27Florida2RoadWin2526SEC48.474.4
11-28-2015Michigan St_B1055Penn State16HomeWin3930B104373
11-27-2015Washington_P1245Washington St10HomeWin3528P1242.470.4
11-27-2015Houston_Amer52Navy31HomeWin2118Amer50.968.9
11-28-2015Memphis_Amer63SMU0HomeWin6342Amer24.866.8
11-28-2015Southern Miss_CUSA58Louisiana Tech24RoadWin3430.5CUSA3666.5
11-27-2015TCU_B1228Baylor21HomeWin77B1256.763.7
11-28-2015Southern Cal_P1240UCLA21HomeWin1916P1247.563.5
11-28-2015Mississippi_SEC38Mississippi St27RoadWin1114SEC49.263.2
11-28-2015Alabama_SEC29Auburn13RoadWin1619SEC42.461.4
11-28-2015Brigham Young_Ind51Utah St28RoadWin2325MWC36.461.4
11-28-2015West Virginia_B1230Iowa St6HomeWin2421B1239.160.1
11-28-2015North Carolina_ACC45North Carolina St34RoadWin1114ACC4660
11-27-2015Arkansas_SEC28Missouri3HomeWin2522SEC36.658.6
11-28-2015Tennessee_SEC53Vanderbilt28HomeWin2522SEC34.256.2
11-28-2015LSU_SEC19Texas A&M7HomeWin129SEC46.555.5
11-28-2015Temple_Amer27Connecticut3HomeWin2421Amer34.455.4
11-28-2015Stanford_P1238Notre Dame36HomeWin20Ind55.455.4
11-27-2015Miami FL_ACC29Pittsburgh24RoadWin58ACC47.355.3
11-24-2015Bowling Green_MAC48Ball St10RoadWin3832.5MAC22.855.3
11-27-2015Western Michigan_MAC35Toledo30RoadWin58MAC47.255.2
11-27-2015Iowa_B1028Nebraska20RoadWin811B1043.954.9
11-27-2015Western Kentucky_CUSA49Marshall28HomeWin2118CUSA36.954.9
11-28-2015Notre Dame_Ind36Stanford38RoadLoss-20P125454
11-28-2015Indiana_B1054Purdue36RoadWin1821B1031.652.6
11-28-2015Georgia_SEC13Georgia Tech7RoadWin69ACC43.252.2
11-28-2015Wisconsin_B1031Minnesota21RoadWin1013B1037.850.8
11-28-2015Georgia Southern_Sun55South Alabama17HomeWin3829.5Sun20.650.1
11-28-2015Middle Tennessee St_CUSA42Texas-San Antonio7RoadWin3531CUSA1950
11-27-2015Boise St_MWC40San José St23RoadWin1720MWC29.949.9
11-28-2015Louisville_ACC38Kentucky24RoadWin1417SEC32.949.9
11-28-2015South Carolina_SEC32Clemson37HomeLoss-5-8ACC57.749.7
11-28-2015Kansas St_B1245Kansas14RoadWin3129B1220.749.7
11-28-2015Northwestern_B1024Illinois14NeutWin1010B1039.549.5
11-26-2015South Florida_Amer44Central Florida3RoadWin4134Amer15.449.4
11-24-2015Ohio U._MAC26Northern Illinois21RoadWin58MAC40.548.5
11-28-2015Arizona St_P1246California48RoadLoss-20P1247.147.1
11-28-2015New Mexico_MWC47Air Force35HomeWin129MWC3847
11-27-2015Baylor_B1221TCU28RoadLoss-7-7B1253.646.6
11-26-2015Texas Tech_B1248Texas45RoadWin37B1238.945.9
11-28-2015Virginia Tech_ACC23Virginia20RoadWin37ACC38.545.5
11-28-2015Cincinnati_Amer19East Carolina16RoadWin37Amer37.644.6
11-28-2015Clemson_ACC37South Carolina32RoadWin58SEC36.344.3
11-28-2015Duke_ACC27Wake Forest21RoadWin69ACC34.643.6
11-28-2015Arkansas St_Sun52New Mexico St28RoadWin2425.5Sun16.942.4
11-28-2015California_P1248Arizona St46HomeWin20P1242.342.3
11-28-2015Auburn_SEC13Alabama29HomeLoss-16-19SEC61.142.1
11-28-2015Colorado_P1214Utah20RoadLoss-6-7P1248.641.6
11-28-2015Texas A&M_SEC7LSU19RoadLoss-12-9SEC50.341.3
11-27-2015Nebraska_B1020Iowa28HomeLoss-8-11B105241
11-28-2015North Carolina St_ACC34North Carolina45HomeLoss-11-14ACC5541
11-27-2015Oregon St_P1242Oregon52RoadLoss-10-7P1247.540.5
11-28-2015San Diego St_MWC31Nevada14HomeWin1714MWC26.240.2
11-28-2015Appalachian St_Sun28Louisiana-Lafayette7HomeWin2118Sun2240
11-28-2015Mississippi St_SEC27Mississippi38HomeLoss-11-14SEC53.439.4
11-28-2015Utah_P1220Colorado14HomeWin67P123239
11-28-2015Maryland_B1046Rutgers41RoadWin58B1030.838.8
11-28-2015Virginia_ACC20Virginia Tech23HomeLoss-3-7ACC44.937.9
11-26-2015Texas_B1245Texas Tech48HomeLoss-3-7B1244.937.9
11-28-2015Syracuse_ACC20Boston College17HomeWin30ACC37.337.3
11-27-2015Akron_MAC20Kent St0HomeWin2017MAC20.337.3
11-27-2015Massachusetts_MAC31Buffalo26RoadWin58MAC28.936.9
11-28-2015Georgia Tech_ACC7Georgia13HomeLoss-6-9SEC45.836.8
11-28-2015Boston College_ACC17Syracuse20RoadLoss-30ACC36.336.3
11-28-2015UCLA_P1221Southern Cal40RoadLoss-19-16P125236
11-27-2015Georgia St_Sun31Troy21HomeWin107Sun28.935.9
11-28-2015Minnesota_B1021Wisconsin31HomeLoss-10-13B1048.535.5
11-28-2015Illinois_B1014Northwestern24NeutLoss-10-10B1045.335.3
11-27-2015Pittsburgh_ACC24Miami FL29HomeLoss-5-8ACC4335
11-27-2015Tulsa_Amer45Tulane34RoadWin1114Amer2135
11-27-2015Oregon_P1252Oregon St42HomeWin107P1226.833.8
11-27-2015Toledo_MAC30Western Michigan35HomeLoss-5-8MAC4133
11-28-2015Wake Forest_ACC21Duke27HomeLoss-6-9ACC41.332.3
11-28-2015Oklahoma St_B1223Oklahoma58HomeLoss-35-31B1262.931.9
11-28-2015East Carolina_Amer16Cincinnati19HomeLoss-3-7Amer38.931.9
11-28-2015Wyoming_MWC35UNLV28HomeWin77MWC24.531.5
11-27-2015Eastern Michigan_MAC28Central Michigan35RoadLoss-7-7MAC38.231.2
11-27-2015Navy_Amer31Houston52RoadLoss-21-18Amer48.930.9
11-28-2015Michigan_B1013Ohio State42HomeLoss-29-28B1058.330.3
11-28-2015Vanderbilt_SEC28Tennessee53RoadLoss-25-22SEC51.729.7
11-28-2015Iowa St_B126West Virginia30RoadLoss-24-21B1250.729.7
11-28-2015Florida_SEC2Florida St27HomeLoss-25-26ACC55.429.4
11-28-2015Rice_CUSA27UNC-Charlotte7HomeWin2017CUSA11.628.6
11-28-2015Kentucky_SEC24Louisville38HomeLoss-14-17ACC45.628.6
11-28-2015Rutgers_B1041Maryland46HomeLoss-5-8B1035.927.9
11-27-2015Missouri_SEC3Arkansas28RoadLoss-25-22SEC49.527.5
11-27-2015Marshall_CUSA28Western Kentucky49RoadLoss-21-18CUSA45.327.3
11-28-2015Idaho_Sun38Texas St-San Marcos31HomeWin77Sun19.426.4
11-28-2015Nevada_MWC14San Diego St31RoadLoss-17-14MWC40.326.3
11-28-2015Colorado St_MWC34Fresno St31RoadWin37MWC1926
11-24-2015Northern Illinois_MAC21Ohio U.26HomeLoss-5-8MAC33.325.3
11-28-2015Connecticut_Amer3Temple27RoadLoss-24-21Amer45.924.9
11-28-2015Penn State_B1016Michigan St55RoadLoss-39-30B1052.922.9
11-28-2015Florida Atlantic_CUSA33Old Dominion31RoadWin27CUSA15.922.9
11-28-2015Louisiana-Lafayette_Sun7Appalachian St28RoadLoss-21-18Sun40.722.7
11-27-2015Central Michigan_MAC35Eastern Michigan28HomeWin77MAC15.322.3
11-27-2015San José St_MWC23Boise St40HomeLoss-17-20MWC42.122.1
11-28-2015Fresno St_MWC31Colorado St34HomeLoss-3-7MWC28.821.8
11-27-2015Washington St_P1210Washington45RoadLoss-35-28P1248.620.6
11-28-2015Utah St_MWC28Brigham Young51HomeLoss-23-25Ind44.719.7
11-28-2015UTEP_CUSA20North Texas17RoadWin37CUSA12.319.3
11-28-2015Purdue_B1036Indiana54HomeLoss-18-21B1039.318.3
11-27-2015Tulane_Amer34Tulsa45HomeLoss-11-14Amer32.118.1
11-28-2015Air Force_MWC35New Mexico47RoadLoss-12-9MWC26.417.4
11-28-2015Louisiana-Monroe_Sun26Hawai`i28RoadLoss-20MWC16.416.4
11-27-2015Troy_Sun21Georgia St31RoadLoss-10-7Sun23.316.3
11-28-2015Old Dominion_CUSA31Florida Atlantic33HomeLoss-2-7CUSA23.116.1
11-27-2015Buffalo_MAC26Massachusetts31HomeLoss-5-8MAC23.815.8
11-24-2015Ball St_MAC10Bowling Green48HomeLoss-38-32.5MAC48.315.8
11-28-2015Hawai`i_MWC28Louisiana-Monroe26HomeWin20Sun15.815.8
11-27-2015Kent St_MAC0Akron20RoadLoss-20-17MAC31.814.8
11-28-2015South Alabama_Sun17Georgia Southern55RoadLoss-38-29.5Sun43.914.4
11-28-2015Texas St-San Marcos_Sun31Idaho38RoadLoss-7-7Sun20.213.2
11-28-2015Kansas_B1214Kansas St45HomeLoss-31-29B124112
11-26-2015Central Florida_Amer3South Florida44HomeLoss-41-34Amer45.111.1
11-28-2015UNLV_MWC28Wyoming35RoadLoss-7-7MWC17.910.9
11-28-2015New Mexico St_Sun28Arkansas St52HomeLoss-24-25.5Sun35.610.1
11-28-2015North Texas_CUSA17UTEP20HomeLoss-3-7CUSA15.48.4
11-28-2015Louisiana Tech_CUSA24Southern Miss58HomeLoss-34-30.5CUSA38.58
11-28-2015SMU_Amer0Memphis63RoadLoss-63-42Amer48.56.5
11-28-2015Texas-San Antonio_CUSA7Middle Tennessee St42HomeLoss-35-31CUSA34.13.1
11-28-2015UNC-Charlotte_CUSA7Rice27RoadLoss-20-17CUSA19.92.9

As always, please leave your thoughts and questions in the comments.

{ 13 comments }