≡ Menu

Bryan Frye, owner and operator of the great site http://www.thegridfe.com, is back for another guest post. You can also view all of Bryan’s guest posts at Football Perspective at this link, and follow him on twitter @LaverneusDingle.


On Monday, I looked at which quarterbacks since 1960 helped or hurt their teams the most by taking or avoiding sacks. On Tuesday, I looked at the quarterbacks who gained the most or fewest yards through the air per attempt or dropback. And yesterday, we looked at completions relative to league average.

Today’s article, “Mile High Club or: Scoring through the Air,” is an examination of how often quarterbacks threw touchdowns.1

I have used the same methodology as before (similar to Chase’s model for Relative Adjusted Net Yards), and I have maintained the same minimum attempt cutoffs. That means we’ll only look at seasons with 224 or more attempts and careers with 1,000 or more attempts. Like before, I didn’t prorate for shorter seasons.2

Single Season Stats

The following table contains the 1,563 qualifying passing seasons and is sorted by marginal touchdowns. Read it thus: In 2004, Peyton Manning turned 497 passes into 49 touchdowns, a rate of 9.86%. The rest of the league threw touchdowns at a 4.27% rate, so Manning had a 5.59% marginal touchdown rate. This results in 28 marginal touchdown throws.3

RkQuarterbackYearTmAttTDTD%LMP TD%Marg TD%Marg TD
1Peyton Manning2004IND497499.86%4.27%5.59%28
2Peyton Manning2013DEN659558.35%4.26%4.08%27
3Tom Brady2007NWE578508.65%4.04%4.61%27
4Dan Marino1984MIA564488.51%4.06%4.45%25
5Aaron Rodgers2011GNB502458.96%4.12%4.84%24
6Kurt Warner1999STL499418.22%3.81%4.4%22
7George Blanda1961HOU362369.94%4.39%5.56%20
8Dan Marino1986MIA623447.06%3.86%3.2%20
9Drew Brees2011NOR657467%4.15%2.85%19
10Brett Favre1996GNB543397.18%3.79%3.4%18
11Steve Young1994SFO461357.59%3.73%3.86%18
12Y.A. Tittle1963NYG367369.81%5.2%4.61%17
13Randall Cunningham1998MIN425348%4.11%3.89%17
14Jim Kelly1991BUF474336.96%3.5%3.46%16
15Aaron Rodgers2012GNB552397.07%4.15%2.92%16
16Brett Favre1995GNB570386.67%3.86%2.8%16
17Philip Rivers2008SDG478347.11%3.77%3.34%16
18Brett Favre1997GNB513356.82%3.79%3.03%16
19Daryle Lamonica1969OAK426347.98%4.34%3.64%16
20Ben Roethlisberger2007PIT404327.92%4.11%3.81%15
21Kurt Warner2001STL546366.59%3.78%2.81%15
22Ken Stabler1976OAK291279.28%4.02%5.26%15
23Daunte Culpepper2004MIN548397.12%4.34%2.77%15
24Frankie Albert1949SFO2602710.38%4.55%5.84%15
25Drew Brees2012NOR670436.42%4.15%2.27%15
26Daunte Culpepper2000MIN474336.96%3.79%3.18%15
27Aaron Rodgers2014GNB520387.31%4.42%2.89%15
28Tom Brady2010NWE492367.32%4.27%3.05%15
29Tony Romo2014DAL435347.82%4.42%3.4%15
30Steve Young1998SFO517366.96%4.12%2.85%15
31Frankie Albert1948SFO2642910.98%5.43%5.56%15
32Tony Romo2007DAL520366.92%4.11%2.81%15
33Len Dawson1962DTX310299.35%4.65%4.7%15
34Ken Stabler1974OAK310268.39%3.72%4.67%14
35Johnny Unitas1959BAL367328.72%4.89%3.83%14
36Steve Beuerlein1999CAR571366.3%3.86%2.44%14
37Terry Bradshaw1978PIT368287.61%3.85%3.76%14
38Brett Favre2003GNB471326.79%3.86%2.93%14
39Len Dawson1964KAN354308.47%4.68%3.8%13
40Tom Brady2011NWE611396.38%4.19%2.2%13
41Joe Montana1987SFO398317.79%4.41%3.37%13
42Matthew Stafford2011DET663416.18%4.19%2%13
43Nick Foles2013PHI317278.52%4.34%4.18%13
44Mark Rypien1991WAS421286.65%3.53%3.12%13
45Drew Brees2009NOR514346.61%4.06%2.56%13
46Boomer Esiason1988CIN388287.22%3.83%3.38%13
47Steve Young1993SFO462296.28%3.48%2.8%13
48Jeff Garcia2001SFO504326.35%3.8%2.55%13
49Len Dawson1966KAN284269.15%4.65%4.51%13
50Y.A. Tittle1962NYG375338.8%5.4%3.4%13
51Andrew Luck2014IND616406.49%4.43%2.06%13
52Peyton Manning2012DEN583376.35%4.17%2.18%13
53Brett Favre2001GNB510326.27%3.8%2.47%13
54Carson Palmer2005CIN509326.29%3.81%2.47%13
55Vince Ferragamo1980RAM404307.43%4.32%3.11%13
56Peyton Manning2014DEN597396.53%4.43%2.1%13
57Frank Ryan1966CLE382297.59%4.39%3.2%12
58Adrian Burk1954PHI231239.96%4.73%5.23%12
59Dave Krieg1984SEA480326.67%4.15%2.52%12
60Vinny Testaverde1996BAL549336.01%3.83%2.18%12
61Joe Ferguson1975BUF321257.79%4.18%3.61%12
62Vinny Testaverde1998NYJ421296.89%4.14%2.75%12
63Cecil Isbell1942GNB268248.96%4.65%4.3%12
64Chris Chandler1998ATL327257.65%4.14%3.51%11
65Frank Ryan1963CLE256259.77%5.3%4.46%11
66Brett Favre2009MIN531336.21%4.07%2.14%11
67Chris Miller1991ATL413266.3%3.54%2.76%11
68John Hadl1973RAM258228.53%4.16%4.37%11
69Lynn Dickey1983GNB484326.61%4.28%2.33%11
70Peyton Manning2000IND571335.78%3.81%1.97%11
71Jim Everett1988RAM517316%3.85%2.15%11
72Roger Staubach1973DAL286238.04%4.16%3.88%11
73Brett Favre1994GNB582335.67%3.78%1.89%11
74Steve Bartkowski1980ATL463316.7%4.33%2.37%11
75Steve Grogan1979NWE423286.62%4.05%2.57%11
76Fran Tarkenton1967NYG377297.69%4.82%2.88%11
77Sonny Jurgensen1961PHI416327.69%5.09%2.6%11
78Randall Cunningham1990PHI465306.45%4.13%2.32%11
79Drew Brees2013NOR650396%4.35%1.65%11
80Joe Montana1989SFO386266.74%3.97%2.77%11
81Peyton Manning2005IND453286.18%3.82%2.36%11
82Donovan McNabb2004PHI469316.61%4.37%2.24%10
83Daryle Lamonica1967OAK425307.06%4.6%2.46%10
84Bob Griese1977MIA307227.17%3.79%3.38%10
85Earl Morrall1968BAL317268.2%4.93%3.27%10
86Jeff George1999MIN329236.99%3.88%3.11%10
87Tommy Thompson1948PHI2462510.16%6.07%4.1%10
88Bert Jones1976BAL343247%4.07%2.93%10
89Bobby Layne1951DET332267.83%4.82%3.02%10
90Joe Montana1984SFO432286.48%4.17%2.32%10
91Dave Krieg1987SEA294237.82%4.44%3.38%10
92Rich Gannon2000OAK473285.92%3.82%2.1%10
93Boomer Esiason1989CIN455286.15%3.97%2.18%10
94Steve Young1992SFO402256.22%3.76%2.46%10
95Norm Van Brocklin1960PHI284248.45%5%3.45%10
96Drew Brees2008NOR635345.35%3.81%1.54%10
97Peyton Manning2009IND571335.78%4.08%1.7%10
98Jim Kelly1990BUF346246.94%4.14%2.79%10
99Peyton Manning2007IND515316.02%4.14%1.88%10
100Dan Fouts1985SDG430276.28%4.04%2.24%10
101Johnny Unitas1957BAL301247.97%4.78%3.2%10
102Boomer Esiason1985CIN431276.26%4.04%2.23%10
103Ken Anderson1981CIN479296.05%4.05%2%10
104Jeff Garcia2000SFO561315.53%3.82%1.71%10
105Russell Wilson2012SEA393266.62%4.18%2.43%10
106Tom Flores1966OAK306247.84%4.73%3.11%10
107Drew Brees2004SDG400276.75%4.38%2.37%9
108Jim Kelly1989BUF391256.39%3.97%2.42%9
109Peyton Manning2006IND557315.57%3.87%1.69%9
110Tommy Kramer1986MIN372246.45%3.93%2.52%9
111Warren Moon1995MIN606335.45%3.9%1.54%9
112Joe Theismann1983WAS459296.32%4.3%2.02%9
113Scott Mitchell1995DET583325.49%3.9%1.58%9
114Billy Kilmer1972WAS225198.44%4.35%4.09%9
115Y.A. Tittle1953SFO259207.72%4.17%3.55%9
116Dave Krieg1988SEA228187.89%3.86%4.03%9
117Dan Fouts1978SDG381246.3%3.89%2.41%9
118Billy Wade1961CHI250228.8%5.12%3.68%9
119Danny White1980DAL436286.42%4.34%2.08%9
120Jeff George1997OAK521295.57%3.83%1.73%9
121Tony Romo2011DAL522315.94%4.21%1.73%9
122Roger Staubach1978DAL413256.05%3.89%2.17%9
123Bobby Hebert1993ATL430245.58%3.5%2.08%9
124John Brodie1965SFO391307.67%5.41%2.26%9
125Tony Romo2008DAL450265.78%3.82%1.96%9
126Ken Stabler1977OAK294206.8%3.8%3%9
127Sonny Jurgensen1970WAS337236.82%4.22%2.61%9
128Warren Moon1990HOU584335.65%4.15%1.5%9
129Neil Lomax1983STL354246.78%4.3%2.48%9
130Don Meredith1966DAL344246.98%4.45%2.52%9
131Erik Kramer1995CHI522295.56%3.91%1.65%9
132Sonny Jurgensen1966WAS436286.42%4.45%1.97%9
133Frank Ryan1964CLE334257.49%4.93%2.56%9
134Billy Kilmer1975WAS346236.65%4.21%2.44%8
135Bob Griese1971MIA263197.22%4.02%3.21%8
136Milt Plum1960CLE250218.4%5.03%3.37%8
137Otto Graham1947CLE269259.29%6.17%3.13%8
138Steve McNair2003TEN400246%3.9%2.1%8
139Jim Everett1989RAM518295.6%3.98%1.62%8
140Steve Bartkowski1981ATL533305.63%4.06%1.57%8
141Kurt Warner2007ARI451275.99%4.15%1.84%8
142Dan Fouts1981SDG609335.42%4.06%1.36%8
143Bobby Thomason1953PHI304216.91%4.19%2.72%8
144Lynn Dickey1984GNB401256.23%4.18%2.06%8
145Philip Rivers2013SDG544325.88%4.37%1.51%8
146Roger Staubach1979DAL461275.86%4.07%1.78%8
147Russell Wilson2013SEA407266.39%4.37%2.02%8
148Babe Parilli1964BOS473316.55%4.82%1.74%8
149John Hadl1970SDG327226.73%4.23%2.5%8
150Philip Rivers2009SDG486285.76%4.09%1.67%8
151Len Dawson1965KAN305216.89%4.24%2.65%8
152Brett Favre1998GNB551315.63%4.16%1.47%8
153John Elway1996DEN466265.58%3.85%1.73%8
154John Brodie1970SFO378246.35%4.23%2.12%8
155Drew Bledsoe1997NWE522285.36%3.84%1.52%8
156Norm Snead1967PHI434296.68%4.86%1.82%8
157Aaron Rodgers2009GNB541305.55%4.09%1.45%8
158Len Dawson1963KAN352267.39%5.17%2.22%8
159Carson Palmer2006CIN520285.38%3.88%1.5%8
160Eli Manning2010NYG539315.75%4.31%1.44%8
161John Elway1997DEN502275.38%3.84%1.54%8
162Kurt Warner2000STL347216.05%3.83%2.22%8
163Johnny Unitas1965BAL282238.16%5.43%2.72%8
164Terry Bradshaw1982PIT240177.08%3.89%3.19%8
165John Hadl1968SDG440276.14%4.4%1.73%8
166Tony Romo2013DAL535315.79%4.37%1.42%8
167Matt Cassel2010KAN450276%4.31%1.69%8
168Johnny Lujack1949CHI312237.37%4.94%2.43%8
169Trent Green2002KAN470265.53%3.92%1.61%8
170Dave Krieg1983SEA243187.41%4.31%3.1%8
171Aaron Rodgers2010GNB475285.89%4.31%1.58%8
172Aaron Rodgers2008GNB536285.22%3.82%1.4%8
173Jeff Hostetler1996OAK402235.72%3.86%1.87%8
174Sammy Baugh1943WAS239239.62%6.5%3.12%7
175Joe Kapp1969MIN237198.02%4.89%3.12%7
176Andy Dalton2013CIN586335.63%4.37%1.26%7
177Ron Jaworski1980PHI451275.99%4.36%1.63%7
178George Ratterman1950NYY294227.48%4.98%2.5%7
179Len Dawson1967KAN357246.72%4.68%2.04%7
180Boomer Esiason1990CIN402245.97%4.16%1.81%7
181Daunte Culpepper2003MIN454255.51%3.9%1.6%7
182Jake Delhomme2005CAR435245.52%3.85%1.67%7
183Tom Brady2012NWE637345.34%4.2%1.14%7
184Dan Marino1983MIA296206.76%4.31%2.44%7
185David Garrard2010JAX366236.28%4.31%1.97%7
186Tom Flores1963OAK247208.1%5.18%2.91%7
187Tom Brady2004NWE474285.91%4.39%1.52%7
188John Elway1998DEN356226.18%4.17%2.01%7
189Ben Roethlisberger2012PIT449265.79%4.2%1.59%7
190Norm Van Brocklin1957RAM265207.55%4.85%2.69%7
191Kurt Warner2008ARI598305.02%3.83%1.19%7
192Len Dawson1968KAN224177.59%4.42%3.17%7
193Derek Anderson2007CLE527295.5%4.16%1.34%7
194Fran Tarkenton1975MIN425255.88%4.22%1.66%7
195Tom Brady2014NWE582335.67%4.46%1.21%7
196Steve Young1991SFO279176.09%3.57%2.52%7
197Elvis Grbac2000KAN547285.12%3.84%1.28%7
198Dan Marino1985MIA567305.29%4.06%1.23%7
199Joe Montana1985SFO494275.47%4.06%1.41%7
200Terry Bradshaw1981PIT370225.95%4.07%1.87%7
201Norm Van Brocklin1953RAM286196.64%4.22%2.42%7
202Daryle Lamonica1970OAK356226.18%4.24%1.94%7
203Roman Gabriel1967RAM371256.74%4.88%1.86%7
204Peyton Manning2003IND566295.12%3.91%1.22%7
205Chris Chandler1997ATL342205.85%3.85%2%7
206Fran Tarkenton1964MIN306227.19%4.96%2.23%7
207Trent Green2000STL240166.67%3.84%2.83%7
208George Ratterman1947BUF244229.02%6.24%2.78%7
209Matt Hasselbeck2005SEA449245.35%3.85%1.5%7
210Terry Bradshaw1979PIT472265.51%4.08%1.42%7
211Ben Roethlisberger2005PIT268176.34%3.85%2.49%7
212Philip Rivers2010SDG541305.55%4.32%1.23%7
213Dan Marino1994MIA615304.88%3.81%1.07%7
214Al Dorow1960NYT396266.57%4.9%1.66%7
215Daryle Lamonica1968OAK416256.01%4.43%1.58%7
216George Blanda1962HOU418276.46%4.89%1.57%7
217Jim Zorn1977SEA251166.37%3.83%2.55%6
218Bob Griese1974MIA253166.32%3.8%2.52%6
219Johnny Unitas1966BAL348226.32%4.49%1.83%6
220Danny White1982DAL247166.48%3.91%2.57%6
221Norm Van Brocklin1950RAM233187.73%5.01%2.72%6
222Chad Pennington2002NYJ399225.51%3.93%1.58%6
223Frank Ryan1967CLE280207.14%4.89%2.26%6
224Earl Morrall1963DET328247.32%5.4%1.92%6
225Joe Namath1974NYJ361205.54%3.8%1.74%6
226Brett Favre2004GNB540305.56%4.4%1.16%6
227Greg Landry1972DET268186.72%4.38%2.33%6
228Aaron Brooks2002NOR528275.11%3.93%1.18%6
229Daryle Lamonica1971OAK242166.61%4.04%2.57%6
230Steve Spurrier1972SFO269186.69%4.38%2.31%6
231Dave Krieg1986SEA375215.6%3.95%1.65%6
232Craig Morton1969DAL302216.95%4.91%2.04%6
233Dan Marino1987MIA444265.86%4.47%1.39%6
234Sonny Jurgensen1967WAS508316.1%4.89%1.21%6
235George Blanda1960HOU363246.61%4.92%1.7%6
236Matt Ryan2012ATL615325.2%4.2%1%6
237Trent Dilfer1997TAM386215.44%3.85%1.59%6
238Eli Manning2009NYG509275.3%4.1%1.2%6
239Brian Sipe1979CLE535285.23%4.09%1.14%6
240Brian Griese2000DEN336195.65%3.84%1.81%6
241Donovan McNabb2001PHI493255.07%3.84%1.23%6
242Danny White1981DAL391225.63%4.08%1.55%6
243Danny White1983DAL533295.44%4.32%1.12%6
244Ken O'Brien1986NYJ482255.19%3.96%1.23%6
245Matt Hasselbeck2003SEA513265.07%3.91%1.16%6
246Rich Gannon2001OAK549274.92%3.84%1.08%6
247Terry Bradshaw1975PIT286186.29%4.23%2.06%6
248Vinny Testaverde1993CLE230146.09%3.53%2.56%6
249Tony Romo2006DAL337195.64%3.9%1.74%6
250Brian Sipe1980CLE554305.42%4.37%1.05%6
251Otto Graham1948CLE333257.51%5.77%1.74%6
252Jeff Blake1995CIN567284.94%3.93%1.01%6
253Johnny Unitas1960BAL378256.61%5.1%1.51%6
254Jim Plunkett1971NWE328195.79%4.05%1.74%6
255Peyton Manning2008IND555274.86%3.83%1.03%6
256Brett Favre2007GNB535285.23%4.17%1.07%6
257Donovan McNabb2006PHI316185.7%3.9%1.8%6
258Bill Nelsen1969CLE352236.53%4.92%1.61%6
259Brian Griese2001DEN451235.1%3.84%1.26%6
260Daryle Lamonica1972OAK281186.41%4.39%2.01%6
261Craig Morton1981DEN376215.59%4.08%1.5%6
262Jon Kitna2003CIN520265%3.91%1.09%6
263Johnny Unitas1958BAL263197.22%5.08%2.14%6
264Ken Stabler1979OAK498265.22%4.09%1.13%6
265Jim Plunkett1974NWE352195.4%3.81%1.59%6
266Steve Grogan1976NWE302185.96%4.11%1.85%6
267Warren Moon1988HOU294175.78%3.89%1.9%6
268Tom Brady2005NWE530264.91%3.86%1.05%6
269John Elway1993DEN551254.54%3.53%1.01%6
270Babe Parilli1962BOS253187.11%4.92%2.2%6
271Jake Delhomme2004CAR533295.44%4.4%1.04%6
272Philip Rivers2014SDG570315.44%4.47%0.97%6
273Don Meredith1968DAL309216.8%5.01%1.78%6
274Ken Anderson1974CIN328185.49%3.81%1.68%5
275Mark Brunell2005WAS454235.07%3.86%1.21%5
276Terry Bradshaw1980PIT424245.66%4.37%1.29%5
277Earl Morrall1965NYG302227.28%5.48%1.81%5
278Jim Kelly1992BUF462234.98%3.8%1.18%5
279Boomer Esiason1986CIN469245.12%3.96%1.16%5
280Greg Landry1971DET261166.13%4.05%2.08%5
281Chris Miller1992ATL253155.93%3.8%2.13%5
282Charley Johnson1973DEN346205.78%4.23%1.55%5
283Brian Sipe1978CLE399215.26%3.92%1.35%5
284Dave Krieg1985SEA532275.08%4.07%1.01%5
285Cotton Davidson1964OAK320216.56%4.9%1.67%5
286Dan Marino1991MIA549254.55%3.58%0.97%5
287Sid Luckman1946CHI229177.42%5.1%2.32%5
288Brett Favre2002GNB551274.9%3.94%0.96%5
289Don Meredith1965DAL305227.21%5.48%1.73%5
290Dan Fouts1983SDG340205.88%4.33%1.56%5
291Steve Grogan1977NWE305175.57%3.84%1.73%5
292Steve Young1997SFO356195.34%3.86%1.48%5
293Ben Roethlisberger2009PIT506265.14%4.11%1.03%5
294Sammy Baugh1949WAS255187.06%5.02%2.04%5
295Doug Flutie1998BUF354205.65%4.18%1.47%5
296Mark Brunell1998JAX354205.65%4.18%1.47%5
297Brian Griese2004TAM336205.95%4.4%1.55%5
298Jim Hart1974STL388205.15%3.81%1.34%5
299Tommy Maddox2002PIT377205.31%3.94%1.37%5
300Bob Griese1968MIA355215.92%4.47%1.45%5
301Ken O'Brien1985NYJ488255.12%4.07%1.05%5
302Peyton Manning1999IND533264.88%3.92%0.96%5
303Ken Anderson1976CIN338195.62%4.12%1.5%5
304Charley Johnson1963STL423286.62%5.42%1.2%5
305Dan Marino1995MIA482244.98%3.93%1.05%5
306Matt Schaub2009HOU583294.97%4.11%0.87%5
307Jay Schroeder1990RAI334195.69%4.18%1.51%5
308Matt Ryan2011ATL566295.12%4.23%0.89%5
309Troy Aikman1992DAL473234.86%3.8%1.06%5
310Greg Landry1976DET291175.84%4.12%1.72%5
311Ken Anderson1975CIN377215.57%4.24%1.33%5
312Sage Rosenfels2007HOU240156.25%4.17%2.08%5
313Tobin Rote1963SDG286206.99%5.25%1.74%5
314Brad Johnson1996MIN311175.47%3.87%1.59%5
315John Hadl1965SDG348205.75%4.32%1.42%5
316Peyton Manning2001IND547264.75%3.85%0.9%5
317Terry Bradshaw1977PIT314175.41%3.84%1.57%5
318Kurt Warner2009ARI513265.07%4.11%0.96%5
319Michael Vick2010PHI372215.65%4.33%1.32%5
320Jim Kelly1994BUF448224.91%3.82%1.09%5
321Tony Eason1984NWE431235.34%4.2%1.13%5
322Michael Vick2006ATL388205.15%3.9%1.25%5
323Warren Moon1992HOU346185.2%3.8%1.4%5
324Randall Cunningham1987PHI406235.67%4.48%1.19%5
325John Hadl1966SDG375236.13%4.85%1.28%5
326Ben Roethlisberger2014PIT608325.26%4.47%0.79%5
327Tom Brady2009NWE565284.96%4.11%0.85%5
328Andy Dalton2012CIN528275.11%4.21%0.9%5
329Sammy Baugh1942WAS225167.11%4.99%2.12%5
330Sonny Jurgensen1964WAS385246.23%5%1.23%5
331Joe Namath1972NYJ324195.86%4.4%1.46%5
332Drew Brees2005SDG500244.8%3.86%0.94%5
333Ron Jaworski1977PHI346185.2%3.85%1.36%5
334Bobby Layne1959PIT297206.73%5.15%1.58%5
335John Elway1995DEN542264.8%3.93%0.87%5
336Richard Todd1981NYJ497255.03%4.09%0.94%5
337Frank Ryan1965CLE243187.41%5.49%1.92%5
338Jim Harbaugh1995IND314175.41%3.93%1.48%5
339Warren Moon1997SEA528254.73%3.86%0.87%5
340Steve Grogan1980NWE306185.88%4.38%1.51%5
341Bernie Kosar1987CLE389225.66%4.48%1.17%5
342Mark Malone1984PIT272165.88%4.2%1.68%5
343Matt Hasselbeck2007SEA562284.98%4.17%0.81%5
344Bob Berry1970ATL269165.95%4.26%1.69%5
345John Hadl1964SDG274186.57%4.92%1.65%5
346Drew Brees2010NOR658335.02%4.33%0.69%5
347Brian Sipe1983CLE496265.24%4.33%0.91%5
348Aaron Brooks2001NOR558264.66%3.85%0.81%5
349Warren Moon1987HOU368215.71%4.48%1.23%5
350Josh Freeman2010TAM474255.27%4.33%0.94%4
351Tony Banks1999BAL320175.31%3.92%1.39%4
352Neil Lomax1984STL560285%4.2%0.8%4
353Steve DeBerg1990KAN444235.18%4.18%1%4
354David Garrard2007JAX325185.54%4.17%1.36%4
355Dan Marino1988MIA606284.62%3.89%0.73%4
356Steve McNair2001TEN431214.87%3.85%1.02%4
357Warren Moon1989HOU464234.96%4.01%0.95%4
358Randall Cunningham1992PHI384194.95%3.8%1.14%4
359Billy Kilmer1973WAS227146.17%4.24%1.93%4
360Drew Brees2006NOR554264.69%3.9%0.79%4
361Phil Simms1987NYG282176.03%4.48%1.55%4
362Jim Hart1975STL345195.51%4.25%1.26%4
363Tom Brady2002NWE601284.66%3.94%0.72%4
364Jay Cutler2010CHI432235.32%4.33%0.99%4
365Bobby Layne1953DET273165.86%4.29%1.57%4
366Otto Graham1949CLE285196.67%5.17%1.5%4
367Roman Gabriel1969RAM399246.02%4.94%1.07%4
368Aaron Rodgers2013GNB290175.86%4.39%1.47%4
369Joe Montana1990SFO520265%4.18%0.82%4
370Rex Grossman2006CHI480234.79%3.91%0.89%4
371Bill Nelsen1968CLE293196.48%5.03%1.45%4
372Craig Morton1977DEN254145.51%3.85%1.66%4
373Brad Johnson2002TAM451224.88%3.94%0.93%4
374Dan Fouts1980SDG589305.09%4.38%0.72%4
375Gary Danielson1978DET351185.13%3.93%1.2%4
376Jay Cutler2009CHI555274.86%4.11%0.75%4
377Ron Jaworski1981PHI461234.99%4.09%0.9%4
378Y.A. Tittle1955SFO287175.92%4.49%1.44%4
379Brian Sipe1976CLE312175.45%4.13%1.32%4
380Roger Staubach1977DAL361184.99%3.85%1.13%4
381Bob Waterfield1946RAM251176.77%5.16%1.61%4
382Ken Anderson1973CIN329185.47%4.24%1.23%4
383Eli Manning2011NYG589294.92%4.24%0.68%4
384Philip Rivers2006SDG460224.78%3.91%0.88%4
385Fran Tarkenton1968NYG337216.23%5.04%1.19%4
386Jake Plummer2004DEN521275.18%4.41%0.77%4
387Jim Plunkett1986RAI252145.56%3.97%1.59%4
388Kordell Stewart1997PIT440214.77%3.86%0.91%4
389Dan Fouts1982SDG330175.15%3.94%1.21%4
390Jim Hardy1950CRD257176.61%5.06%1.55%4
391Ben Roethlisberger2004PIT295175.76%4.41%1.35%4
392Jim Plunkett1980OAK320185.63%4.38%1.25%4
393Bobby Layne1952DET287196.62%5.23%1.39%4
394Jim Kelly1995BUF458224.8%3.94%0.87%4
395Joe Ferguson1983BUF508265.12%4.34%0.78%4
396Chris Chandler1999ATL307165.21%3.92%1.29%4
397Joe Theismann1984WAS477245.03%4.21%0.82%4
398Marlin Briscoe1968DEN224146.25%4.5%1.75%4
399Jim Everett1992RAM475224.63%3.81%0.82%4
400Steve DeBerg1985TAM370195.14%4.08%1.06%4
401Ryan Fitzpatrick2010BUF441235.22%4.33%0.88%4
402Sid Luckman1947CHI323247.43%6.23%1.2%4
403Chris Miller1994RAM317165.05%3.83%1.22%4
404Tom Brady2006NWE516244.65%3.91%0.74%4
405Joe Flacco2010BAL489255.11%4.33%0.78%4
406Bubby Brister1990PIT387205.17%4.19%0.98%4
407Otto Graham1951CLE265176.42%4.98%1.43%4
408Rich Gannon1999OAK515244.66%3.92%0.74%4
409George Blanda1966HOU271176.27%4.88%1.4%4
410Philip Rivers2012SDG527264.93%4.22%0.72%4
411Joe Theismann1979WAS395205.06%4.11%0.96%4
412Donovan McNabb2009PHI443224.97%4.11%0.85%4
413Scott Mitchell1993MIA233125.15%3.54%1.61%4
414Mike Tomczak1989CHI306165.23%4.02%1.21%4
415Richard Todd1982NYJ261145.36%3.94%1.42%4
416Jim Plunkett1982RAI261145.36%3.94%1.42%4
417Drew Bledsoe2005DAL499234.61%3.87%0.74%4
418Johnny Unitas1964BAL305196.23%5.02%1.21%4
419Peyton Manning2002IND591274.57%3.95%0.62%4
420Jim Everett1995NOR567264.59%3.94%0.65%4
421Aaron Brooks2003NOR518244.63%3.93%0.71%4
422Joe Montana1983SFO515265.05%4.34%0.71%4
423Charley Johnson1974DEN244135.33%3.83%1.5%4
424Mike Taliaferro1969BOS331195.74%4.64%1.1%4
425Fran Tarkenton1962MIN329226.69%5.58%1.11%4
426Brad Johnson1999WAS519244.62%3.92%0.7%4
427Brad Johnson2003TAM570264.56%3.93%0.64%4
428Joe Ferguson1981BUF498244.82%4.1%0.72%4
429Eli Manning2006NYG522244.6%3.91%0.69%4
430Milt Plum1964DET287186.27%5.02%1.25%4
431John Hadl1967SDG427245.62%4.78%0.84%4
432Chris Chandler1996HOU320165%3.88%1.12%4
433Jon Kitna1999SEA495234.65%3.92%0.72%4
434Peyton Manning2010IND679334.86%4.33%0.53%4
435Jake Plummer1997ARI296155.07%3.87%1.2%4
436Jim Plunkett1983RAI379205.28%4.34%0.94%4
437Fran Tarkenton1974MIN351174.84%3.83%1.01%4
438Bert Jones1981BAL426214.93%4.1%0.83%4
439Ken Stabler1975OAK293165.46%4.26%1.2%4
440Matt Hasselbeck2006SEA371184.85%3.91%0.94%3
441Charley Johnson1972DEN238145.88%4.42%1.47%3
442Mark Malone1985PIT233135.58%4.08%1.5%3
443Drew Brees2014NOR659335.01%4.48%0.53%3
444Trent Green2003KAN523244.59%3.93%0.66%3
445Josh Freeman2012TAM558274.84%4.22%0.62%3
446Bert Jones1980BAL446235.16%4.38%0.77%3
447Roman Gabriel1973PHI460235%4.25%0.75%3
448John Hadl1971SDG431214.87%4.07%0.8%3
449Matt Ryan2009ATL451224.88%4.12%0.76%3
450Don Meredith1967DAL255166.27%4.93%1.34%3
451Robert Griffin2012WAS393205.09%4.22%0.87%3
452Jay Cutler2013CHI355195.35%4.39%0.96%3
453Eli Manning2012NYG536264.85%4.22%0.63%3
454Tony Romo2009DAL550264.73%4.12%0.61%3
455Fran Tarkenton1973MIN274155.47%4.25%1.22%3
456Bert Jones1975BAL344185.23%4.26%0.97%3
457Fran Tarkenton1961MIN280186.43%5.24%1.19%3
458Joe Montana1982SFO346174.91%3.95%0.96%3
459Ray Lucas1999NYJ272145.15%3.93%1.22%3
460Byron Leftwich2005JAX302154.97%3.87%1.1%3
461Trent Dilfer2000BAL226125.31%3.86%1.45%3
462Mark Rypien1990WAS304165.26%4.19%1.07%3
463Steve Bartkowski1983ATL432225.09%4.34%0.75%3
464Matt Ryan2010ATL571284.9%4.34%0.57%3
465Cam Newton2013CAR473245.07%4.4%0.68%3
466Neil Lomax1987STL463245.18%4.49%0.69%3
467Bill Kenney1985KAN338175.03%4.08%0.95%3
468Steve Beuerlein1993PHO418184.31%3.54%0.76%3
469Josh McCown2013CHI224135.8%4.4%1.41%3
470Jake Plummer2003DEN302154.97%3.93%1.04%3
471Joe Namath1965NYJ340185.29%4.37%0.92%3
472Charlie Conerly1948NYG299227.36%6.31%1.05%3
473Bill Kenney1984KAN282155.32%4.21%1.1%3
474Marc Wilson1984RAI282155.32%4.21%1.1%3
475Joe Ferguson1974BUF232125.17%3.84%1.34%3
476Eli Manning2014NYG601304.99%4.48%0.51%3
477Bobby Hebert1996ATL488224.51%3.88%0.62%3
478Bubby Brister1993PHI309144.53%3.55%0.99%3
479Joe Theismann1982WAS252135.16%3.95%1.21%3
480Joe Montana1980SFO273155.49%4.39%1.11%3
481Ryan Fitzpatrick2014HOU312175.45%4.48%0.97%3
482Trent Dilfer1998TAM429214.9%4.19%0.7%3
483Jay Schroeder1988RAI256135.08%3.9%1.17%3
484Joe Ferguson1978BUF330164.85%3.94%0.91%3
485Chris Chandler1995HOU356174.78%3.94%0.83%3
486Mark Sanchez2011NYJ543264.79%4.25%0.54%3
487Jim Plunkett1976SFO243135.35%4.14%1.21%3
488Ken Stabler1973OAK260145.38%4.26%1.13%3
489Jeff George1994ATL524234.39%3.83%0.56%3
490Don Majkowski1989GNB599274.51%4.02%0.49%3
491Jim Kelly1986BUF480224.58%3.98%0.61%3
492Bobby Hebert1992NOR422194.5%3.82%0.69%3
493Marc Bulger2005STL287144.88%3.87%1.01%3
494Mark Rypien1989WAS476224.62%4.02%0.6%3
495Dan Marino1992MIA554244.33%3.82%0.52%3
496Tobin Rote1956GNB308185.84%4.92%0.93%3
497Jay Cutler2014CHI561284.99%4.48%0.51%3
498Tommy Kramer1982MIN308154.87%3.96%0.91%3
499Sammy Baugh1947WAS354257.06%6.27%0.79%3
500Drew Bledsoe1996NWE623274.33%3.88%0.45%3
501Rudy Bukich1965CHI312206.41%5.53%0.88%3
502Donovan McNabb2002PHI361174.71%3.95%0.76%3
503Bill Kenney1987KAN273155.49%4.49%1%3
504Len Dawson1971KAN301154.98%4.08%0.9%3
505Colin Kaepernick2013SFO416215.05%4.4%0.65%3
506Neil Lomax1988PHO443204.51%3.91%0.61%3
507Fran Tarkenton1969NYG409235.62%4.97%0.65%3
508Ryan Fitzpatrick2012BUF505244.75%4.22%0.53%3
509Alex Smith2009SFO372184.84%4.12%0.72%3
510Jeff Blake1996CIN549244.37%3.89%0.49%3
511Roman Gabriel1971RAM352174.83%4.08%0.75%3
512Norm Snead1972NYG325175.23%4.43%0.81%3
513Jay Fiedler2001MIA450204.44%3.86%0.58%3
514Dick Shiner1968PIT304185.92%5.06%0.86%3
515Steve Beuerlein1998CAR343174.96%4.2%0.76%3
516Danny White1985DAL450214.67%4.09%0.58%3
517Ron Jaworski1979PHI374184.81%4.12%0.7%3
518Matt Schaub2011HOU292155.14%4.25%0.89%3
519Bill Nelsen1970CLE313165.11%4.28%0.83%3
520Jeff Garcia2003SFO392184.59%3.93%0.66%3
521Dennis Shaw1972BUF258145.43%4.43%1%3
522Bart Starr1966GNB251145.58%4.55%1.02%3
523Eric Hipple1981DET279145.02%4.1%0.91%3
524Jeff Hostetler1994RAI455204.4%3.83%0.56%3
525Steve McNair2002TEN492224.47%3.95%0.52%3
526Warren Moon1993HOU520214.04%3.55%0.49%3
527Eli Manning2008NYG479214.38%3.85%0.53%3
528Matt Robinson1978NYJ266134.89%3.94%0.94%3
529Dan Marino1996MIA373174.56%3.89%0.67%3
530Brad Johnson1997MIN452204.42%3.87%0.55%2
531Joe Montana1988SFO397184.53%3.91%0.63%2
532Lynn Dickey1981GNB354174.8%4.1%0.7%2
533Sam Bradford2013STL262145.34%4.4%0.94%2
534Steve Bono1991SFO237114.64%3.6%1.04%2
535Jay Fiedler2002MIA292144.79%3.95%0.84%2
536Babe Parilli1967BOS344195.52%4.81%0.71%2
537Marc Wilson1986RAI240125%3.98%1.02%2
538Fran Tarkenton1978MIN572254.37%3.94%0.43%2
539Mike Tomczak1991GNB238114.62%3.6%1.02%2
540Joe Montana1993KAN298134.36%3.55%0.81%2
541Trent Green2004KAN556274.86%4.42%0.44%2
542Frankie Albert1947SFO242187.44%6.44%1%2
543Eli Manning2005NYG557244.31%3.87%0.43%2
544Charlie Batch1999DET270134.81%3.93%0.88%2
545Elvis Grbac1999KAN499224.41%3.93%0.48%2
546Phil Simms1986NYG468214.49%3.98%0.51%2
547Joe Namath1967NYJ491265.3%4.81%0.48%2
548Steve Young1995SFO447204.47%3.95%0.53%2
549Fran Tarkenton1970NYG389194.88%4.29%0.6%2
550Ken Stabler1981HOU285144.91%4.1%0.81%2
551Butch Songin1960BOS392225.61%5.03%0.59%2
552Ben Roethlisberger2013PIT584284.79%4.4%0.39%2
553Bobby Hoying1997PHI225114.89%3.88%1.01%2
554Phil Simms1988NYG479214.38%3.91%0.47%2
555Philip Rivers2011SDG582274.64%4.25%0.39%2
556Tom Brady2003NWE527234.36%3.93%0.43%2
557Jim Finks1952PIT336205.95%5.28%0.67%2
558Jeff Blake1994CIN306144.58%3.84%0.74%2
559Richard Todd1979NYJ334164.79%4.12%0.67%2
560Billy Volek2004TEN357185.04%4.42%0.62%2
561Sonny Jurgensen1968WAS292175.82%5.07%0.75%2
562Jim McMahon1985CHI313154.79%4.09%0.7%2
563J.P. Losman2006BUF429194.43%3.92%0.51%2
564Jon Kitna2010DAL318165.03%4.34%0.69%2
565John Brodie1971SFO387184.65%4.09%0.56%2
566Tom Flores1965OAK269145.2%4.4%0.8%2
567Dan Fouts1979SDG530244.53%4.12%0.41%2
568Donovan McNabb2005PHI357164.48%3.88%0.61%2
569Lynn Dickey1985GNB314154.78%4.09%0.69%2
570Norm Snead1962WAS354226.21%5.61%0.61%2
571Joe Flacco2014BAL554274.87%4.49%0.39%2
572Roger Staubach1975DAL348174.89%4.27%0.61%2
573Tobin Rote1951GNB256155.86%5.03%0.83%2
574Frank Reich1996NYJ331154.53%3.89%0.64%2
575Jay Schroeder1991RAI357154.2%3.61%0.6%2
576Wade Wilson1987MIN264145.3%4.5%0.8%2
577Milt Plum1961CLE302185.96%5.26%0.7%2
578Joe Namath1969NYJ361195.26%4.68%0.59%2
579Steve Bartkowski1975ATL255135.1%4.27%0.83%2
580Randall Cunningham1988PHI560244.29%3.91%0.38%2
581Bart Starr1965GNB251166.37%5.54%0.84%2
582Phil Simms1979NYG265134.91%4.12%0.78%2
583Billy Kilmer1969NOR360205.56%4.98%0.58%2
584Tom Brady2001NWE413184.36%3.87%0.49%2
585Ken Anderson1979CIN339164.72%4.12%0.6%2
586Wade Wilson1988MIN332154.52%3.91%0.61%2
587Chris Miller1995STL405184.44%3.95%0.5%2
588Jeff George1995ATL557244.31%3.95%0.36%2
589Y.A. Tittle1961NYG285175.96%5.26%0.7%2
590Sammy Baugh1948WAS315226.98%6.35%0.63%2
591Jeff George1990IND334164.79%4.2%0.59%2
592Pat Ryan1984NYJ285144.91%4.22%0.69%2
593John Elway1984DEN380184.74%4.22%0.51%2
594Phil Simms1990NYG311154.82%4.2%0.62%2
595John Hadl1962SDG260155.77%5.03%0.74%2
596Kerry Collins2010TEN278145.04%4.34%0.69%2
597Carson Palmer2007CIN575264.52%4.19%0.33%2
598Jim Hart1976STL388184.64%4.15%0.49%2
599Shaun Hill2008SFO288134.51%3.86%0.66%2
600Chris Chandler2001ATL365164.38%3.87%0.52%2
601Brett Favre2008NYJ522224.21%3.86%0.36%2
602Mike Tomczak1999PIT258124.65%3.93%0.72%2
603Peyton Manning1998IND575264.52%4.2%0.32%2
604Dan Marino1989MIA550244.36%4.03%0.34%2
605Bob Waterfield1949RAM296175.74%5.12%0.62%2
606Jon Kitna2000SEA418184.31%3.87%0.44%2
607James Harris1975RAM285144.91%4.27%0.64%2
608Steve Grogan1983NWE303154.95%4.35%0.6%2
609Stan Humphries1996SDG416184.33%3.89%0.44%2
610Vince Ferragamo1983RAM464224.74%4.35%0.39%2
611Steve Walsh1991NOR255114.31%3.61%0.71%2
612Tyler Thigpen2008KAN420184.29%3.86%0.43%2
613Carson Palmer2009CIN466214.51%4.13%0.38%2
614Bobby Hebert1987NOR294155.1%4.5%0.6%2
615Bert Jones1977BAL393174.33%3.88%0.45%2
616Craig Erickson1993TAM457183.94%3.55%0.38%2
617Len Dawson1970KAN262134.96%4.29%0.67%2
618Bob Berry1971ATL226114.87%4.09%0.78%2
619Phil Simms1985NYG495224.44%4.09%0.35%2
620Bobby Layne1954DET246145.69%4.99%0.71%2
621Philip Rivers2007SDG460214.57%4.19%0.38%2
622Bob Griese1978MIA235114.68%3.95%0.73%2
623Tom Sherman1968BOS226125.31%4.55%0.76%2
624Steve Young1996SFO316144.43%3.89%0.54%2
625Vinny Testaverde1990TAM365174.66%4.2%0.46%2
626Seneca Wallace2008SEA242114.55%3.86%0.69%2
627Tommy Kramer1981MIN593264.38%4.11%0.27%2
628Doug Williams1979TAM397184.53%4.12%0.41%2
629Shane Matthews2002WAS237114.64%3.96%0.68%2
630Steve DeBerg1987TAM275145.09%4.5%0.59%2
631Bart Starr1963GNB244156.15%5.49%0.66%2
632Rodney Peete1990DET271134.8%4.2%0.6%2
633Trent Green1998WAS509234.52%4.2%0.32%2
634Eddie LeBaron1961DAL236145.93%5.27%0.66%2
635Vinny Testaverde1994CLE376164.26%3.84%0.41%2
636Rich Gannon2002OAK618264.21%3.96%0.25%2
637Kerry Collins2000NYG529224.16%3.87%0.29%2
638Vinny Testaverde1995CLE392174.34%3.95%0.39%2
639Bob Griese1970MIA245124.9%4.29%0.6%1
640John Brodie1968SFO404225.45%5.08%0.36%1
641Dan Pastorini1978HOU368164.35%3.95%0.4%1
642Shaun King2000TAM428184.21%3.87%0.34%1
643Erik Kramer1991DET265114.15%3.61%0.54%1
644Damon Huard2006KAN244114.51%3.92%0.59%1
645Sonny Jurgensen1962PHI366226.01%5.62%0.39%1
646Sam Vacanti1947CHR225167.11%6.48%0.63%1
647Tobin Rote1955GNB342174.97%4.56%0.41%1
648Gus Frerotte1997WAS402174.23%3.88%0.35%1
649Trent Dilfer1999TAM244114.51%3.94%0.57%1
650George Blanda1963HOU423245.67%5.36%0.32%1
651Kent Graham1996ARI274124.38%3.89%0.49%1
652Rich Gannon1990MIN349164.58%4.2%0.38%1
653Charlie Conerly1949NYG305175.57%5.14%0.43%1
654Mark Brunell1995JAX346154.34%3.95%0.38%1
655Steve DeBerg1991KAN434173.92%3.61%0.31%1
656Rich Gannon1992MIN279124.3%3.83%0.47%1
657Jim Hart1973STL320154.69%4.28%0.41%1
658Steve Bartkowski1979ATL380174.47%4.13%0.35%1
659Jeff Blake2002BAL295134.41%3.96%0.45%1
660Jay Schroeder1992RAI253114.35%3.83%0.52%1
661Jeff Blake2000NOR302134.3%3.87%0.43%1
662Jake Delhomme2003CAR449194.23%3.94%0.29%1
663Chad Pennington2003NYJ297134.38%3.94%0.44%1
664Jim Kelly1993BUF470183.83%3.56%0.27%1
665Bobby Hebert1988NOR478204.18%3.92%0.27%1
666Jim Everett1994NOR540224.07%3.84%0.23%1
667Matt Moore2011MIA347164.61%4.26%0.36%1
668Bart Starr1964GNB272155.51%5.06%0.45%1
669John Elway1989DEN416184.33%4.03%0.29%1
670Fran Tarkenton1972MIN378184.76%4.44%0.32%1
671Jay Cutler2008DEN616254.06%3.86%0.2%1
672Bob Griese1979MIA310144.52%4.13%0.39%1
673Danny White1984DAL233114.72%4.23%0.49%1
674Tony Eason1986NWE448194.24%3.99%0.25%1
675Babe Parilli1966BOS382205.24%4.94%0.29%1
676Mark Brunell1997JAX435184.14%3.88%0.26%1
677Ed Brown1963PIT362215.8%5.49%0.31%1
678Johnny Unitas1962BAL389235.91%5.63%0.28%1
679Jim Hart1981STL241114.56%4.11%0.45%1
680Kelly Holcomb2005BUF230104.35%3.88%0.46%1
681Matt Cassel2008NWE516214.07%3.86%0.21%1
682Matthew Stafford2013DET634294.57%4.41%0.17%1
683Troy Aikman1993DAL392153.83%3.56%0.27%1
684Paul Governali19472TM252176.75%6.33%0.41%1
685Dieter Brock1985RAM365164.38%4.1%0.29%1
686Joe Namath1975NYJ326154.6%4.28%0.32%1
687Marc Bulger2003STL532224.14%3.94%0.19%1
688Neil O'Donnell1992PIT313134.15%3.83%0.32%1
689Otto Graham1950CLE253145.53%5.14%0.4%1
690Matt Hasselbeck2004SEA474224.64%4.43%0.21%1
691Jeff Kemp1984RAM284134.58%4.23%0.35%1
692Billy Kilmer1974WAS234104.27%3.86%0.41%1
693Donovan McNabb2008PHI571234.03%3.86%0.16%1
694George Blanda1954CHI281155.34%5.01%0.33%1
695Carson Palmer2014ARI224114.91%4.49%0.42%1
696Marc Bulger2006STL588244.08%3.93%0.16%1
697John Brodie1962SFO304185.92%5.63%0.29%1
698Dave Krieg1989SEA499214.21%4.04%0.17%1
699Paul Christman1946CRD229135.68%5.3%0.37%1
700Eli Manning2007NYG529234.35%4.2%0.15%1
701Phil Simms1993NYG400153.75%3.56%0.19%1
702Jim McMahon1991PHI311123.86%3.62%0.24%1
703Bobby Hebert1989NOR353154.25%4.04%0.21%1
704Cotton Davidson1961DTX330175.15%4.93%0.22%1
705Craig Morton1979DEN370164.32%4.13%0.19%1
706Patrick Ramsey2003WAS337144.15%3.94%0.21%1
707Bill Kenney1986KAN308134.22%3.99%0.23%1
708Richard Todd1977NYJ265114.15%3.89%0.26%1
709Jack Thompson1980CIN234114.7%4.4%0.3%1
710Fran Tarkenton1965MIN329195.78%5.56%0.21%1
711Dave Krieg1991SEA285113.86%3.62%0.24%1
712Jeff Hostetler1995OAK286124.2%3.96%0.24%1
713Bob Berry1972ATL277134.69%4.45%0.25%1
714Chris Miller1990ATL388174.38%4.21%0.17%1
715Steve Grogan1978NWE362154.14%3.96%0.19%1
716Mark Brunell2001JAX473194.02%3.88%0.14%1
717Joe Ferguson1980BUF439204.56%4.4%0.15%1
718Jeff Blake1999CIN389164.11%3.94%0.17%1
719Neil O'Donnell1991PIT286113.85%3.62%0.23%1
720Mike Glennon2013TAM416194.57%4.41%0.16%1
721Tony Banks1996STL368154.08%3.9%0.18%1
722Craig Erickson1994TAM399164.01%3.85%0.16%1
723Jack Jacobs1947GNB242166.61%6.35%0.27%1
724Drew Brees2007NOR652284.29%4.2%0.1%1
725Otto Graham1952CLE364205.49%5.32%0.17%1
726Vinny Testaverde1989TAM480204.17%4.04%0.13%1
727Jay Cutler2012CHI434194.38%4.23%0.14%1
728Dan Pastorini1979HOU324144.32%4.13%0.19%1
729Boomer Esiason1995NYJ389164.11%3.96%0.16%1
730Ron Jaworski1982PHI286124.2%3.98%0.21%1
731Christian Ponder2011MIN291134.47%4.26%0.21%1
732Tobin Rote1958DET257145.45%5.21%0.24%1
733Chad Pennington2008MIA476193.99%3.87%0.13%1
734Alex Smith2013KAN508234.53%4.41%0.12%1
735Dan Pastorini1977HOU319134.08%3.89%0.19%1
736Norm Snead1970PHI335154.48%4.3%0.17%1
737Fran Tarkenton1966MIN358174.75%4.59%0.16%1
738Archie Manning1980NOR509234.52%4.4%0.11%1
739Brad Johnson2005MIN294124.08%3.89%0.2%1
740Neil O'Donnell1998CIN343154.37%4.21%0.16%1
741Tony Romo2012DAL648284.32%4.24%0.09%1
742Jim Miller2002CHI314134.14%3.96%0.18%1
743Ron Jaworski1983PHI446204.48%4.36%0.12%1
744Neil O'Donnell1995PIT416174.09%3.96%0.13%1
745Scott Mitchell1994DET246104.07%3.85%0.22%1
746David Garrard2006JAX241104.15%3.93%0.22%1
747Steve Tensi1969DEN286144.9%4.72%0.18%1
748Mark Brunell2002JAX416174.09%3.96%0.12%1
749John Elway1987DEN410194.63%4.51%0.12%1
750Carson Palmer2010CIN586264.44%4.35%0.08%0
751Roman Gabriel1975PHI292134.45%4.29%0.16%0
752Ryan Tannehill2014MIA590274.58%4.5%0.08%0
753Tim Tebow2011DEN271124.43%4.26%0.17%0
754Dan Pastorini1974HOU247104.05%3.86%0.18%0
755Stan Humphries1993SDG324123.7%3.56%0.14%0
756Billy Kilmer1971WAS306134.25%4.11%0.14%0
757Tim Couch2002CLE443184.06%3.97%0.1%0
758George Ratterman1949BUF252145.56%5.39%0.17%0
759Craig Morton1978DEN267114.12%3.96%0.16%0
760Steve Bono1995KAN520214.04%3.96%0.08%0
761Brett Favre1993GNB522193.64%3.56%0.08%0
762Jay Cutler2007DEN467204.28%4.2%0.08%0
763Jay Schroeder1986WAS541224.07%3.99%0.07%0
764Dan Marino1998MIA537234.28%4.21%0.07%0
765Bart Starr1961GNB295165.42%5.29%0.13%0
766Jack Trudeau1989IND362154.14%4.04%0.1%0
767Joe Flacco2009BAL499214.21%4.13%0.07%0
768Gus Frerotte2008MIN301123.99%3.87%0.12%0
769Eric Hipple1985DET406174.19%4.1%0.08%0
770Boomer Esiason1992CIN278113.96%3.84%0.12%0
771Roman Gabriel1968RAM366195.19%5.1%0.09%0
772George Blanda1965HOU442204.52%4.45%0.07%0
773Matt Schaub2008HOU380153.95%3.87%0.08%0
774Cody Carlson1992HOU22793.96%3.84%0.13%0
775Jake Plummer2005DEN456183.95%3.89%0.06%0
776Vinny Testaverde1992TAM358143.91%3.84%0.07%0
777Ron Jaworski1978PHI398164.02%3.96%0.06%0
778Eddie LeBaron1960DAL225125.33%5.24%0.1%0
779Billy Wade1958RAM341185.28%5.22%0.06%0
780Steve Tensi1967DEN325164.92%4.87%0.05%0
781Johnny Unitas1970BAL321144.36%4.31%0.05%0
782Jay Fiedler2000MIA357143.92%3.88%0.04%0
783Mark Brunell2000JAX512203.91%3.88%0.03%0
784Doug Flutie1999BUF478193.97%3.95%0.03%0
785Bob Lee1973ATL230104.35%4.29%0.06%0
786Rob Johnson2000BUF306123.92%3.88%0.04%0
787Warren Moon1998SEA258114.26%4.21%0.05%0
788Bernie Kosar1991CLE494183.64%3.62%0.02%0
789Mark Sanchez2014PHI309144.53%4.5%0.03%0
790Alex Van Pelt2001BUF307123.91%3.88%0.03%0
791Jim Kelly1987BUF419194.53%4.51%0.02%0
792Doug Williams1988WAS380153.95%3.93%0.02%0
793Marc Wilson1985RAI388164.12%4.11%0.02%0
794Joe Pisarcik1978NYG301123.99%3.96%0.02%0
795Ben Roethlisberger2010PIT389174.37%4.36%0.01%0
796Jake Delhomme2006CAR431173.94%3.93%0.01%0
797Boomer Esiason1994NYJ440173.86%3.85%0.01%0
798Jeff Garcia2002SFO528213.98%3.97%0.01%0
799Charley Johnson1965STL322185.59%5.58%0.01%0
800Drew Bledsoe2004BUF450204.44%4.44%0.01%0
801Bobby Hebert1991NOR24893.63%3.62%0.01%0
802Kyle Orton2008CHI465183.87%3.87%0%0
803Norm Snead1969PHI379195.01%5.01%0%0
804Gus Frerotte2000DEN23293.88%3.88%0%0
805Patrick Ramsey2002WAS22793.96%3.97%0%0
806Marc Wilson1987RAI266124.51%4.51%0%0
807Michael Vick2011PHI423184.26%4.26%-0.01%0
808Charley Johnson1969STL260135%5.01%-0.01%0
809Michael Vick2005ATL387153.88%3.89%-0.01%0
810Scott Mitchell1996DET437173.89%3.9%-0.01%0
811Jay Schroeder1987WAS267124.49%4.52%-0.02%0
812Pete Liske1971PHI269114.09%4.11%-0.02%0
813Ed Brown1959CHI247135.26%5.29%-0.03%0
814Milt Plum1959CLE266145.26%5.29%-0.03%0
815Brett Favre1992GNB471183.82%3.84%-0.02%0
816Steve Pelluer1988DAL435173.91%3.93%-0.02%0
817Norm Van Brocklin1954RAM260135%5.03%-0.03%0
818Ken Stabler1978OAK406163.94%3.96%-0.02%0
819Don Meredith1963DAL310175.48%5.52%-0.03%0
820Craig Morton1972DAL339154.42%4.46%-0.03%0
821Bob Celeri1951NYY238125.04%5.09%-0.05%0
822Rodney Peete2002CAR381153.94%3.97%-0.03%0
823Sonny Jurgensen1969WAS442224.98%5.01%-0.04%0
824Bernie Kosar1988CLE259103.86%3.93%-0.07%0
825Fran Tarkenton1976MIN412174.13%4.17%-0.04%0
826Daunte Culpepper2001MIN366143.83%3.88%-0.06%0
827Kerry Collins1996CAR364143.85%3.9%-0.06%0
828Drew Bledsoe2002BUF610243.93%3.97%-0.03%0
829Heath Shuler1994WAS265103.77%3.85%-0.08%0
830Matt Cassel2013MIN254114.33%4.41%-0.08%0
831Kordell Stewart2000PIT289113.81%3.88%-0.07%0
832Michael Vick2004ATL321144.36%4.44%-0.08%0
833Craig Morton19742TM23993.77%3.87%-0.11%0
834Steve DeBerg1988KAN414163.86%3.93%-0.06%0
835Steve Ramsey1976DEN270114.07%4.17%-0.1%0
836Ryan Fitzpatrick2011BUF569244.22%4.26%-0.05%0
837Matt Ryan2014ATL628284.46%4.5%-0.04%0
838Drew Bledsoe1998NWE481204.16%4.21%-0.06%0
839Vinny Testaverde1997BAL470183.83%3.89%-0.06%0
840Drew Bledsoe1993NWE429153.5%3.57%-0.07%0
841Charlie Conerly1953NYG303134.29%4.4%-0.11%0
842Bob Griese1976MIA272114.04%4.17%-0.13%0
843Ken Anderson1982CIN309123.88%4%-0.11%0
844Russell Wilson2014SEA452204.42%4.5%-0.08%0
845Jim Harbaugh1998BAL293124.1%4.22%-0.12%0
846Jim Everett1990RAM554234.15%4.22%-0.06%0
847Otto Graham1953CLE258114.26%4.4%-0.14%0
848Steve McNair2000TEN396153.79%3.88%-0.09%0
849Bill Nelsen1971CLE325134%4.11%-0.11%0
850Gary Danielson1984DET410174.15%4.24%-0.09%0
851Frank Tripucka1960DEN478245.02%5.1%-0.08%0
852Jay Cutler2011CHI314134.14%4.26%-0.12%0
853Ryan Fitzpatrick2009BUF22793.96%4.14%-0.17%0
854Charley Johnson1964STL420215%5.1%-0.1%0
855Steve Bartkowski1984ATL269114.09%4.24%-0.15%0
856Kyle Boller2005BAL293113.75%3.89%-0.14%0
857Norm Snead1964PHI283144.95%5.1%-0.15%0
858Chad Pennington2004NYJ370164.32%4.44%-0.11%0
859Bob Avellini1977CHI293113.75%3.9%-0.15%0
860Doug Williams1981TAM471194.03%4.12%-0.09%0
861David Woodley1980MIA327144.28%4.41%-0.13%0
862Tommy Kramer1979MIN566234.06%4.14%-0.08%0
863Danny Kanell1997NYG294113.74%3.89%-0.15%0
864Ben Roethlisberger2006PIT469183.84%3.93%-0.1%0
865Troy Aikman1999DAL442173.85%3.95%-0.1%0
866Stan Humphries1994SDG453173.75%3.85%-0.1%0
867Jack Thompson1983TAM423184.26%4.37%-0.11%0
868Warren Moon1985HOU377153.98%4.11%-0.13%0
869Randall Cunningham1989PHI532213.95%4.05%-0.1%-1
870Joe Flacco2012BAL531224.14%4.24%-0.1%-1
871Marc Bulger2004STL485214.33%4.44%-0.11%-1
872Jack Kemp1964BUF269134.83%5.05%-0.22%-1
873Phil Simms1984NYG533224.13%4.24%-0.11%-1
874Len Dawson1972KAN305134.26%4.46%-0.2%-1
875Mike Phipps1972CLE305134.26%4.46%-0.2%-1
876Jack Concannon1970CHI385164.16%4.32%-0.16%-1
877Tim Couch2001CLE454173.74%3.88%-0.14%-1
878Mike Tomczak1996PIT401153.74%3.91%-0.17%-1
879Ty Detmer1996PHI401153.74%3.91%-0.17%-1
880Jim Plunkett1977SFO24893.63%3.9%-0.27%-1
881Dan Pastorini1975HOU342144.09%4.3%-0.21%-1
882Michael Vick2002ATL421163.8%3.97%-0.17%-1
883Vince Young2009TEN259103.86%4.14%-0.28%-1
884Dave Krieg1996CHI377143.71%3.91%-0.19%-1
885Gary Hogeboom1989PHO364143.85%4.05%-0.2%-1
886John Skelton2011ARI275114%4.27%-0.27%-1
887Jeff Garcia2007TAM327133.98%4.2%-0.23%-1
888Scott Campbell1987ATL260114.23%4.52%-0.29%-1
889Jack Kemp1960LAC406204.93%5.11%-0.19%-1
890Warren Moon1991HOU655233.51%3.63%-0.12%-1
891Jim Harbaugh1992CHI358133.63%3.84%-0.21%-1
892Tim Couch1999CLE399153.76%3.95%-0.19%-1
893Steve Grogan1975NWE274114.01%4.3%-0.29%-1
894Austin Davis2014STL284124.23%4.5%-0.28%-1
895Jim Kelly1996BUF379143.69%3.91%-0.21%-1
896Matt Ryan2008ATL434163.69%3.87%-0.19%-1
897Scott Mitchell1997DET509193.73%3.89%-0.16%-1
898Charlie Conerly1957NYG232114.74%5.1%-0.36%-1
899Rich Gannon1991MIN354123.39%3.63%-0.24%-1
900Joey Harrington2005DET330123.64%3.89%-0.26%-1
901Jim Hart1967STL397194.79%5%-0.21%-1
902Jim Hart1977STL355133.66%3.9%-0.24%-1
903Shane Matthews1999CHI275103.64%3.95%-0.31%-1
904Chris Chandler1992PHO413153.63%3.84%-0.21%-1
905Dave Krieg1992KAN413153.63%3.84%-0.21%-1
906J.P. Losman2005BUF22883.51%3.89%-0.39%-1
907Tom Flores1960OAK252124.76%5.12%-0.35%-1
908Donovan McNabb2007PHI473194.02%4.21%-0.19%-1
909Ben Roethlisberger2011PIT513214.09%4.27%-0.17%-1
910Jim McMahon1983CHI295124.07%4.37%-0.3%-1
911Boomer Esiason1993NYJ473163.38%3.57%-0.19%-1
912Alex Smith2010SFO342144.09%4.36%-0.27%-1
913Neil O'Donnell1997NYJ460173.7%3.9%-0.2%-1
914Troy Aikman1994DAL361133.6%3.86%-0.26%-1
915Jim Zorn1979SEA505203.96%4.14%-0.18%-1
916Mike Phipps1974CLE25693.52%3.88%-0.36%-1
917Chad Pennington2007NYJ260103.85%4.21%-0.36%-1
918George Shaw1955BAL237104.22%4.62%-0.4%-1
919Donald Hollas1998OAK260103.85%4.22%-0.37%-1
920Jeff Hostetler1993RAI419143.34%3.57%-0.23%-1
921Doug Flutie2000BUF23183.46%3.88%-0.42%-1
922Ken Anderson1983CIN297124.04%4.37%-0.33%-1
923Dennis Shaw1971BUF291113.78%4.12%-0.34%-1
924Dan Fouts1976SDG359143.9%4.18%-0.28%-1
925Carson Palmer2011OAK328133.96%4.27%-0.3%-1
926Jason Campbell2009WAS507203.94%4.14%-0.2%-1
927Nick Foles2014PHI311134.18%4.51%-0.33%-1
928Tommy Kramer1984MIN23693.81%4.24%-0.43%-1
929Pat Haden1979RAM290113.79%4.14%-0.35%-1
930Brian Griese2007CHI262103.82%4.21%-0.39%-1
931Steve Ramsey1975DEN23393.86%4.3%-0.44%-1
932Matt Schaub2010HOU574244.18%4.36%-0.18%-1
933Jake Delhomme2008CAR414153.62%3.88%-0.25%-1
934Dave Wilson1985NOR293113.75%4.11%-0.36%-1
935John Brodie1961SFO283144.95%5.32%-0.37%-1
936Cam Newton2011CAR517214.06%4.27%-0.21%-1
937Fran Tarkenton1977MIN25893.49%3.91%-0.42%-1
938Steve McNair1999TEN331123.63%3.95%-0.33%-1
939Matt Schaub2012HOU544224.04%4.24%-0.2%-1
940Donovan McNabb2000PHI569213.69%3.89%-0.19%-1
941Marc Wilson1981OAK366143.83%4.13%-0.3%-1
942Steve DeBerg19932TM22773.08%3.57%-0.49%-1
943Dick Wood1963NYJ352185.11%5.43%-0.32%-1
944Norm Snead1965PHI288155.21%5.6%-0.39%-1
945Babe Parilli1965BOS426184.23%4.49%-0.26%-1
946Troy Aikman1995DAL432163.7%3.97%-0.26%-1
947Otto Graham1954CLE240114.58%5.06%-0.47%-1
948Billy Kilmer1968NOR315154.76%5.13%-0.36%-1
949Don Majkowski1990GNB264103.79%4.22%-0.43%-1
950Dick Wood1964NYJ358174.75%5.07%-0.32%-1
951Joe Montana1981SFO488193.89%4.13%-0.24%-1
952Chris Chandler1988IND23383.43%3.93%-0.5%-1
953Ben Roethlisberger2008PIT469173.62%3.88%-0.25%-1
954John Elway1986DEN504193.77%4%-0.23%-1
955Troy Aikman1997DAL518193.67%3.9%-0.23%-1
956Carson Palmer2004CIN432184.17%4.44%-0.28%-1
957Jeff Garcia2004CLE252103.97%4.44%-0.47%-1
958Dan Fouts1974SDG23783.38%3.88%-0.51%-1
959Jim Hart1968STL316154.75%5.13%-0.38%-1
960Dan Fouts1986SDG430163.72%4%-0.28%-1
961Elvis Grbac1997KAN314113.5%3.9%-0.39%-1
962Bob Griese1967MIA331154.53%4.91%-0.38%-1
963Gus Frerotte2005MIA494183.64%3.9%-0.25%-1
964Charlie Batch2001DET341123.52%3.89%-0.37%-1
965Y.A. Tittle1957SFO279134.66%5.11%-0.45%-1
966JaMarcus Russell2008OAK368133.53%3.88%-0.34%-1
967Vince Evans1980CHI278113.96%4.42%-0.46%-1
968Neil O'Donnell1994PIT370133.51%3.86%-0.35%-1
969Mike Boryla1976PHI24693.66%4.18%-0.52%-1
970Carson Palmer2013ARI572244.2%4.42%-0.22%-1
971Cade McNown1999CHI23583.4%3.95%-0.55%-1
972Troy Aikman1998DAL315123.81%4.22%-0.41%-1
973Glenn Dobbs1948LAD369215.69%6.04%-0.35%-1
974Craig Morton1980DEN301123.99%4.42%-0.43%-1
975Tony Eason1985NWE299113.68%4.11%-0.44%-1
976Billy Joe Tolliver1990SDG410163.9%4.22%-0.32%-1
977Jason Campbell2010OAK329133.95%4.36%-0.41%-1
978Steve Beuerlein1988RAI23883.36%3.94%-0.57%-1
979Neil Lomax1985STL471183.82%4.12%-0.29%-1
980Alex Smith2006SFO442163.62%3.94%-0.32%-1
981Tommy Thompson1950PHI239114.6%5.2%-0.59%-1
982Jay Fiedler2003MIA314113.5%3.96%-0.45%-1
983Kyle Orton2009DEN541213.88%4.15%-0.26%-1
984Dan Marino1990MIA531213.95%4.22%-0.27%-1
985Roger Staubach1976DAL369143.79%4.18%-0.39%-1
986Bobby Layne1950DET336164.76%5.2%-0.43%-1
987Fran Tarkenton1963MIN297155.05%5.54%-0.49%-1
988John Brodie1969SFO347164.61%5.04%-0.42%-1
989Stan Humphries1992SDG454163.52%3.85%-0.32%-1
990Ryan Fitzpatrick2013TEN350144%4.42%-0.42%-1
991Bobby Layne19582TM294144.76%5.27%-0.5%-1
992Y.A. Tittle1948BCL289165.54%6.05%-0.51%-1
993Matt Cassel2011KAN269103.72%4.27%-0.55%-1
994Jake Plummer2006DEN317113.47%3.94%-0.47%-1
995Charley Johnson1962STL308165.19%5.68%-0.48%-1
996Joe Theismann1981WAS496193.83%4.13%-0.3%-1
997Archie Manning1973NOR267103.75%4.31%-0.56%-2
998Jim Finks1954PIT306144.58%5.07%-0.49%-2
999Dave Brown1994NYG350123.43%3.86%-0.43%-2
1000Ryan Leaf2000SDG322113.42%3.89%-0.47%-2
1001Jeff Blake2003ARI367133.54%3.96%-0.42%-2
1002Bobby Layne1955DET270114.07%4.64%-0.56%-2
1003Josh McCown2005ARI27093.33%3.9%-0.57%-2
1004Brett Favre1999GNB595223.7%3.96%-0.26%-2
1005John Hadl1972SDG370154.05%4.47%-0.42%-2
1006Erik Kramer1998CHI25093.6%4.22%-0.62%-2
1007Steve Grogan1989NWE26193.45%4.05%-0.6%-2
1008Adrian Burk1955PHI22893.95%4.64%-0.69%-2
1009Mike Phipps1979CHI25593.53%4.15%-0.62%-2
1010Cam Newton2012CAR485193.92%4.25%-0.33%-2
1011Roman Gabriel1970RAM407163.93%4.33%-0.4%-2
1012Doug Johnson2003ATL24383.29%3.96%-0.67%-2
1013Danny Kanell1998NYG299113.68%4.22%-0.54%-2
1014Ken Anderson1977CIN323113.41%3.91%-0.51%-2
1015Randy Johnson1966ATL295124.07%4.62%-0.56%-2
1016Matt Hasselbeck2002SEA419153.58%3.98%-0.4%-2
1017Ken Anderson1984CIN275103.64%4.25%-0.61%-2
1018Drew Bledsoe1994NWE691253.62%3.86%-0.25%-2
1019Ken O'Brien1988NYJ424153.54%3.94%-0.4%-2
1020Johnny Green1960BUF228104.39%5.14%-0.75%-2
1021Jeff Kemp19912TM29593.05%3.63%-0.58%-2
1022Kent Graham1999NYG27193.32%3.96%-0.64%-2
1023Steve Beuerlein2000CAR533193.56%3.89%-0.32%-2
1024Archie Manning1978NOR471173.61%3.98%-0.37%-2
1025Kyle Orton2010DEN498204.02%4.37%-0.35%-2
1026Kyle Orton20112TM25293.57%4.27%-0.7%-2
1027Bill Troup1978BAL296103.38%3.98%-0.6%-2
1028Terry Bradshaw1972PIT308123.9%4.47%-0.58%-2
1029David Archer1986ATL294103.4%4.01%-0.61%-2
1030Charlie Batch1998DET303113.63%4.22%-0.59%-2
1031Jim Everett1993RAM27482.92%3.58%-0.66%-2
1032Kevin Kolb2011ARI25393.56%4.27%-0.72%-2
1033Kerry Collins2004OAK513214.09%4.45%-0.35%-2
1034Ron Jaworski1986PHI24583.27%4.01%-0.74%-2
1035Tommy Kramer1985MIN506193.75%4.12%-0.36%-2
1036Kyle Boller2003BAL22473.13%3.96%-0.83%-2
1037Johnny Unitas1967BAL436204.59%5.02%-0.43%-2
1038Wade Wilson1993NOR388123.09%3.58%-0.49%-2
1039Dan Orlovsky2008DET25583.14%3.88%-0.74%-2
1040Bill Munson1968DET329154.56%5.14%-0.58%-2
1041Frankie Albert1950SFO306144.58%5.21%-0.63%-2
1042Ed Brown1964PIT272124.41%5.12%-0.71%-2
1043Billy Wade1959RAM261124.6%5.34%-0.74%-2
1044Vinny Testaverde2000NYJ590213.56%3.89%-0.33%-2
1045Ted Marchibroda1956PIT275124.36%5.08%-0.71%-2
1046Y.A. Tittle1949BCL289144.84%5.52%-0.68%-2
1047Kelly Holcomb2003CLE302103.31%3.96%-0.65%-2
1048Scott Brunner1982NYG298103.36%4.02%-0.66%-2
1049Doug Pederson1999PHI22773.08%3.96%-0.87%-2
1050Derek Anderson2008CLE28393.18%3.88%-0.7%-2
1051Stan Humphries1995SDG478173.56%3.97%-0.42%-2
1052Trent Dilfer2005CLE333113.3%3.9%-0.6%-2
1053Carson Palmer2012OAK565223.89%4.25%-0.36%-2
1054Ryan Tannehill2013MIA588244.08%4.42%-0.34%-2
1055Boomer Esiason1991CIN413133.15%3.64%-0.49%-2
1056Alex Smith2011SFO445173.82%4.27%-0.45%-2
1057Josh Freeman2009TAM290103.45%4.15%-0.7%-2
1058Pat Haden1981RAM26793.37%4.14%-0.76%-2
1059Jim Hart1971STL24383.29%4.13%-0.84%-2
1060Mike Livingston1977KAN28293.19%3.92%-0.72%-2
1061Mark Malone1986PIT425153.53%4.01%-0.48%-2
1062Kerry Collins2005OAK565203.54%3.9%-0.36%-2
1063Bob Griese1969MIA252103.97%4.78%-0.81%-2
1064Andy Dalton2011CIN516203.88%4.27%-0.4%-2
1065Archie Manning1972NOR448184.02%4.48%-0.46%-2
1066Jim Harbaugh1997IND309103.24%3.9%-0.67%-2
1067Phil Simms1981NYG316113.48%4.14%-0.65%-2
1068Vince Young2006TEN357123.36%3.94%-0.58%-2
1069Chad Henne2012JAX308113.57%4.25%-0.68%-2
1070George Blanda1953CHI362143.87%4.45%-0.58%-2
1071Patrick Ramsey2004WAS272103.68%4.45%-0.77%-2
1072Chad Pennington2006NYJ485173.51%3.94%-0.44%-2
1073Steve DeBerg1989KAN324113.4%4.06%-0.66%-2
1074Len Dawson1974KAN23572.98%3.89%-0.91%-2
1075Ron Jaworski1984PHI427163.75%4.25%-0.5%-2
1076Jim Hart1970STL373143.75%4.33%-0.58%-2
1077Mike Livingston1976KAN338123.55%4.19%-0.64%-2
1078Vinny Testaverde2001NYJ441153.4%3.89%-0.49%-2
1079Kyle Orton2014BUF447184.03%4.51%-0.49%-2
1080Shaun Hill2010DET416163.85%4.37%-0.52%-2
1081John Elway1992DEN316103.16%3.85%-0.69%-2
1082Norm Van Brocklin1959PHI340164.71%5.35%-0.64%-2
1083Mike Pagel1985IND393143.56%4.12%-0.56%-2
1084Case Keenum2013HOU25393.56%4.43%-0.87%-2
1085Steve McNair1997TEN415143.37%3.9%-0.53%-2
1086Troy Aikman1991DAL363113.03%3.64%-0.61%-2
1087Steve DeBerg1980SFO321123.74%4.43%-0.69%-2
1088Steve Walsh19902TM336123.57%4.23%-0.66%-2
1089Cam Newton2014CAR448184.02%4.51%-0.49%-2
1090Chris Simms2005TAM313103.19%3.9%-0.71%-2
1091Bernie Kosar1985CLE24883.23%4.12%-0.9%-2
1092Andrew Luck2013IND570234.04%4.43%-0.39%-2
1093Mark Brunell2006WAS26083.08%3.95%-0.87%-2
1094Richard Todd1984NOR312113.53%4.25%-0.73%-2
1095Boomer Esiason1996ARI339113.24%3.92%-0.67%-2
1096Shaun Hill2014STL22983.49%4.51%-1.02%-2
1097Bill Kenney1981KAN27493.28%4.14%-0.85%-2
1098Drew Bledsoe1999NWE539193.53%3.96%-0.43%-2
1099Brian Griese2002DEN436153.44%3.98%-0.54%-2
1100Mike Pagel1983BAL328123.66%4.38%-0.72%-2
1101Jim Miller2001CHI395133.29%3.89%-0.6%-2
1102Jim Harbaugh1991CHI478153.14%3.64%-0.5%-2
1103Pete Beathard19672TM23193.9%4.94%-1.04%-2
1104Gus Frerotte1999DET28893.13%3.96%-0.84%-2
1105Bill Kenney1983KAN603243.98%4.38%-0.4%-2
1106Sam Bradford2012STL551213.81%4.25%-0.44%-2
1107Terry Bradshaw1971PIT373133.49%4.14%-0.65%-2
1108Paul Christman1947CRD301175.65%6.46%-0.81%-2
1109Phil Simms1989NYG405143.46%4.06%-0.6%-2
1110Jake Plummer2001ARI525183.43%3.89%-0.47%-2
1111Archie Manning1979NOR420153.57%4.16%-0.58%-2
1112Steve McNair2006BAL468163.42%3.95%-0.53%-2
1113Roman Gabriel1972RAM323123.72%4.48%-0.77%-2
1114Norm Snead1966PHI22683.54%4.64%-1.1%-2
1115Timm Rosenbach1990PHO437163.66%4.23%-0.57%-2
1116Bert Jones1974BAL27082.96%3.89%-0.93%-3
1117David Carr2005HOU423143.31%3.9%-0.6%-3
1118Jon Kitna2006DET596213.52%3.95%-0.42%-3
1119John Friesz1993SDG23862.52%3.58%-1.06%-3
1120Ty Detmer1997PHI24472.87%3.91%-1.04%-3
1121Jacky Lee1964DEN265114.15%5.11%-0.96%-3
1122Christian Ponder2012MIN483183.73%4.25%-0.53%-3
1123Steve Bartkowski1982ATL26283.05%4.02%-0.97%-3
1124Rick Mirer1995SEA391133.32%3.98%-0.65%-3
1125Joe Theismann1978WAS390133.33%3.99%-0.65%-3
1126EJ Manuel2013BUF306113.59%4.43%-0.83%-3
1127John Elway1988DEN496173.43%3.94%-0.52%-3
1128Byron Leftwich2003JAX418143.35%3.96%-0.61%-3
1129Dan Fouts1984SDG507193.75%4.25%-0.51%-3
1130Tommy Maddox2003PIT519183.47%3.96%-0.5%-3
1131Colin Kaepernick2014SFO478193.97%4.51%-0.54%-3
1132Brett Favre2000GNB580203.45%3.89%-0.45%-3
1133Steve McNair2005TEN476163.36%3.91%-0.54%-3
1134Kyle Boller2007BAL27593.27%4.22%-0.94%-3
1135Jeff Garcia2008TAM376123.19%3.89%-0.69%-3
1136Dan Marino1999MIA369123.25%3.96%-0.71%-3
1137Joe Flacco2008BAL428143.27%3.89%-0.61%-3
1138Brady Quinn2009CLE25683.13%4.15%-1.03%-3
1139Joe Ferguson1984BUF344123.49%4.25%-0.77%-3
1140Matthew Stafford2009DET377133.45%4.15%-0.7%-3
1141Steve DeBerg1984TAM509193.73%4.25%-0.52%-3
1142Jim Zorn1978SEA443153.39%3.99%-0.6%-3
1143Tony Banks2000BAL27482.92%3.9%-0.98%-3
1144Warren Moon1996MIN24772.83%3.92%-1.09%-3
1145David Carr2003HOU29593.05%3.96%-0.91%-3
1146Kerry Collins2002NYG545193.49%3.98%-0.5%-3
1147Kellen Clemens2013STL24283.31%4.43%-1.12%-3
1148Andy Dalton2014CIN481193.95%4.52%-0.56%-3
1149Ken Anderson1978CIN319103.13%3.99%-0.85%-3
1150Joe Namath1968NYJ380153.95%4.67%-0.72%-3
1151Gary Marangi1976BUF23273.02%4.19%-1.18%-3
1152Gus Frerotte1995WAS396133.28%3.98%-0.69%-3
1153Randy Wright1986GNB492173.46%4.02%-0.56%-3
1154Joey Harrington2004DET489193.89%4.45%-0.57%-3
1155Joe Kapp1968MIN248104.03%5.15%-1.12%-3
1156Trent Green2005KAN507173.35%3.91%-0.55%-3
1157Phil Simms1980NYG402153.73%4.43%-0.7%-3
1158Tom Brady2013NWE628253.98%4.43%-0.45%-3
1159Brandon Weeden2013CLE26793.37%4.43%-1.06%-3
1160Jim Hart1980STL425163.76%4.43%-0.66%-3
1161Blaine Gabbert2012JAX27893.24%4.25%-1.02%-3
1162Johnny Unitas1963BAL410204.88%5.57%-0.69%-3
1163Matt Ryan2013ATL651263.99%4.43%-0.44%-3
1164Jim Kelly1988BUF452153.32%3.95%-0.63%-3
1165Mark Brunell1996JAX557193.41%3.92%-0.51%-3
1166Bernie Kosar1989CLE513183.51%4.06%-0.55%-3
1167Jon Kitna2002CIN473163.38%3.98%-0.6%-3
1168Chris Miller1988ATL351113.13%3.95%-0.81%-3
1169Jim Zorn1982SEA24572.86%4.03%-1.17%-3
1170Jim McMahon1993MIN33192.72%3.59%-0.87%-3
1171Jim Harbaugh1996IND405133.21%3.92%-0.71%-3
1172Chris Chandler2000ATL331103.02%3.9%-0.88%-3
1173Troy Aikman1989DAL29393.07%4.06%-0.99%-3
1174Cade McNown2000CHI28082.86%3.9%-1.04%-3
1175Jim McMahon1989SDG318103.14%4.06%-0.92%-3
1176Craig Morton1976NYG28493.17%4.2%-1.03%-3
1177Rich Gannon2003OAK22562.67%3.97%-1.3%-3
1178Michael Vick2012PHI351123.42%4.25%-0.84%-3
1179Kerry Collins19982TM353123.4%4.23%-0.83%-3
1180David Klingler1994CIN23162.6%3.87%-1.27%-3
1181Kordell Stewart2003CHI25172.79%3.97%-1.18%-3
1182Alex Smith2014KAN464183.88%4.52%-0.64%-3
1183Donovan McNabb2003PHI478163.35%3.97%-0.62%-3
1184Chad Hutchinson2002DAL25072.8%3.98%-1.18%-3
1185John Elway1985DEN605223.64%4.13%-0.49%-3
1186Dan Pastorini1976HOU309103.24%4.2%-0.96%-3
1187Randall Cunningham1994PHI490163.27%3.87%-0.61%-3
1188Ron Jaworski1985PHI484173.51%4.13%-0.61%-3
1189Damon Huard2007KAN332113.31%4.22%-0.9%-3
1190Jim Hart1978STL477163.35%3.99%-0.64%-3
1191Quincy Carter2003DAL505173.37%3.97%-0.6%-3
1192Rodney Peete1993DET25262.38%3.59%-1.21%-3
1193Roger Staubach1974DAL360113.06%3.9%-0.84%-3
1194Jason Campbell2013CLE317113.47%4.43%-0.96%-3
1195John Reaves1972PHI22473.13%4.49%-1.36%-3
1196Charlie Batch2000DET412133.16%3.9%-0.74%-3
1197Al Dorow1961NYT438194.34%5.04%-0.7%-3
1198Virgil Carter1970CIN27893.24%4.34%-1.1%-3
1199Bart Starr1970GNB25583.14%4.34%-1.2%-3
1200David Whitehurst1978GNB328103.05%3.99%-0.94%-3
1201Doug Williams1980TAM521203.84%4.43%-0.59%-3
1202Joe Montana1994KAN493163.25%3.87%-0.63%-3
1203Joe Theismann1980WAS454173.74%4.43%-0.69%-3
1204Drew Brees2003SDG356113.09%3.97%-0.88%-3
1205Jake Plummer2002ARI530183.4%3.99%-0.59%-3
1206Mark Sanchez2009NYJ364123.3%4.16%-0.86%-3
1207John Elway1994DEN494163.24%3.87%-0.63%-3
1208Kerry Collins2001NYG568193.35%3.9%-0.55%-3
1209Aaron Brooks2004NOR542213.87%4.46%-0.58%-3
1210David Woodley1981MIA366123.28%4.14%-0.86%-3
1211Norm Snead1973NYG23572.98%4.33%-1.35%-3
1212Matt Schaub2007HOU28993.11%4.22%-1.1%-3
1213Joe Flacco2011BAL542203.69%4.28%-0.59%-3
1214Lynn Dickey1976GNB24372.88%4.2%-1.32%-3
1215Elvis Grbac2001BAL467153.21%3.9%-0.69%-3
1216Troy Aikman2000DAL26272.67%3.9%-1.23%-3
1217Jim Harbaugh1990CHI312103.21%4.24%-1.03%-3
1218Brad Johnson2000WAS365113.01%3.9%-0.88%-3
1219Kerry Collins1995CAR433143.23%3.98%-0.75%-3
1220Kordell Stewart2001PIT442143.17%3.9%-0.73%-3
1221Eric Hipple1986DET30592.95%4.02%-1.07%-3
1222Craig Whelihan1997SDG23762.53%3.91%-1.38%-3
1223Jim Plunkett1973NWE376133.46%4.33%-0.87%-3
1224Matt Hasselbeck2009SEA488173.48%4.16%-0.67%-3
1225Steve Walsh1994CHI343102.92%3.87%-0.96%-3
1226Todd Collins1997BUF391123.07%3.91%-0.84%-3
1227Billy Joe Tolliver1994HOU24062.5%3.87%-1.37%-3
1228Joey Harrington2006MIA388123.09%3.95%-0.86%-3
1229Pete Liske1970DEN23872.94%4.34%-1.4%-3
1230Jack Kemp1961SDG364154.12%5.05%-0.92%-3
1231Jake Locker2012TEN314103.18%4.26%-1.07%-3
1232Johnny Green1962NYT258103.88%5.18%-1.31%-3
1233Bob Avellini1976CHI27182.95%4.2%-1.25%-3
1234Doug Williams1982TAM30792.93%4.03%-1.1%-3
1235Trent Green2001KAN523173.25%3.9%-0.65%-3
1236Bill Munson1974DET29282.74%3.9%-1.16%-3
1237Brooks Bollinger2005NYJ26672.63%3.91%-1.28%-3
1238David Whitehurst1979GNB322103.11%4.16%-1.06%-3
1239Tarvaris Jackson2007MIN29493.06%4.22%-1.16%-3
1240Bob Gagliano1989DET23262.59%4.07%-1.48%-3
1241Greg Landry1977DET24062.5%3.93%-1.43%-3
1242John Elway1991DEN451132.88%3.65%-0.76%-3
1243Neil O'Donnell1993PIT486142.88%3.59%-0.71%-3
1244Brodie Croyle2007KAN22462.68%4.22%-1.54%-3
1245Jim Zorn1981SEA397133.27%4.15%-0.87%-3
1246Tom Flores1961OAK366154.1%5.05%-0.95%-3
1247Mark Brunell1999JAX441143.17%3.97%-0.79%-3
1248Bobby Layne1956DET24493.69%5.13%-1.44%-4
1249Trent Edwards2008BUF374112.94%3.89%-0.95%-4
1250Mark Brunell2004WAS23772.95%4.46%-1.5%-4
1251Jack Kemp1969BUF344133.78%4.82%-1.04%-4
1252Geno Smith2014NYJ367133.54%4.52%-0.98%-4
1253Milt Plum1962DET325154.62%5.72%-1.11%-4
1254Christian Ponder2013MIN23972.93%4.43%-1.5%-4
1255Rex Grossman2011WAS458163.49%4.28%-0.79%-4
1256Bubby Brister1988PIT370112.97%3.95%-0.98%-4
1257Dave Brown1996NYG398123.02%3.93%-0.91%-4
1258Billy Joe Tolliver1999NOR26872.61%3.97%-1.36%-4
1259Joe Ferguson1982BUF26472.65%4.04%-1.39%-4
1260Kurt Warner2005ARI375112.93%3.91%-0.98%-4
1261John Hadl19742TM29982.68%3.91%-1.23%-4
1262Andrew Luck2012IND627233.67%4.26%-0.59%-4
1263Drew Bledsoe2000NWE531173.2%3.9%-0.7%-4
1264Jim Everett1987RAM302103.31%4.54%-1.23%-4
1265Brett Favre2005GNB607203.29%3.91%-0.62%-4
1266Dave Wilson1986NOR342102.92%4.02%-1.1%-4
1267Rick Mirer1994SEA381112.89%3.88%-0.99%-4
1268Josh McCown2014TAM327113.36%4.52%-1.16%-4
1269Stan Humphries1997SDG22552.22%3.91%-1.69%-4
1270Drew Stanton2014ARI24072.92%4.52%-1.6%-4
1271Stan Gelbaugh1992SEA25562.35%3.87%-1.51%-4
1272Aaron Brooks2005NOR431133.02%3.91%-0.9%-4
1273Billy Wade1964CHI327133.98%5.16%-1.18%-4
1274Jeff Garcia1999SFO375112.93%3.97%-1.04%-4
1275Vinny Testaverde1991TAM32682.45%3.65%-1.2%-4
1276John Brodie1966SFO427163.75%4.66%-0.91%-4
1277Daunte Culpepper2002MIN549183.28%3.99%-0.71%-4
1278Matt Leinart2006ARI377112.92%3.96%-1.04%-4
1279Kerry Collins1997CAR381112.89%3.91%-1.03%-4
1280Neil Lomax1986STL421133.09%4.02%-0.94%-4
1281Brian Griese1999DEN452143.1%3.97%-0.87%-4
1282Mike Phipps1973CLE29993.01%4.34%-1.33%-4
1283Dennis Shaw1970BUF321103.12%4.35%-1.24%-4
1284Bruce Gradkowski2006TAM32892.74%3.96%-1.21%-4
1285Drew Brees2002SDG526173.23%3.99%-0.76%-4
1286Boomer Esiason1987CIN440163.64%4.54%-0.91%-4
1287Dave Krieg1990SEA448153.35%4.24%-0.89%-4
1288Earl Morrall1957PIT289113.81%5.2%-1.39%-4
1289Greg Landry1979BAL457153.28%4.17%-0.89%-4
1290Norm Snead1968PHI291113.78%5.17%-1.39%-4
1291Steve DeBerg1978SFO30282.65%4%-1.35%-4
1292Ken Dorsey2004SFO22662.65%4.46%-1.81%-4
1293Kerry Collins2008TEN415122.89%3.89%-1%-4
1294Tommy Kramer1980MIN522193.64%4.44%-0.8%-4
1295Teddy Bridgewater2014MIN402143.48%4.52%-1.04%-4
1296Gary Cuozzo1970MIN25772.72%4.35%-1.63%-4
1297Matt Hasselbeck2011TEN518183.47%4.29%-0.81%-4
1298Steve Fuller1980KAN320103.13%4.44%-1.31%-4
1299Archie Manning1974NOR26162.3%3.91%-1.61%-4
1300Dan Pastorini1971HOU27072.59%4.16%-1.56%-4
1301Roman Gabriel1974PHI33892.66%3.91%-1.25%-4
1302Robert Griffin2013WAS456163.51%4.44%-0.93%-4
1303Richard Todd1980NYJ479173.55%4.44%-0.89%-4
1304Don Majkowski1988GNB33692.68%3.96%-1.28%-4
1305Billy Kilmer1970NOR23762.53%4.35%-1.82%-4
1306Bart Starr1962GNB285124.21%5.74%-1.53%-4
1307Jeff Komlo1979DET368112.99%4.17%-1.18%-4
1308Bobby Douglass1971CHI22552.22%4.16%-1.94%-4
1309Joe Montana1986SFO30782.61%4.03%-1.42%-4
1310Bobby Layne1962PIT23393.86%5.74%-1.87%-4
1311Trent Edwards2007BUF26972.6%4.23%-1.62%-4
1312Bernie Kosar1986CLE531173.2%4.03%-0.83%-4
1313Zeke Bratkowski1961RAM23083.48%5.38%-1.91%-4
1314John Elway1983DEN25972.7%4.4%-1.69%-4
1315Jack Kemp1967BUF369143.79%4.99%-1.2%-4
1316Jack Trudeau1987IND22962.62%4.55%-1.93%-4
1317Anthony Wright2005BAL26662.26%3.92%-1.66%-4
1318Curtis Painter2011IND24362.47%4.29%-1.82%-4
1319Jeff Blake1997CIN31782.52%3.92%-1.39%-4
1320Rudy Bukich1966CHI309103.24%4.67%-1.43%-4
1321Joe Theismann1985WAS30182.66%4.14%-1.48%-4
1322Ken O'Brien1990NYJ411133.16%4.25%-1.08%-4
1323Tony Banks2001WAS370102.7%3.91%-1.2%-4
1324Danny White1987DAL362123.31%4.55%-1.23%-4
1325Tim Rattay2004SFO325103.08%4.46%-1.39%-5
1326Matt Cassel2009KAN493163.25%4.16%-0.92%-5
1327Y.A. Tittle1964NYG281103.56%5.17%-1.61%-5
1328Randy Johnson1967ATL288103.47%5.06%-1.59%-5
1329John McCormick1965DEN25372.77%4.59%-1.82%-5
1330Johnny Unitas1969BAL327123.67%5.09%-1.42%-5
1331Archie Manning1981NOR23252.16%4.15%-2%-5
1332George Ratterman1948BUF335164.78%6.17%-1.4%-5
1333Ken Stabler1983NOR31192.89%4.4%-1.5%-5
1334Jim Zorn1980SEA488173.48%4.44%-0.96%-5
1335Byron Leftwich2004JAX441153.4%4.46%-1.06%-5
1336Brett Favre2010MIN358113.07%4.38%-1.31%-5
1337Erik Kramer1997CHI477142.94%3.92%-0.98%-5
1338Jim Harbaugh1993CHI32572.15%3.6%-1.45%-5
1339Craig Morton1975NYG363113.03%4.34%-1.31%-5
1340Cliff Stoudt1983PIT381123.15%4.4%-1.25%-5
1341Mark Malone1988SDG27262.21%3.96%-1.75%-5
1342Steve Bartkowski1978ATL369102.71%4%-1.29%-5
1343Pat Haden1978RAM444132.93%4%-1.08%-5
1344Dave Krieg1995ARI521163.07%3.99%-0.92%-5
1345Richard Todd1983NYJ518183.47%4.4%-0.92%-5
1346Cotton Davidson1960DTX379153.96%5.23%-1.27%-5
1347David Carr2004HOU466163.43%4.47%-1.03%-5
1348Tobin Rote1950GNB22473.13%5.28%-2.15%-5
1349Jeff George1992IND30672.29%3.87%-1.59%-5
1350Norm Van Brocklin1955RAM27282.94%4.73%-1.79%-5
1351Ken O'Brien1987NYJ393133.31%4.55%-1.24%-5
1352A.J. Feeley2004MIA356113.09%4.47%-1.38%-5
1353Steve Beuerlein1994ARI25551.96%3.88%-1.92%-5
1354Glenn Dobbs1946BDA269134.83%6.66%-1.83%-5
1355Kordell Stewart1999PIT27562.18%3.98%-1.79%-5
1356Bubby Brister1989PIT34292.63%4.08%-1.44%-5
1357Billy Wade1963CHI356154.21%5.61%-1.39%-5
1358Marc Bulger2007STL378112.91%4.23%-1.32%-5
1359Joe Namath1966NYJ471194.03%5.1%-1.06%-5
1360Rich Gannon1998KAN354102.82%4.25%-1.42%-5
1361Eric Hipple1983DET387123.1%4.4%-1.3%-5
1362Norm Van Brocklin1958PHI374154.01%5.36%-1.35%-5
1363Joey Harrington2003DET554173.07%3.98%-0.91%-5
1364Fran Tarkenton1971NYG386112.85%4.17%-1.32%-5
1365Terrelle Pryor2013OAK27272.57%4.44%-1.87%-5
1366Gary Huff1974CHI28362.12%3.92%-1.8%-5
1367Tony Banks1997STL487142.87%3.92%-1.05%-5
1368Vinny Testaverde2004DAL495173.43%4.47%-1.03%-5
1369Rusty Hilger1988DET30672.29%3.96%-1.67%-5
1370Joe Ferguson1979BUF458143.06%4.18%-1.12%-5
1371Bill Munson1965RAM267103.75%5.67%-1.93%-5
1372Joey Harrington2002DET429122.8%4%-1.2%-5
1373Kerry Collins1999NYG33182.42%3.98%-1.56%-5
1374Sonny Jurgensen1965WAS356154.21%5.67%-1.46%-5
1375Jim Finks1953PIT29282.74%4.52%-1.78%-5
1376Steve Bono1996KAN438122.74%3.94%-1.2%-5
1377Mark Sanchez2010NYJ507173.35%4.39%-1.03%-5
1378Randy Wright1987GNB24762.43%4.55%-2.12%-5
1379Jay Schroeder1994ARI23841.68%3.89%-2.21%-5
1380Charley Johnson1970HOU28172.49%4.36%-1.87%-5
1381Matthew Stafford2014DET602223.65%4.53%-0.87%-5
1382Marc Wilson1990NWE26562.26%4.25%-1.99%-5
1383Don Majkowski1991GNB22631.33%3.66%-2.33%-5
1384Steve Fuller1979KAN27062.22%4.18%-1.96%-5
1385Marc Bulger2009STL24752.02%4.17%-2.14%-5
1386Nick Foles2012PHI26562.26%4.27%-2%-5
1387Tarvaris Jackson2011SEA450143.11%4.29%-1.18%-5
1388Warren Moon1994MIN601183%3.89%-0.89%-5
1389Jake Delhomme2009CAR32182.49%4.17%-1.68%-5
1390Doug Flutie2001SDG521152.88%3.91%-1.03%-5
1391Rick Mirer1996SEA26551.89%3.94%-2.05%-5
1392Jeff Hostetler1991NYG28551.75%3.66%-1.91%-5
1393Kyle Orton2005CHI36892.45%3.92%-1.48%-5
1394Bruce Mathison1985BUF22841.75%4.14%-2.39%-5
1395Chris Miller1989ATL526163.04%4.08%-1.04%-5
1396Vinny Testaverde1988TAM466132.79%3.96%-1.17%-5
1397Milt Plum1965DET308123.9%5.68%-1.78%-5
1398Dan Marino1997MIA548162.92%3.92%-1.01%-6
1399Rick Mirer1993SEA486122.47%3.6%-1.14%-6
1400Rex Grossman2007CHI22541.78%4.23%-2.45%-6
1401Joe Pisarcik1977NYG24141.66%3.95%-2.29%-6
1402Tom Tupa1991PHO31561.9%3.66%-1.76%-6
1403Charlie Frye2006CLE392102.55%3.97%-1.41%-6
1404Gary Danielson1980DET417133.12%4.45%-1.33%-6
1405Matt Hasselbeck2001SEA32172.18%3.91%-1.73%-6
1406Kellen Clemens2007NYJ25052%4.23%-2.23%-6
1407Mark Rypien1992WAS479132.71%3.88%-1.17%-6
1408Jake Plummer2000ARI475132.74%3.91%-1.18%-6
1409Bob Avellini1978CHI26451.89%4.01%-2.12%-6
1410Craig Whelihan1998SDG32082.5%4.25%-1.75%-6
1411Kent Nix1967PIT26882.99%5.08%-2.09%-6
1412Ed Luther1983SDG28772.44%4.41%-1.97%-6
1413Jason Campbell2007WAS417122.88%4.23%-1.36%-6
1414Randy Wright1988GNB24441.64%3.97%-2.33%-6
1415Joe Namath1976NYJ23041.74%4.22%-2.49%-6
1416Blaine Gabbert2011JAX413122.91%4.3%-1.39%-6
1417Billy Wade1962CHI412184.37%5.76%-1.39%-6
1418Jon Kitna2007DET561183.21%4.23%-1.03%-6
1419Tobin Rote1954GNB382143.66%5.17%-1.51%-6
1420Babe Parilli1963BOS337133.86%5.57%-1.71%-6
1421Wade Wilson1989MIN36292.49%4.08%-1.6%-6
1422John Hadl1969SDG324103.09%4.87%-1.79%-6
1423Kent Graham1997ARI25041.6%3.93%-2.33%-6
1424Neil Lomax1981STL23641.69%4.16%-2.47%-6
1425Matt Cassel2012KAN27762.17%4.27%-2.1%-6
1426John Friesz1991SDG487122.46%3.66%-1.2%-6
1427Colt McCoy2011CLE463143.02%4.3%-1.27%-6
1428David Garrard2008JAX535152.8%3.91%-1.1%-6
1429Steve McNair1998TEN492153.05%4.25%-1.2%-6
1430Matt Schaub2013HOU358102.79%4.45%-1.65%-6
1431David Archer1985ATL31272.24%4.15%-1.9%-6
1432Hugh Millen1991NWE40992.2%3.66%-1.46%-6
1433Troy Aikman1990DAL399112.76%4.26%-1.5%-6
1434Joe Ferguson1977BUF457122.63%3.96%-1.33%-6
1435Steve Spurrier1976TAM31172.25%4.23%-1.98%-6
1436Frank Tripucka1962DEN440173.86%5.26%-1.4%-6
1437Derek Carr2014OAK599213.51%4.53%-1.03%-6
1438Jake Plummer1999ARI38192.36%3.98%-1.62%-6
1439Marc Bulger2008STL440112.5%3.91%-1.41%-6
1440Gary Cuozzo1967NOR26072.69%5.09%-2.39%-6
1441Ken Anderson1980CIN27562.18%4.45%-2.27%-6
1442Jake Plummer1998ARI547173.11%4.25%-1.15%-6
1443Jim Everett1996NOR464122.59%3.94%-1.36%-6
1444Lynn Dickey1980GNB478153.14%4.46%-1.32%-6
1445Y.A. Tittle1954SFO29593.05%5.19%-2.13%-6
1446Troy Aikman1996DAL465122.58%3.94%-1.36%-6
1447Brett Favre2006GNB613182.94%3.97%-1.03%-6
1448Mark Sanchez2012NYJ453132.87%4.27%-1.4%-6
1449David Klingler1993CIN34361.75%3.61%-1.86%-6
1450John Elway1990DEN502152.99%4.26%-1.27%-6
1451Jim Ninowski1961DET24772.83%5.42%-2.59%-6
1452Kurt Warner2004NYG27762.17%4.48%-2.31%-6
1453John Brodie1964SFO392143.57%5.21%-1.64%-6
1454Jim Finks1955PIT344102.91%4.77%-1.86%-6
1455Eli Manning2013NYG551183.27%4.45%-1.18%-7
1456Chad Henne2010MIA490153.06%4.39%-1.33%-7
1457Gus Frerotte1996WAS470122.55%3.94%-1.39%-7
1458Dan Pastorini1972HOU29972.34%4.53%-2.19%-7
1459Ryan Fitzpatrick2008CIN37282.15%3.91%-1.76%-7
1460David Garrard2009JAX516152.91%4.18%-1.27%-7
1461David Carr2006HOU442112.49%3.97%-1.48%-7
1462Jim Zorn1976SEA439122.73%4.23%-1.5%-7
1463Todd Blackledge1984KAN29462.04%4.28%-2.24%-7
1464Dan Fouts1987SDG364102.75%4.56%-1.82%-7
1465Ken Anderson1972CIN30172.33%4.53%-2.2%-7
1466Brian Sipe1981CLE567173%4.17%-1.17%-7
1467Mike Livingston1978KAN29051.72%4.02%-2.3%-7
1468Steve Young1986TAM36382.2%4.04%-1.84%-7
1469Jeff George1993IND40781.97%3.61%-1.65%-7
1470Warren Moon1986HOU488132.66%4.04%-1.38%-7
1471Donovan McNabb2010WAS472142.97%4.4%-1.43%-7
1472John Brodie1967SFO349113.15%5.09%-1.94%-7
1473Jason Campbell2008WAS506132.57%3.91%-1.34%-7
1474Johnny Unitas1961BAL420163.81%5.43%-1.62%-7
1475Jim Hart1979STL37892.38%4.19%-1.81%-7
1476Chad Henne2009MIA451122.66%4.18%-1.52%-7
1477Vince Ferragamo1985BUF28751.74%4.15%-2.41%-7
1478Kerry Collins2003NYG500132.6%3.99%-1.39%-7
1479Jim Everett1991RAM490112.24%3.67%-1.43%-7
1480Rodney Peete1995PHI37582.13%4%-1.87%-7
1481Trent Dilfer1996TAM482122.49%3.95%-1.46%-7
1482Cleo Lemon2007MIA30961.94%4.24%-2.3%-7
1483Paul McDonald1984CLE493142.84%4.29%-1.45%-7
1484Bobby Layne1949NYY29993.01%5.41%-2.4%-7
1485Vince Evans1981CHI436112.52%4.17%-1.65%-7
1486Vince Young2007TEN38292.36%4.24%-1.89%-7
1487Steve DeBerg1979SFO578172.94%4.19%-1.25%-7
1488Dave Brown1995NYG456112.41%4%-1.59%-7
1489Josh McCown2004ARI408112.7%4.48%-1.78%-7
1490JaMarcus Russell2009OAK24631.22%4.18%-2.96%-7
1491Lamar McHan1954CRD25562.35%5.21%-2.86%-7
1492Warren Moon1984HOU450122.67%4.29%-1.62%-7
1493Steve Pelluer1986DAL37882.12%4.05%-1.93%-7
1494Jim Harbaugh1999SDG434102.3%3.99%-1.69%-7
1495Derek Anderson2010ARI32772.14%4.4%-2.26%-7
1496Ken Stabler1980HOU457132.84%4.46%-1.62%-7
1497Bill Nelsen1965PIT27082.96%5.72%-2.75%-7
1498Akili Smith2000CIN26731.12%3.92%-2.8%-7
1499Norm Snead1963WAS363133.58%5.66%-2.07%-8
1500Ken O'Brien1989NYJ477122.52%4.09%-1.58%-8
1501Matt Hasselbeck2010SEA444122.7%4.4%-1.7%-8
1502Mark Rypien1993WAS31941.25%3.62%-2.36%-8
1503Dan Pastorini1973HOU29051.72%4.38%-2.65%-8
1504Josh Freeman2011TAM551162.9%4.31%-1.4%-8
1505Geno Smith2013NYJ443122.71%4.46%-1.75%-8
1506Archie Manning1975NOR33872.07%4.37%-2.3%-8
1507Joey Harrington2007ATL34872.01%4.25%-2.23%-8
1508Frank Tripucka1961DEN344102.91%5.17%-2.26%-8
1509Kyle Boller2004BAL464132.8%4.48%-1.68%-8
1510Drew Bledsoe2003BUF471112.34%4%-1.66%-8
1511Jeff George1991IND485102.06%3.68%-1.62%-8
1512Dick Wood1966MIA23041.74%5.17%-3.43%-8
1513Brian Hoyer2014CLE438122.74%4.54%-1.8%-8
1514Don Meredith1964DAL32392.79%5.23%-2.45%-8
1515Roman Gabriel1963RAM28182.85%5.66%-2.82%-8
1516Davey O'Brien1940PHI27751.81%4.67%-2.87%-8
1517Sam Bradford2010STL590183.05%4.4%-1.35%-8
1518Andrew Walter2006OAK27631.09%3.98%-2.89%-8
1519Ken O'Brien1991NYJ489102.04%3.68%-1.63%-8
1520Chuck Long1987DET416112.64%4.57%-1.93%-8
1521Scott Brunner1983NYG38692.33%4.42%-2.09%-8
1522Bernie Kosar1990CLE423102.36%4.27%-1.91%-8
1523Browning Nagle1992NYJ38771.81%3.9%-2.09%-8
1524Jim Plunkett1972NWE35582.25%4.55%-2.29%-8
1525Brandon Weeden2012CLE517142.71%4.28%-1.58%-8
1526Pete Beathard1969HOU370102.7%4.94%-2.23%-8
1527Jack Kemp1965BUF391102.56%4.69%-2.13%-8
1528Joe Flacco2013BAL614193.09%4.46%-1.37%-8
1529Ryan Leaf1998SDG24520.82%4.27%-3.45%-8
1530Brad Johnson2006MIN43992.05%3.98%-1.93%-8
1531Kordell Stewart1998PIT458112.4%4.27%-1.87%-9
1532Steve Dils1983MIN444112.48%4.43%-1.95%-9
1533Jack Kemp1963BUF384133.39%5.66%-2.27%-9
1534Ryan Tannehill2012MIA484122.48%4.29%-1.81%-9
1535Gary Hogeboom1984DAL36771.91%4.3%-2.39%-9
1536Roman Gabriel1966RAM397102.52%4.74%-2.22%-9
1537David Carr2002HOU44492.03%4.02%-1.99%-9
1538Jack Trudeau1986IND41781.92%4.06%-2.14%-9
1539Y.A. Tittle1950BAL31582.54%5.38%-2.84%-9
1540Brad Johnson2001TAM559132.33%3.94%-1.61%-9
1541Jack Kemp1966BUF389112.83%5.2%-2.38%-9
1542Mark Malone1987PIT33661.79%4.58%-2.8%-9
1543Sam Bradford2011STL35761.68%4.32%-2.64%-9
1544Chad Henne2013JAX503132.58%4.47%-1.88%-9
1545John Hadl1975GNB35361.7%4.39%-2.69%-9
1546Norm Snead1961WAS375112.93%5.48%-2.55%-10
1547Bobby Hoying1998PHI22400%4.27%-4.27%-10
1548Johnny Lujack1950CHI25441.57%5.4%-3.82%-10
1549Mike Phipps1975CLE31341.28%4.39%-3.11%-10
1550George Blanda1964HOU505173.37%5.3%-1.93%-10
1551Bud Schwenk1947BCL327133.98%7%-3.02%-10
1552Jimmy Clausen2010CAR29931%4.42%-3.41%-10
1553Cotton Davidson19622TM32172.18%5.38%-3.2%-10
1554Chris Weinke2001CAR540112.04%3.94%-1.91%-10
1555Tony Banks1998STL40871.72%4.28%-2.56%-10
1556Blake Bortles2014JAX475112.32%4.56%-2.24%-11
1557Karl Sweetan1966DET30941.29%4.77%-3.48%-11
1558Jon Kitna2001CIN581122.07%3.95%-1.88%-11
1559Bud Schwenk1942CRD29562.03%5.79%-3.76%-11
1560Matthew Stafford2012DET727202.75%4.3%-1.55%-11
1561Drew Bledsoe1995NWE636132.04%4.04%-1.99%-13
1562Trent Dilfer1995TAM41540.96%4.04%-3.07%-13
1563Jim Ninowski1960DET28320.71%5.59%-4.88%-14

Peyton Manning may have broken the touchdown record in 2013, but it took him 162 more attempts to throw six more touchdowns than in 2004. He ended the 2004 season with a 9.86% touchdown rate, which remains the highest rate since 1961. With his incredible scoring rate, and his huge volume lead over the five players with higher rates, Manning earns the top spot for his second MVP season.

In 2007, Tom Brady and the juggernaut Patriots humiliated opposing defenses on their way to the top of the record books. On a per attempt basis, Brady’s performance actually rates higher than Manning’s 55 touchdown output in 2013. However, because Brady threw over 80 fewer passes, his magical season ranks just a hair shy (if a hair equals 0.268 marginal touchdowns) of what Manning did in 2004.

When Manning broke the single season touchdown record in 2004, he wore the crown for three seasons. Brady, for his part, wore it for six. When Dan Marino broke Y.A. Tittle’s record in 1984 (by 33 percent!), he held on to it for twenty years, despite a general upward trend in passing numbers over that time frame. Two years later, he posted just the second season in history with more than forty passing touchdowns. In between that, all he did was throw three touchdowns against the vaunted Chicago defense and allow Mercury Morris to pop the champagne. Marino’s ’84 and ’86 seasons both crack the top eight in marginal touchdown passes.

Although I set high thresholds to weed out the insane variance that comes with low attempt seasons, I like to highlight at least one season that didn’t make the cut. This time around, Sid Luckman’s 1943 is that season. He threw 28 touchdowns on just 202 passes – good for a 13.9% touchdown rate. This was nearly eight percentage points better than the rest of the league and resulted in him earning 16 marginal touchdowns. Not bad.

Career Stats

The next table contains the same information, but for the entire playing careers of the 222 qualifying passers. Read it thus: The same way as the other one. As always, the full table is available, but by default, only the top 10 are shown.

RkQuarterbackAttTDTD%LMP TD%Marg TD%Marg TD
1Peyton Manning90495305.86%4.06%1.8%162
2Brett Favre101695085%3.94%1.05%107
3Tom Brady71683925.47%4.13%1.34%96
4Dan Marino83584205.03%3.98%1.05%88
5Drew Brees74583965.31%4.14%1.17%88
6Aaron Rodgers34752266.5%4.17%2.34%81
7Steve Young41492325.59%3.86%1.73%72
8Len Dawson37412396.39%4.51%1.88%70
9Tony Romo42102425.75%4.17%1.58%66
10Philip Rivers46782525.39%4.19%1.2%56
11Joe Montana53912735.06%4.08%0.98%53
12Terry Bradshaw39012125.43%4.13%1.31%51
13Jim Kelly47792374.96%3.9%1.06%50
14Daryle Lamonica25301616.36%4.42%1.94%49
15Dave Krieg53112614.91%4.01%0.9%48
16Kurt Warner40702085.11%3.96%1.15%47
17Bob Griese34291925.6%4.25%1.35%46
18Fran Tarkenton64673425.29%4.6%0.69%45
19Sonny Jurgensen42622555.98%4.94%1.05%45
20Ben Roethlisberger49542515.07%4.2%0.87%43
21Boomer Esiason52052474.75%3.94%0.8%42
22Frank Ryan21331496.99%5.07%1.91%41
23Sid Luckman16931327.8%5.52%2.28%39
24Ken Stabler37931945.11%4.12%0.99%38
25Otto Graham26261746.63%5.27%1.36%36
26Randall Cunningham42892074.83%4.01%0.82%35
27John Hadl46872445.21%4.48%0.72%34
28Steve Grogan35931825.07%4.13%0.94%34
29Roger Staubach29581535.17%4.07%1.1%33
30Danny White28471525.34%4.21%1.12%32
31George Blanda36492095.73%4.88%0.85%31
32Johnny Unitas51862905.59%5.02%0.57%30
33Earl Morrall26111606.13%5%1.13%29
34Frankie Albert15641157.35%5.47%1.88%29
35Norm Van Brocklin28951735.98%4.99%0.98%28
36Arnie Herber1051757.14%4.46%2.67%28
37Charlie Conerly28331736.11%5.12%0.99%28
38Eli Manning56092594.62%4.18%0.44%24
39Sammy Baugh29951876.24%5.47%0.78%23
40Dan Fouts56042544.53%4.16%0.38%21
41Warren Moon68232914.26%3.96%0.31%21
42Daunte Culpepper31991494.66%4.01%0.65%21
43Craig Morton37861834.83%4.29%0.54%21
44Jay Cutler38711834.73%4.21%0.52%20
45Billy Kilmer29711515.08%4.43%0.65%19
46Bert Jones25511244.86%4.11%0.75%19
47Carson Palmer49062244.57%4.2%0.37%18
48Steve Beuerlein33281474.42%3.88%0.54%18
49Russell Wilson1252725.75%4.36%1.39%17
50Donovan McNabb53742344.35%4.04%0.32%17
51Don Meredith23081355.85%5.17%0.68%16
52Jeff Garcia36761614.38%3.96%0.42%15
53Rich Gannon42061804.28%3.92%0.36%15
54Tommy Thompson1424916.39%5.38%1.01%14
55Mark Rypien26131154.4%3.86%0.54%14
56Matt Ryan39161814.62%4.27%0.36%14
57Babe Parilli33301785.35%4.93%0.42%14
58George Ratterman1396916.52%5.54%0.98%14
59Bobby Hebert31211354.33%3.9%0.43%13
60Y.A. Tittle43952425.51%5.21%0.3%13
61Chris Chandler40051704.24%3.92%0.33%13
62Steve Bartkowski34561564.51%4.16%0.36%12
63Eddie LeBaron17961045.79%5.12%0.67%12
64Bob Berry1173645.46%4.46%1%12
65Ken Anderson44751974.4%4.15%0.25%11
66Brian Sipe34391544.48%4.15%0.33%11
67Trent Green37401624.33%4.04%0.3%11
68John Elway72503004.14%3.99%0.15%11
69Lynn Dickey31251414.51%4.18%0.33%10
70Joe Theismann36021604.44%4.16%0.28%10
71Jim Plunkett37011644.43%4.17%0.26%10
72Phil Simms46471994.28%4.07%0.21%10
73Jim Everett49232034.12%3.93%0.19%9
74Chris Miller28921234.25%3.93%0.32%9
75Ron Jaworski41171794.35%4.13%0.22%9
76Bob Waterfield1617976%5.45%0.55%9
77Joe Ferguson45191964.34%4.14%0.2%9
78Tom Flores1715935.42%4.92%0.5%9
79Vinny Testaverde67012754.1%3.98%0.13%8
80Tommy Kramer36511594.35%4.14%0.22%8
81Vince Ferragamo1615764.71%4.22%0.48%8
82Andy Dalton2111994.69%4.34%0.35%7
83Brian Griese27961194.26%4%0.26%7
84Jake Delhomme29321264.3%4.06%0.24%7
85Bobby Layne37001965.3%5.11%0.19%7
86Andrew Luck1813864.74%4.37%0.37%7
87Bill Nelsen1905985.14%4.79%0.36%7
88Jeff Blake32411344.13%3.93%0.21%7
89Charley Johnson33921705.01%4.85%0.16%5
90Jeff Hostetler2338944.02%3.81%0.21%5
91Neil Lomax31531364.31%4.16%0.15%5
92Aaron Brooks29631234.15%4.01%0.14%4
93Scott Mitchell2346954.05%3.87%0.18%4
94Joe Namath37621734.6%4.49%0.11%4
95Al Dorow1207645.3%4.98%0.32%4
96Elvis Grbac2445994.05%3.92%0.13%3
97Bill Kenney24301054.32%4.21%0.11%3
98Bobby Thomason1346685.05%4.87%0.18%2
99Jay Schroeder28081144.06%3.97%0.09%2
100Chad Pennington24711024.13%4.03%0.1%2
101Erik Kramer2299924%3.91%0.09%2
102Wade Wilson2428994.08%4%0.08%2
103Tobin Rote29071485.09%5.03%0.06%2
104Jay Fiedler1717694.02%3.97%0.05%1
105Colin Kaepernick1117504.48%4.42%0.06%1
106Jeff George39671543.88%3.87%0.01%1
107Greg Landry2300984.26%4.24%0.02%1
108Tommy Maddox1200484%3.96%0.04%0
109Gary Danielson1932814.19%4.17%0.02%0
110Doug Flutie2151864%3.99%0.01%0
111Michael Vick31511314.16%4.15%0.01%0
112Craig Erickson1092413.75%3.74%0.02%0
113Rudy Bukich1190615.13%5.12%0.01%0
114Mark Brunell46401843.97%3.96%0%0
115Richard Todd29671244.18%4.19%-0.01%0
116Ryan Fitzpatrick29111234.23%4.24%-0.01%0
117Lamar McHan1442735.06%5.12%-0.06%-1
118Shaun Hill1183494.14%4.23%-0.09%-1
119Marc Wilson2081864.13%4.19%-0.06%-1
120Cam Newton1923824.26%4.35%-0.09%-2
121Ed Brown1903975.1%5.2%-0.1%-2
122James Harris1149453.92%4.1%-0.18%-2
123Jim McMahon25731003.89%4%-0.12%-3
124Matthew Stafford30991314.23%4.33%-0.1%-3
125Matt Cassel2369964.05%4.18%-0.13%-3
126Charlie Batch1604613.8%4.01%-0.2%-3
127Tim Couch1714643.73%3.93%-0.2%-3
128Pat Haden1363523.82%4.06%-0.25%-3
129Tony Eason1564613.9%4.13%-0.23%-4
130Doug Williams25071003.99%4.15%-0.16%-4
131David Garrard2281893.9%4.09%-0.19%-4
132Brad Johnson43261663.84%3.94%-0.1%-4
133Matt Schaub31911304.07%4.21%-0.14%-4
134Mike Tomczak2337883.77%3.96%-0.19%-4
135Neil O'Donnell32291203.72%3.86%-0.14%-5
136Steve Bono1701623.64%3.92%-0.28%-5
137Jim Miller1046363.44%3.93%-0.49%-5
138Milt Plum24191225.04%5.27%-0.23%-6
139Tarvaris Jackson1067393.66%4.19%-0.53%-6
140Matt Hasselbeck50742034%4.11%-0.11%-6
141Vince Evans1390523.74%4.17%-0.43%-6
142Derek Anderson1537583.77%4.16%-0.39%-6
143Bubby Brister2212813.66%3.94%-0.27%-6
144Gary Hogeboom1325493.7%4.16%-0.47%-6
145Josh Freeman2020803.96%4.27%-0.31%-6
146John Friesz1364453.3%3.77%-0.47%-6
147Robert Griffin1063403.76%4.38%-0.61%-7
148Marc Bulger31711223.85%4.06%-0.21%-7
149David Woodley1300483.69%4.22%-0.52%-7
150Dave Wilson1039363.46%4.13%-0.67%-7
151Steve McNair45441743.83%3.99%-0.16%-7
152Paul Christman1140585.09%5.73%-0.64%-7
153Christian Ponder1057383.6%4.31%-0.71%-8
154Byron Leftwich1605583.61%4.11%-0.5%-8
155Vince Young1304463.53%4.14%-0.62%-8
156Gus Frerotte31061143.67%3.94%-0.27%-8
157Joe Flacco36571484.05%4.28%-0.23%-8
158Stan Humphries2516893.54%3.87%-0.34%-8
159Roman Gabriel44982014.47%4.66%-0.19%-9
160Rex Grossman1562563.59%4.13%-0.55%-9
161John Brodie44912144.77%4.96%-0.19%-9
162Mark Malone1648603.64%4.17%-0.53%-9
163Eric Hipple1546553.56%4.16%-0.6%-9
164Randy Johnson1286513.97%4.69%-0.72%-9
165Steve DeBerg50241963.9%4.09%-0.19%-9
166Bill Munson1982844.24%4.71%-0.47%-9
167Billy Joe Tolliver1707593.46%4%-0.55%-9
168Steve Spurrier1097393.56%4.41%-0.85%-9
169Jon Kitna44421693.8%4.02%-0.22%-10
170Jim Hart50762094.12%4.31%-0.19%-10
171Bart Starr31491524.83%5.14%-0.32%-10
172Dick Wood1194514.27%5.11%-0.84%-10
173Don Majkowski1905663.46%4%-0.53%-10
174Billy Wade25231244.91%5.32%-0.4%-10
175Josh McCown1664613.67%4.28%-0.62%-10
176Ryan Tannehill1662633.79%4.41%-0.62%-10
177Bernie Kosar33651243.68%4.01%-0.33%-11
178Mark Sanchez2176823.77%4.31%-0.54%-12
179Alex Smith31491223.87%4.25%-0.38%-12
180Steve Walsh1317403.04%3.95%-0.91%-12
181Bob Avellini1110332.97%4.08%-1.11%-12
182Kyle Orton27121013.72%4.19%-0.46%-13
183Gary Cuozzo1182433.64%4.73%-1.09%-13
184Jim Finks1358543.98%4.94%-0.96%-13
185Zeke Bratkowski1484654.38%5.26%-0.88%-13
186Trent Dilfer31721133.56%3.99%-0.43%-14
187Cotton Davidson1686734.33%5.14%-0.81%-14
188Mike Pagel1509493.25%4.16%-0.91%-14
189Kent Graham1339392.91%3.95%-1.04%-14
190Jake Plummer43501613.7%4.03%-0.32%-14
191Drew Bledsoe67172513.74%3.96%-0.22%-15
192Bobby Douglass1178363.06%4.33%-1.28%-15
193Scott Brunner1046292.77%4.24%-1.47%-15
194Randy Wright1119312.77%4.14%-1.37%-15
195Kyle Boller1519483.16%4.18%-1.02%-16
196Jack Concannon1110363.24%4.68%-1.44%-16
197Rodney Peete2346763.24%3.93%-0.69%-16
198Tony Banks2356773.27%3.98%-0.71%-17
199Kordell Stewart2358773.27%3.98%-0.72%-17
200Steve Fuller1066282.63%4.23%-1.6%-17
201Mike Livingston1751563.2%4.18%-0.98%-17
202Sam Bradford1760593.35%4.34%-0.99%-17
203Pete Beathard1282433.35%4.72%-1.37%-18
204Ken O'Brien36021283.55%4.05%-0.49%-18
205Jason Campbell2518873.46%4.17%-0.72%-18
206Norm Snead43531964.5%4.94%-0.44%-19
207Troy Aikman47151653.5%3.91%-0.41%-20
208Jim Zorn31491113.52%4.17%-0.64%-20
209Dave Brown1634442.69%3.93%-1.24%-20
210Mike Phipps1799553.06%4.25%-1.19%-21
211Frank Tripucka1745693.95%5.21%-1.26%-22
212Jim Ninowski1048343.24%5.46%-2.22%-23
213Jim Harbaugh39181293.29%3.91%-0.62%-24
214Dan Pastorini30551033.37%4.17%-0.79%-24
215Jack Trudeau1644422.55%4.05%-1.5%-25
216Joey Harrington2538793.11%4.09%-0.98%-25
217Chad Henne1954582.97%4.33%-1.37%-27
218David Carr2267652.87%4.09%-1.22%-28
219Archie Manning36421253.43%4.21%-0.77%-28
220Rick Mirer2043502.45%3.86%-1.41%-29
221Jack Kemp30731143.71%5.08%-1.37%-42
222Kerry Collins62612083.32%4.03%-0.7%-44

Manning, Brett Favre, Marino, Drew Brees, and Brady compose the top five touchdown passers of all time, so it’s no surprise to see them lead the list of marginal scoring passes. The biggest surprise here may be Aaron Rodgers, who already ranks sixth all time. I’ve said this before, and I stand by it: Rodgers has interception rates from fifty years in the future and touchdown rates from fifty years in the past. His 6.5% rate is easily the highest of any of his peers, and his 2.34% marginal rate is second only to Arnie Herber’s.4

Terry Bradshaw catches a lot of flak from modern fans who don’t put his stats in proper context. Lists like this help put his box scores in their rightful place in history. Ranking between Joe Montana and Jim Kelly on any quarterback list is almost always a good thing.

It is interesting to me to note the effect the league passing environment has on quarterbacks’ career rankings. Take, for example, the rates of Steve Young (5.59%) and Paul Christman (5.09%). They were within half a percentage point of one another, but Young’s contemporaries threw touchdowns at a 3.9% rate, while Christman’s scored at a 5.7% rate. The result is that Young ends up ranked seventh all time, and Christman ranks 152nd, just ahead of Christian Ponder.

You may notice a trend of me mentioning Cecil Isbell at the end of most of these posts. It’s not because I’m a big fan (I never saw him play) or even a Packers fan (I grew up a Niners fan before becoming team-agnostic). The reason I mention him is that, of all the quarterbacks with fewer than 1,000 career attempts, Isbell is usually the one who stands out enough to mention. In this case, he’s the runaway leader in marginal touchdowns from non-qualifying passers. In 818 career attempts, he threw 61 touchdown passes. That sounds like 22 games from a top QB today, but in his day it was something special. An average passer would be expected to throw just 36 touchdowns in his situation.5

That’s all for now. Join us tomorrow when the topic is (predictably) interceptions.

  1. Note that I didn’t say “how well quarterbacks threw touchdowns.” A screen with 80 YAC, a bomb to a wide open speedster, and a missile into tight coverage all count for six on the stat sheets. []
  2. Feel free to copy the table and make your own spreadsheet if you’d like. Or don’t. I’m not going to tell you how to live your life. []
  3. The caveat here is the same as it is with any marginal rate stats: one can only fair as poorly as the rest of the league permits. In 1934, the league average TD rate was about 3.5%; in 1943, on the other hand, it was roughly 7.1%. Therefore, if you had a zero percent rate in 1943, your marginal score would look twice as bad as it would if you did the same thing in 1934. This is problematic at the seasonal level, but I think it works itself out at the career level. []
  4. Chase note: A small part of this may be due to Rodgers playing the entirety of his career during the “good” years: he was on the bench during his young seasons and he has yet to enter the decline phase of his career. For example, you won’t be surprised to learn that Rodgers has a TD%+ — the era-adjusted metric on PFR — of 126 for his career, while no other quarterback in history is over 120. But nearly all of Rodgers’ career has been between the ages of 25 and 31. If we look at TD%+ ratings for all quarterbacks during those years, Rodgers is not as much of an outlier in this metric. []
  5. This, of course, ignores the very important fact that Isbell threw the ball to the most dominant wide receiver of his era. []
  • Adam

    To me this shows the utility of TD% in evaluating QB performance, especially over a large sample. Some people in the analytics community poopoo TD’s as a fantasy football stat, but I have to disagree. I see TD% as a nice “cleanup” stat that catches all the little things a QB does to drive his team down the field and into the endzone.

    • Tom

      I’m alright with passing touchdowns as a QB stat, but as Dr_P noted, the biggest issue for me, is opportunity…some guys had more opportunities – due to play calling, better receivers, horrible running back/rushing O-line – than others. But in any event, it’s harder to throw a 10-yard TD pass than a 10-yard pass at the 50, so I think it’s a worthwhile stat.

  • Dr__P

    Troy Aikman did not throw as many TD’s as he could. A lot of his throws were to inside the 10 and then handed the ball off to Emmitt Smith to score.

    • I wouldn’t use TD% as the be all end all of QB stats. It’s just a piece of the puzzle. Besides, my real motivation for this one was getting to call it “Mile High Club: Scoring Through the Air.”

      • Dr__P

        I agree that no ONE stat should rule. Each misses context that is often supplied with other stats. One should use multiple stats at once. That is just another good reason for the entire series of articles.

      • Tom

        Yeah, you can’t leave that title just laying around like that…

  • Tim Truemper

    Good qualifier on # 4 Chase. When we think of Rodgers we need to remember to compare his performance to that age factor. Of course it looks like Manning and Brady are doing all they can to extend it.

  • Ian

    Kerry Collins is last in marginal completions and marginal touchdown. I’m guessing that is what happen when you start 180 games and play below-average your entire career.

  • WR

    Does anyone know why Aaron Rodgers’ interception rate is so low in home games? His INT rate in road games is 1.9%, very close to Brady’s career rate of 2.0. But Rodgers has an incredible INT rate of 1.3% in home games. What’s weird about that is that Rodgers plays his home games at Lambeau, so if anything, you would think the bad weather would hurt his numbers.

    • Ralph Skinner

      #deflategate2

    • Ralph Skinner

      I don’t think it’s a great wonder that his rate is so low in home games, but rather in all games.

      Brady has a 2.5:1.5 ratio (away:home int%) himself despite playing in Gillette, and tougher conditions may cause more incompletions but not interceptions, as it could be harder for defensive backs to catch balls as well. Plus, there is probably something about feeling familiar with play calling and the atmosphere at home. Back to Rodgers’ overall interception rate, I really thing it is remarkable, and most easily explained by his intelligence. Rodgers rarely even makes a bad pass and avoids crowded areas extraordinarily well. He also recognizes which wide receivers are ‘safer’ options and plans his routes and timing meticulously. And then there is his actual accuracy, with a career completion percentage of 66%, to put it all together. I think Rodgers will exit the game as one of the best of all time (7th?).

      • WR

        That’s an interesting point about Brady’s INT splits. I’ve studied Brady’s career quite closely, and I’m still not sure of the impact of cold weather games on his stats. His passer rating from September-November is 97.2, but in December-January it drops to 92.5. But Im not convinced this is because his performance gets worse, because some of his rate stats improve in cold weather games. I haven’t run all the numbers for Brady’s entire career, but it appears the Pats opponents have also lost a few points of rating in Dec-Jan. And Brady’s win pct in Dec-Jan is better than in any other month, an incredible 52-10. So do you think cold weather QBs actually gain an advantage from playing in cold/bad weather?

        • Ralph Skinner

          I don’t think their stats necessarily get a boost, but the teams certainly benefit. The Patriots have an astounding cold weather record for multiple reasons, including the team’s turnover awareness and decision making, but Brady’s unwavering play is certainly a huge factor.

          Something I find really odd about Brady’s stats in December has nothing to do with his passing – nearly 40% of his rushing yards and 6 of his 14 rushing touchdowns come in December. In addition, December holds Brady’s only career reception and his only two punts. I wouldn’t be surprised if Belichick saves some of his best tricks for late in the season to come into postseason form, which could be another factor in their 52-10 record. And perhaps throwing the opposing defenses off guard helps Brady to maintain similar rate stats.

  • Isbell was great. Especially on “Southern Rock Opera.” He made a more convincing dark knight than paladin, though.

    More seriously, he was throwing to Hutson but his numbers are still pretty damn crazy.