Much has been made of Martin’s inability to handle that role. Leading up to the 2012 draft, much was made of how Martin only projected as a right tackle in the pros, even though (or perhaps because of what evaluators saw when) Martin played on the left side at Stanford with Andrew Luck. Miami played Martin on the right side of the line for the first eleven games of the season last year, but switched him to the blind side after Long suffered a season-ending injury. Pro Football Focus graded Martin as a terrible pass blocker in his rookie season, and he was even worse in the five starts he made at left tackle: In those games, he allowed an incredible 17 hurries, two hits, and two sacks.
I thought it might be interesting to run some tests on left tackles, building off a study that Jason Lisk ran on offensive linemen:
To do this, I looked at all offensive linemen since 1978 who made at least 1 pro bowl and started 80 or more games in their careers, and then found any season in which that player played in fewer than 10 games before age 34, after starting more than that amount the previous year at the same position. I then compared the team performance in things like points, yards per attempt, sack rate, and rushing yards per carry. As it turns out, we don’t have very many cases that allow us to look at this (19 players). If I had reliable game by game data for offensive linemen participation, I could broaden the study, but for now, I can’t tell which games a lineman missed, like I can with a quarterback or running back. My goal in setting this up the way I did was to find pretty good tackles and try to see if there were any differences the following year when they missed a large chunk of the season.
Our 19 offensive tackles averaged 15.1 games the year before the injury, and only 6.3 games played during the injury season. That’s a difference of 8.8 games played, or over half a season.
In his conclusion, Lisk noted that “The likely effect on a per game basis when playing versus when out with an injury was somewhere between 0.7 to 0.8 Net Yards per Attempt dropoff.” Well, what if we run the same study but (1) limit ourselves to left tackles1 and (2) look at the yards-per-reception average of the team’s leading receiver? There are only 12 situations to examine, a sample size far too small to really use, but here are the results:
Yr N St
Yr N+1 St
|Bryant McKinnie||2011||BAL||16||0||Anquan Boldin||15.6||63.4||14.2||61.4|
|Orlando Pace||2005||STL||16||8||Torry Holt||13||95.1||12.8||74.3|
|Flozell Adams||2004||DAL||16||6||Keyshawn Johnson||14||61.3||11.8||52.4|
|Matt Light||2004||NWE||16||3||David Givens||15.6||58.3||12.5||56.8|
|Wade Smith||2003||MIA||16||2||Chris Chambers||15||60.2||13||59.9|
|Bob Whitfield||2002||ATL||16||8||Brian Finneran||15||52.4||14.2||30.7|
|Tony Boselli||2000||JAX||16||3||Jimmy Smith||13.3||80.9||12.3||85.8|
|Willie Roaf||2000||NOR||16||7||Joe Horn||14.3||83.8||15.2||79.1|
|Bruce Armstrong||1991||NWE||16||8||Irving Fryar||14.9||63.4||14.4||52.7|
|Steve Wallace||1988||SFO||16||1||Jerry Rice||20.4||81.6||18.1||92.7|
|Bruce Matthews||1986||HOU||16||5||Drew Hill||17.1||69.5||20.2||82.4|
|Doug France||1980||RAM||16||1||Billy Waddy||17.6||44.7||14.8||30.7|
We see an average drop of 1.0 YPR, but even that doesn’t tell us much. If you use Torrey Smith instead of Boldin on the Ravens — a more appropriate comparison — the difference would be even smaller. With Bryant McKinnie around, Smith averaged 16.8 YPR in 2011; with Michael Oher protecting the blind side, Smith averaged 17.4 YPR last year. I recognize that this study has a lot of drawbacks, chief among them being the sample size. Perhaps when we have more time (can you believe we need it to be next offseason already?), we can investigate further. But at first blush, this doesn’t look significant, and this is when going from a Pro Bowl-caliber left tackle to a backup. Say what you will about Martin, but he’s a high-pedigree player who the team handpicked as its starting left tackle.
But I’m not sure we need to study decades of football history to analyze this situation. Perhaps we just need to review Wallace’s career. In 2009, Mike Wallace led the NFL in yards per reception as a rookie, with Max Starks as his left tackle. Pro Football Focus ranked Starks as a good pass blocker that year (and RT Willie Colon as an excellent one), although neither has a reputation as an elite player. In 2010, Wallace had his first 1,000-yard season and averaged an absurd 21.0 yards per catch. Pittsburgh had Jonathan Scott and Starks take the majority of snaps at left tackle, and both graded out as negative players. In fact, PFF ranked every member of the Steelers offensive line as below-average in pass blocking that season other than Ramon Foster, who was graded as just barely above-average. In 2011, Starks was back protecting the blind side, but Wallace actually saw his receiving yards and yards per catch decline that year.
That’s just one example, and we know Ben Roethlisberger (who is getting a lot of play on the blog this week!) played a big part in keeping plays alive for Wallace. But after a rough start to training camp, Jonathan Martin is now getting praise from the South Florida beat writers. Martin doesn’t need to be a Pro Bowl left tackle for the Dolphins to get the most out of Wallace. We’ve seen Wallace in Pittsburgh, Smith in Baltimore, and Jordy Nelson (with Marshall Newhouse at LT in 2011) post big YPR years without great play at left tackle. If the former Steeler doesn’t have a big season in Miami this year, the blame likely falls on the shoulders of Wallace and Ryan Tannehill before you get to play the blame game with Martin.
Previous “Random Perspective On” Articles:
AFC East: Buffalo Bills, Miami Dolphins, New England Patriots, New York Jets
AFC North: Baltimore Ravens, Cincinnati Bengals, Cleveland Browns, Pittsburgh Steelers
AFC South: Houston Texans, Indianapolis Colts, Jacksonville Jaguars, Tennessee Titans
AFC West: Denver Broncos, Kansas City Chiefs, Oakland Raiders, San Diego Chargers
NFC East: Dallas Cowboys, New York Giants, Philadelphia Eagles, Washington Redskins
NFC North: Chicago Bears, Detroit Lions, Green Bay Packers, Minnesota Vikings
NFC South: Atlanta Falcons, Carolina Panthers, New Orleans Saints, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
NFC West: Arizona Cardinals, San Francisco 49ers, Seattle Seahawks, St. Louis Rams
- I changed the cutoffs to 14 starts in Year N and fewer than 9 starts in Year N+1 [↩]