≡ Menu

Bryan Frye, owner and operator of the great site http://www.thegridfe.com, is back for another guest post. You can also view all of Bryan’s guest posts at Football Perspective at this link, and follow him on twitter @LaverneusDingle.


On Monday, I looked at which quarterbacks since 1960 helped or hurt their teams the most by taking or avoiding sacks. Yesterday, I looked at the quarterbacks who gained the most or fewest yards through the air per attempt or dropback. As you may have guessed, I’m keeping the theme going today. This article, “Sharpshooters or: Quarterbacks who were Good at Completing Passes,” is an examination of how passers stacked up statistically against their peers in the not-super-important category of completion rate.

I specifically mentioned that this is a look at how players’ stats compare with those of others instead of a look at how accurate those players were. Given the disparate offensive systems in which quarterbacks play, I think this is an important distinction. One can be an accurate passer and have an underwhelming completion rate, and one can be an inaccurate passer and have a good completion rate.1

That said, I am going to use the word “accurate” throughout the article because it’s easier and takes up less space. I’d also like to point out that, even though I have spike data going back to 2002, I’m not going to incorporate it. I didn’t think it would be fair to players with incomplete data.2

I’m not going to belabor the methodology. If you read the previous two articles, you’ll get what I did here. Just replace sack rate or Y/A with completion rate, and you’re good to go.
Let’s get into the numbers.

Single Season Completions

The following table displays the relevant stats of the 1,563 quarterback seasons with at least 224 pass attempts. Read it thus: In 2011, Drew Brees completed 468 of 657 attempts for a record 71.23% completion rate. The completion rate of the rest of the league’s quarterbacks was 59.7%, giving Brees a marginal completion percentage of 11.54. This results in (657 * 11.54% =) 76 marginal completions.

RkQuarterbackYearTmCmpAttCmp%LMP Cmp%Marg Cmp%Marg Cmp
1Drew Brees2011NOR46865771.23%59.7%11.54%76
2Steve Young1994SFO32446170.28%57.7%12.58%58
3Joe Montana1989SFO27138670.21%55.47%14.73%57
4Kurt Warner2001STL37554668.68%58.67%10.01%55
5Daunte Culpepper2004MIN37954869.16%59.52%9.64%53
6Fran Tarkenton1975MIN27342564.24%51.98%12.26%52
7Drew Brees2009NOR36351470.62%60.65%9.98%51
8Rich Gannon2002OAK41861867.64%59.41%8.22%51
9Drew Brees2010NOR44865868.09%60.49%7.6%50
10Drew Brees2013NOR44665068.62%60.94%7.67%50
11Sammy Baugh1947WAS21035459.32%45.39%13.93%49
12Matt Ryan2012ATL42261568.62%60.64%7.98%49
13Joe Montana1987SFO26639866.83%54.52%12.32%49
14Peyton Manning2013DEN45065968.29%60.95%7.33%48
15Steve Young1993SFO31446267.97%57.65%10.32%48
16Peyton Manning2003IND37956666.96%58.56%8.4%48
17Dan Fouts1979SDG33253062.64%53.77%8.87%47
18Otto Graham1953CLE16725864.73%46.55%18.18%47
19Peyton Manning2009IND39357168.83%60.67%8.15%47
20Peyton Manning2012DEN40058368.61%60.66%7.96%46
21Philip Rivers2013SDG37854469.49%60.96%8.52%46
22Tom Brady2007NWE39857868.86%60.91%7.95%46
23Joe Montana1981SFO31148863.73%54.33%9.39%46
24Dan Marino1984MIA36256464.18%56.14%8.04%45
25Troy Aikman1993DAL27139269.13%57.67%11.46%45
26Len Dawson1962DTX18931060.97%46.48%14.49%45
27Drew Brees2014NOR45665969.2%62.41%6.79%45
28Ken Anderson1982CIN21830970.55%56.09%14.46%45
29Sonny Jurgensen1969WAS27444261.99%51.94%10.05%44
30John Brodie1965SFO24239161.89%50.56%11.33%44
31Carson Palmer2005CIN34550967.78%59.23%8.55%44
32Ken Stabler1976OAK19429166.67%51.75%14.91%43
33Fran Tarkenton1978MIN34557260.31%52.76%7.56%43
34Drew Brees2007NOR44065267.48%60.92%6.56%43
35Archie Manning1978NOR29147161.78%52.76%9.02%42
36Aaron Rodgers2011GNB34350268.33%59.89%8.44%42
37Ken Anderson1974CIN21332864.94%52.08%12.86%42
38Matt Schaub2009HOU39658367.92%60.7%7.22%42
39Matt Ryan2013ATL43965167.43%60.99%6.45%42
40Steve Young1997SFO24135667.7%55.96%11.74%42
41Fran Tarkenton1976MIN25541261.89%51.77%10.12%42
42Kurt Warner1999STL32549965.13%56.87%8.26%41
43Brett Favre2009MIN36353168.36%60.71%7.65%41
44Peyton Manning2002IND39259166.33%59.47%6.86%41
45Joe Montana1983SFO33251564.47%56.67%7.79%40
46Peyton Manning2004IND33649767.61%59.6%8.01%40
47Steve Young1995SFO29944766.89%57.99%8.9%40
48Ken Anderson1981CIN30047962.63%54.38%8.25%40
49Len Dawson1967KAN20635757.7%46.72%10.98%39
50Peyton Manning2010IND45067966.27%60.55%5.72%39
51David Carr2006HOU30244268.33%59.59%8.73%39
52Rich Gannon2001OAK36154965.76%58.77%6.99%38
53Steve Young1992SFO26840266.67%57.27%9.4%38
54Chad Pennington2002NYJ27539968.92%59.49%9.43%38
55Trent Green2004KAN36955666.37%59.61%6.75%38
56Y.A. Tittle1957SFO17627963.08%49.65%13.44%37
57Kurt Warner2008ARI40159867.06%60.79%6.26%37
58Ken Stabler1980HOU29345764.11%55.99%8.12%37
59Peyton Manning2005IND30545367.33%59.27%8.06%37
60Warren Moon1990HOU36258461.99%55.76%6.22%36
61Brett Favre1998GNB34755162.98%56.4%6.58%36
62Joe Montana1984SFO27943264.58%56.21%8.38%36
63Aaron Rodgers2012GNB37155267.21%60.71%6.5%36
64Ken Stabler1979OAK30449861.04%53.86%7.18%36
65Steve DeBerg1979SFO34757860.03%53.86%6.17%36
66Tom Brady2011NWE40161165.63%59.93%5.7%35
67Johnny Unitas1967BAL25543658.49%50.61%7.88%34
68Sammy Baugh1948WAS18531558.73%47.84%10.89%34
69Frank Tripucka1962DEN24044054.55%46.79%7.75%34
70Dan Marino1986MIA37862360.67%55.22%5.45%34
71Sammy Baugh1942WAS13222558.67%43.59%15.08%34
72Ken O'Brien1986NYJ30048262.24%55.22%7.02%34
73Kurt Warner2000STL23534767.72%58%9.72%34
74Y.A. Tittle1963NYG22136760.22%51.08%9.14%34
75Jim Everett1994NOR34654064.07%57.87%6.21%34
76Otto Graham1947CLE16326960.59%48.13%12.46%34
77Peyton Manning2008IND37155566.85%60.82%6.03%33
78Mark Brunell1996JAX35355763.38%57.43%5.94%33
79Tony Romo2011DAL34652266.28%59.94%6.34%33
80Jim Kelly1991BUF30447464.14%57.15%6.98%33
81Tobin Rote1963SDG17028659.44%47.96%11.48%33
82Joe Montana1985SFO30349461.34%54.69%6.64%33
83Brian Griese2004TAM23333669.35%59.64%9.7%33
84Steve Young1996SFO21431667.72%57.43%10.29%33
85Tony Romo2014DAL30443569.89%62.48%7.41%32
86Brett Favre1992GNB30247164.12%57.31%6.81%32
87Dan Fouts1984SDG31750762.52%56.24%6.29%32
88Brett Favre2003GNB30847165.39%58.66%6.73%32
89Marc Bulger2004STL32148566.19%59.65%6.54%32
90Roman Gabriel1973PHI27046058.7%51.81%6.89%32
91Danny White1983DAL33453362.66%56.73%5.93%32
92Brian Griese2002DEN29143666.74%59.53%7.22%31
93Chad Pennington2008MIA32147667.44%60.83%6.61%31
94Tony Romo2012DAL42564865.59%60.74%4.85%31
95Ken Anderson1975CIN22837760.48%52.19%8.29%31
96Sonny Jurgensen1966WAS25443658.26%51.11%7.14%31
97John Brodie1970SFO22337858.99%50.81%8.19%31
98Troy Aikman1992DAL30247363.85%57.32%6.53%31
99Joe Montana1990SFO32152061.73%55.81%5.92%31
100Roger Staubach1973DAL17928662.59%51.82%10.77%31
101Sonny Jurgensen1970WAS20233759.94%50.81%9.13%31
102Fran Tarkenton1971NYG22638658.55%50.59%7.96%31
103Sonny Jurgensen1967WAS28850856.69%50.67%6.02%31
104Steve Young1998SFO32251762.28%56.43%5.85%30
105Ken O'Brien1985NYJ29748860.86%54.71%6.15%30
106Neil Lomax1984STL34556061.61%56.25%5.36%30
107Peyton Manning2006IND36255764.99%59.65%5.34%30
108Steve Bartkowski1984ATL18126967.29%56.25%11.03%30
109John Elway1993DEN34855163.16%57.77%5.38%30
110Brett Favre2007GNB35653566.54%61%5.54%30
111Warren Moon1991HOU40465561.68%57.18%4.5%29
112Ben Roethlisberger2009PIT33750666.6%60.78%5.83%29
113Len Dawson1966KAN15928455.99%45.61%10.38%29
114Ken Anderson1983CIN19829766.67%56.75%9.92%29
115Jeff Garcia2000SFO35556163.28%58.03%5.25%29
116Troy Aikman1991DAL23736365.29%57.18%8.11%29
117Sammy Baugh1943WAS13323955.65%43.41%12.23%29
118Troy Aikman1995DAL28043264.81%58.05%6.76%29
119Dan Marino1995MIA30948264.11%58.05%6.05%29
120Philip Rivers2010SDG35754165.99%60.61%5.38%29
121Bert Jones1976BAL20734360.35%51.9%8.45%29
122Dan Marino1994MIA38561562.6%57.9%4.7%29
123John Hadl1966SDG20037553.33%45.62%7.71%29
124Steve Bartkowski1983ATL27443263.43%56.75%6.67%29
125Troy Aikman1996DAL29646563.66%57.46%6.2%29
126Norm Snead1972NYG19632560.31%51.5%8.81%29
127Daunte Culpepper2003MIN29545464.98%58.68%6.3%29
128Cecil Isbell1942GNB14626854.48%43.86%10.61%28
129Tony Eason1986NWE27644861.61%55.26%6.35%28
130George Ratterman1949BUF14625257.94%46.68%11.26%28
131Dan Fouts1981SDG36060959.11%54.46%4.65%28
132Bernie Kosar1987CLE24138961.95%54.67%7.28%28
133Ken Stabler1973OAK16326062.69%51.85%10.85%28
134Jim Everett1988RAM30851759.57%54.14%5.43%28
135Brett Favre1995GNB35957062.98%58.06%4.92%28
136Ben Roethlisberger2014PIT40860867.11%62.5%4.61%28
137Otto Graham1949CLE16128556.49%46.7%9.79%28
138Len Dawson1964KAN19935456.21%48.39%7.83%28
139Matt Hasselbeck2005SEA29444965.48%59.32%6.15%28
140Tom Brady2009NWE37156565.66%60.79%4.88%28
141Bart Starr1966GNB15625162.15%51.17%10.98%28
142Peyton Manning1999IND33153362.1%56.96%5.14%27
143Len Dawson1965KAN16330553.44%44.47%8.97%27
144Sammy Baugh1949WAS14525556.86%46.18%10.69%27
145Y.A. Tittle1953SFO14925957.53%47.04%10.49%27
146Kurt Warner2009ARI33951366.08%60.79%5.29%27
147Johnny Unitas1963BAL23741057.8%51.2%6.6%27
148Joe Namath1967NYJ25849152.55%47.04%5.51%27
149Bart Starr1962GNB17828562.46%53.01%9.44%27
150Fran Tarkenton1973MIN16927461.68%51.86%9.82%27
151Sid Luckman1947CHI17632354.49%46.2%8.29%27
152John Brodie1968SFO23440457.92%51.3%6.62%27
153Milt Plum1960CLE15125060.4%49.73%10.67%27
154Drew Brees2008NOR41363565.04%60.86%4.18%27
155Len Dawson1968KAN13122458.48%46.64%11.84%27
156Brian Sipe1980CLE33755460.83%56.07%4.76%26
157Drew Brees2005SDG32350064.6%59.33%5.27%26
158Brett Favre1994GNB36358262.37%57.92%4.45%26
159Dan Marino1988MIA35460658.42%54.16%4.26%26
160Jim Kelly1990BUF21934663.29%55.84%7.45%26
161Tom Brady2010NWE32449265.85%60.63%5.22%26
162Frankie Albert1948SFO15426458.33%48.61%9.72%26
163Dan Marino1985MIA33656759.26%54.74%4.52%26
164Warren Moon1992HOU22434664.74%57.36%7.38%26
165Jim Kelly1994BUF28544863.62%57.92%5.7%26
166Peyton Manning2000IND35757162.52%58.06%4.47%26
167Archie Manning1979NOR25242060%53.94%6.06%25
168Drew Brees2006NOR35655464.26%59.67%4.59%25
169Bobby Hebert1989NOR22235362.89%55.7%7.19%25
170Roger Staubach1977DAL21036158.17%51.15%7.03%25
171Brett Favre2008NYJ34352265.71%60.87%4.84%25
172Warren Moon1995MIN37760662.21%58.08%4.13%25
173Otto Graham1951CLE14726555.47%46.12%9.35%25
174Bernie Kosar1991CLE30749462.15%57.22%4.93%24
175Wade Wilson1988MIN20433261.45%54.17%7.28%24
176Jim Kelly1988BUF26945259.51%54.17%5.34%24
177Aaron Rodgers2010GNB31247565.68%60.64%5.04%24
178Dave Krieg1991SEA18728565.61%57.22%8.4%24
179Troy Aikman1994DAL23336164.54%57.93%6.61%24
180Marc Bulger2003STL33653263.16%58.71%4.45%24
181Bob Griese1978MIA14823562.98%52.92%10.06%24
182Brett Favre2004GNB34654064.07%59.7%4.37%24
183Bart Starr1964GNB16327259.93%51.26%8.67%24
184Chad Pennington2006NYJ31348564.54%59.68%4.85%24
185Archie Manning1980NOR30950960.71%56.09%4.62%24
186Greg Landry1979BAL27045759.08%53.96%5.13%23
187Eric Hipple1986DET19230562.95%55.29%7.66%23
188Matthew Stafford2011DET42166363.5%60%3.5%23
189Drew Brees2004SDG26240065.5%59.7%5.8%23
190Bert Jones1975BAL20334459.01%52.27%6.74%23
191Ryan Tannehill2014MIA39259066.44%62.53%3.91%23
192Fran Tarkenton1977MIN15525860.08%51.17%8.91%23
193Trent Green2003KAN33052363.1%58.71%4.39%23
194Joe Montana1988SFO23839759.95%54.18%5.77%23
195Bob Griese1977MIA18030758.63%51.17%7.46%23
196Bert Jones1977BAL22439357%51.17%5.83%23
197Joe Montana1980SFO17627364.47%56.09%8.37%23
198Milt Plum1959CLE15626658.65%50.06%8.59%23
199Warren Moon1994MIN37160161.73%57.94%3.79%23
200Joe Theismann1981WAS29349659.07%54.5%4.57%23
201Peyton Manning2007IND33751565.44%61.04%4.39%23
202Philip Rivers2014SDG37957066.49%62.53%3.96%23
203Dan Fouts1978SDG22438158.79%52.93%5.86%22
204Matt Ryan2014ATL41562866.08%62.53%3.55%22
205Billy Wade1959RAM15326158.62%50.08%8.54%22
206Tommy Thompson1948PHI14124657.32%48.26%9.06%22
207Steve Beuerlein1998CAR21634362.97%56.49%6.49%22
208Ken O'Brien1989NYJ28847760.38%55.72%4.66%22
209Ken Stabler1978OAK23740658.37%52.94%5.44%22
210Carson Palmer2007CIN37357564.87%61.05%3.82%22
211Dan Fouts1983SDG21534063.24%56.8%6.43%22
212Daunte Culpepper2000MIN29747462.66%58.08%4.58%22
213Peyton Manning2014DEN39559766.16%62.53%3.63%22
214Neil Lomax1987STL27546359.4%54.72%4.67%22
215Marc Bulger2005STL19228766.9%59.36%7.54%22
216Brad Johnson1997MIN27545260.84%56.09%4.75%21
217Warren Moon1989HOU28046460.34%55.72%4.62%21
218Bob Berry1971ATL13622660.18%50.69%9.49%21
219Dan Fouts1976SDG20835957.94%51.97%5.97%21
220Philip Rivers2009SDG31748665.23%60.82%4.4%21
221Steve DeBerg1984TAM30850960.51%56.31%4.2%21
222Drew Bledsoe1997NWE31452260.15%56.09%4.06%21
223Joe Montana1986SFO19130762.21%55.31%6.91%21
224Vinny Testaverde1998NYJ25942161.52%56.49%5.03%21
225Gary Danielson1984DET25241061.46%56.31%5.15%21
226Chad Pennington2004NYJ24237065.41%59.71%5.69%21
227Norm Van Brocklin1953RAM15628654.55%47.19%7.36%21
228Johnny Unitas1957BAL17230157.14%50.15%6.99%21
229Bobby Hebert1988NOR28047858.58%54.19%4.39%21
230Fran Tarkenton1970NYG21938956.3%50.91%5.39%21
231Peyton Manning2001IND34354762.71%58.88%3.83%21
232Aaron Rodgers2009GNB35054164.7%60.83%3.87%21
233Philip Rivers2008SDG31247865.27%60.89%4.38%21
234Brian Griese2000DEN21633664.29%58.08%6.2%21
235Tom Brady2001NWE26441363.92%58.88%5.04%21
236John Elway1994DEN30749462.15%57.95%4.19%21
237Jim Kelly1987BUF25041959.67%54.73%4.94%21
238Y.A. Tittle1954SFO17029557.63%50.62%7.01%21
239Bob Griese1976MIA16227259.56%51.98%7.58%21
240Babe Parilli1962BOS14025355.34%47.19%8.14%21
241Norm Van Brocklin1959PHI19134056.18%50.12%6.05%21
242Otto Graham1954CLE14224059.17%50.62%8.54%21
243Danny White1985DAL26745059.33%54.78%4.56%21
244Steve Young1991SFO18027964.52%57.24%7.27%20
245Chad Pennington2007NYJ17926068.85%61.06%7.79%20
246Brad Johnson1999WAS31651960.89%57%3.89%20
247Johnny Unitas1965BAL16428258.16%51.01%7.14%20
248Ken Anderson1984CIN17527563.64%56.32%7.32%20
249Tom Flores1961OAK19036651.91%46.43%5.48%20
250Craig Morton1981DEN22537659.84%54.52%5.32%20
251Dan Marino1987MIA26344459.23%54.73%4.5%20
252Fran Tarkenton1972MIN21537856.88%51.6%5.28%20
253Mark Brunell1997JAX26443560.69%56.1%4.59%20
254Donovan McNabb2004PHI30046963.97%59.72%4.24%20
255Y.A. Tittle1948BCL16128955.71%48.83%6.88%20
256Len Dawson1963KAN19035253.98%48.34%5.63%20
257Bob Griese1968MIA18635552.39%46.81%5.59%20
258Ben Roethlisberger2004PIT19629566.44%59.72%6.72%20
259Joe Theismann1979WAS23339558.99%53.98%5%20
260Milt Plum1961CLE17730258.61%52.1%6.51%20
261Bob Griese1974MIA15225360.08%52.31%7.76%20
262Matt Schaub2008HOU25138066.05%60.9%5.15%20
263Jim Zorn1981SEA23639759.45%54.52%4.92%20
264Otto Graham1950CLE13725354.15%46.43%7.72%20
265Daunte Culpepper2001MIN23536664.21%58.89%5.32%19
266George Blanda1963HOU22442352.96%48.36%4.6%19
267Jim Kelly1986BUF28548059.38%55.32%4.05%19
268Kurt Warner2005ARI24237564.53%59.37%5.16%19
269Norm Snead1967PHI24043455.3%50.85%4.45%19
270Tom Brady2005NWE33453063.02%59.37%3.64%19
271Daryle Lamonica1967OAK22042551.76%47.24%4.52%19
272Brad Johnson2003TAM35457062.11%58.73%3.37%19
273Matt Schaub2012HOU35054464.34%60.81%3.53%19
274Jeff Garcia2001SFO31650462.7%58.89%3.81%19
275Don Majkowski1989GNB35359958.93%55.74%3.19%19
276Jay Cutler2014CHI37056165.95%62.55%3.4%19
277Robert Griffin2012WAS25839365.65%60.81%4.84%19
278Bob Berry1970ATL15626957.99%50.93%7.06%19
279John Elway1996DEN28746661.59%57.52%4.07%19
280Earl Morrall1968BAL18231757.41%51.43%5.98%19
281Marc Bulger2006STL37058862.93%59.71%3.21%19
282Ken O'Brien1987NYJ23439359.54%54.74%4.8%19
283Randall Cunningham1998MIN25942560.94%56.51%4.43%19
284Joe Theismann1982WAS16125263.89%56.42%7.47%19
285George Blanda1961HOU18736251.66%46.47%5.19%19
286Norm Van Brocklin1950RAM12723354.51%46.45%8.05%19
287Tony Romo2006DAL22033765.28%59.71%5.57%19
288Cody Carlson1992HOU14922765.64%57.41%8.23%19
289Jon Kitna2003CIN32452062.31%58.74%3.57%19
290Jason Campbell2009WAS32750764.5%60.84%3.66%19
291Kelly Holcomb2005BUF15523067.39%59.38%8.01%18
292Ken Stabler1977OAK16929457.48%51.22%6.27%18
293Dan Fouts1985SDG25443059.07%54.79%4.28%18
294John Hadl1965SDG17434850%44.72%5.28%18
295Bobby Thomason1953PHI16230453.29%47.25%6.04%18
296Jeff George1994ATL32252461.45%57.97%3.48%18
297Bart Starr1961GNB17229558.31%52.13%6.18%18
298Steve Bartkowski1982ATL16626263.36%56.42%6.93%18
299Neil O'Donnell1998CIN21234361.81%56.51%5.3%18
300Sonny Jurgensen1961PHI23541656.49%52.13%4.36%18
301Chris Chandler1995HOU22535663.2%58.12%5.08%18
302Roger Staubach1979DAL26746157.92%54%3.92%18
303Ben Roethlisberger2013PIT37558464.21%61.12%3.09%18
304Dieter Brock1985RAM21836559.73%54.79%4.93%18
305Steve McNair2000TEN24839662.63%58.1%4.52%18
306Charlie Frye2006CLE25239264.29%59.72%4.57%18
307Dan Fouts1982SDG20433061.82%56.43%5.39%18
308Joe Montana1982SFO21334661.56%56.43%5.13%18
309Ken Stabler1975OAK17129358.36%52.33%6.04%18
310Len Dawson1972KAN17530557.38%51.62%5.75%18
311Dave Krieg1986SEA22537560%55.34%4.66%17
312Jim Harbaugh1995IND20031463.69%58.12%5.57%17
313Philip Rivers2012SDG33852764.14%60.82%3.32%17
314Steve Beuerlein1999CAR34357160.07%57.02%3.05%17
315Tony Romo2007DAL33552064.42%61.07%3.35%17
316Fran Tarkenton1963MIN17029757.24%51.38%5.86%17
317Dan Fouts1980SDG34858959.08%56.13%2.95%17
318Ben Roethlisberger2007PIT26440465.35%61.07%4.27%17
319Matt Hasselbeck2002SEA26741963.72%59.61%4.12%17
320Bob Griese1970MIA14224557.96%50.95%7.01%17
321Trent Edwards2008BUF24537465.51%60.92%4.59%17
322Charlie Conerly1948NYG16229954.18%48.44%5.74%17
323Dave Krieg1987SEA17829460.54%54.76%5.79%17
324Bernie Kosar1989CLE30351359.06%55.76%3.31%17
325Frank Tripucka1960DEN24847851.88%48.33%3.55%17
326Johnny Lujack1949CHI16231251.92%46.5%5.42%17
327Danny White1987DAL21536259.39%54.76%4.63%17
328Sonny Jurgensen1968WAS16729257.19%51.47%5.72%17
329Warren Moon1997SEA31352859.28%56.12%3.16%17
330Matt Schaub2010HOU36557463.59%60.68%2.9%17
331Rudy Bukich1965CHI17631256.41%51.08%5.33%17
332Greg Landry1976DET16829157.73%52.02%5.71%17
333Philip Rivers2011SDG36658262.89%60.04%2.85%17
334Danny White1982DAL15624763.16%56.45%6.71%17
335Bob Waterfield1949RAM15429652.03%46.52%5.51%16
336Johnny Unitas1966BAL19534856.03%51.36%4.68%16
337Jim Hart1976STL21838856.19%52.02%4.16%16
338Tony Eason1984NWE25943160.09%56.35%3.75%16
339Bernie Kosar1986CLE31053158.38%55.35%3.04%16
340Steve Beuerlein1993PHO25841861.72%57.87%3.85%16
341Jon Kitna2000SEA25941861.96%58.11%3.85%16
342Brett Favre1997GNB30451359.26%56.12%3.14%16
343George Blanda1964HOU26250551.88%48.7%3.18%16
344Brad Johnson1996MIN19531162.7%57.54%5.16%16
345Roman Gabriel1974PHI19333857.1%52.35%4.75%16
346Roger Staubach1976DAL20836956.37%52.02%4.34%16
347Jon Kitna2010DAL20931865.72%60.69%5.04%16
348Jim Kelly1993BUF28847061.28%57.87%3.41%16
349Jon Kitna2006DET37259662.42%59.73%2.69%16
350Ben Roethlisberger2011PIT32451363.16%60.04%3.12%16
351Brett Favre1993GNB31852260.92%57.87%3.05%16
352Brad Johnson2000WAS22836562.47%58.11%4.35%16
353Trent Green2005KAN31750762.52%59.4%3.13%16
354Bobby Layne1949NYY15529951.84%46.53%5.3%16
355Roger Staubach1975DAL19834856.9%52.34%4.55%16
356Jeff Hostetler1991NYG17928562.81%57.28%5.53%16
357Aaron Rodgers2013GNB19329066.55%61.13%5.42%16
358Ken Stabler1974OAK17831057.42%52.36%5.06%16
359Brian Sipe1976CLE17831257.05%52.03%5.02%16
360Bob Waterfield1946RAM12725150.6%44.36%6.24%16
361Aaron Rodgers2014GNB34152065.58%62.57%3.01%16
362Jim Harbaugh1997IND18930961.17%56.13%5.04%16
363Kelly Holcomb2003CLE19330263.91%58.76%5.15%16
364Ken Anderson1972CIN17130156.81%51.64%5.17%16
365Bernie Kosar1988CLE15625960.23%54.23%6%16
366Joe Namath1966NYJ23247149.26%45.96%3.29%16
367Phil Simms1993NYG24740061.75%57.87%3.88%16
368Matt Schaub2007HOU19228966.44%61.09%5.35%15
369Steve McNair2006BAL29546863.03%59.73%3.3%15
370Jim Everett1995NOR34556760.85%58.14%2.71%15
371Steve DeBerg1989KAN19632460.49%55.77%4.73%15
372Terry Bradshaw1975PIT16528657.69%52.35%5.34%15
373Fran Tarkenton1974MIN19935156.7%52.36%4.33%15
374Danny White1980DAL26043659.63%56.15%3.48%15
375Josh Freeman2011TAM34655162.79%60.05%2.75%15
376Jim Everett1989RAM30451858.69%55.77%2.92%15
377Joe Theismann1983WAS27645960.13%56.85%3.28%15
378Steve McNair2003TEN25040062.5%58.76%3.74%15
379Len Dawson1974KAN13823558.72%52.36%6.36%15
380Tony Romo2013DAL34253563.93%61.14%2.79%15
381Jeff Garcia2008TAM24437664.89%60.93%3.96%15
382Johnny Unitas1962BAL22238957.07%53.25%3.82%15
383John Hadl1967SDG21742750.82%47.36%3.46%15
384Jake Plummer1998ARI32454759.23%56.53%2.7%15
385Boomer Esiason1985CIN25143158.24%54.82%3.42%15
386Neil Lomax1988PHO25544357.56%54.24%3.33%15
387Tom Brady2002NWE37360162.06%59.62%2.44%15
388Mark Rypien1989WAS28047658.82%55.77%3.05%15
389Jim Plunkett1983RAI23037960.69%56.85%3.83%15
390Jack Kemp1960LAC21140651.97%48.4%3.57%14
391Drew Bledsoe1996NWE37362359.87%57.55%2.32%14
392Chad Pennington2003NYJ18929763.64%58.76%4.87%14
393Billy Kilmer1974WAS13723458.55%52.37%6.18%14
394Dave Krieg1990SEA26544859.15%55.93%3.22%14
395Drew Brees2012NOR42267062.99%60.84%2.15%14
396Aaron Rodgers2008GNB34153663.62%60.93%2.69%14
397Dennis Shaw1970BUF17832155.45%50.98%4.47%14
398Y.A. Tittle1950BAL16131551.11%46.56%4.55%14
399Y.A. Tittle1961NYG16328557.19%52.2%4.99%14
400Boomer Esiason1993NYJ28847360.89%57.88%3.01%14
401Steve Beuerlein2000CAR32453360.79%58.12%2.66%14
402Len Dawson1971KAN16730155.48%50.77%4.71%14
403John Hadl1971SDG23343154.06%50.77%3.29%14
404Billy Kilmer1970NOR13523756.96%50.98%5.98%14
405Joe Theismann1984WAS28347759.33%56.36%2.97%14
406Jeff George1991IND29248560.21%57.29%2.92%14
407Bobby Hebert1993ATL26343061.16%57.88%3.28%14
408Tom Flores1960OAK13625253.97%48.42%5.55%14
409Craig Morton1980DEN18330160.8%56.16%4.64%14
410Dan Fouts1986SDG25243058.6%55.36%3.24%14
411David Garrard2010JAX23636664.48%60.7%3.78%14
412Norm Van Brocklin1955RAM14427252.94%47.86%5.09%14
413Lynn Dickey1983GNB28948459.71%56.86%2.85%14
414Billy Wade1964CHI18232755.66%51.44%4.22%14
415Bobby Layne1955DET14327052.96%47.86%5.11%14
416Terry Bradshaw1971PIT20337354.42%50.78%3.65%14
417Fran Tarkenton1964MIN17130655.88%51.44%4.44%14
418Brett Favre2001GNB31451061.57%58.92%2.64%13
419Richard Todd1983NYJ30851859.46%56.86%2.6%13
420Tom Brady2012NWE40163762.95%60.84%2.11%13
421Mark Brunell2000JAX31151260.74%58.13%2.61%13
422John Hadl1964SDG14727453.65%48.77%4.88%13
423Boomer Esiason1986CIN27346958.21%55.36%2.84%13
424Carson Palmer2006CIN32452062.31%59.75%2.56%13
425Steve Fuller1980KAN19332060.31%56.16%4.15%13
426John Elway1990DEN29450258.57%55.94%2.63%13
427Norm Van Brocklin1958PHI19837452.94%49.42%3.53%13
428Jim Zorn1978SEA24844355.98%53.01%2.97%13
429Jeff Garcia2002SFO32852862.12%59.63%2.49%13
430Bobby Hebert1996ATL29448860.25%57.56%2.69%13
431Vince Ferragamo1980RAM24040459.41%56.17%3.24%13
432Mike Livingston1976KAN18933855.92%52.05%3.86%13
433Vinny Testaverde1995CLE24139261.48%58.15%3.33%13
434Joe Montana1994KAN29949360.65%58%2.65%13
435Bill Munson1974DET16629256.85%52.38%4.47%13
436John Brodie1962SFO17530457.57%53.29%4.28%13
437Gary Danielson1978DET19935156.7%53.01%3.68%13
438Russell Wilson2012SEA25239364.12%60.84%3.28%13
439Roman Gabriel1966RAM21739754.66%51.42%3.24%13
440Alex Smith2014KAN30346465.3%62.59%2.72%13
441Matt Cassel2008NWE32751663.37%60.94%2.43%13
442Boomer Esiason1988CIN22338857.47%54.25%3.22%13
443Brett Favre1996GNB32554359.85%57.56%2.29%12
444Billy Wade1958RAM18134153.08%49.44%3.64%12
445John Brodie1966SFO23242754.33%51.42%2.91%12
446Brett Favre2002GNB34155161.89%59.64%2.25%12
447Frankie Albert1950SFO15530650.65%46.61%4.05%12
448Randall Cunningham1992PHI23338460.68%57.46%3.22%12
449Carson Palmer2013ARI36257263.29%61.15%2.14%12
450Jon Kitna2007DET35556163.28%61.1%2.18%12
451Tony Romo2009DAL34755063.09%60.88%2.21%12
452Jim Zorn1979SEA28550556.44%54.04%2.39%12
453Jeff George1995ATL33655760.32%58.16%2.17%12
454Brad Johnson2002TAM28145162.31%59.64%2.67%12
455Roger Staubach1978DAL23141355.93%53.02%2.91%12
456Josh McCown2013CHI14922466.52%61.15%5.37%12
457John Brodie1969SFO19434755.91%52.46%3.45%12
458Greg Landry1977DET13524056.25%51.28%4.97%12
459Jon Kitna2002CIN29447362.16%59.64%2.52%12
460Terry Bradshaw1978PIT20736856.25%53.02%3.23%12
461Fran Tarkenton1967NYG20437754.11%50.96%3.15%12
462Jim Harbaugh1993CHI20032561.54%57.9%3.64%12
463Eli Manning2010NYG33953962.89%60.71%2.18%12
464Don Meredith1968DAL17130955.34%51.56%3.78%12
465Dan Marino1992MIA33055459.57%57.46%2.1%12
466J.P. Losman2006BUF26842962.47%59.76%2.71%12
467Jay Cutler2007DEN29746763.6%61.11%2.49%12
468Hugh Millen1991NWE24640960.15%57.31%2.84%12
469Bart Starr1965GNB14025155.78%51.17%4.6%12
470Ken Anderson1980CIN16627560.36%56.18%4.19%12
471Bert Jones1981BAL24442657.28%54.58%2.7%11
472Jim Hart1973STL17832055.63%52.04%3.59%11
473Jake Plummer2003DEN18930262.58%58.78%3.8%11
474Matt Hasselbeck2003SEA31351361.01%58.78%2.23%11
475John Brodie1971SFO20838753.75%50.8%2.95%11
476Erik Kramer1995CHI31552260.34%58.16%2.18%11
477Bob Griese1971MIA14526355.13%50.8%4.33%11
478Bill Munson1968DET18132955.02%51.56%3.45%11
479Brett Favre2005GNB37260761.29%59.42%1.86%11
480Joe Namath1965NYJ16434048.24%44.91%3.32%11
481Dan Marino1997MIA31954858.21%56.15%2.06%11
482Ryan Fitzpatrick2011BUF35356962.04%60.07%1.97%11
483Joe Flacco2009BAL31549963.13%60.88%2.24%11
484Drew Bledsoe2002BUF37561061.48%59.64%1.83%11
485Rodney Peete1993DET15725262.3%57.9%4.4%11
486Jeff Garcia1999SFO22537560%57.05%2.95%11
487Charlie Conerly1957NYG12823255.17%50.46%4.71%11
488Lynn Dickey1984GNB23740159.1%56.38%2.72%11
489Randall Cunningham1990PHI27146558.28%55.95%2.33%11
490Troy Aikman1999DAL26344259.5%57.06%2.45%11
491Bob Berry1972ATL15427755.6%51.7%3.9%11
492Lynn Dickey1981GNB20435457.63%54.58%3.04%11
493Ben Roethlisberger2012PIT28444963.25%60.86%2.4%11
494Steve McNair1998TEN28949258.74%56.56%2.18%11
495Gus Frerotte1999DET17528860.76%57.06%3.71%11
496Fran Tarkenton1961MIN15728056.07%52.27%3.8%11
497Norm Van Brocklin1960PHI15328453.87%50.13%3.74%11
498Tom Brady2006NWE31951661.82%59.76%2.06%11
499Jeff Hostetler1996OAK24240260.2%57.57%2.63%11
500Dan Pastorini1974HOU14024756.68%52.41%4.27%11
501Billy Kilmer1971WAS16630654.25%50.81%3.44%11
502Brad Johnson2001TAM34055960.82%58.94%1.88%11
503Brian Sipe1978CLE22239955.64%53.04%2.6%10
504Otto Graham1952CLE18136449.73%46.9%2.83%10
505Matt Ryan2010ATL35757162.52%60.72%1.8%10
506Daryle Lamonica1968OAK20641649.52%47.05%2.47%10
507Dave Krieg1988SEA13422858.77%54.27%4.5%10
508Tony Banks1998STL24140859.07%56.56%2.5%10
509Mark Brunell2001JAX28947361.1%58.94%2.16%10
510Rich Gannon1999OAK30451559.03%57.06%1.97%10
511Y.A. Tittle1949BCL14828951.21%47.72%3.49%10
512Shane Matthews1999CHI16727560.73%57.06%3.67%10
513Norm Snead1970PHI18133554.03%51.02%3.01%10
514Vince Ferragamo1983RAM27446459.05%56.89%2.16%10
515Phil Simms1990NYG18431159.16%55.96%3.2%10
516Steve McNair2001TEN26443161.25%58.95%2.31%10
517Tom Flores1966OAK15130649.35%46.1%3.24%10
518Chris Chandler1997ATL20234259.06%56.16%2.9%10
519Daryle Lamonica1969OAK22142651.88%49.55%2.33%10
520Kerry Collins2002NYG33554561.47%59.65%1.82%10
521Bart Starr1970GNB14025554.9%51.02%3.88%10
522Bobby Layne1954DET13524654.88%50.89%3.99%10
523Jim Kelly1989BUF22839158.31%55.81%2.51%10
524Craig Morton1972DAL18533954.57%51.71%2.86%10
525Gary Danielson1980DET24441758.51%56.19%2.32%10
526Erik Kramer1998CHI15125060.4%56.57%3.83%10
527Danny White1981DAL22339157.03%54.59%2.44%10
528Steve DeBerg1990KAN25844458.11%55.96%2.14%10
529Charlie Conerly1949NYG15230549.84%46.74%3.1%9
530Ken Stabler1981HOU16528557.89%54.59%3.3%9
531Lynn Dickey1980GNB27847858.16%56.19%1.97%9
532Johnny Unitas1961BAL22942054.52%52.3%2.23%9
533David Garrard2007JAX20832564%61.12%2.88%9
534Y.A. Tittle1955SFO14728751.22%47.98%3.24%9
535Brad Johnson2005MIN18429462.59%59.44%3.15%9
536Elvis Grbac1999KAN29449958.92%57.07%1.85%9
537Brian Griese2001DEN27545160.98%58.95%2.02%9
538Jeff Garcia2007TAM20932763.91%61.12%2.79%9
539Tommy Maddox2002PIT23437762.07%59.65%2.41%9
540Nick Foles2013PHI20331764.04%61.17%2.87%9
541Steve McNair2005TEN29247661.34%59.44%1.91%9
542Philip Rivers2006SDG28446061.74%59.77%1.97%9
543Joe Flacco2010BAL30648962.58%60.73%1.85%9
544Otto Graham1948CLE17333351.95%49.25%2.7%9
545Tommy Kramer1979MIN31556655.65%54.07%1.59%9
546Steve Walsh1994CHI20834360.64%58.03%2.61%9
547Rich Gannon2000OAK28447360.04%58.16%1.89%9
548Dave Krieg1996CHI22637759.95%57.58%2.36%9
549Charley Johnson1972DEN13223855.46%51.72%3.74%9
550Steve Pelluer1988DAL24543556.32%54.28%2.04%9
551Vinny Testaverde1996BAL32554959.2%57.58%1.62%9
552David Garrard2008JAX33553562.62%60.97%1.65%9
553Bill Nelsen1971CLE17432553.54%50.83%2.71%9
554Dan Marino1990MIA30653157.63%55.97%1.66%9
555Brian Sipe1983CLE29149658.67%56.9%1.77%9
556Troy Aikman1998DAL18731559.37%56.57%2.79%9
557Frankie Albert1947SFO12824252.89%49.26%3.63%9
558Dave Krieg1983SEA14724360.49%56.9%3.6%9
559Tim Couch2002CLE27344361.63%59.66%1.97%9
560Bob Griese1967MIA16633150.15%47.52%2.63%9
561Jim McMahon1991PHI18731160.13%57.33%2.8%9
562Ben Roethlisberger2005PIT16826862.69%59.44%3.25%9
563Al Dorow1960NYT20139650.76%48.57%2.19%9
564Norm Snead1973NYG13123555.74%52.07%3.68%9
565Tom Brady2014NWE37358264.09%62.61%1.48%9
566John Elway1998DEN21035658.99%56.57%2.41%9
567Sonny Jurgensen1964WAS20738553.77%51.54%2.23%9
568Randy Wright1988GNB14124457.79%54.28%3.51%9
569Billy Wade1963CHI19235653.93%51.55%2.39%8
570Matt Hasselbeck2007SEA35256262.63%61.13%1.51%8
571Jay Cutler2008DEN38461662.34%60.97%1.37%8
572Phil Simms1987NYG16328257.8%54.82%2.98%8
573Joe Montana1993KAN18129860.74%57.92%2.82%8
574Bob Griese1979MIA17631056.77%54.07%2.7%8
575Kurt Warner2004NYG17427762.82%59.79%3.02%8
576Jeff Blake2000NOR18430260.93%58.16%2.77%8
577Jack Thompson1983TAM24942358.87%56.9%1.97%8
578Jim McMahon1993MIN20033160.42%57.92%2.5%8
579Steve DeBerg1987TAM15927557.82%54.82%3%8
580Billy Wade1961CHI13925055.6%52.32%3.28%8
581Jim Finks1954PIT16430653.59%50.93%2.67%8
582Charley Johnson1974DEN13624455.74%52.44%3.3%8
583Fran Tarkenton1968NYG18233754.01%51.62%2.39%8
584Rich Gannon1991MIN21135459.6%57.33%2.27%8
585Russell Wilson2013SEA25740763.14%61.17%1.97%8
586Joe Namath1968NYJ18738049.21%47.11%2.1%8
587Jim Everett1992RAM28147559.16%57.49%1.67%8
588Elvis Grbac2000KAN32654759.6%58.16%1.43%8
589Steve Spurrier1972SFO14726954.65%51.73%2.92%8
590Andy Dalton2014CIN30948164.24%62.61%1.63%8
591Chris Chandler2001ATL22336561.1%58.96%2.14%8
592Matt Hasselbeck2011TEN31951861.58%60.09%1.5%8
593Johnny Unitas1959BAL19336752.59%50.49%2.1%8
594Mark Brunell1998JAX20835458.76%56.58%2.18%8
595Jay Fiedler2001MIA27345060.67%58.96%1.71%8
596Ken Anderson1973CIN17932954.41%52.08%2.33%8
597Fran Tarkenton1966MIN19235853.63%51.5%2.13%8
598Mark Rypien1991WAS24942159.14%57.34%1.81%8
599Richard Todd1981NYJ27949756.14%54.61%1.53%8
600Andy Dalton2012CIN32952862.31%60.87%1.44%8
601Sid Luckman1946CHI11022948.03%44.72%3.31%8
602James Harris1975RAM15728555.09%52.43%2.66%8
603Neil Lomax1983STL20935459.04%56.9%2.13%8
604Sonny Jurgensen1965WAS19035653.37%51.25%2.12%8
605Brad Johnson2006MIN27043961.5%59.78%1.72%8
606Chris Chandler1992PHO24541359.32%57.5%1.83%8
607Steve McNair2002TEN30149261.18%59.66%1.51%7
608Dave Krieg1989SEA28649957.31%55.82%1.49%7
609Roman Gabriel1969RAM21739954.39%52.53%1.85%7
610Archie Manning1981NOR13423257.76%54.61%3.15%7
611Mark Brunell1999JAX25944158.73%57.08%1.65%7
612Teddy Bridgewater2014MIN25940264.43%62.62%1.81%7
613Sage Rosenfels2007HOU15424064.17%61.13%3.03%7
614Len Dawson1970KAN14126253.82%51.05%2.77%7
615Steve DeBerg1991KAN25643458.99%57.34%1.65%7
616Bill Munson1965RAM14426753.93%51.26%2.68%7
617Don Meredith1963DAL16731053.87%51.57%2.3%7
618Jim McMahon1983CHI17529559.32%56.91%2.41%7
619Kyle Orton2014BUF28744764.21%62.62%1.59%7
620Tom Brady2003NWE31752760.15%58.81%1.34%7
621Ty Detmer1996PHI23840159.35%57.59%1.76%7
622Michael Vick2010PHI23337262.63%60.74%1.89%7
623Scott Mitchell1997DET29350957.56%56.18%1.38%7
624Erik Kramer1997CHI27547757.65%56.18%1.47%7
625Eli Manning2009NYG31750962.28%60.91%1.37%7
626Vinny Testaverde1997BAL27147057.66%56.18%1.48%7
627Matt Ryan2011ATL34756661.31%60.09%1.21%7
628John Brodie1961SFO15528354.77%52.34%2.43%7
629Jay Cutler2013CHI22435563.1%61.18%1.92%7
630Joe Theismann1980WAS26245457.71%56.21%1.5%7
631Bobby Hebert1991NOR14924860.08%57.34%2.74%7
632Scott Mitchell1995DET34658359.35%58.19%1.16%7
633Trent Dilfer1999TAM14624459.84%57.08%2.76%7
634Neil Lomax1986STL24042157.01%55.41%1.6%7
635Doug Williams1988WAS21338056.05%54.29%1.76%7
636Roman Gabriel1967RAM19637152.83%51.05%1.78%7
637Bud Schwenk1947BCL16832751.38%49.36%2.02%7
638Ken O'Brien1991NYJ28748958.69%57.34%1.35%7
639Trent Green2002KAN28747061.06%59.67%1.39%7
640Mark Brunell2006WAS16226062.31%59.79%2.52%7
641Neil Lomax1985STL26547156.26%54.87%1.39%7
642Chris Miller1992ATL15225360.08%57.5%2.58%7
643Norm Van Brocklin1954RAM13926053.46%50.97%2.49%6
644Kyle Orton2009DEN33654162.11%60.91%1.2%6
645Jason Campbell2008WAS31550662.25%60.98%1.27%6
646Dan Fouts1987SDG20636456.59%54.84%1.76%6
647Charley Johnson1964STL22342053.1%51.58%1.52%6
648Bobby Hebert1992NOR24942259%57.5%1.5%6
649Patrick Ramsey2004WAS16927262.13%59.81%2.33%6
650Bubby Brister1990PIT22338757.62%55.99%1.64%6
651David Carr2004HOU28546661.16%59.81%1.35%6
652Jim McMahon1985CHI17831356.87%54.88%1.99%6
653Pete Liske1971PHI14326953.16%50.86%2.3%6
654Johnny Unitas1969BAL17832754.43%52.55%1.88%6
655Dan Marino1996MIA22137359.25%57.6%1.65%6
656Pat Haden1979RAM16329056.21%54.09%2.12%6
657Marc Wilson1987RAI15226657.14%54.84%2.31%6
658Drew Brees2002SDG32052660.84%59.67%1.16%6
659Bart Starr1963GNB13224454.1%51.59%2.51%6
660Dan Marino1998MIA31053757.73%56.59%1.14%6
661Carson Palmer2010CIN36258661.77%60.75%1.03%6
662Milt Plum1964DET15428753.66%51.58%2.07%6
663Dan Pastorini1976HOU16730954.05%52.12%1.92%6
664Christian Ponder2012MIN30048362.11%60.88%1.23%6
665Frank Tripucka1961DEN16734448.55%46.83%1.72%6
666Steve Bartkowski1981ATL29753355.72%54.62%1.1%6
667Jeff Blake1997CIN18431758.04%56.19%1.86%6
668Jake Plummer2005DEN27745660.75%59.46%1.29%6
669John Hadl1975GNB19135354.11%52.45%1.66%6
670Anthony Wright2005BAL16426661.65%59.46%2.2%6
671Steve Ramsey1975DEN12823354.94%52.45%2.49%6
672Ken O'Brien1988NYJ23642455.66%54.3%1.36%6
673Christian Ponder2013MIN15223963.6%61.19%2.41%6
674Jack Kemp1963BUF19338450.26%48.76%1.5%6
675Joe Namath1969NYJ18536151.25%49.66%1.59%6
676Ray Lucas1999NYJ16127259.19%57.09%2.1%6
677Rich Gannon1998KAN20635458.19%56.59%1.6%6
678Ken Anderson1979CIN18933955.75%54.09%1.66%6
679Jeff Hostetler1995OAK17228660.14%58.2%1.94%6
680Alex Smith2011SFO27344561.35%60.1%1.25%6
681Steve DeBerg1980SFO18632157.94%56.22%1.72%6
682Tommy Kramer1980MIN29952257.28%56.22%1.06%6
683Steve Pelluer1986DAL21537856.88%55.42%1.46%6
684Johnny Unitas1958BAL13626351.71%49.61%2.1%6
685Daunte Culpepper2002MIN33354960.66%59.68%0.98%5
686Trent Green2000STL14524060.42%58.18%2.24%5
687Shaun Hill2008SFO18128862.85%60.99%1.86%5
688Kordell Stewart2001PIT26644260.18%58.97%1.21%5
689Milt Plum1962DET17932555.08%53.44%1.64%5
690Richard Todd1982NYJ15326158.62%56.59%2.03%5
691Jim Harbaugh1990CHI18031257.69%56%1.7%5
692Kent Graham1999NYG16027159.04%57.09%1.95%5
693Jake Delhomme2006CAR26343161.02%59.8%1.22%5
694Kurt Warner2007ARI28145162.31%61.15%1.16%5
695Dan Pastorini1977HOU16931952.98%51.35%1.62%5
696Adrian Burk1954PHI12323153.25%51%2.24%5
697Dave Krieg1984SEA27648057.5%56.42%1.08%5
698Ron Jaworski1982PHI16728658.39%56.59%1.8%5
699Warren Moon1984HOU25945057.56%56.42%1.13%5
700Steve Bono1991SFO14123759.49%57.35%2.14%5
701Johnny Green1962NYT12825849.61%47.65%1.96%5
702Mike Livingston1978KAN15929054.83%53.08%1.75%5
703George Shaw1955BAL11923750.21%48.1%2.12%5
704Eli Manning2011NYG35958960.95%60.1%0.85%5
705Fran Tarkenton1969NYG22040953.79%52.57%1.22%5
706Neil O'Donnell1992PIT18531359.11%57.51%1.59%5
707Bobby Layne1956DET12924452.87%50.83%2.04%5
708Bill Nelsen1969CLE19035253.98%52.57%1.41%5
709Craig Morton1976NYG15328453.87%52.13%1.74%5
710Chris Chandler1998ATL19032758.1%56.6%1.51%5
711Chris Simms2005TAM19131361.02%59.46%1.56%5
712David Whitehurst1979GNB17932255.59%54.1%1.49%5
713Billy Wade1962CHI22541254.61%53.45%1.16%5
714Jay Fiedler2002MIA17929261.3%59.68%1.62%5
715Chris Miller1990ATL22238857.22%56%1.22%5
716Earl Morrall1963DET17432853.05%51.62%1.43%5
717John Elway1988DEN27449655.24%54.31%0.93%5
718Carson Palmer2004CIN26343260.88%59.82%1.06%5
719Dan Marino1983MIA17329658.45%56.93%1.52%4
720Mark Sanchez2014PHI19830964.08%62.63%1.45%4
721Tom Brady2004NWE28847460.76%59.82%0.94%4
722David Carr2005HOU25642360.52%59.47%1.05%4
723Billy Volek2004TEN21835761.06%59.82%1.25%4
724Steve DeBerg19932TM13622759.91%57.95%1.96%4
725Vince Young2007TEN23838262.3%61.15%1.15%4
726Andy Dalton2013CIN36358661.95%61.19%0.75%4
727Babe Parilli1966BOS18138247.38%46.24%1.14%4
728Jim Plunkett1982RAI15226158.24%56.6%1.64%4
729Bill Kenney1987KAN15427356.41%54.85%1.56%4
730Craig Morton1978DEN14626754.68%53.09%1.59%4
731Shaun Hill2010DET25741661.78%60.76%1.02%4
732Tim Couch2001CLE27245459.91%58.98%0.93%4
733Billy Kilmer1968NOR16731553.02%51.68%1.33%4
734Joe Ferguson1980BUF25143957.18%56.23%0.94%4
735Frankie Albert1949SFO12926049.62%48.06%1.55%4
736Bobby Layne1952DET13928748.43%47.07%1.36%4
737Boomer Esiason1989CIN25845556.7%55.85%0.86%4
738Tony Eason1985NWE16829956.19%54.89%1.29%4
739Neil O'Donnell1995PIT24641659.13%58.21%0.93%4
740Chuck Long1987DET23241655.77%54.85%0.91%4
741Craig Morton1979DEN20437055.14%54.11%1.03%4
742Stan Humphries1995SDG28247859%58.21%0.79%4
743Billy Kilmer1973WAS12222753.74%52.13%1.62%4
744Billy Kilmer1969NOR19336053.61%52.59%1.02%4
745Ben Roethlisberger2010PIT24038961.7%60.76%0.94%4
746Charley Johnson1973DEN18434653.18%52.13%1.05%4
747Jim Hart1977STL18635552.39%51.37%1.03%4
748Jim Kelly1996BUF22237958.58%57.62%0.96%4
749Ken Anderson1978CIN17331954.23%53.09%1.14%4
750Dan Pastorini1978HOU19936854.08%53.09%0.98%4
751Terry Bradshaw1979PIT25947254.87%54.11%0.76%4
752Tim Rattay2004SFO19832560.92%59.82%1.1%4
753Charley Johnson1963STL22242352.48%51.64%0.84%4
754Troy Aikman2000DAL15626259.54%58.19%1.35%4
755Daryle Lamonica1972OAK14928153.02%51.78%1.25%3
756Billy Kilmer1972WAS12022553.33%51.78%1.55%3
757Bob Avellini1977CHI15429352.56%51.37%1.19%3
758Zeke Bratkowski1961RAM12423053.91%52.41%1.5%3
759Ron Jaworski1980PHI25745156.98%56.24%0.75%3
760Steve Grogan1977NWE16030552.46%51.37%1.09%3
761Jake Delhomme2005CAR26243560.23%59.47%0.76%3
762Chad Henne2010MIA30149061.43%60.76%0.67%3
763Phil Simms1985NYG27549555.56%54.9%0.66%3
764Davey O'Brien1940PHI12427744.77%43.59%1.17%3
765Drew Bledsoe2005DAL30049960.12%59.47%0.65%3
766Jim Kelly1992BUF26946258.23%57.53%0.7%3
767Brian Sipe1981CLE31356755.2%54.64%0.57%3
768George Ratterman1947BUF12424450.82%49.51%1.31%3
769Greg Landry1971DET13626152.11%50.89%1.22%3
770Byron Leftwich2004JAX26744160.54%59.82%0.72%3
771Kerry Collins2000NYG31152958.79%58.19%0.6%3
772Craig Morton1969DAL16230253.64%52.6%1.04%3
773Jeff George1999MIN19132958.05%57.1%0.95%3
774Dan Marino1991MIA31854957.92%57.37%0.56%3
775Roman Gabriel1970RAM21140751.84%51.1%0.75%3
776Jacky Lee1964DEN13326550.19%49.05%1.14%3
777Drew Bledsoe2000NWE31253158.76%58.19%0.56%3
778Gus Frerotte2000DEN13823259.48%58.19%1.29%3
779Josh Freeman2010TAM29147461.39%60.76%0.63%3
780Frank Ryan1966CLE20038252.36%51.58%0.78%3
781Kordell Stewart1999PIT16027558.18%57.1%1.08%3
782Damon Huard2007KAN20633262.05%61.16%0.89%3
783Steve Grogan1980NWE17530657.19%56.24%0.95%3
784Brian Griese1999DEN26145257.74%57.1%0.64%3
785Dan Pastorini1973HOU15429053.1%52.14%0.97%3
786Phil Simms1988NYG26347954.91%54.32%0.59%3
787Ryan Fitzpatrick2013TEN21735062%61.2%0.8%3
788Frank Ryan1963CLE13525652.73%51.65%1.08%3
789Ken Anderson1976CIN17933852.96%52.16%0.8%3
790Bobby Hebert1987NOR16429455.78%54.86%0.92%3
791Bill Kenney1983KAN34660357.38%56.94%0.44%3
792Eli Manning2014NYG37960163.06%62.64%0.42%3
793Cam Newton2013CAR29247361.73%61.2%0.53%3
794Elvis Grbac1997KAN17931457.01%56.21%0.8%2
795Troy Aikman1990DAL22639956.64%56.02%0.63%2
796Trent Dilfer2000BAL13422659.29%58.2%1.1%2
797Matt Schaub2011HOU17829260.96%60.12%0.84%2
798Jack Kemp1965BUF17939145.78%45.16%0.62%2
799Chris Chandler1988IND12923355.36%54.32%1.04%2
800Josh McCown2005ARI16327060.37%59.48%0.89%2
801Dennis Shaw1972BUF13625852.71%51.79%0.92%2
802Jack Trudeau1987IND12822955.9%54.87%1.03%2
803Glenn Dobbs1948LAD18536950.14%49.51%0.63%2
804Jim Hart1981STL13424155.6%54.64%0.96%2
805George Ratterman1950NYY14029447.62%46.85%0.77%2
806Joey Harrington2007ATL21534861.78%61.16%0.62%2
807George Ratterman1948BUF16833550.15%49.51%0.63%2
808Norm Snead1965PHI15028852.08%51.35%0.73%2
809Don Majkowski1990GNB15026456.82%56.02%0.8%2
810Austin Davis2014STL18028463.38%62.64%0.74%2
811Fran Tarkenton1965MIN17132951.98%51.35%0.62%2
812Damon Huard2006KAN14824460.66%59.82%0.84%2
813Glenn Dobbs1946BDA13526950.19%49.45%0.74%2
814Johnny Lujack1950CHI12125447.64%46.86%0.78%2
815Johnny Unitas1970BAL16632151.71%51.11%0.61%2
816Bubby Brister1993PHI18130958.58%57.97%0.61%2
817Russell Wilson2014SEA28545263.05%62.65%0.41%2
818Y.A. Tittle1964NYG14728152.31%51.66%0.65%2
819Jake Delhomme2003CAR26644959.24%58.84%0.4%2
820Carson Palmer2011OAK19932860.67%60.12%0.55%2
821Stan Humphries1992SDG26345457.93%57.54%0.39%2
822Phil Simms1989NYG22840556.3%55.86%0.43%2
823Tommy Kramer1986MIN20837255.91%55.44%0.47%2
824Joe Theismann1985WAS16730155.48%54.91%0.57%2
825Donovan McNabb2007PHI29147361.52%61.17%0.36%2
826Doug Flutie1998BUF20235457.06%56.62%0.44%2
827Tommy Kramer1982MIN17630857.14%56.64%0.51%2
828Warren Moon1993HOU30352058.27%57.97%0.3%2
829Ryan Fitzpatrick2014HOU19731263.14%62.65%0.49%2
830Shaun Hill2014STL14522963.32%62.65%0.67%2
831Bobby Hoying1997PHI12822556.89%56.22%0.67%2
832Jim Zorn1980SEA27648856.56%56.25%0.31%1
833Norm Snead1968PHI15229152.23%51.73%0.51%1
834Joe Namath1974NYJ19136152.91%52.5%0.4%1
835Tony Romo2008DAL27645061.33%61.01%0.32%1
836Charlie Batch1998DET17330357.1%56.62%0.48%1
837Frank Ryan1964CLE17433452.1%51.67%0.43%1
838Matt Moore2011MIA21034760.52%60.12%0.39%1
839Bert Jones1974BAL14327052.96%52.51%0.46%1
840Aaron Brooks2003NOR30651859.07%58.84%0.23%1
841Brett Favre1999GNB34159557.31%57.11%0.2%1
842Scott Mitchell1996DET25343757.89%57.63%0.26%1
843Jim Harbaugh1999SDG24943457.37%57.11%0.26%1
844Gary Cuozzo1967NOR13426051.54%51.14%0.4%1
845Roger Staubach1974DAL19036052.78%52.51%0.27%1
846Kerry Collins1999NYG19033157.4%57.11%0.29%1
847Trent Dilfer2005CLE19933359.76%59.49%0.27%1
848Virgil Carter1970CIN14327851.44%51.12%0.32%1
849Jim Hart1975STL18234552.75%52.5%0.26%1
850Stan Humphries1994SDG26445358.28%58.08%0.19%1
851Carson Palmer2012OAK34556561.06%60.91%0.15%1
852Dennis Shaw1971BUF14929151.2%50.92%0.29%1
853David Garrard2006JAX14524160.17%59.82%0.34%1
854Vinny Testaverde2004DAL29749560%59.84%0.16%1
855Roman Gabriel1971RAM18035251.14%50.92%0.22%1
856Troy Aikman1997DAL29251856.37%56.22%0.15%1
857Bob Avellini1978CHI14126453.41%53.12%0.29%1
858Archie Manning1973NOR14026752.43%52.16%0.27%1
859Brian Griese2007CHI16126261.45%61.17%0.28%1
860Dan Marino1989MIA30855056%55.87%0.13%1
861Jim Harbaugh1991CHI27547857.53%57.39%0.15%1
862Joe Kapp1968MIN12924852.02%51.74%0.28%1
863Carson Palmer2014ARI14122462.95%62.65%0.29%1
864Dave Krieg1995ARI30452158.35%58.22%0.12%1
865Gary Hogeboom1989PHO20436456.04%55.87%0.17%1
866Terry Bradshaw1977PIT16231451.59%51.4%0.19%1
867Jim Plunkett1977SFO12824851.61%51.4%0.21%1
868John Elway1986DEN28050455.56%55.45%0.1%1
869Joe Ferguson1975BUF16932152.65%52.5%0.15%0
870Craig Morton1977DEN13125451.57%51.4%0.17%0
871John Hadl1973RAM13525852.33%52.16%0.16%0
872Tarvaris Jackson2011SEA27145060.22%60.13%0.09%0
873John Elway1995DEN31654258.3%58.23%0.08%0
874Peyton Manning1998IND32657556.7%56.63%0.07%0
875Brett Favre2000GNB33858058.28%58.21%0.07%0
876Bill Nelsen1968CLE15229351.88%51.75%0.13%0
877Tom Flores1965OAK12226945.35%45.21%0.14%0
878Neil O'Donnell1997NYJ25946056.3%56.22%0.08%0
879Johnny Unitas1964BAL15830551.8%51.69%0.11%0
880Charley Johnson1970HOU14428151.25%51.12%0.12%0
881Warren Moon1988HOU16029454.42%54.34%0.08%0
882Randall Cunningham1987PHI22340654.93%54.88%0.04%0
883Matt Ryan2008ATL26543461.06%61.02%0.04%0
884Sonny Jurgensen1962PHI19636653.55%53.54%0.01%0
885Adrian Burk1955PHI11022848.25%48.23%0.01%0
886Eric Hipple1985DET22340654.93%54.92%0.01%0
887Bob Lee1973ATL12023052.17%52.17%0.01%0
888Trent Dilfer1997TAM21738656.22%56.23%-0.01%0
889Vinny Testaverde1992TAM20635857.54%57.55%-0.01%0
890Ken Anderson1977CIN16632351.39%51.41%-0.01%0
891Matt Schaub2013HOU21935861.17%61.22%-0.05%0
892Steve Fuller1979KAN14627054.07%54.14%-0.06%0
893John Hadl1968SDG20844047.27%47.31%-0.04%0
894Earl Morrall1965NYG15530251.32%51.39%-0.07%0
895Vinny Testaverde2001NYJ26044158.96%59.01%-0.05%0
896Kyle Boller2007BAL16827561.09%61.18%-0.09%0
897Ed Brown1959CHI12524750.61%50.71%-0.1%0
898Joe Ferguson1978BUF17533053.03%53.13%-0.1%0
899Nick Foles2012PHI16126560.75%60.92%-0.16%0
900Chris Chandler1996HOU18432057.5%57.64%-0.14%0
901Jim Everett1996NOR26746457.54%57.64%-0.1%0
902Lynn Dickey1985GNB17231454.78%54.92%-0.15%0
903Mark Brunell1995JAX20134658.09%58.23%-0.14%0
904David Garrard2009JAX31451660.85%60.95%-0.1%-1
905Jim Finks1952PIT15833647.02%47.19%-0.16%-1
906Phil Simms1986NYG25946855.34%55.46%-0.12%-1
907John Elway1984DEN21438056.32%56.46%-0.15%-1
908Johnny Unitas1960BAL19037850.26%50.41%-0.15%-1
909Brett Favre2010MIN21735860.61%60.78%-0.17%-1
910Boomer Esiason1994NYJ25544057.95%58.09%-0.14%-1
911Ben Roethlisberger2006PIT28046959.7%59.83%-0.13%-1
912Don Meredith1966DAL17734451.45%51.64%-0.19%-1
913Dave Wilson1986NOR18934255.26%55.46%-0.2%-1
914Chris Chandler2000ATL19233158.01%58.22%-0.21%-1
915Phil Simms1981NYG17231654.43%54.66%-0.23%-1
916Mark Malone1988SDG14727254.04%54.35%-0.3%-1
917Jim Plunkett1976SFO12624351.85%52.19%-0.34%-1
918Y.A. Tittle1962NYG20037553.33%53.56%-0.22%-1
919Chad Henne2009MIA27445160.75%60.95%-0.2%-1
920Cam Newton2011CAR31051759.96%60.14%-0.18%-1
921Tommy Kramer1985MIN27750654.74%54.93%-0.18%-1
922Gus Frerotte1996WAS27047057.45%57.64%-0.2%-1
923Steve DeBerg1988KAN22441454.11%54.35%-0.24%-1
924Jim Finks1955PIT16534447.97%48.26%-0.29%-1
925John Elway1987DEN22441054.63%54.89%-0.26%-1
926Bill Nelsen1970CLE15931350.8%51.14%-0.34%-1
927Warren Moon1998SEA14525856.2%56.64%-0.44%-1
928Kent Nix1967PIT13626850.75%51.17%-0.42%-1
929Ken Stabler1983NOR17631156.59%56.97%-0.38%-1
930Donovan McNabb2000PHI33056958%58.22%-0.22%-1
931Terry Bradshaw1981PIT20137054.32%54.67%-0.34%-1
932Boomer Esiason1990CIN22440255.72%56.04%-0.32%-1
933Jeff Hostetler1994RAI26345557.8%58.1%-0.3%-1
934Bobby Layne19582TM14529449.32%49.79%-0.47%-1
935Chris Chandler1999ATL17430756.68%57.13%-0.45%-1
936Michael Vick2011PHI25342359.81%60.14%-0.33%-1
937Sam Bradford2013STL15926260.69%61.23%-0.54%-1
938Donovan McNabb2005PHI21135759.1%59.5%-0.4%-1
939Jack Kemp1969BUF17034449.42%49.84%-0.42%-1
940Drew Bledsoe1994NWE40069157.89%58.1%-0.21%-1
941Jim Harbaugh1996IND23240557.28%57.65%-0.36%-1
942Boomer Esiason1987CIN24044054.55%54.89%-0.35%-2
943Kyle Orton20112TM15025259.52%60.14%-0.62%-2
944Craig Morton19742TM12423951.88%52.54%-0.65%-2
945Vinny Testaverde1990TAM20336555.62%56.05%-0.43%-2
946Rich Gannon1992MIN15927956.99%57.56%-0.57%-2
947Jay Cutler2010CHI26143260.42%60.79%-0.37%-2
948Charlie Conerly1953NYG14330347.19%47.75%-0.55%-2
949Ryan Fitzpatrick2012BUF30650560.59%60.93%-0.33%-2
950Jim McMahon1989SDG17631855.35%55.89%-0.54%-2
951Alex Smith2009SFO22537260.48%60.96%-0.48%-2
952Steve Bartkowski1979ATL20438053.68%54.15%-0.47%-2
953Matt Cassel2011KAN16026959.48%60.14%-0.66%-2
954John Hadl1972SDG19037051.35%51.84%-0.49%-2
955Jim Harbaugh1998BAL16429355.97%56.64%-0.67%-2
956Mike Livingston1977KAN14328250.71%51.43%-0.72%-2
957Jeff George1993IND23440757.49%58%-0.5%-2
958Ron Jaworski1981PHI25046154.23%54.67%-0.44%-2
959Carson Palmer2009CIN28246660.52%60.96%-0.45%-2
960Steve McNair1999TEN18733156.5%57.13%-0.64%-2
961Scott Mitchell1993MIA13323357.08%58%-0.91%-2
962Tommy Kramer1981MIN32259354.3%54.68%-0.37%-2
963Archie Manning1972NOR23044851.34%51.84%-0.5%-2
964John Elway1997DEN28050255.78%56.24%-0.46%-2
965Jay Cutler2009CHI33655560.54%60.96%-0.42%-2
966Dave Brown1994NYG20135057.43%58.11%-0.68%-2
967Roman Gabriel1975PHI15129251.71%52.53%-0.82%-2
968Mike Phipps1975CLE16231351.76%52.53%-0.77%-2
969Cotton Davidson1964OAK15532048.44%49.19%-0.76%-2
970Roman Gabriel1972RAM16532351.08%51.85%-0.76%-2
971Doug Flutie2000BUF13223157.14%58.23%-1.08%-3
972Matt Cassel2013MIN15325460.24%61.23%-1%-3
973Don Meredith1967DAL12825550.2%51.19%-1%-3
974Eddie LeBaron1960DAL11122549.33%50.46%-1.13%-3
975Karl Sweetan1966DET15730950.81%51.67%-0.86%-3
976Bill Kenney1981KAN14727453.65%54.68%-1.03%-3
977Norm Van Brocklin1957RAM13226549.81%50.89%-1.08%-3
978Joe Ferguson1974BUF11923251.29%52.55%-1.26%-3
979Jack Concannon1970CHI19438550.39%51.16%-0.77%-3
980Drew Bledsoe1999NWE30553956.59%57.14%-0.55%-3
981Neil O'Donnell1994PIT21237057.3%58.11%-0.81%-3
982Chad Henne2013JAX30550360.64%61.24%-0.6%-3
983Bert Jones1980BAL24844655.61%56.28%-0.68%-3
984Jeff George1997OAK29052155.66%56.25%-0.58%-3
985Alex Smith2013KAN30850860.63%61.24%-0.61%-3
986Donovan McNabb2009PHI26744360.27%60.97%-0.7%-3
987Daryle Lamonica1970OAK17935650.28%51.16%-0.88%-3
988Archie Manning1974NOR13426151.34%52.55%-1.21%-3
989George Blanda1962HOU19741847.13%47.89%-0.76%-3
990Rob Johnson2000BUF17530657.19%58.23%-1.04%-3
991Alex Van Pelt2001BUF17830757.98%59.03%-1.05%-3
992Joe Flacco2014BAL34455462.09%62.67%-0.58%-3
993David Klingler1994CIN13123156.71%58.11%-1.4%-3
994Ty Detmer1997PHI13424454.92%56.25%-1.33%-3
995Charlie Batch1999DET15127055.93%57.14%-1.21%-3
996Charlie Batch2001DET19834158.06%59.03%-0.96%-3
997Drew Bledsoe2003BUF27447158.17%58.87%-0.7%-3
998Jim Plunkett1973NWE19337651.33%52.21%-0.88%-3
999Joe Ferguson1984BUF19134455.52%56.48%-0.96%-3
1000Richard Todd1977NYJ13326550.19%51.44%-1.25%-3
1001Bill Troup1978BAL15429652.03%53.15%-1.13%-3
1002Kyle Boller2005BAL17129358.36%59.51%-1.15%-3
1003Eli Manning2008NYG28947960.33%61.04%-0.71%-3
1004Vinny Testaverde1993CLE13023056.52%58%-1.48%-3
1005Rodney Peete1995PHI21537557.33%58.25%-0.92%-3
1006Randall Cunningham1988PHI30156053.75%54.37%-0.62%-3
1007Mark Brunell2002JAX24541658.89%59.73%-0.83%-3
1008Gary Cuozzo1970MIN12825749.81%51.16%-1.36%-3
1009Donovan McNabb2008PHI34557160.42%61.04%-0.62%-4
1010Paul Christman1946CRD10022943.67%45.22%-1.55%-4
1011Babe Parilli1967BOS16134446.8%47.84%-1.04%-4
1012Jim Everett1990RAM30755455.42%56.06%-0.65%-4
1013Steve Bartkowski1980ATL25746355.51%56.29%-0.78%-4
1014Randy Wright1987GNB13224753.44%54.91%-1.47%-4
1015John Hadl1969SDG15832448.77%49.89%-1.13%-4
1016Bobby Layne1951DET15233245.78%46.88%-1.1%-4
1017Brian Sipe1979CLE28653553.46%54.17%-0.71%-4
1018Jim Hardy1950CRD11725745.53%47%-1.48%-4
1019Billy Kilmer1975WAS17834651.45%52.54%-1.1%-4
1020Jim Everett1987RAM16230253.64%54.91%-1.27%-4
1021George Blanda1966HOU12227145.02%46.45%-1.43%-4
1022Jay Fiedler2000MIA20435757.14%58.24%-1.09%-4
1023Chris Miller1995STL23240557.28%58.25%-0.97%-4
1024Jim Hart1974STL20038851.55%52.56%-1.01%-4
1025Alex Smith2010SFO20434259.65%60.8%-1.16%-4
1026Matt Hasselbeck2010SEA26644459.91%60.8%-0.89%-4
1027Eddie LeBaron1961DAL12023650.85%52.55%-1.71%-4
1028George Blanda1953CHI16936246.69%47.8%-1.12%-4
1029Wade Wilson1993NOR22138856.96%58.01%-1.05%-4
1030Mike Phipps1979CHI13425552.55%54.17%-1.62%-4
1031Boomer Esiason1991CIN23341356.42%57.42%-1%-4
1032Jim Harbaugh1992CHI20235856.42%57.58%-1.16%-4
1033Marc Wilson1986RAI12924053.75%55.49%-1.74%-4
1034Bubby Brister1989PIT18734254.68%55.9%-1.23%-4
1035Joe Flacco2008BAL25742860.05%61.05%-1%-4
1036Jeff Blake1995CIN32656757.5%58.25%-0.76%-4
1037Jim Everett1991RAM27749056.53%57.42%-0.89%-4
1038Paul Christman1947CRD13830145.85%47.31%-1.47%-4
1039Ken O'Brien1990NYJ22641154.99%56.07%-1.08%-4
1040Mark Rypien1990WAS16630454.61%56.07%-1.46%-4
1041Cotton Davidson1961DTX15133045.76%47.12%-1.36%-4
1042Philip Rivers2007SDG27746060.22%61.2%-0.99%-5
1043Matt Hasselbeck2009SEA29348860.04%60.98%-0.93%-5
1044Rodney Peete2002CAR22338158.53%59.73%-1.2%-5
1045Drew Brees2003SDG20535657.58%58.88%-1.3%-5
1046Tom Brady2013NWE38062860.51%61.24%-0.73%-5
1047Donovan McNabb2002PHI21136158.45%59.73%-1.29%-5
1048Steve Grogan1983NWE16830355.45%56.99%-1.55%-5
1049Pete Beathard1969HOU18037048.65%49.92%-1.27%-5
1050Don Majkowski1988GNB17833652.98%54.37%-1.4%-5
1051Bill Kenney1985KAN18133853.55%54.95%-1.4%-5
1052Byron Leftwich2005JAX17530257.95%59.52%-1.57%-5
1053Craig Morton1975NYG18636351.24%52.55%-1.31%-5
1054Sam Bradford2010STL35459060%60.81%-0.81%-5
1055Bob Griese1969MIA12125248.02%49.92%-1.9%-5
1056Matt Hasselbeck2004SEA27947458.86%59.87%-1.01%-5
1057Butch Songin1960BOS18739247.7%48.95%-1.25%-5
1058Joe Kapp1969MIN12023750.63%52.73%-2.1%-5
1059Todd Collins1997BUF21539154.99%56.26%-1.27%-5
1060Wade Wilson1987MIN14026453.03%54.92%-1.89%-5
1061Steve Grogan1975NWE13927450.73%52.55%-1.82%-5
1062Pat Ryan1984NYJ15628554.74%56.49%-1.76%-5
1063Babe Parilli1964BOS22847348.2%49.26%-1.06%-5
1064Greg Landry1972DET13426850%51.87%-1.87%-5
1065Tim Couch1999CLE22339955.89%57.15%-1.26%-5
1066Ryan Tannehill2013MIA35558860.37%61.25%-0.87%-5
1067Jim Miller2001CHI22839557.72%59.04%-1.32%-5
1068Jason Campbell2007WAS25041759.95%61.21%-1.25%-5
1069Mike Taliaferro1969BOS16033148.34%49.93%-1.59%-5
1070Jay Schroeder1990RAI18233454.49%56.07%-1.58%-5
1071Robert Griffin2013WAS27445660.09%61.25%-1.16%-5
1072Ben Roethlisberger2008PIT28146959.91%61.05%-1.14%-5
1073Jay Schroeder1994ARI13323855.88%58.12%-2.24%-5
1074Quincy Carter2003DAL29250557.82%58.88%-1.06%-5
1075John Hadl1970SDG16232749.54%51.18%-1.64%-5
1076Daryle Lamonica1971OAK11824248.76%50.98%-2.22%-5
1077Tommy Thompson1950PHI10723944.77%47.04%-2.27%-5
1078Steve Walsh1991NOR14125555.29%57.43%-2.14%-5
1079John Elway1985DEN32760554.05%54.96%-0.91%-5
1080Mike Boryla1976PHI12324650%52.24%-2.24%-6
1081Boomer Esiason1996ARI19033956.05%57.67%-1.63%-6
1082Randy Johnson1967ATL14228849.31%51.24%-1.93%-6
1083Stan Humphries1997SDG12122553.78%56.26%-2.48%-6
1084Bobby Layne1953DET12527345.79%47.84%-2.05%-6
1085Ron Jaworski1978PHI20639851.76%53.17%-1.41%-6
1086Boomer Esiason1995NYJ22138956.81%58.26%-1.45%-6
1087Danny White1984DAL12623354.08%56.5%-2.42%-6
1088Eli Manning2012NYG32153659.89%60.95%-1.06%-6
1089Richard Todd1980NYJ26447955.11%56.3%-1.19%-6
1090Joe Ferguson1982BUF14426454.55%56.73%-2.18%-6
1091Roman Gabriel1968RAM18436650.27%51.85%-1.58%-6
1092Gus Frerotte2008MIN17830159.14%61.06%-1.92%-6
1093Jeff Garcia2003SFO22539257.4%58.89%-1.49%-6
1094Jay Fiedler2003MIA17931457.01%58.89%-1.88%-6
1095Kerry Collins1996CAR20436456.04%57.68%-1.63%-6
1096Vince Young2009TEN15225958.69%60.98%-2.3%-6
1097Norm Snead1962WAS18435451.98%53.66%-1.68%-6
1098Jake Plummer2001ARI30452557.9%59.04%-1.14%-6
1099Jason Campbell2010OAK19432958.97%60.82%-1.85%-6
1100Donovan McNabb2001PHI28549357.81%59.05%-1.24%-6
1101Bobby Layne1950DET15233645.24%47.06%-1.82%-6
1102Joe Namath1972NYJ16232450%51.89%-1.89%-6
1103Ryan Fitzpatrick2008CIN22137259.41%61.06%-1.65%-6
1104Andrew Luck2013IND34357060.18%61.25%-1.08%-6
1105Charley Johnson1969STL13126050.38%52.75%-2.36%-6
1106Frank Ryan1965CLE11924348.97%51.5%-2.53%-6
1107Joe Namath1976NYJ11423049.57%52.24%-2.68%-6
1108Andrew Luck2014IND38061661.69%62.69%-1%-6
1109Kevin Kolb2011ARI14625357.71%60.17%-2.46%-6
1110Kellen Clemens2013STL14224258.68%61.25%-2.58%-6
1111Jeff George1990IND18133454.19%56.08%-1.89%-6
1112Marc Wilson1984RAI15328254.26%56.5%-2.25%-6
1113Steve DeBerg1985TAM19737053.24%54.96%-1.72%-6
1114David Whitehurst1978GNB16832851.22%53.18%-1.96%-6
1115Steve Young1986TAM19536353.72%55.5%-1.78%-6
1116Steve Spurrier1976TAM15631150.16%52.25%-2.09%-6
1117Donovan McNabb2003PHI27547857.53%58.89%-1.36%-6
1118Joe Flacco2012BAL31753159.7%60.95%-1.26%-7
1119Jack Jacobs1947GNB10824244.63%47.4%-2.77%-7
1120Mark Malone1984PIT14727254.04%56.51%-2.46%-7
1121Jake Plummer2000ARI27047556.84%58.25%-1.41%-7
1122Cotton Davidson1960DTX17937947.23%49%-1.77%-7
1123David Carr2003HOU16729556.61%58.89%-2.28%-7
1124Jack Kemp1961SDG16536445.33%47.18%-1.85%-7
1125Seneca Wallace2008SEA14124258.26%61.06%-2.8%-7
1126Jake Delhomme2008CAR24641459.42%61.06%-1.64%-7
1127Scott Campbell1987ATL13626052.31%54.93%-2.63%-7
1128Gary Huff1974CHI14228350.18%52.59%-2.41%-7
1129Jim Plunkett1986RAI13325252.78%55.5%-2.73%-7
1130Chris Miller1988ATL18435152.42%54.39%-1.97%-7
1131Jeff Garcia2004CLE14425257.14%59.89%-2.74%-7
1132Mark Rypien1992WAS26947956.16%57.6%-1.45%-7
1133Dan Marino1999MIA20436955.28%57.16%-1.88%-7
1134Jay Cutler2011CHI18231457.96%60.17%-2.21%-7
1135Craig Erickson1994TAM22539956.39%58.14%-1.74%-7
1136Doug Johnson2003ATL13624355.97%58.89%-2.93%-7
1137Pat Haden1978RAM22944451.58%53.19%-1.61%-7
1138Jeff Hostetler1993RAI23641956.32%58.03%-1.71%-7
1139Byron Leftwich2003JAX23941857.18%58.9%-1.72%-7
1140Warren Moon1985HOU20037753.05%54.97%-1.92%-7
1141Bernie Kosar1990CLE23042354.37%56.09%-1.71%-7
1142Ron Jaworski1984PHI23442754.8%56.51%-1.71%-7
1143Cade McNown1999CHI12723554.04%57.16%-3.12%-7
1144Jeff Blake1999CIN21538955.27%57.16%-1.89%-7
1145Dave Krieg1985SEA28553253.57%54.97%-1.4%-7
1146EJ Manuel2013BUF18030658.82%61.26%-2.44%-7
1147Blaine Gabbert2012JAX16227858.27%60.96%-2.68%-7
1148Rich Gannon2003OAK12522555.56%58.9%-3.34%-8
1149Randall Cunningham1989PHI29053254.51%55.93%-1.42%-8
1150Frank Ryan1967CLE13628048.57%51.27%-2.7%-8
1151Kordell Stewart1998PIT25245855.02%56.68%-1.66%-8
1152Paul McDonald1984CLE27149354.97%56.51%-1.54%-8
1153Dick Wood1964NYJ16935847.21%49.33%-2.13%-8
1154Jim Miller2002CHI18031457.32%59.75%-2.43%-8
1155Alex Smith2006SFO25744258.14%59.88%-1.73%-8
1156Tommy Maddox2003PIT29851957.42%58.9%-1.48%-8
1157Mike Glennon2013TAM24741659.38%61.26%-1.89%-8
1158Matt Cassel2012KAN16127758.12%60.96%-2.84%-8
1159Sam Bradford2012STL32855159.53%60.96%-1.43%-8
1160Dave Krieg1992KAN23041355.69%57.61%-1.92%-8
1161Stan Humphries1996SDG23241655.77%57.69%-1.92%-8
1162Ron Jaworski1986PHI12824552.24%55.51%-3.27%-8
1163John Elway1992DEN17431655.06%57.61%-2.55%-8
1164Rick Mirer1993SEA27448656.38%58.04%-1.66%-8
1165Pat Haden1981RAM13826751.69%54.72%-3.03%-8
1166Timm Rosenbach1990PHO23743754.23%56.09%-1.86%-8
1167Scott Brunner1982NYG16129854.03%56.76%-2.73%-8
1168Jeff Blake2003ARI20836756.68%58.9%-2.23%-8
1169David Woodley1980MIA17632753.82%56.32%-2.5%-8
1170Matthew Stafford2012DET43572759.83%60.96%-1.13%-8
1171Mike Phipps1973CLE14829949.5%52.26%-2.76%-8
1172John Reaves1972PHI10822448.21%51.91%-3.7%-8
1173Neil O'Donnell1991PIT15628654.55%57.45%-2.9%-8
1174Mark Brunell2005WAS26245457.71%59.54%-1.83%-8
1175Bill Kenney1984KAN15128253.55%56.52%-2.97%-8
1176Brooks Bollinger2005NYJ15026656.39%59.54%-3.15%-8
1177Kerry Collins2001NYG32756857.57%59.06%-1.49%-8
1178Tom Flores1963OAK11324745.75%49.18%-3.44%-8
1179Wade Wilson1989MIN19436253.59%55.94%-2.34%-8
1180Joey Harrington2005DET18833056.97%59.54%-2.57%-8
1181Warren Moon1996MIN13424754.25%57.69%-3.44%-8
1182Mike Tomczak1999PIT13925853.88%57.17%-3.3%-9
1183Earl Morrall1957PIT13928948.1%51.06%-2.97%-9
1184Vince Evans1980CHI14827853.24%56.32%-3.09%-9
1185Joe Ferguson1983BUF28150855.31%57.02%-1.71%-9
1186Jeff Blake1996CIN30854956.1%57.69%-1.59%-9
1187Mike Tomczak1991GNB12823853.78%57.45%-3.67%-9
1188Norm Snead1964PHI13828348.76%51.86%-3.1%-9
1189Tobin Rote1955GNB15734245.91%48.47%-2.56%-9
1190Vince Ferragamo1985BUF14928751.92%54.98%-3.06%-9
1191Troy Aikman1989DAL15529352.9%55.94%-3.04%-9
1192Jim Finks1953PIT13129244.86%47.92%-3.06%-9
1193Bud Schwenk1942CRD12629542.71%45.74%-3.03%-9
1194Tarvaris Jackson2007MIN17129458.16%61.23%-3.07%-9
1195Nick Foles2014PHI18631159.81%62.71%-2.9%-9
1196Jake Plummer2004DEN30352158.16%59.9%-1.74%-9
1197David Klingler1993CIN19034355.39%58.04%-2.65%-9
1198Kerry Collins2010TEN16027857.55%60.83%-3.28%-9
1199George Blanda1960HOU16936346.56%49.07%-2.51%-9
1200Cade McNown2000CHI15428055%58.27%-3.27%-9
1201Bobby Layne1962PIT11623349.79%53.72%-3.94%-9
1202Donovan McNabb2006PHI18031656.96%59.89%-2.92%-9
1203Terry Bradshaw1982PIT12724052.92%56.77%-3.86%-9
1204Jake Delhomme2004CAR31053358.16%59.9%-1.74%-9
1205Jim Ninowski1960DET13428347.35%50.63%-3.28%-9
1206David Woodley1981MIA19136652.19%54.73%-2.54%-9
1207Doug Flutie1999BUF26447855.23%57.18%-1.95%-9
1208Steve Bartkowski1978ATL18736950.68%53.2%-2.53%-9
1209Jeff George1992IND16730654.58%57.62%-3.05%-9
1210Joey Harrington2006MIA22338857.47%59.89%-2.41%-9
1211Jim Plunkett1971NWE15832848.17%51.03%-2.86%-9
1212Mike Tomczak1996PIT22240155.36%57.7%-2.34%-9
1213Bobby Layne1959PIT14229747.81%50.97%-3.16%-9
1214Tommy Kramer1984MIN12423652.54%56.53%-3.98%-9
1215Danny Kanell1997NYG15629453.06%56.29%-3.23%-9
1216Danny Kanell1998NYG16029953.51%56.69%-3.18%-10
1217Steve Walsh19902TM17933653.27%56.1%-2.83%-10
1218Don Meredith1964DAL15832348.92%51.87%-2.96%-10
1219Jake Plummer1997ARI15729653.04%56.29%-3.25%-10
1220Jay Cutler2012CHI25543458.76%60.97%-2.21%-10
1221Phil Simms1979NYG13426550.57%54.21%-3.65%-10
1222Tony Banks2000BAL15027454.74%58.27%-3.53%-10
1223Marc Wilson1990NWE13926552.45%56.11%-3.65%-10
1224Drew Bledsoe1998NWE26348154.68%56.69%-2.01%-10
1225Dan Fouts1974SDG11523748.52%52.62%-4.1%-10
1226John Elway1989DEN22341653.61%55.94%-2.34%-10
1227Dick Shiner1968PIT14830448.68%51.92%-3.23%-10
1228Pete Liske1970DEN11223847.06%51.23%-4.17%-10
1229Kyle Orton2010DEN29349858.84%60.84%-2%-10
1230Bob Celeri1951NYY10223842.86%47.05%-4.2%-10
1231Michael Vick2012PHI20435158.12%60.97%-2.85%-10
1232Bill Kenney1986KAN16130852.27%55.53%-3.25%-10
1233Rodney Peete1990DET14227152.4%56.11%-3.71%-10
1234Al Dorow1961NYT19743844.98%47.27%-2.3%-10
1235Richard Todd1979NYJ17133451.2%54.22%-3.02%-10
1236Steve Bono1995KAN29352056.35%58.29%-1.94%-10
1237Norm Snead1969PHI19037950.13%52.81%-2.68%-10
1238John Friesz1993SDG12823853.78%58.05%-4.27%-10
1239Neil Lomax1981STL11923650.42%54.73%-4.31%-10
1240Brodie Croyle2007KAN12722456.7%61.24%-4.54%-10
1241Randy Wright1986GNB26349253.46%55.53%-2.07%-10
1242Joe Ferguson1979BUF23845851.97%54.22%-2.25%-10
1243Doug Williams1982TAM16430753.42%56.79%-3.37%-10
1244John Brodie1964SFO19339249.23%51.89%-2.66%-10
1245Marc Bulger2007STL22137858.47%61.24%-2.77%-10
1246Vinny Testaverde1989TAM25848053.75%55.95%-2.2%-11
1247Tobin Rote1958DET11825745.91%50.03%-4.11%-11
1248Kerry Collins2003NYG28450056.8%58.92%-2.12%-11
1249David Archer1985ATL16131251.6%54.99%-3.39%-11
1250Trent Green1998WAS27850954.62%56.7%-2.08%-11
1251Andy Dalton2011CIN30051658.14%60.19%-2.05%-11
1252Terrelle Pryor2013OAK15627257.35%61.28%-3.92%-11
1253Rex Grossman2011WAS26545857.86%60.19%-2.33%-11
1254Marc Bulger2009STL14024756.68%61.01%-4.33%-11
1255Kent Graham1997ARI13025052%56.29%-4.29%-11
1256Colin Kaepernick2014SFO28947860.46%62.72%-2.26%-11
1257Doug Pederson1999PHI11922752.42%57.19%-4.76%-11
1258Dan Pastorini1971HOU12727047.04%51.04%-4%-11
1259Elvis Grbac2001BAL26546756.75%59.07%-2.33%-11
1260Jim Hart1979STL19437851.32%54.22%-2.9%-11
1261John Brodie1967SFO16834948.14%51.33%-3.19%-11
1262Charley Johnson1965STL15532248.14%51.6%-3.46%-11
1263Mark Malone1985PIT11723350.21%55%-4.78%-11
1264Trent Dilfer1996TAM26748255.39%57.71%-2.31%-11
1265Geno Smith2014NYJ21936759.67%62.72%-3.05%-11
1266Ron Jaworski1985PHI25548452.69%55%-2.31%-11
1267Dan Pastorini1972HOU14429948.16%51.95%-3.78%-11
1268Michael Vick2004ATL18132156.39%59.91%-3.53%-11
1269Jeff Blake2002BAL16529555.93%59.77%-3.84%-11
1270Chris Miller1994RAM17331754.57%58.17%-3.59%-11
1271Josh McCown2004ARI23340857.11%59.91%-2.81%-11
1272Jim Hart1980STL22842553.65%56.35%-2.7%-11
1273Ryan Fitzpatrick2009BUF12722755.95%61.02%-5.07%-12
1274Kerry Collins2008TEN24241558.31%61.09%-2.78%-12
1275Steve Grogan1978NWE18136250%53.22%-3.22%-12
1276Eli Manning2006NYG30152257.66%59.9%-2.24%-12
1277Vinny Testaverde1994CLE20737655.05%58.17%-3.11%-12
1278Kordell Stewart1997PIT23644053.64%56.3%-2.66%-12
1279Jim Hart1967STL19239748.36%51.34%-2.98%-12
1280Matt Cassel2010KAN26245058.22%60.85%-2.63%-12
1281Matt Leinart2006ARI21437756.76%59.9%-3.14%-12
1282Dave Brown1995NYG25445655.7%58.3%-2.6%-12
1283Paul Governali19472TM10825242.86%47.58%-4.72%-12
1284Colin Kaepernick2013SFO24341658.41%61.28%-2.87%-12
1285Jim Kelly1995BUF25545855.68%58.3%-2.62%-12
1286Kyle Orton2008CHI27246558.49%61.09%-2.6%-12
1287Lynn Dickey1976GNB11524347.33%52.3%-4.98%-12
1288Kent Graham1996ARI14627453.28%57.71%-4.43%-12
1289Neil O'Donnell1993PIT27048655.56%58.07%-2.51%-12
1290Matt Ryan2009ATL26345158.31%61.02%-2.71%-12
1291Donovan McNabb2010WAS27547258.26%60.85%-2.59%-12
1292Matt Hasselbeck2006SEA21037156.6%59.9%-3.3%-12
1293John McCormick1965DEN10325340.71%45.56%-4.85%-12
1294Tobin Rote1956GNB14630847.4%51.39%-3.99%-12
1295Ron Jaworski1977PHI16634647.98%51.53%-3.56%-12
1296Steve Tensi1969DEN13128645.8%50.11%-4.3%-12
1297Jim Plunkett1974NWE17335249.15%52.65%-3.5%-12
1298Bruce Mathison1985BUF11322849.56%55.01%-5.44%-12
1299Bernie Kosar1985CLE12424850%55.01%-5.01%-12
1300Ken Dorsey2004SFO12322654.42%59.92%-5.5%-12
1301Donald Hollas1998OAK13526051.92%56.71%-4.79%-12
1302Gary Hogeboom1984DAL19536753.13%56.55%-3.41%-13
1303Jack Trudeau1989IND19036252.49%55.96%-3.48%-13
1304Dan Pastorini1979HOU16332450.31%54.24%-3.93%-13
1305Ed Luther1983SDG15128752.61%57.05%-4.44%-13
1306Eric Hipple1981DET14027950.18%54.75%-4.57%-13
1307Dan Orlovsky2008DET14325556.08%61.1%-5.02%-13
1308Bob Gagliano1989DET11723250.43%55.97%-5.53%-13
1309Ron Jaworski1979PHI19037450.8%54.24%-3.43%-13
1310Steve Grogan1976NWE14530248.01%52.31%-4.3%-13
1311Trent Green2001KAN29652356.6%59.09%-2.49%-13
1312Bobby Hoying1998PHI11422450.89%56.71%-5.82%-13
1313Terry Bradshaw1972PIT14730847.73%51.96%-4.24%-13
1314Steve Grogan1989NWE13326150.96%55.97%-5.01%-13
1315Jon Kitna1999SEA27049554.55%57.2%-2.65%-13
1316Ryan Tannehill2012MIA28248458.26%60.99%-2.73%-13
1317Rudy Bukich1966CHI14730947.57%51.85%-4.27%-13
1318Jim Zorn1982SEA12624551.43%56.83%-5.4%-13
1319Babe Parilli1963BOS15333745.4%49.32%-3.92%-13
1320Steve Ramsey1976DEN12827047.41%52.31%-4.91%-13
1321Jim Ninowski1961DET11724747.37%52.73%-5.36%-13
1322David Archer1986ATL15029451.02%55.55%-4.53%-13
1323Ryan Fitzpatrick2010BUF25544157.82%60.86%-3.04%-13
1324Norm Snead1963WAS17536348.21%51.96%-3.75%-14
1325George Blanda1954CHI13128146.62%51.47%-4.85%-14
1326Dick Wood1963NYJ16035245.45%49.34%-3.88%-14
1327Drew Bledsoe2004BUF25645056.89%59.93%-3.04%-14
1328Matt Hasselbeck2001SEA17632154.83%59.09%-4.26%-14
1329Marlin Briscoe1968DEN9322441.52%47.66%-6.14%-14
1330Colt McCoy2011CLE26546357.24%60.21%-2.98%-14
1331Trent Edwards2007BUF15126956.13%61.26%-5.12%-14
1332Doug Flutie2001SDG29452156.43%59.09%-2.66%-14
1333Rich Gannon1990MIN18234952.15%56.14%-3.99%-14
1334Jim Hart1978STL24047750.31%53.24%-2.93%-14
1335Tony Banks1999BAL16932052.81%57.2%-4.39%-14
1336Fran Tarkenton1962MIN16332949.54%53.82%-4.27%-14
1337Jim Hart1971STL11024345.27%51.08%-5.81%-14
1338Billy Joe Tolliver1990SDG21641052.68%56.14%-3.46%-14
1339Jack Kemp1964BUF11926944.24%49.51%-5.27%-14
1340Norm Snead1966PHI10322645.58%51.86%-6.29%-14
1341Billy Joe Tolliver1999NOR13926851.87%57.21%-5.34%-14
1342Jason Campbell2013CLE18031756.78%61.3%-4.52%-14
1343Curtis Painter2011IND13224354.32%60.21%-5.89%-14
1344Steve Dils1983MIN23944453.83%57.06%-3.23%-14
1345Joe Flacco2011BAL31254257.56%60.21%-2.65%-14
1346Joe Flacco2013BAL36261458.96%61.3%-2.34%-14
1347Chris Miller1989ATL28052653.23%55.98%-2.75%-14
1348Jake Locker2012TEN17731456.37%61%-4.63%-15
1349Mike Phipps1972CLE14430547.21%51.98%-4.77%-15
1350Kerry Collins1997CAR20038152.49%56.32%-3.83%-15
1351John Skelton2011ARI15127554.91%60.22%-5.31%-15
1352Joe Ferguson1977BUF22145748.36%51.56%-3.2%-15
1353Joe Namath1975NYJ15732648.16%52.65%-4.49%-15
1354Matthew Stafford2014DET36360260.3%62.74%-2.44%-15
1355Tobin Rote1951GNB10625641.41%47.18%-5.78%-15
1356Don Majkowski1991GNB11522650.88%57.5%-6.61%-15
1357Jake Plummer2006DEN17531755.21%59.92%-4.72%-15
1358Warren Moon1986HOU25648852.46%55.56%-3.1%-15
1359Stan Humphries1993SDG17332453.4%58.09%-4.69%-15
1360Mike Tomczak1989CHI15630650.98%55.98%-5%-15
1361Jim Plunkett1980OAK16532051.56%56.37%-4.81%-15
1362Craig Whelihan1997SDG11823749.79%56.32%-6.54%-15
1363Richard Todd1984NOR16131251.6%56.57%-4.97%-15
1364Phil Simms1984NYG28653353.66%56.57%-2.91%-16
1365John Hadl19742TM14229947.49%52.68%-5.19%-16
1366Jim Plunkett1972NWE16935547.61%51.99%-4.39%-16
1367Dave Brown1996NYG21439853.77%57.74%-3.97%-16
1368George Blanda1965HOU18644242.08%45.66%-3.58%-16
1369Rex Grossman2007CHI12222554.22%61.27%-7.05%-16
1370Charley Johnson1962STL15030848.7%53.85%-5.15%-16
1371Jack Kemp1966BUF16638942.67%46.75%-4.08%-16
1372Cam Newton2012CAR28048557.73%61.01%-3.27%-16
1373Aaron Brooks2004NOR30954257.01%59.94%-2.93%-16
1374Vinny Testaverde2000NYJ32859055.59%58.31%-2.72%-16
1375Kyle Boller2003BAL11622451.79%58.95%-7.16%-16
1376Frank Reich1996NYJ17533152.87%57.74%-4.87%-16
1377Roman Gabriel1963RAM13028146.26%52.01%-5.74%-16
1378Tom Tupa1991PHO16531552.38%57.51%-5.13%-16
1379Milt Plum1965DET14330846.43%51.69%-5.26%-16
1380Dave Wilson1985NOR14529349.49%55.03%-5.54%-16
1381Jay Schroeder1991RAI18935752.94%57.51%-4.57%-16
1382Cleo Lemon2007MIA17330955.99%61.27%-5.28%-16
1383Boomer Esiason1992CIN14427851.8%57.67%-5.88%-16
1384Erik Kramer1991DET13626551.32%57.51%-6.19%-16
1385Shaun King2000TAM23342854.44%58.31%-3.87%-17
1386Michael Vick2005ATL21438755.3%59.59%-4.3%-17
1387Don Meredith1965DAL14130546.23%51.7%-5.47%-17
1388Jeff Komlo1979DET18336849.73%54.27%-4.54%-17
1389Jack Kemp1967BUF16136943.63%48.19%-4.56%-17
1390Aaron Brooks2005NOR24043155.68%59.59%-3.91%-17
1391Eric Hipple1983DET20438752.71%57.08%-4.37%-17
1392Tobin Rote1954GNB18038247.12%51.55%-4.43%-17
1393Jack Thompson1980CIN11523449.15%56.39%-7.24%-17
1394Jake Plummer1999ARI20138152.76%57.22%-4.47%-17
1395Rick Mirer1996SEA13626551.32%57.75%-6.42%-17
1396Dan Pastorini1975HOU16334247.66%52.68%-5.02%-17
1397Christian Ponder2011MIN15829154.3%60.23%-5.94%-17
1398Mike Pagel1985IND19939350.64%55.04%-4.4%-17
1399Pete Beathard19672TM9423140.69%48.2%-7.51%-17
1400Joe Pisarcik1978NYG14330147.51%53.27%-5.76%-17
1401John Elway1991DEN24245153.66%57.52%-3.86%-17
1402Sam Vacanti1947CHR9622542.67%50.46%-7.79%-18
1403Chris Miller1991ATL22041353.27%57.52%-4.25%-18
1404Kordell Stewart2000PIT15128952.25%58.32%-6.07%-18
1405Joey Harrington2003DET30955455.78%58.96%-3.18%-18
1406Jeff Kemp1984RAM14328450.35%56.58%-6.23%-18
1407Matt Robinson1978NYJ12426646.62%53.28%-6.66%-18
1408Matthew Stafford2013DET37163458.52%61.32%-2.8%-18
1409Shane Matthews2002WAS12423752.32%59.81%-7.49%-18
1410Steve McNair1997TEN21641552.05%56.34%-4.29%-18
1411Ted Marchibroda1956PIT12427545.09%51.57%-6.48%-18
1412Aaron Brooks2001NOR31255855.91%59.12%-3.2%-18
1413Jay Schroeder1987WAS12926748.31%55.02%-6.7%-18
1414Mike Phipps1974CLE11725645.7%52.71%-7%-18
1415Tom Sherman1968BOS9022639.82%47.76%-7.94%-18
1416Steve Bono1996KAN23543853.65%57.75%-4.1%-18
1417Marc Bulger2008STL25144057.05%61.13%-4.08%-18
1418Jake Delhomme2009CAR17832155.45%61.05%-5.6%-18
1419Blake Bortles2014JAX28047558.95%62.76%-3.81%-18
1420Trent Dilfer1995TAM22441553.98%58.34%-4.36%-18
1421John Friesz1991SDG26248753.8%57.52%-3.72%-18
1422Case Keenum2013HOU13725354.15%61.32%-7.17%-18
1423Andrew Walter2006OAK14727653.26%59.94%-6.68%-18
1424Steve Beuerlein1994ARI13025550.98%58.21%-7.23%-18
1425Trent Dilfer1998TAM22542952.45%56.75%-4.3%-18
1426Warren Moon1987HOU18436850%55.02%-5.02%-18
1427Brandon Weeden2012CLE29751757.45%61.02%-3.57%-18
1428Kerry Collins2004OAK28951356.34%59.96%-3.62%-19
1429Drew Stanton2014ARI13224055%62.76%-7.76%-19
1430Bill Nelsen1965PIT12127044.81%51.74%-6.92%-19
1431Jeff Kemp19912TM15129551.19%57.52%-6.34%-19
1432John Hadl1962SDG10726041.15%48.35%-7.19%-19
1433Billy Joe Tolliver1994HOU12124050.42%58.21%-7.8%-19
1434Patrick Ramsey2002WAS11722751.54%59.82%-8.27%-19
1435Josh Freeman2009TAM15829054.48%61.06%-6.58%-19
1436Mark Sanchez2011NYJ30854356.72%60.24%-3.52%-19
1437Archie Manning1975NOR15933847.04%52.7%-5.66%-19
1438Rick Mirer1995SEA20939153.45%58.34%-4.89%-19
1439Cam Newton2014CAR26244858.48%62.76%-4.28%-19
1440Joey Harrington2004DET27448956.03%59.96%-3.93%-19
1441Charlie Batch2000DET22141253.64%58.33%-4.69%-19
1442Steve Bartkowski1975ATL11525545.1%52.7%-7.6%-19
1443Mark Rypien1993WAS16631952.04%58.12%-6.08%-19
1444Todd Blackledge1984KAN14729450%56.6%-6.6%-19
1445Bruce Gradkowski2006TAM17732853.96%59.95%-5.99%-20
1446Ron Jaworski1983PHI23544652.69%57.1%-4.41%-20
1447Patrick Ramsey2003WAS17933753.12%58.97%-5.86%-20
1448Doug Williams1981TAM23847150.53%54.8%-4.27%-20
1449Kyle Boller2004BAL25846455.6%59.97%-4.36%-20
1450Mark Malone1986PIT21642550.82%55.6%-4.77%-20
1451Randall Cunningham1994PHI26549054.08%58.22%-4.14%-20
1452Brady Quinn2009CLE13625653.13%61.07%-7.94%-20
1453Jim Hart1970STL17137345.84%51.34%-5.49%-20
1454Ed Brown1963PIT16836246.41%52.09%-5.68%-21
1455Cliff Stoudt1983PIT19738151.71%57.11%-5.4%-21
1456Tony Banks1996STL19236852.17%57.77%-5.59%-21
1457Marc Wilson1985RAI19338849.74%55.06%-5.32%-21
1458Ed Brown1964PIT12127244.49%52.08%-7.6%-21
1459Tony Banks2001WAS19837053.51%59.14%-5.62%-21
1460Joe Theismann1978WAS18739047.95%53.3%-5.35%-21
1461Michael Vick2002ATL23142154.87%59.83%-4.96%-21
1462Joe Ferguson1981BUF25249850.6%54.81%-4.21%-21
1463Eli Manning2013NYG31755157.53%61.33%-3.8%-21
1464Terry Bradshaw1980PIT21842451.42%56.42%-5%-21
1465Josh McCown2014TAM18432756.27%62.78%-6.51%-21
1466Joe Pisarcik1977NYG10324142.74%51.63%-8.89%-21
1467Vinny Testaverde1991TAM16632650.92%57.55%-6.63%-22
1468Chad Henne2012JAX16630853.9%61.04%-7.14%-22
1469Jim Zorn1976SEA20843947.38%52.4%-5.02%-22
1470Kordell Stewart2003CHI12625150.2%58.99%-8.79%-22
1471Jeff Blake1994CIN15630650.98%58.24%-7.26%-22
1472Babe Parilli1965BOS17342640.61%45.84%-5.23%-22
1473Tony Banks1997STL25248751.75%56.37%-4.62%-23
1474A.J. Feeley2004MIA19135653.65%59.98%-6.33%-23
1475Chad Hutchinson2002DAL12725050.8%59.84%-9.04%-23
1476Gus Frerotte1997WAS20440250.75%56.37%-5.62%-23
1477Brandon Weeden2013CLE14126752.81%61.34%-8.54%-23
1478J.P. Losman2005BUF11322849.56%59.63%-10.07%-23
1479Jay Schroeder1992RAI12325348.62%57.72%-9.11%-23
1480Kellen Clemens2007NYJ13025052%61.31%-9.31%-23
1481Tobin Rote1950GNB8322437.05%47.48%-10.42%-23
1482Steve Grogan1979NWE20642348.7%54.32%-5.62%-24
1483Johnny Green1960BUF8922839.04%49.49%-10.45%-24
1484Steve DeBerg1978SFO13730245.36%53.33%-7.97%-24
1485Bob Avellini1976CHI11827143.54%52.42%-8.88%-24
1486Sam Bradford2011STL19135753.5%60.27%-6.77%-24
1487Bobby Douglass1971CHI9122540.44%51.19%-10.74%-24
1488Mark Brunell2004WAS11823749.79%59.99%-10.2%-24
1489Scott Mitchell1994DET11924648.37%58.25%-9.88%-24
1490Jim Everett1993RAM13527449.27%58.15%-8.88%-24
1491Mike Pagel1983BAL16332849.7%57.13%-7.44%-24
1492Randy Johnson1966ATL12929543.73%52.03%-8.3%-24
1493Brett Favre2006GNB34361355.95%59.98%-4.03%-25
1494Steve Beuerlein1988RAI10523844.12%54.52%-10.4%-25
1495Geno Smith2013NYJ24744355.76%61.36%-5.6%-25
1496Jim Hart1968STL14031644.3%52.17%-7.87%-25
1497Jay Schroeder1986WAS27654151.02%55.63%-4.61%-25
1498John Elway1983DEN12325947.49%57.14%-9.65%-25
1499Dick Wood1966MIA8323036.09%46.99%-10.9%-25
1500Jimmy Clausen2010CAR15729952.51%60.93%-8.42%-25
1501Derek Anderson2007CLE29852756.55%61.32%-4.78%-25
1502Jim Zorn1977SEA10425141.43%51.67%-10.24%-26
1503Rex Grossman2006CHI26248054.58%59.99%-5.4%-26
1504Stan Gelbaugh1992SEA12125547.45%57.75%-10.3%-26
1505Mark Sanchez2009NYJ19636453.85%61.1%-7.26%-26
1506Steve Tensi1967DEN13132540.31%48.44%-8.13%-26
1507Chris Weinke2001CAR29354054.26%59.17%-4.91%-27
1508Jay Schroeder1988RAI11325644.14%54.53%-10.39%-27
1509Norm Snead1961WAS17237545.87%52.99%-7.12%-27
1510Bubby Brister1988PIT17537047.3%54.53%-7.23%-27
1511Tyler Thigpen2008KAN23042054.76%61.18%-6.42%-27
1512Ryan Leaf2000SDG16132250%58.38%-8.38%-27
1513Rick Mirer1994SEA19538151.18%58.27%-7.09%-27
1514Lamar McHan1954CRD10525541.18%51.81%-10.63%-27
1515JaMarcus Russell2008OAK19836853.8%61.18%-7.38%-27
1516Eli Manning2007NYG29752956.14%61.34%-5.19%-27
1517Marc Wilson1981OAK17336647.27%54.86%-7.59%-28
1518Jack Trudeau1986IND20441748.92%55.65%-6.73%-28
1519Ryan Leaf1998SDG11124545.31%56.81%-11.51%-28
1520Derek Carr2014OAK34859958.1%62.81%-4.72%-28
1521Michael Vick2006ATL20438852.58%60.01%-7.43%-29
1522Mark Malone1987PIT15633646.43%55.1%-8.67%-29
1523Matthew Stafford2009DET20137753.32%61.12%-7.81%-29
1524Kyle Orton2005CHI19036851.63%59.67%-8.04%-30
1525Vince Young2006TEN18435751.54%60.01%-8.47%-30
1526Derek Anderson2010ARI16932751.68%60.96%-9.28%-30
1527Matt Cassel2009KAN27149354.97%61.13%-6.16%-30
1528JaMarcus Russell2009OAK12024648.78%61.13%-12.35%-30
1529Kerry Collins19982TM17035348.16%56.83%-8.67%-31
1530Scott Brunner1983NYG19038649.22%57.18%-7.96%-31
1531Mark Sanchez2012NYJ24645354.3%61.09%-6.78%-31
1532Jon Kitna2001CIN31358153.87%59.2%-5.33%-31
1533Mark Sanchez2010NYJ27850754.83%60.96%-6.13%-31
1534Derek Anderson2008CLE14228350.18%61.21%-11.03%-31
1535Browning Nagle1992NYJ19238749.61%57.79%-8.18%-32
1536Vinny Testaverde1988TAM22246647.64%54.57%-6.93%-32
1537Gus Frerotte1995WAS19939650.25%58.42%-8.17%-32
1538Craig Whelihan1998SDG14932046.56%56.84%-10.28%-33
1539David Carr2002HOU23344452.48%59.9%-7.42%-33
1540Craig Erickson1993TAM23345750.98%58.21%-7.23%-33
1541Brian Hoyer2014CLE24243855.25%62.84%-7.59%-33
1542Aaron Brooks2002NOR28352853.6%59.9%-6.3%-33
1543Jake Plummer2002ARI28453053.58%59.9%-6.32%-33
1544Phil Simms1980NYG19340248.01%56.51%-8.5%-34
1545Heath Shuler1994WAS12026545.28%58.32%-13.04%-35
1546Josh Freeman2012TAM30655854.84%61.11%-6.27%-35
1547Kerry Collins2005OAK30256553.45%59.71%-6.26%-35
1548Drew Bledsoe1993NWE21442949.88%58.23%-8.35%-36
1549Tim Tebow2011DEN12627146.49%60.35%-13.85%-38
1550Cotton Davidson19622TM11932137.07%48.91%-11.84%-38
1551Gus Frerotte2005MIA25749452.02%59.72%-7.7%-38
1552Akili Smith2000CIN11826744.19%58.45%-14.25%-38
1553Eli Manning2005NYG29455752.78%59.73%-6.95%-39
1554Kerry Collins1995CAR21443349.42%58.46%-9.04%-39
1555Blaine Gabbert2011JAX21041350.85%60.36%-9.51%-39
1556Gary Marangi1976BUF8223235.34%52.58%-17.23%-40
1557Doug Williams1980TAM25452148.75%56.56%-7.81%-41
1558Rusty Hilger1988DET12630641.18%54.63%-13.46%-41
1559Joey Harrington2002DET21542950.12%59.95%-9.84%-42
1560Andrew Luck2012IND33962754.07%61.17%-7.1%-45
1561Vince Evans1981CHI19543644.72%54.98%-10.25%-45
1562Drew Bledsoe1995NWE32363650.79%58.52%-7.74%-49
1563Doug Williams1979TAM16639741.81%54.53%-12.72%-50

Let me start with a shout out to Sammy Baugh. His 1945 season didn’t meet the minimum attempt threshold, but it deserves mention nonetheless. He completed 128 or 182 passes; his rate of 70.3% remained the record for nearly four decades. His 26.6% marginal rate looks like a typo, and it results in him being worth 48 completions above expectation, despite his low volume of attempts.

After Baugh’s 1945 season, the first quarterbacks to break the 70% mark were Bill Walsh disciples Ken Anderson and Joe Montana. Although they clear the threshold for pass attempts, neither played a full season when he broke seventy.

Afterwards, another Walsh quarterback, Steve Young, broke the 70% mark. In doing so, he became the first quarterback to achieve the feat in a full, 16-game season.

Then we have Drew Brees. Brees is famous for passing for more than 5,000 yards four times in his career. However, he is also the only passer to break the 70% mark more than once in his career (and he did it in seasons with 514 and 657 attempts!). In NFL history, more quarterbacks have thrown for over 5,000 yards (5) than have completed more than 70% of their passes (4).3 Brees did both in the same season.

When you sort the table by the column “Marg Cmp%,” you’ll see Otto Graham leap to the top. Completing nearly 65% of your passes is impressive today; it’s even more impressive when the rest of the league is completing passes at a 47% rate.

You can say the same about Ken Stabler, who led the NFL in Cmp%, TD%, and Y/A in 1976 but lost the MVP nod to Bert Jones because he turned the ball over too often. The tales of the Snake ignoring the playbook seem overblown when you look at his amazing accuracy numbers. It wasn’t just a one-season fluke; his career stats support his case for being the most accurate passer of his generation.

Career Completions

The following table shows the 222 quarterback careers with more than 1,000 pass attempts. Read it like you read the first one.

RkQuarterbackCmpAttCmp%LMP Cmp%Marg Cmp%Marg Cmp
1Peyton Manning5927904965.5%59.7%5.8%526
2Drew Brees4937745866.2%60.4%5.8%431
3Joe Montana3409539163.2%55.8%7.4%401
4Sammy Baugh1693299556.5%44.8%11.7%351
5Fran Tarkenton3686646757%51.8%5.2%336
6Brett Favre63001016962%58.7%3.2%329
7Len Dawson2136374157.1%48.6%8.5%316
8Steve Young2667414964.3%56.8%7.4%309
9Dan Marino4967835859.4%56.3%3.1%258
10Ken Anderson2654447559.3%53.6%5.7%256
11Kurt Warner2666407065.5%59.5%6%245
12Y.A. Tittle2427439555.2%49.7%5.5%244
13Dan Fouts3297560458.8%54.6%4.3%239
14Sonny Jurgensen2433426257.1%51.6%5.5%234
15Ken Stabler2270379359.8%53.7%6.2%234
16Tom Brady4551716863.5%60.3%3.2%228
17Otto Graham1464262655.8%47.7%8%211
18Troy Aikman2898471561.5%57.1%4.3%205
19Bart Starr1808314957.4%51.3%6.1%192
20Tony Romo2743421065.2%60.9%4.3%180
21Philip Rivers3025467864.7%60.9%3.8%178
22Bob Griese1926342956.2%51.1%5.1%175
23Johnny Unitas2830518654.6%51.3%3.3%172
24Jim Kelly2874477960.1%56.6%3.5%169
25Aaron Rodgers2286347565.8%60.9%4.8%168
26John Brodie2469449155%51.4%3.5%159
27Chad Pennington1632247166%59.9%6.1%151
28Ben Roethlisberger3157495463.7%60.8%2.9%146
29Brad Johnson2668432661.7%58.4%3.3%142
30Norm Van Brocklin1553289553.6%48.9%4.8%138
31Roger Staubach1685295857%52.3%4.6%137
32Warren Moon3988682358.4%56.6%1.9%128
33Danny White1705284759.9%55.6%4.3%121
34Matt Ryan2508391664%61%3%118
35Daunte Culpepper2016319963%59.4%3.6%117
36Bernie Kosar1994336559.3%56%3.3%111
37Sid Luckman881169352%45.6%6.4%109
38Dave Krieg3105531158.5%56.4%2%109
39Ken O'Brien2110360258.6%55.7%2.9%104
40Matt Schaub2040319163.9%60.7%3.2%102
41Rich Gannon2533420660.2%57.8%2.4%101
42Brian Griese1752279662.7%59.1%3.6%100
43Carson Palmer3071490662.6%60.6%2%99
44Jeff Garcia2264367661.6%59.2%2.4%87
45Frankie Albert831156453.1%47.9%5.2%81
46Steve DeBerg2874502457.2%55.6%1.6%80
47Bobby Hebert1839312158.9%56.4%2.5%78
48Billy Wade1370252354.3%51.2%3.1%78
49Steve McNair2733454460.1%58.5%1.6%74
50Greg Landry1276230055.5%52.4%3.1%71
51Brian Sipe1944343956.5%54.5%2%70
52Neil Lomax1817315357.6%55.4%2.2%70
53Tommy Thompson732142451.4%46.6%4.8%69
54Bert Jones1430255156.1%53.4%2.7%68
55Marc Bulger1969317162.1%60%2.1%67
56Jim Harbaugh2305391858.8%57.2%1.7%66
57Joe Theismann2044360256.7%55%1.8%64
58Milt Plum1306241954%51.3%2.6%64
59Archie Manning2011364255.2%53.5%1.7%63
60George Ratterman737139652.8%48.3%4.5%63
61Bob Waterfield814161750.3%46.6%3.8%61
62Trent Green2266374060.6%59%1.6%59
63Mark Brunell2761464059.5%58.2%1.3%59
64Bob Berry661117356.4%51.5%4.9%57
65Frank Tripucka879174550.4%47.3%3.1%53
66Craig Morton2053378654.2%52.8%1.4%52
67Jim Everett2841492357.7%56.7%1%49
68John Hadl2363468750.4%49.4%1%47
69Jon Kitna2677444260.3%59.2%1%46
70Jim McMahon1492257358%56.2%1.7%45
71Bill Munson1070198254%51.9%2.1%42
72Tony Eason911156458.2%55.6%2.6%41
73Gary Danielson1105193257.2%55.2%2%38
74Roman Gabriel2366449852.6%51.8%0.8%37
75Billy Kilmer1577297153.1%51.9%1.2%36
76Steve Bartkowski1932345655.9%54.9%1%36
77Bobby Thomason687134651%48.4%2.6%36
78Elvis Grbac1446244559.1%57.7%1.4%35
79Charlie Conerly1418283350.1%48.9%1.2%33
80Joe Namath1886376250.1%49.3%0.9%32
81Boomer Esiason2969520557%56.5%0.6%31
82Lynn Dickey1747312555.9%54.9%1%30
83Tom Flores838171548.9%47.3%1.6%28
84John Elway4123725056.9%56.5%0.4%27
85Robert Griffin679106363.9%61.4%2.5%27
86Wade Wilson1391242857.3%56.2%1.1%26
87Jay Cutler2390387161.7%61.1%0.6%24
88Chris Chandler2328400558.1%57.5%0.6%24
89Russell Wilson794125263.4%61.6%1.8%23
90David Garrard1406228161.6%60.6%1%23
91Jeff George2298396757.9%57.4%0.5%21
92Tim Couch1025171459.8%58.6%1.2%20
93Matt Hasselbeck3066507460.4%60.1%0.3%16
94Steve Fuller605106656.8%55.4%1.4%15
95Rudy Bukich626119052.6%51.4%1.2%14
96Norm Snead2276435352.3%52%0.3%12
97Randall Cunningham2429428956.6%56.4%0.3%12
98Arnie Herber431105141%39.9%1.1%12
99Shaun Hill736118362.2%61.2%1%12
100Jeff Hostetler1357233858%57.6%0.4%10
101James Harris607114952.8%52%0.8%9
102Andy Dalton1301211161.6%61.2%0.4%9
103Daryle Lamonica1255253049.6%49.2%0.4%9
104Neil O'Donnell1865322957.8%57.5%0.3%8
105Gary Hogeboom743132556.1%55.7%0.4%6
106Ryan Tannehill1029166261.9%61.6%0.3%5
107Pat Haden731136353.6%53.4%0.2%3
108Erik Kramer1317229957.3%57.2%0.1%1
109Mike Livingston912175152.1%52.1%0%0
110David Carr1353226759.7%59.7%0%-1
111Steve Spurrier571109752.1%52.2%-0.2%-2
112Vince Ferragamo902161555.9%56%-0.2%-3
113Jay Fiedler1008171758.7%58.9%-0.2%-4
114Earl Morrall1341261151.4%51.5%-0.2%-4
115Zeke Bratkowski762148451.3%51.6%-0.3%-4
116Tommy Kramer2012365155.1%55.2%-0.1%-4
117Jim Miller610104658.3%58.8%-0.5%-5
118Eddie LeBaron898179650%50.3%-0.3%-5
119Bobby Layne1814370049%49.2%-0.2%-7
120Rodney Peete1344234657.3%57.6%-0.4%-8
121George Blanda1740364947.7%48%-0.3%-10
122Tarvaris Jackson636106759.6%60.6%-1%-11
123Christian Ponder632105759.8%60.8%-1.1%-11
124Jim Finks647135847.6%48.5%-0.8%-11
125Jack Concannon560111050.5%51.6%-1.1%-12
126Frank Ryan1090213351.1%51.7%-0.6%-12
127Steve Beuerlein1894332856.9%57.3%-0.4%-12
128Don Majkowski1056190555.4%56.1%-0.7%-13
129Jason Campbell1519251860.3%60.9%-0.6%-14
130Phil Simms2576464755.4%55.7%-0.3%-14
131Randy Wright602111953.8%55.1%-1.3%-15
132Al Dorow572120747.4%48.7%-1.3%-15
133Alex Smith1901314960.4%60.9%-0.5%-16
134Jake Delhomme1741293259.4%60%-0.6%-17
135Randy Johnson647128650.3%51.8%-1.5%-19
136Stan Humphries1431251656.9%57.6%-0.8%-19
137Colin Kaepernick671111760.1%61.8%-1.7%-19
138Bill Nelsen963190550.6%51.6%-1%-20
139Mark Rypien1466261356.1%56.9%-0.8%-21
140Ryan Fitzpatrick1752291160.2%60.9%-0.7%-22
141Joe Flacco2213365760.5%61.1%-0.6%-23
142Tommy Maddox686120057.2%59.1%-1.9%-23
143Gary Cuozzo584118249.4%51.5%-2%-24
144Dave Wilson551103953%55.4%-2.4%-25
145Bob Avellini560111050.5%52.7%-2.3%-25
146Bill Kenney1330243054.7%55.8%-1.1%-26
147Don Meredith1170230850.7%51.8%-1.1%-26
148Richard Todd1610296754.3%55.2%-0.9%-26
149Charley Johnson1737339251.2%52%-0.8%-27
150Charlie Batch908160456.6%58.3%-1.7%-27
151Byron Leftwich930160557.9%59.7%-1.8%-29
152Eric Hipple830154653.7%55.6%-2%-30
153Josh McCown978166458.8%60.6%-1.9%-31
154Jim Ninowski513104849%51.9%-3%-31
155Paul Christman504114044.2%47%-2.8%-32
156Chad Henne1159195459.3%61%-1.7%-33
157Cam Newton1144192359.5%61.2%-1.7%-33
158Jack Kemp1436307346.7%47.9%-1.2%-36
159Vince Young755130457.9%60.7%-2.8%-36
160Steve Walsh713131754.1%57%-2.9%-38
161Sam Bradford1032176058.6%60.8%-2.2%-38
162David Woodley687130052.8%55.8%-3%-38
163Kyle Orton1613271259.5%61%-1.5%-41
164John Friesz745136454.6%57.7%-3.1%-42
165Jim Zorn1669314953%54.4%-1.4%-43
166Bubby Brister1207221254.6%56.5%-1.9%-43
167Craig Erickson591109254.1%58.1%-3.9%-43
168Donovan McNabb3170537459%59.8%-0.8%-44
169Babe Parilli1552333046.6%47.9%-1.3%-44
170Steve Bono934170154.9%57.6%-2.7%-45
171Kordell Stewart1316235855.8%57.8%-2%-46
172Matt Cassel1397236959%60.9%-2%-47
173Matthew Stafford1848309959.6%61.2%-1.6%-48
174Scott Mitchell1301234655.5%57.6%-2.1%-50
175Jim Plunkett1943370152.5%53.9%-1.4%-51
176Jack Trudeau873164453.1%56.2%-3.1%-51
177Kyle Boller861151956.7%60.1%-3.4%-51
178Dave Brown892163454.6%57.8%-3.2%-52
179Pete Beathard575128244.9%48.9%-4.1%-52
180Terry Bradshaw2025390151.9%53.3%-1.4%-53
181Jeff Blake1827324156.4%58%-1.6%-53
182Dan Pastorini1556305550.9%52.7%-1.7%-53
183Dick Wood522119443.7%48.2%-4.5%-54
184Andrew Luck1062181358.6%61.7%-3.1%-57
185Doug Flutie1177215154.7%57.5%-2.8%-60
186Chris Miller1580289254.6%56.7%-2.1%-61
187Josh Freeman1164202057.6%60.8%-3.1%-63
188Ed Brown906190347.6%51%-3.4%-65
189Jake Plummer2484435057.1%58.6%-1.5%-65
190Mike Phipps886179949.2%52.9%-3.6%-65
191Vinny Testaverde3787670156.5%57.5%-1%-68
192Marc Wilson1085208152.1%55.5%-3.4%-71
193Mark Malone839164850.9%55.3%-4.4%-73
194Kent Graham694133951.8%57.3%-5.4%-73
195Drew Bledsoe3839671757.2%58.2%-1.1%-73
196Cotton Davidson742168644%48.5%-4.5%-76
197Steve Grogan1879359352.3%54.4%-2.1%-77
198Vince Evans704139050.6%56.2%-5.6%-77
199Tony Banks1278235654.2%57.5%-3.3%-77
200Mike Tomczak1248233753.4%56.7%-3.3%-78
201Scott Brunner512104648.9%56.4%-7.5%-78
202Ron Jaworski2187411753.1%55%-1.9%-78
203Rex Grossman863156255.2%60.3%-5%-79
204Billy Joe Tolliver891170752.2%56.9%-4.7%-80
205Trent Dilfer1759317255.5%58.1%-2.7%-84
206Aaron Brooks1673296356.5%59.4%-3%-88
207Jim Hart2593507651.1%52.8%-1.7%-88
208Mike Pagel756150950.1%56.1%-6%-91
209Joe Ferguson2369451952.4%54.5%-2.1%-94
210Joey Harrington1424253856.1%59.8%-3.7%-95
211Rick Mirer1088204353.3%58%-4.8%-98
212Mark Sanchez1226217656.3%61.1%-4.7%-103
213Eli Manning3308560959%60.8%-1.9%-105
214Tobin Rote1329290745.7%49.3%-3.6%-105
215Bobby Douglass507117843%52.1%-9.1%-107
216Derek Anderson825153753.7%61.2%-7.5%-115
217Gus Frerotte1699310654.7%58.5%-3.8%-119
218Lamar McHan610144242.3%50.9%-8.6%-124
219Michael Vick1767315156.1%60.2%-4.2%-131
220Doug Williams1240250749.5%55.2%-5.8%-144
221Jay Schroeder1426280850.8%56.3%-5.5%-154
222Kerry Collins3487626155.7%59%-3.3%-206

Although Brees is the most accurate passer of all time, Peyton Manning is far behind, ranking fifth in career completion rate. When you factor in Manning’s advantage in passing volume, as well as the fact that he played in a slightly more depressed passing environment, he ends up leading the pack in career marginal completions.

The three primary Walsh quarterbacks (Anderson, Montana, and Young) all rate highly. They all rank in the top thirteen in marginal completion rate and in the top ten in marginal completions.

Brett Favre, Dan Marino, and Tom Brady don’t stand out as having historically great marginal completion rates, but they were still solid in the area, ranking between 38th and 41st all time. Combine their above average rates with a large volume of passes, and you get three guys who rank in the top twenty for marginal completions.

When we look at career marginal rate, Baugh’s numbers jump off the screen. Over the course of a career spanning two very different generations of offensive football, Slingin’ Sammy managed to complete passes at a rate nearly twelve points higher than his peers.
Len Dawson ranks a distant second, and he can probably thank coach Hank Stram (and some questionable defensive competition) for that. Stram realized Dawson wasn’t the classic field general in the Johnny Unitas mode, but instead possessed a mix of accuracy and athleticism. The innovative Hall of Fame coach utilized a moving pocket to capitalize on Dawson’s strengths. Given the Texans/Chiefs rank as the runaway most efficient offense of the AFL, I’d say the experiment worked.

A brief word on two quarterbacks who fell short of the thousand attempt cutoff. Two time NFL champion Ed Danowski only attempted 637 passes in his career. However, he was 8.9% better than the rest of the league, giving him 57 completions above expectation. Cecil Isbell was also a champion, takin over for Hall of Fame passer Arnie Herber almost seamlessly. He completed 411 of his 818 career attempts, which is 48 more than average.

I’ve previously commented on the biggest underachievers as well, but I’ve exhausted my negativity. You can be as negative as you’d like in the comments.

  1. Maybe the first guy plays for Bruce Arians and the second plays for Chip Kelly. []
  2. Sorry Ben Roethlisberger. Stop spiking the ball so much. []
  3. With the NFL’s minimum 224 attempt threshold. []
  • sacramento gold miners

    Good stuff. Although he played too long, I would take Stabler’s Oakland career over Anderson’s Cincinnati career any day of the week. Were not for injury, Bert Jones may have been a hall of famer.

    • Bert Jones, nicknamed The Ruston Rifle in high school, was a Louisiana State product who actually became the first LSU quarterback ever to earn consensus All American honors. After an illustrious senior year that saw him finish fourth in Heisman voting, he was drafted by the Colts with the number two overall pick. The Colts were in Baltimore at this time. A lot of people forget that. During his time in Baltimore, he earned a league MVP award in the same year he led the greatest offensive team of the 1970s.

      Unfortunately, injuries made his career shorter and less effective. These days he just operates a wood treatment facility near his hometown and laments his life’s disappointments.

  • Clint

    I’ve noticed that Brett Favre doesn’t come up on this site very often. I’m thinking it’s because he never had historically great seasons. He mostly had a lot of very good ones. He led the league a few times in touchdowns, yards and even completion % once (with 63%, really?) but didn’t do what guys are doing now with 5,000 yards and 40 touchdowns occuring regularly.
    For his time though, Favre was the leader in pretty much everything.

    http://pfref.com/tiny/tq5Vu

    • I was a bit surprised to see him and Marino so high on this list. They both felt like gunslingers who didn’t mind throwing an INT or an incomplete 10 rows into the stands for the sake of being aggressive or not taking a sack. I tend to remember Favre having pretty good talent around him. Maybe he didn’t, which is why he didn’t have those elite individual seasons. Or maybe he did and he was too careless with INTs.

      • Clint

        The three receivers who caught the most yards from him are Antonio Freeman, Donald Driver and Bill Schroeder. Not a bad list, but not a HOF one either. One of those things where it’s hard to tell if the receivers were just good or if Favre helped them to be more productive than they otherwise would be. Ahman Green was the only “great” back he had in Green Bay and his tight ends were solid. Never had particularly spectacular teams.
        Favre threw a ton of interceptions, but usually threw more touchdowns, so it’s not so bad.

        • Favre wouldn’t have had the opportunity to throw so many interceptions if he wasn’t good enough at the other stuff to make it worth it to keep playing him. His super long playing career meant he inevitably suffered some down seasons, which brings down his career rate stats (and, consequently, his marginal totals).

          If we don’t look at marginal stats and instead focus just on his total adjusted stats, we can see how impressive his stats are. He ranks second all time in AY, ANY, and TAY (AY/A, ANY/A, and TAY/P not divided by attempts, dropbacks, or plays). He’s comfortably behind Manning, but he’s comfortably ahead of anyone else. He didn’t have insane rate states like Steve Young, but he managed to play good football for a long time, for different coaches, in somewhat different schemes, with a revolving door of teammates, in terrible weather, and as an old veteran in a league that barely resembled the one he entered as young man.

          Despite his reputation as a gunslinger, Favre relied pretty heavily on short passes and finished his career ranked 21st in completion rate among QBs with 1,000 or more attempts (and something like 85th in career Y/A). I think most of the QBs ahead of him had better talent around them, and it’s a shame we didn’t get to see Favre’s prime take place with a healthy Sterling Sharpe.

          • Clint

            Because of obnoxious media coverage and Favre’s indecisiveness, we didn’t get to truly appreciate the end of his career. He was STILL great with Minnesota. It’s unbelievable. The odds were always against this guy.
            And yes, imagine how good those late 90s teams would’ve been with Sterling Sharpe? Maaannnnnnnn

            • If you like imagining things, imagine if the Packers had taken ANY of the other top 5 players in this draft http://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/1989/draft.htm

              • Clint

                Barry Sanders inparticular would’ve been excellent! Especially since he probably would’ve stayed there his whole career. Btw, he grew up around ten minutes from where I’m sitting. No big deal.
                I have Tony Mandarich’s book. Basically, he got hooked on pain killers and couldn’t stop. He would shoot himself up in the locker room. The guy played while he was high! Got to where he was popping 80+ pills a day. 100% insane. They say he was pretty great when he came back later on. I suspect a smilar story will eventually come out about how Jamarcus Russell was playing while high, but I digress. #purpledrankdoe

        • Richie

          Favre (and Rodgers) have done an excellent job of turning guys into star receivers. Sterling Sharpe, Robert Brooks, Antonio Freeman, Bill Schroeder, Javon Walker, Donald Driver, Greg Jennings, Jordy Nelson and Randall Cobb.

  • Ralph Skinner

    I wish there was a quick way to adjust the statistics for different eras in terms of pass attempts. For example, Sammy Baugh played more years than Drew Brees has, yet has 40% of Brees’ attempts. Therefore, he has to work much harder for marginal completions. If the marginal completions could be weighted to eliminate differences in sheer quantity of passing in each era (i.e. through passes per game multiplied by 16 compared to passes per game in 2014 [as a base season]), Baugh would skyrocket and other older quarterbacks would rise as well.

    i.e. Baugh’s 1947 season compared to Brees’ 2011 season:

    Baugh threw 354 passes, vs. 299 expected passes (12 x 24.9). 1.185 times more.
    In 2011, expected passes was 544 (16 x 34.0), projecting Baugh at 644 attempts (544 x 1.185).
    With an era-adjusted 644 attempts, Baugh’s 1947 season would have 89.7 weighted marginal completions. Over the course of a weighted career, I’m sure Baugh would take top spot on the second list.

    Given, the same era that minimized Baugh’s pass attempts also gave him a low bar for completion percentage and consequently a Marg Cmp % which would be nearly impossible today, but I think it should still be factored in to benefit Baugh, Graham, Unitas, etc.

    All in all, Baugh’s outrageous accuracy, whether with weighted attempts or not, shows what a special player he was. Taking into account his special teams and defensive play, Baugh is one of, if not the best football player of all-time.

    • There is a quick and easy way to adjust for eras, and I did it in my spreadsheet. I just didn’t feel like including it in this series of data dumps. Maybe later I’ll give credit for games that never happened, but now’s not that time. That’s part of the tradeoff guys like Baugh and Graham have: their marginal rate stats are way better than any modern player can hope to match, but their low volume hurts the cumulative value. The easiest way to get the old guy you want at the top is to sort the table by the penultimate column.

      • Ralph Skinner

        Personally, I don’t look at it as giving credit for games that never happened. I think it further puts the players’ statistics into historical context. To arrive at your marginal completions number, you use two statistics: completion percentage and attempts. You get halfway there by putting completion percentage into context, but then place no adjustments to reflect the difference in attempts across eras. Thus, I feel like there is a place in this article for that adjustment to be made, if only as a supplement your primary list.

        As to getting the old guy I want at the top: again, this adjustment would be made to give a more accurate representation of these players’ achievements by accounting for different tendencies of their eras. I’m not looking to overadjust and I certainly don’t want the top 5 to be filled with guys from the 1940s; just a lack of bias in the formula.

        • I would prefer to perhaps incorporate a per/game column than to give credit for an extra 2-5 games that never took place. The absolute biggest problem I have with prorating stats is that there is almost always an inverse correlation between volume and efficiency, and I have little faith that someone like Baugh or Graham (or even Dick Wood, if we want to go with bad players) would have maintained the same level of play on twice as many passes. It’s why I don’t harp too much on what might have happened if Fouts played a full schedule in 1982.

          Change in topic (sort of): I hear a lot about prorating the stats of older QBs to put them into historical context, but I rarely hear about doing this with running backs. Yes, we sometimes adjust for a 16 game schedule, but no one ever says “hey the number of plays per game has remained relatively stable since forever, but the percentage of pass plays has risen from 28% to 54% since 1935. We should take some of those rushing yards away from Jim Brown.”

          Not saying I lean one way or another. Just throwing it out there.

          • Ralph Skinner

            Personally, I’d adjust both the older quarterbacks and running backs, but I think you’d find that not many rushing yards would be taken away from Jim Brown.

            During Brown’s nine years in the NFL, teams averaged 131.8 yards per game. In the past nine years (2006-2014), teams averaged 114.7 yards per game. Admittedly, this seems like a significant difference. However, we are looking at an individual; not a team. Between 1957 and 1965, there were 15 seasons with 80 ypg. 7 belonged to Brown. Between 2006 and 2014, there were 73 seasons with 80 ypg. 73 compared to 15, 37 to 6 for non-repeats.

            For a limit of 70 ypg, the modern nine seasons once again outnumbers Brown’s, this time 138 to 28 (including all nine of Brown’s). My point is that while the team running game was more dominant prior to the 2000s, individual running backs are finding far more success now then in Brown’s era. Rather than use a team adjustment, it’s better to use an adjustment like Chase’s “worst starter” in his wide receiver article http://www.footballperspective.com/adjusted-catch-yards-over-worst-starter/. I’ll compare Brown’s 1800 yard season in 1963 to LT’s 1800 yard season in 2006. Since I find running backs to be slightly more selective, I will use “average starter” to use the 8th best and 17th best respectively instead of 14th and 30th (exactly the middle, when you factor out Brown and LT themselves).

            In 1963, the 8th best running back had 54.8 yards per game.
            In 2006, the 17th best running back had 72.4 yards per game.

            Using Brown’s 133 ypg and LT’s 113 ypg, we see that Brown outperformed the baseline by a staggering 243%, compared to LT’s 156%. Clearly for me, Brown’s numbers are more impressive in the context of time, rather than less.

            • Personally, I still don’t see the point other than to try to clear things up for people who don’t understand how to put things into historical context. Comparing players against other players in their own era is one thing, but just adding fake volume to artificially adjust for inflation just doesn’t do it for me. Primarily, as I said before, because I don’t believe the good QBs or bad QBs would maintain the same level of great or poor performance over nearly double the dropbacks. Granted, some would, but I think the majority would not.

              For QBs, you’re getting into double prorating because you’re adding extra attempts per game, and then you’re adding extra games (with those extra attempts). I think it’s silly to basically give Otto Graham credit for double the dropbacks he actually took just to satisfy some abstract notion of fairness. Otto Graham did what he did, and it was better than what anyone else in his era did (sorry, Kibbles). That should be enough. If I prorated, it would be an extra column or two that was just a “hey check that out,” but it wouldn’t serve as the focus of my argument by any means.

              When measuring career value added, I think it is fair to keep older guys behind because, by taking so many fewer dropbacks and playing in so many fewer games, they absolutely added less career value. That doesn’t mean they were just as good; it just means there was less value to be added, so it was impossible for them to add much more than they did. I could see comparing value added in a season versus what everyone else added per season and giving them a score based on that.

              I’d be comfortable saying that if Otto Graham had 1,000 units of value, while the average QB had 600 units, we would give him 1.67 points. And if Peyton Manning had 4,000 units of value, but the league average was 2,400 units, we’d also give him 1.67 points. So even though Manning had quadruple the RANY (or whatever), the two earn the same score. This effectively does the same thing as prorating, but it doesn’t involve just inventing games and plays that never happened.

    • I think a person would have to be crazy not to agree that Baugh is one of the truly great and special players in the rich history of the NFL. He’s possibly the most overrated punter not named Shane Lechler, but when you play DB and QB that well it doesn’t much matter.

  • LightsOut85

    While schemes of today feature shorter (& theoretically easier to complete) passes much more than they ever have, I still think the most impressive marks are Pennington, Warner, Manning & Brees – able to be above 6% higher than LMP in an era where the LMP is about 5-10% higher than anyone ranked above them (ranked by MargComp%).

  • Ralph Skinner

    Running down the numbers if they were adjusted for varying pass attempts with my best estimate for Otto Graham, Sid Luckman and Sammy Baugh:

    Graham – 330
    Luckman – 260
    Baugh – 767

    I’m sure adjusting for Tarkenton, Dawson and Favre would put them back over Graham but the real story here is Sammy Baugh’s awesome tally.

  • I thought Brees would have a shot at taking the top spot here (for career), but he still wasn’t particularly close to Manning.