≡ Menu

Bryan Frye, owner and operator of the great site http://www.thegridfe.com, is back for another guest post. You can also view all of Bryan’s guest posts at Football Perspective at this link, and follow him on twitter @LaverneusDingle.


On Monday, I looked at which quarterbacks since 1960 helped or hurt their teams the most by taking or avoiding sacks. On Tuesday, I looked at the quarterbacks who gained the most or fewest yards through the air per attempt or dropback, and on Wednesday, we looked at completions relative to league average. Yesterday, the metric of the day was touchdown pass rate.

As promised, this article, “Dr. Safelove or: How I Learned to Start Worrying and Fear the Bomb,” centers on interceptions. The methodology here is no different from before: Figure out each player’s rate stats relative to the average of the rest of the league minus that player (LMP) that year and multiply it by his attempts to find the marginal total.

The caveat for this article is a big one: it is mathematically impossible for modern players to rank highly on a per play basis. In 1945, Sammy Baugh threw interceptions at a rate 7.4% lower than his peers. Because the league average today is so low (about 2.5%), a current quarterback would have to throw negative interceptions to match a -7.4% relative pick rate. Even if a quarterback threw 700 passes without an interception, the best he could possibly do is about -2.5%.

For single seasons, this makes a big difference. For entire careers, however, it isn’t as big of a deal. The higher volume of modern passers helps offset the superior rates of older quarterbacks. It’s not perfect, but hey … this is a data dump.1

Single Season Stats

The first table presents the 1,563 passing seasons with at least 224 attempts and is sorted by marginal interceptions (lower is better). Read it thus: In 1947, Sammy Baugh threw 15 interceptions on 354 attempts, or 4.24% of his passes. The rest of the league threw picks on 8.73% of passes, so Baugh’s marginal rate was -4.49%. This gave him -16 marginal interceptions.

RkQuarterbackYearTmAttIntInt%LMP Int%Marg Int%Marg Int
1Sammy Baugh1947WAS354154.248.73-4.49-16
2Steve Bartkowski1983ATL43251.164.48-3.32-14
3Cecil Isbell1942GNB268145.2210.41-5.19-14
4Sonny Jurgensen1967WAS508163.155.8-2.65-13
5Roman Gabriel1969RAM39971.755.1-3.34-13
6Roman Gabriel1973PHI460122.615.43-2.83-13
7Otto Graham1949CLE285103.518.02-4.51-13
8Fran Tarkenton1969NYG40981.965.09-3.13-13
9Ken O'Brien1985NYJ48881.644.26-2.62-13
10Jim Hart1974STL38882.065.32-3.26-13
11Milt Plum1960CLE250526.98-4.98-12
12Sammy Baugh1942WAS225114.8910.33-5.44-12
13Fran Tarkenton1976MIN41281.944.9-2.96-12
14Roger Staubach1977DAL36192.495.84-3.35-12
15Steve DeBerg1990KAN44440.93.62-2.72-12
16Bert Jones1977BAL393112.85.84-3.04-12
17Brian Sipe1980CLE554142.534.66-2.14-12
18Bernie Kosar1986CLE531101.884.08-2.19-12
19Johnny Unitas1963BAL410122.935.75-2.82-12
20Davey O'Brien1940PHI277176.1410.3-4.16-12
21Y.A. Tittle1954SFO29593.056.96-3.91-12
22Y.A. Tittle1948BCL28993.116.96-3.84-11
23Joe Montana1983SFO515122.334.46-2.13-11
24Marc Bulger2006STL58881.363.22-1.86-11
25Tom Brady2010NWE49240.813.02-2.21-11
26Ken Anderson1981CIN479102.094.35-2.26-11
27Roman Gabriel1971RAM352102.845.89-3.05-11
28Bert Jones1975BAL34482.335.44-3.11-11
29Chris Miller1989ATL526101.93.93-2.03-11
30Bill Munson1968DET32982.435.64-3.21-11
31Babe Parilli1962BOS25383.167.33-4.17-11
32Roger Staubach1979DAL461112.394.67-2.28-11
33Tom Brady2007NWE57881.383.2-1.81-10
34Bart Starr1966GNB25131.25.35-4.15-10
35Otto Graham1953CLE25893.497.47-3.98-10
36Fran Tarkenton1975MIN425133.065.43-2.37-10
37John Brodie1970SFO378102.655.27-2.62-10
38Ken O'Brien1988NYJ42471.653.97-2.32-10
39Aaron Rodgers2009GNB54171.293.1-1.81-10
40Charlie Conerly1948NYG299134.357.61-3.27-10
41Tony Eason1984NWE43181.864.12-2.26-10
42Archie Manning1978NOR471163.45.45-2.06-10
43Rich Gannon2001OAK54991.643.4-1.76-10
44Johnny Unitas1958BAL26372.666.33-3.66-10
45Ken Anderson1975CIN377112.925.43-2.51-9
46Brett Favre2009MIN53171.323.1-1.78-9
47Roman Gabriel1970RAM407122.955.26-2.32-9
48Daryle Lamonica1968OAK416153.615.87-2.26-9
49Joe Theismann1983WAS459112.44.45-2.05-9
50Dan Fouts1981SDG609172.794.34-1.55-9
51Ken Anderson1972CIN30172.335.43-3.11-9
52Bart Starr1964GNB27241.474.89-3.42-9
53Milt Plum1961CLE302103.316.38-3.07-9
54Joe Montana1981SFO488122.464.33-1.88-9
55Rich Gannon2002OAK618101.623.09-1.47-9
56Aaron Brooks2003NOR51881.543.3-1.75-9
57Bobby Layne1950DET336185.368.06-2.7-9
58Tom Brady2012NWE63781.262.68-1.42-9
59Neil O'Donnell1993PIT48671.443.3-1.86-9
60Johnny Unitas1967BAL436163.675.73-2.06-9
61Ron Jaworski1980PHI451122.664.64-1.98-9
62Otto Graham1947CLE269114.097.41-3.32-9
63Johnny Unitas1964BAL30561.974.88-2.91-9
64Peyton Manning2006IND55791.623.21-1.59-9
65Aaron Rodgers2011GNB50261.22.96-1.76-9
66Bill Kenney1983KAN603182.994.44-1.46-9
67Steve Young1992SFO40271.743.92-2.18-9
68Peyton Manning2003IND566101.773.3-1.53-9
69Bernie Kosar1991CLE49491.823.56-1.74-9
70Peyton Manning2013DEN659101.522.82-1.3-9
71Earl Morrall1957PIT289124.157.12-2.97-9
72Richard Todd1981NYJ497132.624.33-1.71-9
73Jason Campbell2008WAS50661.192.86-1.67-8
74Fran Tarkenton1970NYG389123.085.25-2.17-8
75Jeff Garcia2000SFO561101.783.29-1.5-8
76John Hadl1969SDG324113.45.99-2.6-8
77Bill Munson1974DET29272.45.27-2.88-8
78Gary Danielson1980DET417112.644.64-2-8
79Aaron Rodgers2014GNB52050.962.56-1.6-8
80Tobin Rote1954GNB382184.716.88-2.17-8
81Billy Wade1963CHI356123.375.69-2.32-8
82Josh Freeman2010TAM47461.273-1.74-8
83Roman Gabriel1967RAM371133.55.72-2.21-8
84Butch Songin1960BOS392153.835.92-2.09-8
85Jim Zorn1981SEA39792.274.33-2.06-8
86Bart Starr1962GNB28593.166.03-2.87-8
87Doug Williams1980TAM521163.074.64-1.57-8
88Tony Eason1986NWE448102.234.05-1.82-8
89Matt Ryan2010ATL57191.583-1.43-8
90Alex Smith2011SFO44551.122.95-1.83-8
91John Elway1993DEN551101.813.29-1.47-8
92Johnny Unitas1959BAL367143.816.02-2.21-8
93Dan Marino1990MIA531112.073.59-1.52-8
94Donovan McNabb2007PHI47371.483.18-1.7-8
95Frankie Albert1948SFO264103.796.84-3.05-8
96Milt Plum1959CLE26683.016.02-3.01-8
97Tony Romo2009DAL55091.643.09-1.45-8
98Phil Simms1988NYG479112.33.96-1.66-8
99Warren Moon1990HOU584132.233.59-1.36-8
100Brad Johnson2001TAM559111.973.39-1.42-8
101Jim Hart1978STL477183.775.44-1.66-8
102Brad Johnson2002TAM45161.333.09-1.76-8
103Ken O'Brien1987NYJ39382.044.05-2.01-8
104Neil Lomax1985STL471122.554.22-1.68-8
105Joe Montana1985SFO494132.634.22-1.59-8
106Otto Graham1948CLE333154.56.83-2.32-8
107Ken Anderson1977CIN323113.415.8-2.39-8
108Fran Tarkenton1973MIN27472.555.37-2.82-8
109Joe Montana1984SFO432102.314.1-1.79-8
110Sonny Jurgensen1970WAS337102.975.25-2.28-8
111Bert Jones1976BAL34392.624.85-2.23-8
112Jim Finks1953PIT292144.797.41-2.61-8
113Tobin Rote1956GNB308154.877.34-2.47-8
114Tommy Thompson1948PHI246114.477.53-3.06-8
115Fran Tarkenton1972MIN378133.445.41-1.97-7
116Neil O'Donnell1998CIN34341.173.33-2.16-7
117John Elway1986DEN504132.584.05-1.47-7
118Jeff George1993IND40761.473.28-1.81-7
119David Garrard2007JAX32530.923.18-2.26-7
120Alex Smith2013KAN50871.382.81-1.44-7
121Ken Anderson1974CIN328103.055.26-2.21-7
122Jake Plummer2005DEN45671.543.12-1.59-7
123Neil O'Donnell1997NYJ46071.523.08-1.56-7
124Jim Hart1973STL320103.135.37-2.24-7
125Norm Van Brocklin1953RAM286144.97.39-2.5-7
126Phil Simms1990NYG31141.293.58-2.3-7
127Rudy Bukich1965CHI31292.885.17-2.28-7
128Dan Marino1983MIA29662.034.43-2.4-7
129Donovan McNabb2004PHI46981.713.22-1.52-7
130Sonny Jurgensen1969WAS442153.395-1.6-7
131Joe Montana1989SFO38682.073.91-1.84-7
132Jeff George1997OAK52191.733.08-1.35-7
133Andrew Luck2013IND57091.582.81-1.23-7
134Brian Griese2000DEN33641.193.28-2.09-7
135Vinny Testaverde1998NYJ42171.663.33-1.66-7
136Neil Lomax1984STL560162.864.1-1.24-7
137Nick Foles2013PHI31720.632.81-2.18-7
138Greg Landry1977DET24072.925.79-2.87-7
139Roger Staubach1976DAL369112.984.85-1.87-7
140Troy Aikman1993DAL39261.533.28-1.75-7
141Damon Huard2006KAN24410.413.2-2.79-7
142John Hadl1966SDG375143.735.55-1.81-7
143Fran Tarkenton1968NYG337123.565.57-2.01-7
144Y.A. Tittle1963NYG367143.815.66-1.85-7
145Boomer Esiason1989CIN455112.423.91-1.49-7
146Frank Tripucka1962DEN440255.687.22-1.54-7
147Aaron Rodgers2012GNB55281.452.67-1.22-7
148Drew Brees2006NOR554111.993.2-1.21-7
149Bernie Kosar1987CLE38992.314.04-1.72-7
150Craig Morton1977DEN25483.155.79-2.64-7
151Neil Lomax1987STL463122.594.04-1.44-7
152Joe Montana1994KAN49391.833.18-1.35-7
153Brian Sipe1978CLE399153.765.43-1.67-7
154Ben Roethlisberger2010PIT38951.293-1.71-7
155Tom Brady2013NWE628111.752.81-1.06-7
156Daunte Culpepper2004MIN548112.013.22-1.21-7
157Chad Pennington2008MIA47671.472.85-1.38-7
158Rich Gannon1991MIN35461.693.55-1.85-7
159Joe Theismann1984WAS477132.734.09-1.37-7
160Ben Roethlisberger2014PIT60891.482.55-1.07-7
161Neil Lomax1988PHO443112.483.95-1.47-7
162Bob Waterfield1946RAM251176.779.36-2.58-6
163Craig Morton1978DEN267835.43-2.43-6
164Matt Cassel2010KAN45071.562.99-1.44-6
165Dan Marino1991MIA549132.373.55-1.18-6
166Fran Tarkenton1974MIN351123.425.25-1.83-6
167Terry Bradshaw1975PIT28693.155.4-2.25-6
168Roger Staubach1978DAL413163.875.42-1.55-6
169Mark Brunell1997JAX43571.613.08-1.47-6
170Jeff Garcia2007TAM32741.223.17-1.95-6
171Bob Griese1971MIA26393.425.84-2.42-6
172Drew Bledsoe1996NWE623152.413.43-1.02-6
173Bobby Layne19582TM294124.086.24-2.16-6
174Steve McNair1998TEN492102.033.32-1.29-6
175Ken O'Brien1991NYJ489112.253.54-1.3-6
176Troy Aikman1995DAL43271.623.09-1.47-6
177Doug Williams1981TAM471142.974.31-1.34-6
178Bill Nelsen1968CLE293103.415.57-2.15-6
179Norm Van Brocklin1959PHI340144.125.97-1.85-6
180Billy Kilmer1974WAS23462.565.25-2.69-6
181Chad Pennington2002NYJ39961.53.08-1.57-6
182George Ratterman1949BUF252135.167.65-2.49-6
183Sammy Baugh1943WAS239197.9510.57-2.62-6
184Drew Brees2013NOR650121.852.81-0.96-6
185Jeff Garcia2002SFO528101.893.08-1.18-6
186Joe Ferguson1979BUF458153.284.64-1.36-6
187Glenn Dobbs1946BDA269155.587.89-2.32-6
188Cotton Davidson1960DTX379164.225.86-1.64-6
189Jeff George1995ATL557111.973.09-1.11-6
190Greg Landry1979BAL457153.284.64-1.35-6
191Y.A. Tittle1950BAL315196.037.99-1.96-6
192Frank Ryan1966CLE382143.665.28-1.61-6
193Boomer Esiason1985CIN431122.784.21-1.43-6
194Don Meredith1966DAL344123.495.28-1.79-6
195Steve McNair2003TEN40071.753.28-1.53-6
196Randall Cunningham1988PHI560162.863.95-1.09-6
197Erik Kramer1995CHI522101.923.08-1.17-6
198Jeff Hostetler1991NYG28541.43.54-2.14-6
199Greg Landry1976DET29182.754.84-2.09-6
200Dan Marino1984MIA564173.014.09-1.08-6
201Steve Bono1995KAN520101.923.08-1.16-6
202Tobin Rote1958DET257103.896.23-2.34-6
203Y.A. Tittle1961NYG285124.216.32-2.11-6
204Bernie Kosar1989CLE513142.733.9-1.17-6
205Scott Mitchell1995DET583122.063.08-1.03-6
206Peyton Manning2004IND497102.013.21-1.2-6
207Mark Brunell1999JAX44192.043.4-1.35-6
208Tom Brady2011NWE611121.962.94-0.98-6
209Philip Rivers2009SDG48691.853.08-1.23-6
210Fran Tarkenton1965MIN329113.345.15-1.8-6
211Trent Green1998WAS509112.163.32-1.16-6
212Kyle Orton2010DEN49891.812.99-1.18-6
213Jim Kelly1987BUF419112.634.03-1.41-6
214John Brodie1961SFO283124.246.32-2.08-6
215David Garrard2009JAX516101.943.08-1.14-6
216George Blanda1964HOU505275.356.51-1.16-6
217Drew Brees2004SDG40071.753.21-1.46-6
218Dan Marino1997MIA548112.013.07-1.07-6
219Tom Brady2014NWE58291.552.55-1-6
220Alex Smith2014KAN46461.292.55-1.26-6
221Neil O'Donnell1995PIT41671.683.08-1.4-6
222Matt Hasselbeck2007SEA562122.143.17-1.04-6
223Trent Green2005KAN507101.973.12-1.14-6
224Mark Brunell2002JAX41671.683.07-1.39-6
225Steve DeBerg1979SFO578213.634.63-1-6
226Jim Hart1976STL388133.354.84-1.49-6
227Rich Gannon1998KAN35461.693.32-1.62-6
228Randall Cunningham1989PHI532152.823.9-1.08-6
229Roman Gabriel1974PHI338123.555.25-1.7-6
230Ken Anderson1979CIN339102.954.63-1.68-6
231Philip Rivers2006SDG46091.963.19-1.23-6
232Len Dawson1966KAN284103.525.52-2-6
233John Elway1994DEN494102.023.17-1.15-6
234Joe Montana1988SFO397102.523.94-1.43-6
235Ken Anderson1973CIN329123.655.35-1.7-6
236Donovan McNabb2000PHI569132.283.27-0.98-6
237Kerry Collins2005OAK565122.123.11-0.99-6
238Brett Favre1996GNB543132.393.42-1.03-6
239Dan Marino1992MIA554162.893.89-1.01-6
240Daryle Lamonica1967OAK425204.716.02-1.31-6
241Ron Jaworski1978PHI398164.025.42-1.4-6
242Mark Rypien1989WAS476132.733.9-1.17-6
243Sonny Jurgensen1964WAS385133.384.82-1.44-6
244Virgil Carter1970CIN27893.245.22-1.99-6
245Norm Snead1972NYG325123.695.39-1.7-6
246Jim Finks1952PIT336195.657.29-1.64-5
247Sammy Baugh1949WAS255145.497.65-2.15-5
248Jim Harbaugh1997IND30941.293.07-1.78-5
249Robert Griffin2012WAS39351.272.66-1.39-5
250Troy Aikman1998DAL31551.593.32-1.73-5
251Jack Kemp1966BUF389164.115.51-1.4-5
252Steve Bartkowski1980ATL463163.464.62-1.16-5
253Jim Zorn1979SEA505183.564.63-1.06-5
254Brett Favre1992GNB471132.763.89-1.13-5
255Tony Romo2011DAL522101.922.94-1.02-5
256Ron Jaworski1979PHI374123.214.63-1.42-5
257Sid Luckman1946CHI229166.999.3-2.32-5
258Charlie Conerly1957NYG232114.747.02-2.28-5
259Drew Brees2011NOR657142.132.94-0.8-5
260Joe Theismann1979WAS395133.294.63-1.34-5
261Josh McCown2013CHI22410.452.8-2.36-5
262Tom Brady2003NWE527122.283.27-1-5
263Len Dawson1962DTX310175.487.18-1.69-5
264Donovan McNabb2008PHI571111.932.84-0.91-5
265Bill Kenney1985KAN33892.664.2-1.54-5
266Sonny Jurgensen1968WAS292113.775.55-1.78-5
267Jeff George1991IND485122.473.54-1.06-5
268Brad Johnson2005MIN29441.363.11-1.75-5
269Matt Schaub2010HOU574122.092.99-0.9-5
270Don Meredith1968DAL309123.885.55-1.66-5
271Jim Harbaugh1990CHI31261.923.57-1.65-5
272Steve Young1998SFO517122.323.31-0.99-5
273Trent Green2003KAN523122.293.27-0.98-5
274Michael Vick2010PHI37261.612.99-1.37-5
275Bubby Brister1993PHI30951.623.27-1.65-5
276Donovan McNabb2002PHI36161.663.07-1.41-5
277Gus Frerotte1996WAS470112.343.42-1.08-5
278Rick Mirer1994SEA38171.843.17-1.33-5
279Pat Haden1978RAM444194.285.41-1.13-5
280Tommy Kramer1986MIN372102.694.03-1.34-5
281Jeff Garcia2001SFO504122.383.37-0.99-5
282Tony Romo2013DAL535101.872.8-0.93-5
283Neil Lomax1986STL421122.854.03-1.18-5
284Matt Hasselbeck2005SEA449923.11-1.11-5
285Len Dawson1964KAN354185.086.49-1.4-5
286Joe Theismann1980WAS454163.524.61-1.09-5
287Steve Young1997SFO35661.693.07-1.38-5
288Michael Vick2002ATL42181.93.07-1.17-5
289Dan Pastorini1976HOU309103.244.83-1.59-5
290Kurt Warner2004NYG27741.443.21-1.76-5
291Steve Tensi1969DEN286124.25.9-1.71-5
292Joe Namath1968NYJ380174.475.76-1.28-5
293Roman Gabriel1966RAM397164.035.25-1.22-5
294Dan Marino1987MIA444132.934.02-1.09-5
295Billy Kilmer1971WAS306134.255.83-1.58-5
296Roman Gabriel1963RAM281113.915.62-1.71-5
297Steve Young1996SFO31661.93.42-1.52-5
298Bobby Layne1949NYY299186.027.62-1.6-5
299Drew Brees2009NOR514112.143.07-0.93-5
300Glenn Dobbs1948LAD369205.426.71-1.29-5
301Kerry Collins2008TEN41571.692.84-1.15-5
302Jeff Blake1996CIN549142.553.42-0.87-5
303Bob Griese1977MIA307134.235.77-1.53-5
304Roman Gabriel1975PHI292113.775.38-1.61-5
305Bobby Layne1954DET246124.886.79-1.91-5
306Jeff Garcia2008TAM37661.62.84-1.24-5
307Jim Harbaugh1995IND31451.593.08-1.48-5
308Ken O'Brien1990NYJ411102.433.57-1.13-5
309Warren Moon1995MIN606142.313.08-0.77-5
310Donovan McNabb2003PHI478112.33.27-0.97-5
311Ed Brown1959CHI247104.055.92-1.87-5
312Neil Lomax1983STL354113.114.41-1.3-5
313Ken Anderson1982CIN30992.914.41-1.49-5
314Donovan McNabb2001PHI493122.433.37-0.93-5
315Kyle Orton2009DEN541122.223.07-0.85-5
316Phil Simms1981NYG31692.854.3-1.45-5
317Matt Ryan2011ATL566122.122.93-0.81-5
318Joe Flacco2010BAL489102.042.98-0.94-5
319Steve Young1994SFO461102.173.16-0.99-5
320Jeff Kemp1984RAM28472.464.08-1.61-5
321Brad Johnson1999WAS519132.53.39-0.88-5
322Terry Bradshaw1972PIT308123.95.38-1.48-5
323Doug Flutie2000BUF23131.33.26-1.96-5
324Len Dawson1971KAN301134.325.82-1.5-5
325Brett Favre1995GNB570132.283.08-0.79-5
326Norm Van Brocklin1950RAM233146.017.95-1.94-5
327Y.A. Tittle1957SFO279155.387-1.62-5
328Russell Wilson2014SEA45271.552.54-0.99-4
329John Elway1987DEN410122.934.02-1.09-4
330Peyton Manning2012DEN583111.892.65-0.77-4
331Sam Bradford2011STL35761.682.93-1.25-4
332Boomer Esiason1993NYJ473112.333.26-0.94-4
333Rich Gannon2000OAK473112.333.26-0.94-4
334Tom Brady2002NWE601142.333.07-0.74-4
335Earl Morrall1963DET328144.275.62-1.35-4
336Tom Brady2006NWE516122.333.18-0.86-4
337Brett Favre1994GNB582142.413.16-0.76-4
338Len Dawson1972KAN305123.935.38-1.44-4
339Bob Griese1968MIA355164.515.74-1.24-4
340Tobin Rote1955GNB342195.566.84-1.28-4
341John Elway1997DEN502112.193.06-0.87-4
342Byron Leftwich2005JAX30251.663.11-1.45-4
343Troy Aikman1992DAL473142.963.89-0.93-4
344Steve Bono1991SFO23741.693.53-1.84-4
345Len Dawson1967KAN357174.765.98-1.22-4
346Warren Moon1984HOU450143.114.08-0.97-4
347Tom Brady2009NWE565132.33.07-0.77-4
348Steve Beuerlein1999CAR571152.633.39-0.76-4
349Randall Cunningham1987PHI406122.964.02-1.06-4
350Drew Bledsoe2000NWE531132.453.26-0.81-4
351Mark Brunell2006WAS26041.543.18-1.64-4
352Bob Lee1973ATL23083.485.33-1.86-4
353Tom Flores1961OAK366195.196.36-1.17-4
354Joe Namath1969NYJ361174.715.89-1.18-4
355Kerry Collins2000NYG529132.463.26-0.8-4
356Roman Gabriel1968RAM366164.375.53-1.16-4
357Joe Montana1982SFO346113.184.4-1.22-4
358Ken Stabler1974OAK310123.875.23-1.36-4
359Philip Rivers2013SDG544112.022.8-0.77-4
360Joe Namath1965NYJ340154.415.65-1.24-4
361Tom Flores1965OAK269114.095.65-1.56-4
362Byron Leftwich2004JAX441102.273.2-0.94-4
363Scott Brunner1982NYG29893.024.4-1.38-4
364Mark Brunell2005WAS454102.23.1-0.9-4
365Dave Krieg1986SEA375112.934.02-1.09-4
366Joe Flacco2012BAL531101.882.65-0.77-4
367Jack Kemp1965BUF391184.65.64-1.04-4
368Dan Pastorini1972HOU299124.015.37-1.36-4
369Peyton Manning2005IND453102.213.1-0.9-4
370Wade Wilson1988MIN33292.713.93-1.22-4
371Randall Cunningham1998MIN425102.353.31-0.95-4
372Donovan McNabb2006PHI31661.93.18-1.28-4
373Steve DeBerg1987TAM27572.554.02-1.47-4
374Phil Simms1993NYG40092.253.26-1.01-4
375Dave Krieg1992KAN413122.913.88-0.98-4
376Warren Moon1989HOU464143.023.89-0.87-4
377Charlie Batch1998DET30361.983.31-1.33-4
378Johnny Unitas1957BAL301175.656.98-1.33-4
379Dave Brown1995NYG456102.193.07-0.88-4
380John Brodie1965SFO391164.095.11-1.02-4
381Jim Zorn1978SEA443204.515.4-0.89-4
382John Elway1991DEN451122.663.53-0.87-4
383Randall Cunningham1992PHI384112.863.88-1.02-4
384Ben Roethlisberger2012PIT44981.782.65-0.87-4
385Kurt Warner1999STL499132.613.38-0.78-4
386Kordell Stewart2001PIT442112.493.36-0.88-4
387John Elway1990DEN502142.793.56-0.77-4
388Joe Flacco2011BAL542122.212.93-0.71-4
389Troy Aikman1997DAL518122.323.06-0.74-4
390Ken Stabler1973OAK260103.855.33-1.48-4
391Ron Jaworski1986PHI24562.454.02-1.57-4
392Kyle Boller2004BAL464112.373.2-0.83-4
393Seneca Wallace2008SEA24231.242.83-1.59-4
394Mark Rypien1991WAS421112.613.53-0.91-4
395Sonny Jurgensen1966WAS436194.365.24-0.88-4
396Len Dawson1968KAN22494.025.73-1.71-4
397Daunte Culpepper2003MIN454112.423.27-0.84-4
398Bart Starr1965GNB25193.595.11-1.52-4
399Chris Miller1992ATL25362.373.88-1.51-4
400Elvis Grbac2000KAN547142.563.26-0.7-4
401Roger Staubach1974DAL360154.175.23-1.06-4
402Otto Graham1951CLE265166.047.47-1.44-4
403Danny White1981DAL391133.324.3-0.97-4
404Carson Palmer2005CIN509122.363.1-0.75-4
405Bobby Hebert1988NOR478153.143.93-0.79-4
406Mike Phipps1979CHI25583.144.62-1.48-4
407Steve McNair2005TEN476112.313.1-0.79-4
408Cleo Lemon2007MIA30961.943.16-1.22-4
409John Friesz1993SDG23841.683.26-1.58-4
410Charley Johnson1974DEN24493.695.23-1.54-4
411Dan Marino1996MIA37392.413.41-1-4
412Peyton Manning2008IND555122.162.83-0.67-4
413Phil Simms1984NYG533183.384.07-0.7-4
414John Brodie1967SFO349164.585.65-1.06-4
415Drew Bledsoe2002BUF610152.463.06-0.6-4
416Y.A. Tittle1949BCL289186.237.5-1.27-4
417Bart Starr1963GNB244104.15.6-1.5-4
418Jake Plummer2001ARI525142.673.36-0.7-4
419Jeff Hostetler1993RAI419102.393.26-0.87-4
420Joey Harrington2004DET489122.453.2-0.75-4
421Dan Fouts1984SDG507173.354.07-0.72-4
422Fran Tarkenton1964MIN306113.594.78-1.19-4
423Mark Brunell1995JAX34672.023.07-1.05-4
424Colin Kaepernick2013SFO41681.922.79-0.87-4
425Elvis Grbac1997KAN31461.913.06-1.15-4
426Matt Cassel2008NWE516112.132.83-0.7-4
427Peyton Manning2000IND571152.633.26-0.63-4
428Donovan McNabb2009PHI443102.263.06-0.81-4
429Joe Montana1980SFO27393.34.6-1.31-4
430Steve Dils1983MIN444163.64.4-0.8-4
431Eli Manning2008NYG479102.092.83-0.74-4
432Warren Moon1988HOU29482.723.93-1.21-4
433Randall Cunningham1990PHI465132.83.56-0.76-4
434Norm Van Brocklin1955RAM272155.516.82-1.3-4
435Daryle Lamonica1970OAK356154.215.2-0.99-4
436Drew Bledsoe1995NWE636162.523.07-0.55-4
437Carson Palmer2006CIN520132.53.18-0.68-4
438Ben Roethlisberger2009PIT506122.373.06-0.69-3
439Dan Fouts1982SDG330113.334.39-1.06-3
440Babe Parilli1964BOS473275.716.45-0.74-3
441Craig Morton1975NYG363164.415.37-0.96-3
442Frankie Albert1949SFO260166.157.49-1.33-3
443Richard Todd1982NYJ26183.074.39-1.33-3
444Chris Chandler1997ATL34272.053.06-1.01-3
445John Hadl1967SDG427225.155.96-0.81-3
446George Blanda1953CHI362236.357.3-0.95-3
447Archie Manning1980NOR509203.934.6-0.67-3
448Kerry Collins1996CAR36492.473.41-0.94-3
449Rich Gannon1999OAK515142.723.38-0.66-3
450Bud Schwenk1947BCL327206.127.16-1.04-3
451Earl Morrall1965NYG302123.975.1-1.13-3
452Jim Everett1995NOR567142.473.07-0.6-3
453Bernie Kosar1985CLE24872.824.19-1.37-3
454Jack Kemp1963BUF384205.216.09-0.88-3
455Matthew Stafford2011DET663162.412.92-0.51-3
456Ron Jaworski1984PHI427143.284.07-0.79-3
457Gary Cuozzo1970MIN257103.895.2-1.31-3
458Drew Bledsoe2003BUF471122.553.26-0.72-3
459Rich Gannon2003OAK22541.783.26-1.49-3
460Joe Montana1986SFO30792.934.02-1.09-3
461Sam Bradford2013STL26241.532.79-1.26-3
462Jim Kelly1990BUF34692.63.56-0.95-3
463Shane Matthews1999CHI27562.183.38-1.2-3
464Joe Flacco2009BAL499122.43.06-0.66-3
465Jim Miller2001CHI395102.533.36-0.83-3
466Bubby Brister1989PIT342102.923.88-0.96-3
467Mike Livingston1976KAN338133.854.81-0.96-3
468Matthew Stafford2014DET602121.992.53-0.54-3
469Don Majkowski1989GNB599203.343.88-0.54-3
470Peyton Manning2010IND679172.52.97-0.47-3
471Ray Lucas1999NYJ27262.213.38-1.17-3
472Steve McNair1999TEN33182.423.38-0.96-3
473Jack Trudeau1987IND22962.624.01-1.39-3
474Derek Carr2014OAK5991222.53-0.53-3
475Bernie Kosar1988CLE25972.73.93-1.22-3
476Johnny Green1960BUF228104.395.77-1.39-3
477Len Dawson1965KAN305144.595.62-1.03-3
478Neil O'Donnell1992PIT31392.883.88-1-3
479Aaron Rodgers2010GNB475112.322.97-0.66-3
480Jim Everett1989RAM518173.283.88-0.6-3
481Dan Fouts1980SDG589244.074.6-0.53-3
482Philip Rivers2010SDG541132.42.97-0.57-3
483Charlie Conerly1949NYG305206.567.57-1.01-3
484Kerry Collins2001NYG568162.823.36-0.54-3
485Paul Christman1946CRD229187.869.2-1.34-3
486Billy Kilmer1973WAS22793.965.32-1.36-3
487Neil O'Donnell1991PIT28672.453.52-1.07-3
488Daryle Lamonica1972OAK281124.275.36-1.09-3
489Jim Plunkett1971NWE328164.885.81-0.93-3
490Joe Theismann1978WAS390184.625.4-0.78-3
491Josh McCown2004ARI408102.453.2-0.75-3
492Norm Van Brocklin1958PHI374205.356.16-0.81-3
493Archie Manning1972NOR448214.695.36-0.67-3
494Peyton Manning1999IND533152.813.38-0.56-3
495Jim Plunkett1973NWE376174.525.32-0.8-3
496Jack Jacobs1947GNB242177.028.26-1.24-3
497Steve Walsh1991NOR25562.353.52-1.17-3
498Joey Harrington2007ATL34882.33.15-0.86-3
499Joe Montana1987SFO398133.274.01-0.74-3
500Steve Spurrier1976TAM311123.864.81-0.95-3
501Rob Johnson2000BUF30672.293.25-0.96-3
502Ryan Tannehill2014MIA590122.032.53-0.5-3
503Troy Aikman1999DAL442122.713.38-0.66-3
504Doug Williams1988WAS380123.163.93-0.77-3
505Kurt Warner2008ARI598142.342.83-0.48-3
506Dan Pastorini1974HOU247104.055.22-1.17-3
507Mark Brunell2001JAX473132.753.36-0.61-3
508Y.A. Tittle1953SFO259166.187.29-1.11-3
509Jay Schroeder1990RAI33492.693.55-0.86-3
510Paul Christman1947CRD301227.318.26-0.95-3
511Brett Favre2000GNB580162.763.25-0.49-3
512Dan Pastorini1978HOU368174.625.39-0.78-3
513Steve McNair2006BAL468122.563.17-0.61-3
514Bob Berry1972ATL277124.335.36-1.03-3
515Jake Plummer2003DEN30272.323.26-0.94-3
516Troy Aikman1996DAL465132.83.41-0.61-3
517Matt Schaub2009HOU583152.573.06-0.49-3
518Chad Pennington2004NYJ37092.433.2-0.76-3
519Steve Walsh1994CHI34382.333.15-0.82-3
520David Archer1986ATL29493.064.02-0.95-3
521Tony Banks1999BAL32082.53.38-0.88-3
522Matt Hasselbeck2002SEA419102.393.06-0.67-3
523Trent Green2000STL24052.083.25-1.17-3
524Joe Ferguson1978BUF330154.555.39-0.85-3
525Jim Harbaugh1996IND405112.723.41-0.69-3
526Bobby Hebert1987NOR29493.064.01-0.95-3
527Matt Hasselbeck2001SEA32182.493.36-0.87-3
528Troy Aikman1991DAL363102.753.52-0.76-3
529Jim McMahon1993MIN33182.423.25-0.84-3
530Mark Malone1985PIT233734.19-1.18-3
531Dan Marino1985MIA567213.74.19-0.48-3
532Gus Frerotte1999DET28872.433.38-0.95-3
533Bob Celeri1951NYY238156.37.44-1.14-3
534John Hadl1973RAM258114.265.32-1.05-3
535Dan Marino1998MIA537152.793.3-0.51-3
536Steve Fuller1980KAN320123.754.6-0.85-3
537David Woodley1981MIA366133.554.29-0.74-3
538Steve Young1995SFO447112.463.06-0.6-3
539Steve DeBerg1984TAM509183.544.07-0.53-3
540Chris Simms2005TAM31372.243.1-0.86-3
541Joe Montana1993KAN29872.353.25-0.9-3
542Fran Tarkenton1966MIN358164.475.22-0.75-3
543Jeff Blake1997CIN31772.213.05-0.85-3
544Akili Smith2000CIN26762.253.25-1-3
545John Brodie1964SFO392164.084.76-0.68-3
546Mark Brunell1998JAX35492.543.3-0.76-3
547Jim Everett1990RAM554173.073.55-0.48-3
548Carson Palmer2014ARI22431.342.53-1.19-3
549Jake Delhomme2006CAR431112.553.17-0.62-3
550Neil O'Donnell1994PIT37092.433.15-0.72-3
551Marc Wilson1987RAI26683.014.01-1-3
552Tom Flores1966OAK306144.585.44-0.87-3
553Kerry Collins2002NYG545142.573.05-0.49-3
554Roger Staubach1975DAL348164.65.36-0.76-3
555Mark Brunell2000JAX512142.733.25-0.52-3
556Billy Wade1961CHI250135.26.26-1.06-3
557Mike Livingston1978KAN290134.485.39-0.91-3
558Gary Cuozzo1967NOR260124.625.63-1.01-3
559Kent Graham1997ARI250523.05-1.05-3
560Charley Johnson1963STL423214.965.58-0.62-3
561Kurt Warner2005ARI37592.43.1-0.7-3
562John Elway1995DEN542142.583.06-0.48-3
563Charley Johnson1970HOU281124.275.19-0.92-3
564John Hadl1964SDG274155.476.42-0.95-3
565Mike Glennon2013TAM41692.162.79-0.62-3
566Craig Erickson1994TAM399102.513.15-0.64-3
567Drew Brees2007NOR652182.763.15-0.39-3
568Billy Kilmer1975WAS346164.625.36-0.73-3
569Sam Bradford2010STL590152.542.97-0.43-3
570Matt Schaub2011HOU29262.052.92-0.86-3
571Colt McCoy2011CLE463112.382.92-0.54-3
572Don Meredith1965DAL305134.265.08-0.82-3
573Tom Flores1960OAK252124.765.76-0.99-3
574Philip Rivers2008SDG478112.32.82-0.52-2
575Steve McNair2001TEN431122.783.36-0.57-2
576Joe Montana1990SFO520163.083.55-0.47-2
577Doug Williams1982TAM307113.584.38-0.8-2
578Bart Starr1961GNB295165.426.25-0.83-2
579Randall Cunningham1994PHI490132.653.15-0.5-2
580Jim Zorn1980SEA488204.14.6-0.5-2
581Tony Banks2001WAS370102.73.36-0.65-2
582Tom Brady2005NWE530142.643.09-0.45-2
583JaMarcus Russell2008OAK36882.172.82-0.65-2
584Matt Schaub2012HOU544122.212.64-0.44-2
585Dan Marino1994MIA615172.763.15-0.38-2
586Russell Wilson2013SEA40792.212.79-0.57-2
587Steve Beuerlein1988RAI23872.943.92-0.98-2
588Dick Wood1963NYJ352195.46.06-0.66-2
589Len Dawson1963KAN352195.46.06-0.66-2
590Johnny Unitas1965BAL282124.265.08-0.82-2
591Kent Graham1996ARI27472.553.4-0.85-2
592Jim McMahon1989SDG318103.143.87-0.73-2
593John Elway1985DEN605233.84.18-0.38-2
594Dan Pastorini1975HOU342164.685.35-0.68-2
595Phil Simms1987NYG28293.194-0.81-2
596Roman Gabriel1972RAM323154.645.35-0.71-2
597Gus Frerotte2005MIA494132.633.09-0.46-2
598Dieter Brock1985RAM365133.564.18-0.62-2
599Steve Tensi1967DEN325175.235.93-0.7-2
600Jim Everett1988RAM517183.483.92-0.44-2
601Ben Roethlisberger2013PIT584142.42.79-0.39-2
602Stan Humphries1994SDG453122.653.15-0.5-2
603Dave Krieg1985SEA532203.764.18-0.42-2
604Jim Kelly1986BUF480173.544.01-0.47-2
605Johnny Unitas1961BAL420245.716.25-0.53-2
606Matt Ryan2012ATL615142.282.64-0.36-2
607Joe Ferguson1977BUF457245.255.74-0.49-2
608Dan Fouts1976SDG359154.184.8-0.62-2
609Brooks Bollinger2005NYJ26662.263.09-0.84-2
610Ken Anderson1976CIN338144.144.8-0.66-2
611Peyton Manning2007IND515142.723.15-0.43-2
612Otto Graham1952CLE364246.597.2-0.61-2
613Matthew Stafford2012DET727172.342.64-0.3-2
614Fran Tarkenton1967NYG377195.045.62-0.58-2
615Frankie Albert1947SFO242156.27.1-0.9-2
616Archie Manning1973NOR267124.495.31-0.82-2
617Don Majkowski1988GNB336113.273.92-0.65-2
618Joe Ferguson1980BUF439184.14.59-0.49-2
619Jay Cutler2011CHI31472.232.92-0.69-2
620Y.A. Tittle1962NYG375205.335.91-0.58-2
621David Klingler1993CIN34392.623.25-0.62-2
622Jason Campbell2007WAS417112.643.15-0.51-2
623Greg Landry1971DET261134.985.8-0.82-2
624Aaron Rodgers2008GNB536132.432.82-0.4-2
625John Friesz1991SDG487153.083.51-0.43-2
626Craig Morton1981DEN376143.724.28-0.56-2
627Charlie Batch1999DET27072.593.37-0.78-2
628Brett Favre2001GNB510152.943.35-0.41-2
629Bobby Thomason1953PHI304206.587.27-0.69-2
630Karl Sweetan1966DET309144.535.21-0.68-2
631Jim McMahon1985CHI313113.514.18-0.67-2
632David Garrard2008JAX535132.432.82-0.39-2
633Colin Kaepernick2014SFO478102.092.53-0.44-2
634David Carr2005HOU423112.63.09-0.49-2
635Norm Van Brocklin1960PHI284175.996.72-0.73-2
636Aaron Rodgers2013GNB29062.072.78-0.72-2
637Sonny Jurgensen1965WAS356164.495.07-0.58-2
638John Brodie1969SFO347154.324.92-0.59-2
639Bert Jones1974BAL270124.445.21-0.76-2
640Tommy Kramer1979MIN566244.244.6-0.36-2
641Andy Dalton2011CIN516132.522.92-0.4-2
642Mark Sanchez2010NYJ507132.562.97-0.4-2
643Donovan McNabb2005PHI35792.523.09-0.57-2
644Joe Theismann1982WAS25293.574.37-0.8-2
645Wade Wilson1989MIN362123.313.87-0.56-2
646Warren Moon1991HOU655213.213.51-0.31-2
647Jake Delhomme2004CAR533152.813.19-0.38-2
648Joe Flacco2014BAL554122.172.53-0.36-2
649David Carr2006HOU442122.713.17-0.45-2
650Nick Foles2012PHI26551.892.64-0.75-2
651Vinny Testaverde1995CLE392102.553.06-0.51-2
652Tony Romo2014DAL43592.072.53-0.46-2
653Dan Marino1986MIA623233.694.01-0.32-2
654Jack Concannon1970CHI385184.685.19-0.51-2
655Sonny Jurgensen1961PHI416245.776.24-0.47-2
656Patrick Ramsey2003WAS33792.673.25-0.58-2
657John Hadl1970SDG327154.595.19-0.6-2
658John Brodie1962SFO304165.265.9-0.64-2
659Bud Schwenk1942CRD295279.159.81-0.66-2
660Tom Flores1963OAK247135.266.05-0.78-2
661Bill Kenney1987KAN27393.34-0.7-2
662Jon Kitna2003CIN520152.883.25-0.37-2
663Gary Danielson1978DET351174.845.39-0.54-2
664Tim Tebow2011DEN27162.212.92-0.7-2
665Steve Bono1996KAN438132.973.4-0.43-2
666George Blanda1954CHI281176.056.72-0.67-2
667Steve Bartkowski1978ATL369184.885.39-0.51-2
668Matt Ryan2014ATL628142.232.53-0.3-2
669Terry Bradshaw1981PIT370143.784.28-0.5-2
670Tony Banks1997STL487132.673.05-0.38-2
671Jim Harbaugh1992CHI358123.353.87-0.51-2
672Tom Brady2001NWE413122.913.35-0.45-2
673John Elway1996DEN4661433.4-0.4-2
674Brett Favre2007GNB535152.83.15-0.34-2
675Drew Bledsoe1998NWE481142.913.29-0.38-2
676Elvis Grbac1999KAN499153.013.37-0.36-2
677Danny White1985DAL450173.784.18-0.4-2
678Boomer Esiason1986CIN469173.624.01-0.38-2
679Steve Young1991SFO27982.873.51-0.64-2
680Brad Johnson1997MIN452122.653.05-0.39-2
681Jason Campbell2010OAK32982.432.97-0.53-2
682Chris Miller1988ATL351123.423.92-0.5-2
683John Elway1998DEN356102.813.29-0.48-2
684Ben Roethlisberger2007PIT404112.723.15-0.42-2
685Matt Hasselbeck2003SEA513152.923.25-0.33-2
686Phil Simms1989NYG405143.463.87-0.41-2
687Kurt Warner2009ARI513142.733.05-0.32-2
688Bob Griese1978MIA235114.685.38-0.7-2
689Gary Danielson1984DET410153.664.06-0.4-2
690Jeff Garcia1999SFO375112.933.37-0.44-2
691Bobby Layne1951DET332236.937.42-0.49-2
692Rodney Peete1990DET27182.953.54-0.59-2
693Norm Snead1965PHI288134.515.07-0.55-2
694Ron Jaworski1983PHI446184.044.39-0.35-2
695Bob Griese1967MIA331185.445.91-0.47-2
696John Hadl19742TM299144.685.2-0.52-2
697Mark Brunell2004WAS23762.533.19-0.66-2
698Steve Young1986TAM363133.584.01-0.43-2
699Marc Bulger2009STL24762.433.05-0.62-2
700Jim Finks1954PIT306196.216.71-0.5-2
701Eli Manning2009NYG509142.753.05-0.3-2
702Sam Bradford2012STL551132.362.64-0.28-2
703Fran Tarkenton1963MIN297155.055.56-0.51-2
704Billy Wade1964CHI327144.284.74-0.46-2
705Mark Rypien1992WAS479173.553.86-0.32-2
706Scott Mitchell1997DET509142.753.05-0.3-2
707Ryan Fitzpatrick2008CIN37292.422.82-0.4-1
708Marc Bulger2004STL485142.893.19-0.3-1
709Johnny Lujack1949CHI312227.057.52-0.47-1
710Cotton Davidson1964OAK320195.946.39-0.45-1
711Tommy Kramer1982MIN308123.94.37-0.47-1
712Bill Kenney1984KAN282103.554.06-0.51-1
713Ty Detmer1997PHI24462.463.05-0.59-1
714Mike Pagel1985IND393153.824.18-0.36-1
715Peyton Manning2009IND571162.83.05-0.25-1
716Norm Snead1964PHI283124.244.74-0.5-1
717Brett Favre2006GNB613182.943.16-0.23-1
718Tommy Kramer1981MIN593244.054.28-0.23-1
719Bruce Gradkowski2006TAM32892.743.16-0.42-1
720Billy Volek2004TEN357102.83.19-0.39-1
721Kordell Stewart2000PIT28982.773.24-0.47-1
722Norm Snead1961WAS375225.876.23-0.37-1
723Warren Moon1992HOU346123.473.86-0.39-1
724Fran Tarkenton1971NYG386215.445.79-0.35-1
725Charley Johnson1973DEN346174.915.3-0.39-1
726Bill Kenney1986KAN308113.574.01-0.43-1
727Zeke Bratkowski1961RAM230135.656.23-0.58-1
728Pete Liske1970DEN238114.625.18-0.56-1
729Blaine Gabbert2012JAX27862.162.64-0.48-1
730Jim Hart1970STL373184.835.18-0.36-1
731Trent Green2002KAN470132.773.05-0.28-1
732Johnny Unitas1960BAL378246.356.7-0.35-1
733Joe Ferguson1981BUF498204.024.28-0.26-1
734Erik Kramer1991DET26583.023.51-0.49-1
735Steve Grogan1983NWE303123.964.39-0.43-1
736Charley Johnson1965STL322154.665.06-0.4-1
737Kyle Orton2014BUF447102.242.52-0.29-1
738Aaron Brooks2004NOR542162.953.19-0.23-1
739Mike Taliaferro1969BOS331185.445.81-0.37-1
740Bobby Layne1955DET270176.36.75-0.46-1
741Steve DeBerg1991KAN434143.233.51-0.28-1
742Frank Ryan1963CLE256135.085.56-0.48-1
743Erik Kramer1998CHI25072.83.29-0.49-1
744Joe Theismann1981WAS496204.034.28-0.25-1
745Shane Matthews2002WAS23762.533.05-0.52-1
746Brian Griese1999DEN452143.13.37-0.27-1
747Matt Ryan2008ATL434112.532.82-0.28-1
748Eric Hipple1986DET305113.614-0.4-1
749Carson Palmer2009CIN466132.793.05-0.26-1
750Boomer Esiason1988CIN388143.613.91-0.3-1
751Eli Manning2014NYG601142.332.52-0.19-1
752Mike Livingston1977KAN282155.325.73-0.41-1
753Eli Manning2011NYG589162.722.91-0.19-1
754John Brodie1968SFO404215.25.48-0.28-1
755Stan Humphries1996SDG416133.133.39-0.27-1
756Matt Moore2011MIA34792.592.91-0.32-1
757Tom Brady2004NWE474142.953.18-0.23-1
758Jeff Blake1999CIN389123.083.37-0.28-1
759Matt Ryan2013ATL651172.612.78-0.17-1
760Jim Plunkett1986RAI25293.574-0.43-1
761Kyle Orton2008CHI465122.582.81-0.23-1
762Aaron Brooks2002NOR528152.843.05-0.2-1
763Matt Hasselbeck2011TEN518142.72.91-0.21-1
764Frankie Albert1950SFO306237.527.86-0.35-1
765Drew Stanton2014ARI24052.082.52-0.44-1
766Brodie Croyle2007KAN22462.683.14-0.46-1
767Case Keenum2013HOU25362.372.78-0.41-1
768Bob Griese1976MIA272124.414.79-0.38-1
769Blaine Gabbert2011JAX413112.662.91-0.25-1
770Billy Kilmer1972WAS225114.895.34-0.45-1
771Jack Trudeau1989IND362133.593.87-0.27-1
772Jim Kelly1995BUF458132.843.05-0.22-1
773Joe Namath1967NYJ491285.75.89-0.19-1
774Chris Chandler1992PHO413153.633.86-0.23-1
775Brian Sipe1976CLE312144.494.79-0.3-1
776Tommy Kramer1980MIN522234.414.58-0.18-1
777Ben Roethlisberger2011PIT513142.732.91-0.18-1
778Jim Ninowski1960DET283186.366.69-0.33-1
779Bob Berry1970ATL269134.835.18-0.34-1
780Dave Krieg1988SEA22883.513.91-0.4-1
781Todd Blackledge1984KAN294113.744.05-0.31-1
782Steve Bartkowski1984ATL269103.724.05-0.34-1
783Vince Young2009TEN25972.73.05-0.34-1
784Drew Bledsoe1997NWE522152.873.04-0.17-1
785Carson Palmer2012OAK565142.482.63-0.16-1
786Ken Stabler1979OAK498224.424.59-0.18-1
787Tony Banks2000BAL27482.923.24-0.32-1
788Gary Hogeboom1984DAL367143.814.05-0.24-1
789Chris Chandler1995HOU356102.813.05-0.24-1
790Shaun King2000TAM428133.043.24-0.2-1
791Drew Brees2008NOR635172.682.81-0.14-1
792Stan Humphries1997SDG22562.673.04-0.38-1
793Bobby Hoying1997PHI22562.673.04-0.38-1
794David Carr2004HOU4661433.18-0.18-1
795Boomer Esiason1994NYJ440132.953.14-0.18-1
796Jason Campbell2013CLE31782.522.78-0.25-1
797Brady Quinn2009CLE25672.733.05-0.31-1
798Craig Morton1980DEN301134.324.58-0.26-1
799Dave Krieg1996CHI377123.183.39-0.21-1
800Jack Kemp1961SDG364226.046.26-0.22-1
801Jeff Blake2000NOR30292.983.24-0.26-1
802Fran Tarkenton1977MIN258145.435.73-0.3-1
803Brett Favre2002GNB551162.93.04-0.14-1
804Cam Newton2012CAR485122.472.63-0.16-1
805Jim Harbaugh1991CHI478163.353.5-0.16-1
806Vinny Testaverde2001NYJ441143.173.34-0.17-1
807Trent Dilfer1997TAM386112.853.04-0.19-1
808Norm Snead1966PHI226114.875.19-0.32-1
809Christian Ponder2012MIN483122.482.63-0.15-1
810Trent Green2004KAN556173.063.18-0.12-1
811Bobby Hebert1991NOR24883.233.5-0.28-1
812Dan Marino1988MIA606233.83.91-0.11-1
813Matt Schaub2008HOU380102.632.81-0.18-1
814Mike Tomczak1999PIT25883.13.36-0.26-1
815Jim Kelly1988BUF452173.763.91-0.15-1
816Jay Cutler2007DEN4671433.14-0.14-1
817Robert Griffin2013WAS456122.632.78-0.14-1
818Jay Schroeder1987WAS267103.753.99-0.25-1
819Phil Simms1985NYG495204.044.17-0.13-1
820Jon Kitna1999SEA495163.233.36-0.13-1
821George Blanda1961HOU362226.086.26-0.18-1
822David Whitehurst1978GNB328175.185.38-0.19-1
823Doug Flutie1998BUF354113.113.28-0.18-1
824Billy Kilmer1969NOR360174.724.89-0.17-1
825Ty Detmer1996PHI401133.243.39-0.15-1
826Jeff Blake1994CIN30692.943.14-0.2-1
827Jim Harbaugh1999SDG434143.233.36-0.14-1
828Babe Parilli1966BOS382205.245.39-0.15-1
829Stan Humphries1995SDG478142.933.05-0.12-1
830Ted Marchibroda1956PIT275196.917.11-0.2-1
831Jim Miller2002CHI31492.873.04-0.18-1
832Pete Liske1971PHI269155.585.78-0.2-1
833Bobby Layne1952DET287206.977.16-0.19-1
834Brad Johnson1996MIN311103.223.39-0.18-1
835Billy Joe Tolliver1994HOU24072.923.14-0.22-1
836Trent Edwards2008BUF374102.672.81-0.14-1
837Frank Tripucka1961DEN344216.16.25-0.15-1
838Erik Kramer1997CHI477142.943.04-0.1-1
839Stan Humphries1993SDG324103.093.24-0.150
840Dan Fouts1978SDG381205.255.37-0.130
841Warren Moon1998SEA25883.13.28-0.180
842Jay Schroeder1994ARI23872.943.14-0.20
843Bubby Brister1988PIT370143.783.91-0.120
844Ron Jaworski1982PHI286124.24.35-0.160
845Trent Edwards2007BUF26982.973.14-0.170
846Jason Campbell2009WAS507152.963.05-0.090
847Pete Beathard1969HOU370215.685.79-0.120
848Ken O'Brien1989NYJ477183.773.86-0.090
849Tim Couch1999CLE399133.263.36-0.10
850Drew Brees2005SDG5001533.08-0.080
851Steve Bartkowski1982ATL262114.24.35-0.160
852Fran Tarkenton1961MIN280176.076.21-0.140
853George Blanda1963HOU423255.916-0.090
854John Elway1984DEN380153.954.05-0.10
855John Elway1988DEN496193.833.91-0.080
856Danny White1983DAL533234.324.38-0.070
857Russell Wilson2012SEA393102.542.63-0.090
858Bobby Layne1956DET244176.977.1-0.140
859Tim Rattay2004SFO325103.083.18-0.10
860Earl Morrall1968BAL317175.365.47-0.10
861Dan Fouts1979SDG530244.534.59-0.060
862Mark Rypien1993WAS319103.133.23-0.10
863Jim Hart1977STL355205.635.72-0.090
864Jim Everett1992RAM475183.793.86-0.070
865Shaun Hill2010DET416122.882.96-0.070
866Jeff Blake1995CIN5671733.05-0.050
867Bobby Hebert1992NOR422163.793.85-0.060
868Norm Snead1967PHI434245.535.59-0.060
869Mike Phipps1972CLE305165.255.33-0.080
870Dan Pastorini1977HOU319185.645.72-0.080
871Kerry Collins2010TEN27882.882.96-0.080
872Kerry Collins2003NYG500163.23.24-0.040
873Gus Frerotte1997WAS402122.993.04-0.050
874Billy Kilmer1968NOR315175.45.46-0.070
875James Harris1975RAM285155.265.33-0.070
876Jim Plunkett1977SFO248145.655.72-0.080
877Billy Wade1962CHI412245.835.87-0.040
878Bart Starr1970GNB255135.15.17-0.070
879Ron Jaworski1985PHI484204.134.17-0.040
880Bill Nelsen1970CLE313165.115.17-0.060
881Steve DeBerg1988KAN414163.863.91-0.040
882Brett Favre2004GNB540173.153.18-0.030
883Eli Manning2005NYG557173.053.08-0.030
884Tobin Rote1963SDG286175.945.99-0.050
885Kerry Collins1999NYG331113.323.36-0.040
886Johnny Green1962NYT258186.987.02-0.050
887Roger Staubach1973DAL286155.245.29-0.040
888Cam Newton2013CAR473132.752.77-0.030
889Lynn Dickey1981GNB354154.244.27-0.030
890Joe Ferguson1975BUF321175.35.33-0.040
891Alex Smith2010SFO342102.922.96-0.030
892Kent Graham1999NYG27193.323.36-0.040
893John Brodie1966SFO427225.155.18-0.020
894Shaun Hill2008SFO28882.782.81-0.030
895Neil Lomax1981STL236104.244.27-0.030
896Tarvaris Jackson2011SEA450132.892.91-0.020
897Matt Schaub2007HOU28993.113.14-0.020
898Matt Hasselbeck2004SEA474153.163.18-0.010
899Doug Flutie1999BUF478163.353.36-0.010
900Rex Grossman2007CHI22573.113.14-0.030
901Cade McNown2000CHI28093.213.23-0.020
902Warren Moon1997SEA528163.033.04-0.010
903Ed Brown1963PIT362205.525.53-0.010
904Joe Ferguson1974BUF232125.175.19-0.010
905Jim Hart1971STL243145.765.77-0.010
906Peyton Manning2014DEN597152.512.5200
907Joe Flacco2008BAL428122.82.8100
908Ken Anderson1983CIN297134.384.3800
909John McCormick1965DEN253145.535.5300
910Drew Brees2002SDG526163.043.0400
911Steve McNair2002TEN492153.053.040.010
912Chad Henne2013JAX503142.782.770.010
913Rusty Hilger1988DET306123.923.90.020
914Derek Anderson2008CLE28382.832.810.020
915Bernie Kosar1990CLE423153.553.530.020
916John Reaves1972PHI224125.365.330.030
917Danny Kanell1997NYG29493.063.040.030
918Jim McMahon1983CHI295134.414.380.030
919Don Majkowski1991GNB22683.543.50.040
920Steve Ramsey1976DEN270134.814.780.040
921Matt Leinart2006ARI377123.183.150.030
922Dan Fouts1983SDG340154.414.380.030
923Sammy Baugh1948WAS315237.37.260.040
924John Hadl1971SDG431255.85.770.030
925Jim McMahon1991PHI311113.543.50.040
926Jay Fiedler2002MIA29293.083.040.040
927George Ratterman1948BUF335226.576.530.040
928Ryan Fitzpatrick2014HOU31282.562.520.050
929Chris Chandler1996HOU320113.443.390.050
930Marc Bulger2005STL28793.143.080.060
931Jimmy Clausen2010CAR29993.012.960.050
932Warren Moon1994MIN601193.163.130.030
933Tommy Maddox2003PIT519173.283.240.030
934Otto Graham1950CLE253207.917.830.070
935Danny Kanell1998NYG299103.343.280.060
936Johnny Unitas1962BAL389235.915.860.050
937Steve McNair2000TEN396133.283.230.050
938Tyler Thigpen2008KAN420122.862.810.050
939Joe Pisarcik1977NYG241145.815.720.090
940Terry Bradshaw1978PIT368205.435.370.070
941Steve Bartkowski1981ATL533234.324.270.050
942Craig Morton1969DAL302154.974.880.090
943Sam Vacanti1947CHR225167.116.990.120
944Mark Rypien1990WAS304113.623.530.090
945Ryan Tannehill2012MIA484132.692.630.060
946Chad Henne2009MIA451143.13.040.060
947Matt Ryan2009ATL451143.13.040.060
948Jeff Hostetler1995OAK28693.153.050.10
949Jim Everett1996NOR464163.453.390.060
950Kellen Clemens2013STL24272.892.770.120
951Jeff Garcia2003SFO392133.323.240.080
952Chris Miller1990ATL388143.613.530.080
953Charley Johnson1969STL2601354.880.120
954Dan Marino1995MIA482153.113.050.070
955Ron Jaworski1981PHI461204.344.270.070
956Derek Anderson2010ARI327103.062.950.10
957Bubby Brister1990PIT387143.623.530.090
958Jim Zorn1982SEA245114.494.340.150
959Dave Krieg1983SEA243114.534.380.150
960Frank Ryan1967CLE280165.715.580.130
961Jake Delhomme2008CAR414122.92.810.090
962Jeff Hostetler1996OAK402143.483.390.10
963Jay Schroeder1986WAS541224.073.990.070
964Marlin Briscoe1968DEN224135.85.620.180
965Chad Hutchinson2002DAL25083.23.040.160
966Steve McNair1997TEN415133.133.030.10
967Vinny Testaverde1996BAL549193.463.390.080
968Daryle Lamonica1969OAK426255.875.770.10
969Ken Anderson1980CIN275134.734.570.150
970Dick Shiner1968PIT304175.595.450.140
971Jim Kelly1991BUF474173.593.50.090
972Drew Brees2014NOR659172.582.510.070
973Brett Favre1997GNB513163.123.030.090
974Tommy Kramer1984MIN236104.244.040.190
975Pete Beathard19672TM231146.065.860.20
976Len Dawson1970KAN262145.345.160.180
977Scott Mitchell1993MIA23383.433.230.20
978J.P. Losman2006BUF429143.263.150.110
979Terry Bradshaw1971PIT373225.95.770.130
980Dan Fouts1987SDG364154.123.980.141
981Gus Frerotte2000DEN23283.453.230.221
982Jim Harbaugh1993CHI325113.383.230.161
983Cotton Davidson19622TM321237.177.010.161
984Andrew Luck2014IND616162.62.510.081
985Vince Ferragamo1980RAM404194.74.570.131
986EJ Manuel2013BUF30692.942.770.171
987Stan Humphries1992SDG454183.963.850.121
988Jim Hart1980STL425204.714.570.131
989Terry Bradshaw1982PIT240114.584.340.241
990Bill Munson1965RAM267145.245.030.221
991Philip Rivers2007SDG460153.263.130.131
992Bert Jones1980BAL446214.714.570.141
993Steve Grogan1979NWE423204.734.580.151
994Phil Simms1980NYG402194.734.570.151
995Doug Flutie2001SDG521183.453.340.121
996Craig Morton19742TM239135.445.180.261
997Charlie Batch2001DET341123.523.340.181
998Jim Hart1975STL345195.515.320.181
999Tony Banks1998STL408143.433.280.151
1000Warren Moon1996MIN24793.643.380.261
1001Kevin Kolb2011ARI25383.162.90.261
1002Marc Bulger2008STL440132.952.80.151
1003Mike Tomczak1991GNB23893.783.490.291
1004Daunte Culpepper2000MIN474163.383.230.151
1005Alex Smith2009SFO372123.233.040.191
1006Chris Chandler1999ATL307113.583.360.231
1007Troy Aikman1994DAL361123.323.130.21
1008Pat Haden1979RAM290144.834.580.251
1009Ryan Tannehill2013MIA588172.892.770.121
1010Chad Pennington2006NYJ485163.33.150.151
1011Dan Fouts1974SDG237135.495.180.311
1012Jay Cutler2008DEN616182.922.80.121
1013Cam Newton2014CAR448122.682.510.171
1014Vinny Testaverde1997BAL470153.193.030.161
1015Ben Roethlisberger2005PIT26893.363.080.281
1016Archie Manning1979NOR420204.764.580.181
1017Alex Van Pelt2001BUF307113.583.340.251
1018Ken O'Brien1986NYJ482204.153.990.161
1019Steve Beuerlein1998CAR343123.53.280.221
1020Kordell Stewart1999PIT275103.643.360.281
1021Dave Krieg1989SEA499204.013.850.161
1022Michael Vick2006ATL388133.353.150.21
1023Steve Beuerlein2000CAR533183.383.230.151
1024Jim Hart1968STL316185.75.450.251
1025Michael Vick2012PHI351102.852.620.221
1026Daunte Culpepper2001MIN366133.553.340.221
1027Frank Ryan1965CLE243135.355.020.331
1028Dan Marino1989MIA5502243.850.151
1029Don Meredith1964DAL323164.954.70.251
1030Anthony Wright2005BAL26693.383.070.311
1031Brian Sipe1981CLE567254.414.260.151
1032Len Dawson1974KAN235135.535.180.351
1033Dan Orlovsky2008DET25583.142.80.331
1034Chad Pennington2007NYJ26093.463.130.331
1035Ken Anderson1984CIN275124.364.040.321
1036Don Meredith1963DAL310185.815.520.291
1037Kelly Holcomb2005BUF23083.483.070.41
1038Eli Manning2012NYG536152.82.620.181
1039Trent Dilfer1998TAM429153.53.270.221
1040Gus Frerotte1995WAS396133.283.040.241
1041Jeff George1999MIN329123.653.350.291
1042Jim Everett1987RAM302134.33.980.331
1043J.P. Losman2005BUF22883.513.070.431
1044Chris Weinke2001CAR540193.523.330.181
1045Milt Plum1962DET325206.155.850.311
1046Jeff Garcia2004CLE25293.573.170.41
1047Steve Beuerlein1994ARI25593.533.130.41
1048George Ratterman1950NYY294248.167.810.351
1049Matt Cassel2009KAN493163.253.040.211
1050Mark Malone1986PIT425184.243.990.251
1051Otto Graham1954CLE240177.086.650.441
1052Peyton Manning2002IND591193.213.030.181
1053Donovan McNabb2010WAS472153.182.950.231
1054Terry Bradshaw1977PIT314196.055.710.341
1055Eric Hipple1983DET387184.654.370.281
1056Steve Young1993SFO462163.463.230.241
1057Michael Vick2005ATL387133.363.070.291
1058Eric Hipple1985DET406184.434.160.271
1059Archie Manning1981NOR232114.744.260.481
1060Patrick Ramsey2002WAS22783.523.030.491
1061Jim Everett1994NOR540183.333.130.211
1062Todd Collins1997BUF391133.323.030.31
1063Johnny Lujack1950CHI254218.277.810.461
1064Steve Walsh19902TM336133.873.520.351
1065Drew Bledsoe1993NWE429153.53.220.271
1066Mark Brunell1996JAX557203.593.380.211
1067Randy Wright1987GNB247114.453.980.481
1068Brad Johnson2006MIN439153.423.150.271
1069Philip Rivers2012SDG527152.852.620.221
1070Stan Gelbaugh1992SEA255114.313.840.471
1071Matt Cassel2011KAN26993.352.90.451
1072Tobin Rote1951GNB256207.817.340.471
1073Jeff George1990IND334133.893.520.371
1074Jim Kelly1992BUF462194.113.840.271
1075Shaun Hill2014STL22973.062.510.551
1076Ron Jaworski1977PHI346216.075.710.361
1077Jay Schroeder1992RAI253114.353.840.51
1078Bob Avellini1977CHI293186.145.710.441
1079Chris Chandler1998ATL327123.673.270.41
1080Danny White1982DAL247124.864.330.531
1081Jack Thompson1980CIN234125.134.570.561
1082Chris Chandler2000ATL331123.633.230.41
1083Norm Snead1962WAS354226.215.840.371
1084Brian Sipe1983CLE496234.644.370.271
1085Rick Mirer1993SEA486173.53.220.271
1086Fran Tarkenton1978MIN572325.595.360.241
1087Brian Griese2004TAM336123.573.170.41
1088Charley Johnson1972DEN238145.885.310.571
1089Jack Trudeau1986IND417184.323.990.331
1090Jim Plunkett1980OAK3201654.570.431
1091Bobby Layne1953DET273217.697.180.511
1092Doug Pederson1999PHI22793.963.350.611
1093Kyle Boller2007BAL275103.643.130.511
1094Billy Wade1958RAM341226.456.040.411
1095Tony Romo2008DAL450143.112.80.311
1096Jim Harbaugh1998BAL293113.753.270.481
1097Bobby Hebert1989NOR353154.253.850.41
1098David Garrard2006JAX24193.733.150.591
1099Eddie LeBaron1961DAL236166.786.180.61
1100Vince Evans1981CHI436204.594.260.331
1101Jim Plunkett1983RAI379184.754.370.381
1102Steve Bartkowski1975ATL255155.885.320.571
1103Drew Brees2012NOR670192.842.620.221
1104Johnny Unitas1970BAL321185.615.150.461
1105Matthew Stafford2013DET6341932.760.231
1106Joe Kapp1969MIN237135.494.860.621
1107Jake Delhomme2003CAR449163.563.230.331
1108Boomer Esiason1987CIN440194.323.980.342
1109George Blanda1960HOU363226.065.640.422
1110Brian Sipe1979CLE535264.864.580.282
1111Bob Griese1969MIA252166.355.740.612
1112David Carr2002HOU444153.383.030.352
1113Milt Plum1964DET287155.234.690.542
1114Billy Joe Tolliver1990SDG410163.93.520.382
1115Andrew Luck2012IND627182.872.620.252
1116Eli Manning2006NYG522183.453.150.32
1117Paul Governali19472TM252228.738.10.632
1118Vinny Testaverde1993CLE23093.913.220.692
1119Boomer Esiason1991CIN413163.873.490.392
1120Danny White1984DAL233114.724.040.692
1121Steve Ramsey1975DEN233146.015.310.692
1122Brandon Weeden2013CLE26793.372.760.612
1123Timm Rosenbach1990PHO437173.893.520.372
1124Pat Haden1981RAM267134.874.260.612
1125Jeff George1994ATL524183.443.120.312
1126Steve Fuller1979KAN270145.194.570.612
1127Ben Roethlisberger2004PIT295113.733.170.562
1128Jon Kitna2002CIN473163.383.030.352
1129Bobby Hoying1998PHI22494.023.270.752
1130Marc Wilson1990NWE265114.153.520.632
1131Drew Bledsoe2005DAL499173.413.070.342
1132Adrian Burk1954PHI231177.366.630.732
1133Kyle Orton2005CHI368133.533.070.462
1134Kyle Orton20112TM25293.572.890.682
1135Charlie Batch2000DET412153.643.220.422
1136Steve Spurrier1972SFO269165.955.310.642
1137John Brodie1971SFO387246.25.760.452
1138Dan Pastorini1973HOU290175.865.270.62
1139Dick Wood1966MIA230146.095.330.762
1140Drew Bledsoe2004BUF450163.563.170.392
1141Matt Robinson1978NYJ266166.025.360.662
1142Michael Vick2011PHI423143.312.890.412
1143Kyle Boller2003BAL22494.023.230.792
1144Vince Young2006TEN357133.643.140.52
1145Trent Dilfer2005CLE333123.63.070.532
1146David Klingler1994CIN23193.93.120.772
1147Adrian Burk1955PHI228177.466.670.792
1148Brian Griese2002DEN436153.443.030.412
1149Jeff Hostetler1994RAI455163.523.120.42
1150Bob Griese1979MIA310165.164.570.592
1151Don Meredith1967DAL255166.275.560.722
1152Michael Vick2004ATL321123.743.170.572
1153Ken Dorsey2004SFO22693.983.170.822
1154Chris Chandler2001ATL365143.843.330.512
1155Bob Avellini1978CHI264166.065.350.712
1156Bert Jones1981BAL426204.694.260.442
1157Joey Harrington2005DET330123.643.070.572
1158Phil Simms1979NYG265145.284.570.712
1159Ben Roethlisberger2008PIT469153.22.80.42
1160Austin Davis2014STL28493.172.510.662
1161Richard Todd1977NYJ265176.425.70.722
1162Joe Namath1966NYJ471275.735.330.412
1163Bill Nelsen1969CLE352195.44.850.542
1164Teddy Bridgewater2014MIN402122.992.510.482
1165Bob Griese1974MIA253155.935.170.762
1166John Hadl1965SDG348216.035.480.562
1167Steve Pelluer1986DAL378174.53.980.512
1168Curtis Painter2011IND24393.72.890.812
1169Matt Cassel2013MIN25493.542.760.782
1170John Elway1989DEN416184.333.840.482
1171Ryan Fitzpatrick2010BUF441153.42.940.462
1172Tom Tupa1991PHO315134.133.480.642
1173Billy Wade1959RAM261176.515.740.782
1174Brian Hoyer2014CLE438132.972.50.462
1175Carson Palmer2007CIN575203.483.130.352
1176Tony Romo2012DAL648192.932.620.322
1177Cam Newton2011CAR517173.292.890.42
1178Archie Manning1975NOR338205.925.310.612
1179Charley Johnson1962STL308206.495.830.672
1180Bobby Douglass1971CHI225156.675.750.912
1181Jeff Blake2002BAL295113.733.030.72
1182Dave Krieg1991SEA285124.213.480.732
1183Bob Waterfield1949RAM296248.117.410.72
1184Steve Pelluer1988DAL435194.373.890.482
1185Daryle Lamonica1971OAK242166.615.750.862
1186David Woodley1980MIA327175.24.560.642
1187Craig Morton1979DEN370195.144.570.562
1188Bob Avellini1976CHI271155.544.760.782
1189Alex Smith2006SFO442163.623.140.482
1190Jake Plummer1998ARI547203.663.270.392
1191Cade McNown1999CHI235104.263.350.912
1192Dan Fouts1985SDG430204.654.150.52
1193Browning Nagle1992NYJ387174.393.840.562
1194Jack Kemp1960LAC406256.165.620.532
1195Andy Dalton2012CIN528163.032.620.412
1196Kellen Clemens2007NYJ2501043.120.882
1197Jay Cutler2013CHI355123.382.760.622
1198Nick Foles2014PHI311103.222.50.712
1199Matt Hasselbeck2009SEA488173.483.030.452
1200Kelly Holcomb2003CLE302123.973.230.742
1201Scott Mitchell1996DET437173.893.370.522
1202John Hadl1975GNB353215.955.310.642
1203Vinny Testaverde1992TAM358164.473.840.632
1204Cody Carlson1992HOU227114.853.841.012
1205Mark Sanchez2011NYJ543183.312.890.422
1206Rich Gannon1992MIN279134.663.840.822
1207Mike Boryla1976PHI246145.694.760.932
1208Jack Kemp1969BUF344226.45.720.672
1209Ryan Fitzpatrick2013TEN350123.432.760.672
1210Steve DeBerg1980SFO321175.34.560.742
1211Mike Phipps1975CLE313196.075.310.762
1212Gary Huff1974CHI283176.015.160.852
1213Patrick Ramsey2004WAS272114.043.160.882
1214Christian Ponder2013MIN23993.772.761.012
1215Josh Freeman2012TAM558173.052.610.432
1216Chad Pennington2003NYJ297124.043.230.812
1217Tony Romo2006DAL337133.863.140.722
1218Mark Malone1988SDG272134.783.890.892
1219Lynn Dickey1976GNB243145.764.751.012
1220Elvis Grbac2001BAL467183.853.320.532
1221Rodney Peete2002CAR381143.673.030.652
1222Jon Kitna2007DET561203.573.120.442
1223Dick Wood1964NYJ358256.986.290.72
1224Jay Fiedler2000MIA357143.923.220.73
1225Byron Leftwich2003JAX418163.833.230.63
1226Pat Ryan1984NYJ285144.914.030.883
1227Wade Wilson1987MIN264134.923.970.963
1228Wade Wilson1993NOR388153.873.220.653
1229Archie Manning1974NOR261166.135.160.973
1230Derek Anderson2007CLE527193.613.120.483
1231Jack Thompson1983TAM423214.964.360.63
1232Boomer Esiason1996ARI339144.133.370.763
1233Tony Banks1996STL368154.083.370.73
1234Brad Johnson2003TAM570213.683.230.463
1235Rodney Peete1995PHI375143.733.030.73
1236Damon Huard2007KAN332133.923.120.793
1237Danny White1987DAL362174.73.970.733
1238Steve DeBerg1985TAM370184.864.150.713
1239Steve Bartkowski1979ATL380205.264.570.73
1240Jon Kitna2010DAL318123.772.940.833
1241Drew Brees2010NOR658223.342.940.43
1242Jay Cutler2012CHI434143.232.610.613
1243Cotton Davidson1961DTX330236.976.160.813
1244Jake Delhomme2005CAR435163.683.060.613
1245Terry Bradshaw1980PIT424225.194.560.633
1246Jon Kitna2001CIN581223.793.320.463
1247Mike Pagel1983BAL328175.184.360.823
1248Steve DeBerg19932TM227104.413.211.193
1249John Elway1983DEN259145.414.361.053
1250Chris Miller1995STL405153.73.030.673
1251Josh McCown2005ARI270114.073.061.013
1252Don Majkowski1990GNB264124.553.511.033
1253Jim Hart1979STL378205.294.570.733
1254Trent Dilfer1996TAM482193.943.370.573
1255Babe Parilli1965BOS426266.15.460.653
1256Carson Palmer2010CIN586203.412.940.473
1257Vince Ferragamo1983RAM464234.964.360.63
1258Tony Romo2007DAL520193.653.120.533
1259Norm Snead1970PHI335205.975.140.833
1260Jake Locker2012TEN314113.52.610.893
1261Ryan Fitzpatrick2012BUF505163.172.610.563
1262Jim Ninowski1961DET247187.296.151.143
1263Greg Landry1972DET268176.345.31.053
1264Joey Harrington2006MIA388153.873.140.733
1265Tarvaris Jackson2007MIN294124.083.120.963
1266Trent Dilfer1999TAM244114.513.341.173
1267Dave Wilson1985NOR293155.124.150.973
1268Craig Whelihan1997SDG237104.223.021.23
1269Lynn Dickey1984GNB401194.744.030.713
1270Joe Ferguson1983BUF508254.924.360.563
1271Jay Fiedler2003MIA314134.143.230.923
1272Jim Kelly1993BUF470183.833.210.623
1273Kurt Warner2007ARI451173.773.120.653
1274Chris Chandler1988IND233125.153.881.273
1275Chad Henne2012JAX308113.572.610.963
1276Jim Everett1991RAM490204.083.480.63
1277Drew Bledsoe1999NWE539213.93.340.553
1278Jim Kelly1989BUF391184.63.840.773
1279Bob Berry1971ATL226167.085.741.343
1280Kyle Boller2005BAL293124.13.061.033
1281Joey Harrington2002DET429163.733.020.713
1282Al Dorow1961NYT438306.856.150.73
1283Jim Kelly1994BUF448173.793.110.683
1284Craig Morton1972DAL339216.195.290.93
1285Jake Plummer2006DEN317134.13.140.963
1286Jay Schroeder1988RAI256135.083.881.23
1287Kordell Stewart1998PIT458183.933.260.673
1288Rick Mirer1996SEA265124.533.371.163
1289Norm Van Brocklin1957RAM265217.926.761.163
1290Bob Gagliano1989DET232125.173.841.343
1291Brett Favre1999GNB595233.873.340.523
1292Ryan Fitzpatrick2009BUF227104.413.021.383
1293Eric Hipple1981DET279155.384.251.133
1294Joe Ferguson1984BUF344174.944.020.923
1295Paul McDonald1984CLE493234.674.020.643
1296Jeff Blake2003ARI367154.093.220.863
1297Jim Finks1955PIT344267.566.630.933
1298Ken Stabler1976OAK291175.844.751.093
1299Bobby Hebert1993ATL430173.953.210.743
1300Philip Rivers2011SDG582203.442.890.553
1301Jim Everett1993RAM274124.383.211.173
1302Marc Bulger2007STL378153.973.120.853
1303Boomer Esiason1995NYJ389153.863.030.833
1304Dan Pastorini1979HOU324185.564.560.993
1305Lynn Dickey1980GNB478255.234.550.683
1306Brad Johnson2000WAS365154.113.210.93
1307George Ratterman1947BUF244208.26.851.343
1308Mark Sanchez2014PHI309113.562.51.063
1309Jeff George1992IND306154.93.831.073
1310Ken Stabler1977OAK294206.85.681.123
1311George Shaw1955BAL237198.026.631.393
1312Jay Cutler2010CHI432163.72.940.773
1313David Whitehurst1979GNB322185.594.561.033
1314Jon Kitna2006DET596223.693.130.563
1315Vince Evans1980CHI278165.764.551.23
1316Scott Mitchell1994DET246114.473.111.363
1317Dennis Shaw1972BUF258176.595.291.33
1318Dave Krieg1987SEA294155.13.961.143
1319Matt Hasselbeck2006SEA371154.043.130.913
1320Warren Moon1985HOU377195.044.140.893
1321Charlie Conerly1953NYG303258.257.141.123
1322Joe Namath1974NYJ361226.095.150.943
1323Phil Simms1986NYG468224.73.970.733
1324Jacky Lee1964DEN265207.556.261.293
1325Dave Wilson1986NOR342174.973.9713
1326Warren Moon1987HOU368184.893.960.933
1327Richard Todd1983NYJ518265.024.350.663
1328Randy Wright1986GNB492234.673.970.73
1329Marc Wilson1981OAK366195.194.250.953
1330Tom Sherman1968BOS226167.085.551.533
1331Tommy Thompson1950PHI239229.217.751.453
1332Frank Ryan1964CLE334195.694.651.043
1333Terry Bradshaw1979PIT472255.34.560.743
1334Aaron Brooks2001NOR558223.943.320.623
1335Steve Grogan1975NWE274186.575.31.273
1336Bobby Layne1962PIT233177.35.81.53
1337David Carr2003HOU295134.413.221.193
1338Kerry Collins19982TM353154.253.260.993
1339Mike Tomczak1996PIT401174.243.370.874
1340Terrelle Pryor2013OAK272114.042.751.294
1341Brandon Weeden2012CLE517173.292.610.684
1342Eli Manning2007NYG529203.783.120.664
1343Chuck Long1987DET416204.813.960.854
1344Joe Theismann1985WAS301165.324.141.174
1345Dennis Shaw1970BUF321206.235.131.14
1346Drew Brees2003SDG356154.213.220.994
1347Randy Wright1988GNB244135.333.881.454
1348Jake Plummer2004DEN521203.843.160.684
1349JaMarcus Russell2009OAK246114.473.021.454
1350Steve DeBerg1989KAN324164.943.831.114
1351Bill Nelsen1965PIT270176.34.971.334
1352Steve Beuerlein1993PHO418174.073.210.864
1353Jay Schroeder1991RAI357164.483.471.014
1354Vinny Testaverde1989TAM480224.583.830.754
1355Joe Kapp1968MIN248176.855.41.464
1356Chris Miller1991ATL413184.363.470.894
1357Steve Grogan1978NWE362236.355.341.014
1358Steve Grogan1977NWE305216.895.681.24
1359Vinny Testaverde1991TAM326154.63.471.134
1360Milt Plum1965DET308196.174.971.24
1361Scott Campbell1987ATL260145.383.961.434
1362Trent Dilfer2000BAL226114.873.211.664
1363Kordell Stewart1997PIT440173.863.010.854
1364Heath Shuler1994WAS265124.533.111.424
1365A.J. Feeley2004MIA356154.213.151.064
1366Jim Hart1981STL241145.814.241.574
1367Rich Gannon1990MIN349164.583.51.084
1368Jim Plunkett1982RAI261155.754.31.454
1369Philip Rivers2014SDG570183.162.490.664
1370Hugh Millen1991NWE409184.43.470.934
1371Kerry Collins2004OAK513203.93.150.744
1372Aaron Brooks2005NOR431173.943.060.894
1373Mike Phipps1974CLE256176.645.151.494
1374Brian Griese2007CHI262124.583.111.474
1375Geno Smith2014NYJ367133.542.491.054
1376Andy Dalton2013CIN586203.412.750.664
1377Joe Namath1972NYJ324216.485.281.24
1378Jim Plunkett1974NWE352226.255.151.14
1379Kurt Warner2001STL546224.033.320.714
1380Norm Van Brocklin1954RAM260218.086.571.54
1381Kordell Stewart2003CHI251124.783.221.564
1382Al Dorow1960NYT396266.575.570.994
1383Matt Hasselbeck2010SEA444173.832.930.94
1384Lynn Dickey1985GNB314175.414.141.274
1385Steve Grogan1989NWE261145.363.831.534
1386Jay Cutler2014CHI561183.212.490.714
1387Jake Plummer2002ARI530203.773.020.764
1388Troy Aikman1990DAL399184.513.51.014
1389Brian Griese2001DEN451194.213.320.94
1390Jay Fiedler2001MIA450194.223.310.914
1391David Archer1985ATL312175.454.141.314
1392Jim Hardy1950CRD257249.347.741.64
1393Bobby Layne1959PIT297217.075.681.394
1394Chris Miller1994RAM317144.423.111.314
1395Matt Schaub2013HOU358143.912.751.164
1396Joey Harrington2003DET554223.973.220.754
1397Doug Johnson2003ATL243124.943.221.724
1398Babe Parilli1967BOS344246.985.761.224
1399Kent Nix1967PIT268197.095.521.574
1400Babe Parilli1963BOS337247.125.861.264
1401Johnny Unitas1969BAL327206.124.821.34
1402David Garrard2010JAX366154.12.931.174
1403Mike Tomczak1989CHI306165.233.831.44
1404Dave Krieg1990SEA448204.463.50.974
1405Mike Phipps1973CLE299206.695.241.454
1406Warren Moon1993HOU520214.043.20.844
1407Andrew Walter2006OAK276134.713.131.584
1408Boomer Esiason1992CIN278155.43.821.584
1409Bill Kenney1981KAN274165.844.241.64
1410Carson Palmer2004CIN432184.173.151.024
1411Bill Nelsen1971CLE325237.085.731.354
1412Vinny Testaverde2004DAL495204.043.150.894
1413Cliff Stoudt1983PIT381215.514.351.164
1414Bob Griese1970MIA245176.945.121.824
1415Ken Stabler1983NOR311185.794.351.444
1416Jim Plunkett1976SFO243166.584.731.854
1417Ed Luther1983SDG287175.924.351.585
1418Sage Rosenfels2007HOU2401253.111.895
1419Charley Johnson1964STL420245.714.631.085
1420Bruce Mathison1985BUF228146.144.1425
1421Christian Ponder2011MIN291134.472.881.595
1422Tony Eason1985NWE299175.694.141.555
1423Tommy Maddox2002PIT377164.243.011.235
1424Chad Henne2010MIA490193.882.930.955
1425Tim Couch2002CLE443184.063.011.055
1426Joe Ferguson1982BUF264166.064.291.775
1427Dan Marino1999MIA369174.613.331.285
1428Dave Krieg1984SEA4802454.010.995
1429Charlie Frye2006CLE392174.343.131.215
1430Jim Zorn1977SEA251197.575.671.95
1431Quincy Carter2003DAL505214.163.210.945
1432Norm Snead1969PHI379236.074.811.265
1433Matt Cassel2012KAN277124.332.61.735
1434Jack Kemp1967BUF369267.055.741.35
1435Billy Kilmer1970NOR237177.175.122.065
1436Sonny Jurgensen1962PHI366267.15.771.335
1437Frank Reich1996NYJ331164.833.361.485
1438Peyton Manning2001IND547234.23.310.895
1439Marc Bulger2003STL532224.143.210.925
1440John Elway1992DEN316175.383.821.565
1441Marc Wilson1985RAI388215.414.131.285
1442Dan Fouts1986SDG430225.123.961.155
1443Rex Grossman2006CHI480204.173.121.045
1444Ken Anderson1978CIN319226.95.331.575
1445Gary Marangi1976BUF232166.94.732.175
1446Andy Dalton2014CIN481173.532.491.055
1447Tommy Kramer1985MIN506265.144.131.015
1448Gary Hogeboom1989PHO364195.223.821.45
1449Brett Favre1998GNB551234.173.250.935
1450Joe Namath1976NYJ230166.964.732.235
1451Vince Young2007TEN382174.453.111.345
1452Vince Ferragamo1985BUF287175.924.131.795
1453Randy Johnson1967ATL288217.295.511.795
1454Joe Flacco2013BAL614223.582.740.845
1455Dave Brown1994NYG350164.573.11.475
1456Blake Bortles2014JAX475173.582.491.095
1457Danny White1980DAL436255.734.541.195
1458Bill Troup1978BAL296217.095.331.775
1459Scott Brunner1983NYG386225.74.341.365
1460Vinny Testaverde1990TAM365184.933.491.445
1461Sid Luckman1947CHI323319.67.971.635
1462Rudy Bukich1966CHI309216.85.091.715
1463Dave Krieg1995ARI521214.033.021.015
1464Lamar McHan1954CRD255228.636.542.095
1465Norm Snead1968PHI291217.225.371.855
1466Trent Dilfer1995TAM415184.343.021.325
1467Marc Wilson1986RAI240156.253.962.296
1468Dan Pastorini1971HOU270217.785.712.066
1469Drew Bledsoe1994NWE691273.913.10.816
1470Troy Aikman2000DAL262145.343.22.146
1471Jon Kitna2000SEA418194.553.21.356
1472Marc Wilson1984RAI282176.034.012.026
1473Steve Grogan1976NWE302206.624.721.96
1474Mark Malone1987PIT336195.653.941.716
1475Jake Plummer2000ARI475214.423.21.226
1476Josh McCown2014TAM327144.282.481.86
1477Brett Favre2003GNB471214.463.211.256
1478Steve DeBerg1978SFO302227.285.321.966
1479Ken Stabler1981HOU285186.324.232.096
1480Kerry Collins1995CAR433194.393.011.386
1481Rodney Peete1993DET252145.563.192.366
1482Doug Williams1979TAM397246.054.541.56
1483Tim Couch2001CLE454214.633.31.326
1484Randy Johnson1966ATL295217.125.072.046
1485Fran Tarkenton1962MIN329257.65.751.856
1486John Skelton2011ARI275145.092.872.226
1487Mark Malone1984PIT272176.2542.256
1488Jake Plummer1997ARI296155.0732.076
1489Vinny Testaverde2000NYJ590254.243.21.046
1490Josh Freeman2011TAM551223.992.871.126
1491John Hadl1962SDG260249.236.842.396
1492Mark Sanchez2012NYJ453183.972.591.386
1493Jim Zorn1976SEA439276.154.721.436
1494Jeff Komlo1979DET368236.254.541.716
1495Jim Kelly1996BUF379195.013.351.666
1496George Blanda1965HOU442306.795.361.436
1497Carson Palmer2013ARI572223.852.741.116
1498Jim Plunkett1972NWE355257.045.261.796
1499Johnny Unitas1966BAL348246.95.071.836
1500Vinny Testaverde1994CLE376184.793.091.76
1501Craig Erickson1993TAM457214.63.191.416
1502Ed Brown1964PIT272196.994.592.397
1503Richard Todd1984NOR312196.0942.097
1504Daunte Culpepper2002MIN549234.1931.197
1505John Hadl1972SDG370267.035.251.777
1506Carson Palmer2011OAK328164.882.872.017
1507Craig Morton1976NYG284207.044.712.337
1508Gus Frerotte2008MIN301154.982.772.227
1509Dave Brown1996NYG398205.033.351.687
1510Ryan Fitzpatrick2011BUF569234.042.871.187
1511Warren Moon1986HOU488265.333.951.387
1512Trent Green2001KAN523244.593.31.297
1513Tobin Rote1950GNB2242410.717.673.047
1514Jeff Kemp19912TM295175.763.452.317
1515Troy Aikman1989DAL293186.143.812.337
1516Richard Todd1979NYJ334226.594.532.057
1517Rex Grossman2011WAS458204.372.871.57
1518George Blanda1966HOU271217.755.22.557
1519Kurt Warner2000STL347185.193.1927
1520Joe Pisarcik1978NYG301237.645.312.337
1521Ryan Leaf1998SDG245156.123.242.897
1522Billy Joe Tolliver1999NOR268165.973.322.657
1523Ken Stabler1980HOU457286.134.521.67
1524Brett Favre1993GNB522244.63.181.427
1525Norm Snead1963WAS363277.445.42.047
1526Brett Favre2008NYJ522224.212.761.458
1527Donald Hollas1998OAK260166.153.232.928
1528Ryan Leaf2000SDG322185.593.192.48
1529Frank Tripucka1960DEN478347.115.461.658
1530Boomer Esiason1990CIN402225.473.4728
1531Lynn Dickey1983GNB484295.994.321.678
1532John Hadl1968SDG440327.275.431.858
1533Steve Grogan1980NWE306227.194.522.678
1534Rick Mirer1995SEA391205.1232.128
1535Jim Hart1967STL397307.565.462.18
1536Richard Todd1980NYJ479306.264.521.758
1537Jake Delhomme2009CAR321185.612.992.618
1538Ben Roethlisberger2006PIT469234.93.11.88
1539Ken Stabler1978OAK406307.395.32.098
1540Brett Favre2010MIN358195.312.912.49
1541Ken Stabler1975OAK293248.195.242.959
1542Craig Whelihan1998SDG320195.943.222.719
1543Matthew Stafford2009DET377205.312.992.319
1544Bobby Hebert1996ATL488255.123.331.799
1545Geno Smith2013NYJ443214.742.722.029
1546Mark Sanchez2009NYJ364205.492.992.519
1547Y.A. Tittle1964NYG281227.834.543.299
1548Josh Freeman2009TAM290186.212.993.229
1549Eli Manning2010NYG539254.642.91.749
1550Jay Cutler2009CHI555264.682.991.79
1551Y.A. Tittle1955SFO287289.766.463.299
1552Peyton Manning1998IND575284.873.221.659
1553Dennis Shaw1971BUF291268.935.673.269
1554Jack Kemp1964BUF269269.676.093.5710
1555Kerry Collins1997CAR381215.512.982.5410
1556Norm Snead1973NYG235229.365.174.1910
1557Eddie LeBaron1960DAL2252511.116.44.7111
1558Brett Favre2005GNB607294.783.011.7611
1559Joe Namath1975NYJ326288.595.223.3711
1560Jake Plummer1999ARI381246.33.293.0111
1561Eli Manning2013NYG551274.92.712.1912
1562George Blanda1962HOU4184210.056.63.4514
1563Vinny Testaverde1988TAM466357.513.783.7317

Like I said, the significant decrease in interceptions over the years makes it impossible for a recent player to rank highly. I’m not really worried about that, because I really want to highlight efficient seasons from bygone eras.

I’ve discussed Baugh ad nauseam in these posts (and for good reason). For now, I’ll just say: hey, he’s number one again.

Steve Bartkowski was decent quarterback on some exceedingly mediocre Falcons squads. He picked up a few Pro Bowl nods, but no one put him on the level of a Fouts or Montana (or even Ken Anderson) among his contemporaries. However, he did lead the league in touchdowns (1980), completion rate (1984), and interception rate (1983) once apiece. The passing environment in 1983 was such that a quarterback would be expected to throw about 19 picks on 432 attempts. Bartkowski threw 14 fewer than expectation – good for second best all time.

Sonny Jurgensen had the misfortune of playing on some pretty awful teams. However, despite playing for more than one team, in more than one system, and with a cast of uninspiring teammates, Jurgensen consistently produced on the field. He was a contemporary of Bart Starr and Johnny Unitas, but it was he who was considered the finest pure passer of his generation. In 1967, he led the league in both pass attempts and interception percentage. That combination resulted in 13 interceptions below expectation.

Roman Gabriel is all but forgotten by most modern fans (but certainly not by loyal FP readers), but he deserves much credit for his ability to avoid throwing the ball to the wrong team. No, Gabriel’s 3.3% interception rate can’t compare with Aaron Rodgers’ 1.6% or Tom Brady’s 2.0%, but for his era, he played it about as safe as a passer can play it. Four years apart, and with two different teams, Gabriel led the NFL in interception rate and saved his teams 13 picks.

The highest ranked season of recent vintage is Damon Huard’s magical one interception campaign in 2006. It was a complete fluke, as stats like these often are, but his 0.4% interception rate still ranks number one in history (among qualifying passers, obviously).2

There are two notable passing seasons that are omitted by using a 224 attempt threshold. In 1936, Arnie Herber threw 13 interceptions on 173 passes, which is good for a 7.5% rate. That sounds pretty terrible at face value, but the rest of the league threw picks on 13.8% of their passes (it was a different age, folks). If he threw the ball to opponents at the same rate as his contemporaries, he would have tossed 24 interceptions.

Whizzer White’s 1938 offering is a different story entirely. On just 73 passes, he threw 19 interceptions. His rate of 15.9% was even bad for pre-WW2 passers. He gave the ball away at such a high rate that he produced twelve interceptions above expectation, despite his low volume. Good thing he could fall back on being a Supreme Court Justice. 3

Career Stats

This table shows the 222 careers with 1,000 or more pass attempts. You probably know how to read these things by now.

RkQuarterbackAttIntInt%LMP Int%Marg Int%Marg Int
1Roman Gabriel44981493.315.39-2.08-94
2Fran Tarkenton64672664.115.4-1.28-83
3Joe Montana53911392.583.99-1.41-76
4Tom Brady71681431.993.01-1.02-73
5Sammy Baugh29952036.788.93-2.15-65
6Ken Anderson44751603.584.92-1.35-60
7Otto Graham26261355.147.36-2.22-58
8Dan Marino83582523.023.66-0.65-54
9Donovan McNabb53741172.183.14-0.96-52
10Johnny Unitas51862534.885.79-0.91-47
11Roger Staubach29581093.685.25-1.57-46
12Sonny Jurgensen42621894.435.46-1.02-44
13Peyton Manning90492342.593.05-0.47-42
14Bart Starr31491384.385.71-1.33-42
15Aaron Rodgers3475571.642.84-1.2-42
16Y.A. Tittle43952485.646.59-0.95-42
17Mark Brunell46401082.333.22-0.9-42
18Ken O'Brien3602982.723.88-1.15-42
19Bernie Kosar3365872.593.8-1.21-41
20Neil Lomax3153902.854.14-1.29-41
21Neil O'Donnell3229682.113.31-1.2-39
22John Elway72502263.123.63-0.52-37
23Rich Gannon42061042.473.35-0.88-37
24Steve Young41491072.583.45-0.87-36
25Len Dawson37411834.895.84-0.94-35
26Jeff Garcia3676832.263.19-0.93-34
27Charlie Conerly28331675.897.02-1.12-32
28Phil Simms46471573.384-0.62-29
29Joe Theismann36021383.834.58-0.75-27
30Steve McNair45441192.623.21-0.59-27
31Bert Jones25511013.964.97-1.01-26
32Drew Brees74581942.62.94-0.34-26
33Sid Luckman16931287.569.07-1.5-25
34Ron Jaworski41171643.984.56-0.58-24
35Bill Munson1982804.045.2-1.17-23
36John Brodie44912244.995.49-0.5-23
37Randall Cunningham42891343.123.63-0.5-22
38Paul Christman1140766.678.41-1.74-20
39Norm Van Brocklin28951786.156.83-0.68-20
40Arnie Herber1051948.9410.77-1.82-19
41Matt Ryan3916912.322.81-0.48-19
42Troy Aikman47151412.993.38-0.39-18
43Jeff George39671132.853.31-0.46-18
44Doug Williams2507933.714.41-0.7-18
45Frankie Albert1564986.277.37-1.11-17
46Brad Johnson43261222.823.22-0.4-17
47Tommy Thompson14241037.238.39-1.16-16
48Bill Kenney2430863.544.21-0.67-16
49Jim Harbaugh39181172.993.4-0.41-16
50Steve Bartkowski34561444.174.62-0.45-16
51Billy Kilmer29711434.815.34-0.52-16
52Billy Wade25231345.315.93-0.62-16
53Alex Smith3149762.412.9-0.49-15
54Greg Landry23001034.485.14-0.66-15
55David Garrard2281542.373.02-0.65-15
56Steve Bono1701422.473.34-0.87-15
57Jason Campbell2518602.382.97-0.59-15
58Don Meredith23081114.815.45-0.64-15
59Jim Hart50762474.875.14-0.28-14
60Brian Sipe34391494.334.72-0.38-13
61Ben Roethlisberger49541312.642.9-0.26-13
62Joe Flacco3657902.462.81-0.35-13
63Tony Eason1564513.264.07-0.81-13
64Philip Rivers46781222.612.88-0.27-13
65Milt Plum24191275.255.77-0.52-13
66Bob Griese34291725.025.38-0.36-12
67Chad Pennington2471642.593.09-0.5-12
68Dan Fouts56042424.324.53-0.22-12
69Sam Bradford1760382.162.83-0.67-12
70Bobby Layne37002436.576.88-0.31-12
71Kent Graham1339332.463.31-0.85-11
72Tony Romo42101102.612.87-0.26-11
73Jim McMahon2573903.53.9-0.4-10
74Gary Danielson1932784.044.57-0.53-10
75Archie Manning36421734.755.03-0.28-10
76Warren Moon68232333.413.56-0.15-10
77Mike Livingston1751834.745.31-0.57-10
78Daryle Lamonica25301345.35.69-0.39-10
79Kyle Orton2712692.542.9-0.36-10
80Tom Flores1715925.365.92-0.55-9
81Colin Kaepernick1117211.882.65-0.77-9
82Byron Leftwich1605422.623.14-0.53-8
83Jim Finks1358876.417.03-0.62-8
84Drew Bledsoe67172063.073.19-0.12-8
85Gary Cuozzo1182554.655.35-0.7-8
86Pat Haden1363604.45-0.59-8
87Jim Zorn31491414.484.72-0.25-8
88Matt Hasselbeck50741482.923.07-0.15-8
89Russell Wilson1252262.082.65-0.57-7
90Michael Vick3151872.762.99-0.23-7
91Tobin Rote29071916.576.8-0.23-7
92Jeff Hostetler2338713.043.33-0.29-7
93Matt Schaub3191862.72.91-0.21-7
94Steve Fuller1066413.854.41-0.57-6
95Bobby Thomason1346906.697.1-0.41-6
96Mark Rypien2613883.373.58-0.21-6
97Earl Morrall26111425.445.65-0.21-6
98Frank Ryan21331115.25.46-0.26-6
99Trent Green37401143.053.2-0.15-6
100Marc Bulger3171932.933.11-0.17-6
101Robert Griffin1063232.162.68-0.52-5
102Doug Flutie2151683.163.4-0.24-5
103Andrew Luck1813432.372.64-0.27-5
104Jeff Blake3241993.053.2-0.15-5
105Boomer Esiason52051843.543.62-0.09-5
106Joe Ferguson45192094.624.72-0.09-4
107Craig Morton37861874.945.05-0.11-4
108George Ratterman1396966.887.16-0.28-4
109Tony Banks2356733.13.26-0.16-4
110Shaun Hill1183302.542.86-0.32-4
111John Friesz1364423.083.33-0.25-3
112Don Majkowski1905673.523.69-0.18-3
113Steve Spurrier1097534.835.11-0.28-3
114Jim Miller1046312.963.24-0.28-3
115Cotton Davidson16861026.056.21-0.16-3
116James Harris1149595.135.35-0.22-3
117Aaron Brooks2963923.13.19-0.08-2
118Steve DeBerg50242044.064.1-0.04-2
119Ryan Tannehill1662422.532.64-0.12-2
120Kerry Collins62611963.133.15-0.02-1
121Chris Miller28921023.533.56-0.03-1
122Bubby Brister2212783.533.57-0.04-1
123Bob Waterfield16171287.927.97-0.05-1
124Dick Wood1194715.956.01-0.06-1
125Matthew Stafford3099852.742.76-0.020
126Dave Krieg53111993.753.7500
127Charlie Batch1604523.243.2400
128David Carr2267713.133.1300
129Stan Humphries2516843.343.320.020
130Kurt Warner40701283.143.130.010
131Bill Nelsen19051015.35.270.031
132Jim Everett49231753.553.540.011
133Tommy Kramer36511584.334.310.021
134Steve Beuerlein33281123.373.340.031
135Mike Pagel1509634.174.120.061
136Elvis Grbac2445813.313.260.051
137Bob Berry1173645.465.340.121
138Cam Newton1923542.812.710.12
139Matt Cassel2369702.952.870.082
140Jack Kemp30731835.965.890.072
141Bobby Douglass1178645.435.250.192
142Dan Pastorini30551615.275.180.093
143Jay Schroeder28081083.853.740.113
144Charley Johnson33921815.345.250.093
145Craig Erickson1092383.483.190.293
146Tarvaris Jackson1067353.282.970.313
147Jim Kelly47791753.663.580.084
148Erik Kramer2299793.443.260.174
149John Hadl46872685.725.630.094
150Jim Ninowski1048676.395.980.414
151Steve Walsh1317503.83.450.345
152Jack Concannon1110635.685.260.425
153Daunte Culpepper31991063.313.160.155
154Danny White28471264.434.250.185
155Eric Hipple1546704.534.20.335
156Joey Harrington2538853.353.140.215
157Billy Joe Tolliver1707643.753.420.336
158Dave Brown1634583.553.180.376
159Kyle Boller1519543.553.140.426
160Scott Mitchell2346813.453.170.287
161David Woodley1300634.854.320.537
162Jack Trudeau1644694.23.770.437
163Christian Ponder1057363.412.720.687
164Gary Hogeboom1325604.533.980.557
165Chad Henne1954633.222.850.387
166Kordell Stewart2358843.563.220.348
167Gus Frerotte31061063.413.140.278
168Scott Brunner1046545.164.350.818
169Andy Dalton2111663.132.70.439
170Rudy Bukich1190746.225.450.779
171Derek Anderson1537553.582.980.69
172Frank Tripucka17451247.116.570.539
173Bobby Hebert31211243.973.670.310
174Josh Freeman2020673.322.840.4810
175Josh McCown1664593.552.960.5810
176Brian Griese2796993.543.180.3610
177Carson Palmer49061553.162.950.2110
178Jake Delhomme29321013.443.090.3611
179Jay Fiedler1717663.843.220.6311
180Rick Mirer2043763.723.190.5311
181Vince Young1304513.913.060.8511
182Pete Beathard1282846.555.660.8911
183Chris Chandler40051463.653.350.2912
184Tim Couch1714673.913.220.6812
185Wade Wilson24281024.23.720.4812
186Bob Avellini1110696.225.151.0712
187Brett Favre101693363.33.180.1212
188Dave Wilson1039555.294.111.1812
189Randy Wright1119575.093.971.1313
190Rex Grossman1562603.843.030.8113
191Rodney Peete2346923.923.330.614
192Terry Bradshaw39012105.385.020.3614
193Joe Namath37622205.855.470.3814
194Mark Malone1648814.924.010.915
195Tommy Maddox1200544.53.211.2915
196Mike Phipps179910865.120.8916
197Lamar McHan14421087.496.381.1116
198Babe Parilli33302206.616.120.4816
199Vince Evans1390745.324.071.2617
200Ed Brown19031326.945.980.9618
201Marc Wilson20811024.94.020.8818
202Jim Plunkett37011985.354.850.519
203Al Dorow1207937.716.161.5419
204Mark Sanchez2176803.682.810.8719
205Ryan Fitzpatrick29111013.472.80.6720
206Vince Ferragamo1615915.634.391.2520
207Jay Cutler38711303.362.840.5220
208George Blanda36492496.826.250.5821
209Randy Johnson12869075.281.7222
210Mike Tomczak23371064.543.580.9522
211Jake Plummer43501613.73.190.5222
212Eli Manning56091853.32.890.423
213Norm Snead43532575.95.350.5524
214Jon Kitna44421653.713.170.5424
215Eddie LeBaron17961417.856.441.4125
216Richard Todd29671615.434.540.8926
217Trent Dilfer31721294.073.180.8928
218Zeke Bratkowski14841228.225.922.334
219Ken Stabler37932225.854.870.9837
220Lynn Dickey31251795.734.531.238
221Vinny Testaverde67012673.983.370.6241
222Steve Grogan35932085.794.591.243

There are effectively three tiers at the top of this list: the Roman Gabriel tier, the Fran Tarkenton tier, and the Joe Montana and Tom Brady tier.

In his sixteen years with the Rams and Eagles, Gabriel never threw interceptions at a rate worse than average.4 Over the course of his 4,498 attempt career, he saved his teams 94 interceptions.5 Think about it like this: the formula for ANY/A values interceptions at -45 yards. That means he saved 4,230 adjusted net yards by playing it safe.

Tarkenton’s career began a year before and ended a year after Gabriel’s. He ranks a distant to his rival in marginal interceptions; however, unlike Gabriel, he didn’t sacrifice positive plays while keeping his turnovers to a minimum.

Montana and Brady are often lumped together by fan and analysts alike (I can’t imagine why). Here, they sit side by side in their own tier, far below Tarkenton, but far above Baugh. Both quarterbacks thrived in systems that emphasized their intelligence and accuracy, which led to high completion and low interception rates for both. However, let’s not forget that the two also gained yards and threw touchdowns at a higher rate than their peers as well.

I want to avoid being negative today, so I’ll wrap a negative in a positive. Ken Stabler, threw 37 interceptions more than expectation over the course of his career. However, the rest of his rate stats compare favorably to almost any passer in history. This is pure speculation, but his interceptions may be the primary reason he doesn’t currently have a bust in Canton.6

Another article, another shout out to Cecil Isbell and Ed Danowski. They don’t reach the thousand attempt threshold, but they rank very highly in marginal interceptions. In 818 attempts, Isbell threw 28 fewer picks than you’d expect. In 637 attempts, Danowski was 27 picks below expectation. Those numbers would rank 29th and 30th all time.

That’s it for me, friends. Thanks for helping me steward the site in Chase’s absence. Leave your thoughts in the comments.

  1. I thought about using standard deviations instead of just subtracting from the league average. This would be more mathematically honest, but it’s also beyond the scope of a simple data dump. []
  2. I think we can write this season off not only because of the rest of Huard’s career, but also because this performance came at the tail end of a half decade of efficient passing seasons from three different quarterbacks. []
  3. Also, White led the league in rushing yards and yards from scrimmage in 1938. It was a different time, folks. []
  4. If you check out his PFR page, you’ll see his lowest INT%+ score was 108 in 1972. []
  5. He balanced it out by throwing touchdowns at a below average rate, but we’re focusing on positives here. []
  6. I think it’s important to mention that interceptions weren’t as harmful in Stabler’s era as they are now. The dataset on which ANY/A is based comes from an era of increased offensive effectiveness when turning the ball over to the opposing offense was more dangerous than ever. Interestingly, Brian Burke’s study on a more recent dataset (limited to first downs) showed that an interception in today’s scoring environment may be worth a 60 yard penalty. []
  • sacramento gold miners

    The 1980 Falcons and Steve Bartkowski had such a frustrating end to their season, blowing a big lead at home to the Cowboys in the playoffs. Atlanta would have Philadelphia in the NFC TG had they prevailed, and the Falcons already defeated the Eagles in Philadelphia during the regular season. Too bad the Falcons abandoned those red helmets.

    • Call me crazy, but I think the end to almost ever Atlanta Falcons football season is pretty frustrating.

      • Clint

        Bartkowski could be a good case for patient QB development. Took around 6 years, but he was great from there on out. Seems like he had lousy offenses at the beginning and end, as well. Life was a bit rough without William Andrews and Alfred Jenkins. Regardless, if you have the talent and desire you should be able to eventually get there as long as those around you have the capability and belief in you to make it happen. Right? Maybe that’s too hokey.
        Everyone just develops differently.

        • sacramento gold miners

          Couldn’t agree more about patient QB development, and a case could be made many college QBs who ran spread offenses need ample time to adjust to the NFL. But everyone is less patient than they were decades ago, and rookie high draft choices don’t even consume as much of the salary cap as they once did. A young, talented QB, may have the advantage of not being a top draft pick without the expectation, and just developing out of the spotlight. There has been talk of the NFL bringing back a developmental minor league in the hopes of helping the QB position, among others.

          • What makes people think that NFL teams are less patient now than they used to be? As a Jets fan who has endured the Mark Sanchez and Geno Smith eras, I think the Jets have been pretty freakin’ patient.

  • Tom

    Bryan – these posts have been awesome. Great reads and great titles.

    Regarding Stabler and interceptions, etc., it’s true that tuturnovers, in general, just weren’t as disastrous 40 years ago as they are now. The obvious reason being that there were more of them per game; teams could almost anticipate that if they gave the ball away, they’d most likely take it back later in the game.

    I have the numbers somewhere on this, but even anecdotedly, listen to a game from the 1970’s on YouTube (yes, I do this) – the number of turnovers is hilarious, the guys calling the game sometimes don’t even get excited about it.

    • Adam

      Not only were there more turnovers, but interceptions happened deeper down the field than they do today. I wish we had play by play to prove this, but I feel reasonably certain that a high percentage of INT’s back then came on third down, and served as glorified punts.

      • Tom

        The discussion between Bradshaw and Swann/Stallworth or Stabler and Branch/Biletnikoff on a third-and-long might have been: “Just start running towards the end zone, I’ll chuck it way out there. If you don’t catch it, that’s fine, we’ll punt, but just make sure you tackle the guy if it gets picked off. Also, see if you can make it look like you were interfered with.”

        Just messing around, but yeah, I agree with you. Don’t know enough about X’s and O’s, and game strategy, etc., but I’m wondering why more teams don’t do this – maybe they do and I’m not catching it, or they’re not successful at it. Recently, it seems like the Flacco-led Ravens do it a lot…

        • Adam

          I’ve also wondered why teams don’t throw more bombs on third and long. This strategy seems especially sound in today’s game with all the ticky-tack defensive penalties being called.

          • Tom

            Yep, exactly…with the penalties I would think it would be more enticing. Or maybe field position is a lot more fluid and not quite the big deal it was back in the day? In any event, I typed in “Flacco pass interference” into Google and about 15 articles came up if you’re interested…didn’t read any, but I’m thinking some of them might go over this very topic.

      • Tom

        Just looked at some data that I had…the change is not that drastic, but substantial: from 1970 to now, turnovers in a game have dropped from around 5 to 3. The peak year was 1978 with 5.8 T/O per game.

    • Thanks, Tom.

      I think picks were less important back then for a few reasons. First, as Adam mentioned below, they did tend to come further downfield. Second, the offense’s ability to move the ball wasn’t as great as it is today, meaning that turning the ball over back then was less likely to result in an opponent scoring. The data used to derive the 45 yard interception penalty in THGOF came from the 80s, which was a more offense-oriented decade than the 70s, or even the 90s, really.

      When Brian Burke did a study a few years ago, he used more recent data and concluded that, at least on first downs, a 60 yard penalty is more appropriate. The bigger penalty is fitting for modern offenses because the original 45 yards penalty (and the new 60 yard one) is based on expected points; these days, you cede more expected points when you turn the ball over, both by losing your own and giving them to your opponent.

      I don’t have the play by play to do an expected points analysis for the 70s or earlier, but I think it is reasonable to assume that, given the harsher offensive environment back then, the EP swing from a turnover would be much lower and result in a concomitant decrease in the interception penalty. This is just a theory; I could be wrong (I often am).

  • Adam

    I wonder if Roman Gabriel’s INT avoidance was actually suboptimal for his teams. It’s impossible to know how many big plays he left on the table due to his conservative play, but I’m betting it was a significant number. Tarkenton’s INT rate is more impressive for exactly the reason you mentioned.

    • sacramento gold miners

      Gabriel was one of those QBs with a sudden decline, his age 33 season with the Eagles was impressive. I do remember Gabriel resurfacing with the Rams in 1977, but Pro Football Reference doesn’t have a record of this.

    • LightsOut85

      It’s hard to knock Aaron Rodgers, but I’ve heard similar arguments regarding him (& his record when games are close – not taking enough chances).

      • Adam

        I do think Rodgers would be better served throwing more INTs and taking fewer sacks, but his Y/A and TD% are so high that it probably doesn’t matter.

        • LightsOut85

          Agreed. If it ain’t broke…

    • I don’t know if there’s an equilibrium, but Rodgers seems to have found it.

  • Steve Bartkowski may have been good. But his son Chuck is even better.

    Couldn’t resist the “Chuck” reference. And I agree with Tom. I’ve really been enjoying these posts. A little surprised to see Manning where he is. I guess he does have a tendency to make poor throws on the rare occasions he doesn’t get rid of the ball really quickly.

    • Jamie

      A big reason Manning is so low is his rookie year and his 2001 season with the worst defense in the league. He had +9 and +5 INTs over expectation in those two seasons. Remove those and he bumps up to -56, which would put him at 8th on the list.

    • I think Manning is one of the only QBs who could end up ranked 13th, surrounded by all time greats, and still seem like he is rated too low. Keep in mind he was still well above average at avoiding interceptions, and unlike Gabriel, he didn’t have to sacrifice Y/A, TD%, or sacks in order to get there. I remember Dungy saying that one of the primary things he had to teach Manning when he took over for the Colts was not to feel like he had to win the game all by himself. It may be anecdotal, but it does seem that once Dungy imparted that wisdom, Manning never fell below average in Int% again.

  • John

    I didn’t know mcnabb had such a low interception percentage. It’s crazy because for most of his prime he was playing with terrible receivers

    • LightsOut85

      I remember reading (roughly, this was a while ago), that it’s largely due to the way QBs were coached in PHI (under Reid) – to throw more towards the ground/feet, so if it’s INC there’s a bigger chance it’ll be a harmless INC rather than an INT. Also why his Cmp% Index was lower than average in all but 3 seasons of his career.

  • I’d like to thank Bryan for pitching in this week. It’s been a lot of fun following this series, and these data sources should be a great resource for folks.

    • Thanks for letting me help out. I love the FP community.