≡ Menu

Red Zone Performance Since 2002

As noted yesterday, red zone performance is mildly correlated with team success. One team that was a big outlier last year was the Steelers. Pittsburgh’s offense made it into the red zone 63 times, but converted those trips into touchdowns just 32 times (50.8%), slightly below-average. On defense, the Steelers allowed touchdowns on 24 of 39 red zone trips, a 61.5% rate that was the 5th-worst in the league. Of course, the Steelers were actually one of the best teams in the league.

On one hand, this seems kind of silly: of course red zone performance alone won’t tell us much about a team’s record! It says nothing about a team’s turnover rate, how effective the team is at producing or preventing big plays, overall team efficiency, or special teams. Perhaps the most remarkable part is that it does tell us quite a bit.

The table below has a lot of information, so to analyze it, let’s look at the best red zone team of the modern era, the 2005 Seattle Seahawks. That year, the Seahawks offense had 60 red zone trips and scored a touchdown on 43 of them, a conversion rate of 71.7%.  Given that 53% of red zone trips yield a touchdown, this means Seattle’s offense scored 11.1 more red zone touchdowns than expected. On defense, Seattle faced 47 red zone trips, and allowed just 19 touchdowns, a 40.4% conversion rate that was 6.0 touchdowns better than average. Therefore, overall, the team’s red zone performance yielded 17.1 touchdowns better than average, the most of any team since 2002.  Based on the best-fit formula derived yesterday, a team’s expected winning percentage based on its red zone team value is 0.0154*(Team Value) +0.500.  Since Seattle’s red zone value was +17.1, we would have expected the Seahawks to win 76.3% of their games; they actually won 81.3% of their games, a difference of 0.049.

YearTeamRZ Att ORZ Sc OPercValueRZ Att DRZ Sc DPercValueTm ValExp Win%Act Win%Diff
2005SEA604371.7%11.1471940.4%6.017.10.7630.8130.049
2003KAN544277.8%13.3472451.1%1.014.30.7200.8130.093
2015NYJ533566.0%6.8401435.0%7.314.10.7170.625-0.092
2008IND503468.0%7.4471940.4%6.013.40.7060.7500.044
2003GNB523465.4%6.4461839.1%6.412.80.6970.625-0.072
2009ARI543870.4%9.3472246.8%3.012.30.6890.625-0.064
2012NWE704970.0%11.8462452.2%0.412.20.6890.7500.061
2004SDG634469.8%10.5542750.0%1.712.20.6880.7500.062
2002MIA563664.3%6.2441840.9%5.411.60.6790.563-0.117
2013DET563562.5%5.2421638.1%6.311.60.6780.438-0.241
2009NOR714157.7%3.3562239.3%7.811.00.6700.8130.143
2006NWE603660.0%4.1351234.3%6.610.70.6650.7500.085
2013CIN463473.9%9.6361850.0%1.110.70.6650.6880.023
2002CLE432353.5%0.2551934.5%10.210.40.6600.563-0.097
2013DEN675176.1%15.4603761.7%-5.110.30.6580.8130.154
2014KAN482858.3%2.5542138.9%7.710.20.6570.563-0.094
2015CAR634368.3%9.5402152.5%0.39.80.6510.9380.287
2002WAS442659.1%2.6512039.2%7.19.70.6500.438-0.212
2016TEN503672.0%9.4552952.7%0.29.70.6490.563-0.086
2010TEN432558.1%2.2632641.3%7.59.60.6480.375-0.273
2009MIN694362.3%6.3401845.0%3.39.60.6480.7500.102
2004NWE633758.7%3.5492040.8%6.09.60.6470.8750.228
2007NWE725069.4%11.7412458.5%-2.29.50.6471.0000.353
2007NOR503672.0%9.4472553.2%0.09.40.6450.438-0.207
2015CIN583865.5%7.2381847.4%2.29.40.6440.7500.106
2017JAX503264.0%5.4281139.3%3.99.30.6430.625-0.018
2017NWE704260.0%4.8482143.8%4.59.30.6430.8130.169
2008PIT492755.1%1.0421433.3%8.39.30.6430.7500.107
2009IND533566.0%6.8512549.0%2.18.90.6380.8750.237
2002KAN644265.6%8.0603151.7%0.98.90.6370.500-0.137
2004IND674262.7%6.4462247.8%2.48.80.6360.7500.114
2010IND563867.9%8.2482552.1%0.58.70.6350.625-0.010
2005SDG503570.0%8.4552952.7%0.28.70.6330.563-0.071
2007ARI503468.0%7.4532750.9%1.28.60.6320.500-0.132
2016IND533566.0%6.8502550.0%1.68.40.6290.500-0.129
2011DET583763.8%6.2532649.1%2.28.30.6280.625-0.003
2009SFO392359.0%2.3471940.4%6.08.30.6270.500-0.127
2016CAR492959.2%3.0552443.6%5.28.20.6260.375-0.251
2003SEA503162.0%4.4502346.0%3.68.00.6230.6250.002
2003TAM402255.0%0.7401435.0%7.38.00.6230.438-0.186
2017MIN573357.9%2.7401640.0%5.38.00.6230.8130.190
2008NOR623861.3%5.1602948.3%2.97.90.6220.500-0.122
2013SEA573256.1%1.7361336.1%6.17.80.6210.8130.192
2005WAS473063.8%5.0371745.9%2.77.70.6180.6250.007
2003HOU342161.8%2.9522344.2%4.67.60.6160.313-0.304
2005CAR533158.5%2.8391641.0%4.77.60.6160.6880.071
2004PHI473063.8%5.0462247.8%2.47.50.6150.8130.197
2009MIA543361.1%4.3512447.1%3.17.40.6140.438-0.177
2016DAL573866.7%7.7542953.7%-0.37.40.6140.8130.198
2009WAS462656.5%1.6411639.0%5.87.30.6130.250-0.363
2016PIT492959.2%3.0572645.6%4.37.30.6120.6880.076
2013CAR502958.0%2.4411741.5%4.87.20.6110.7500.139
2003PHI513262.7%4.9422047.6%2.37.20.6110.7500.139
2002CHI402357.5%1.7612744.3%5.47.20.6100.250-0.360
2011NWE724765.3%8.7613455.7%-1.67.20.6100.8130.202
2011NYJ553665.5%6.8442352.3%0.47.20.6100.500-0.110
2012BAL492857.1%2.0532343.4%5.27.10.6100.6250.015
2006SDG624267.7%9.1472757.4%-2.07.00.6080.8750.267
2003MIA432148.8%-1.8431432.6%8.87.00.6080.6250.017
2008TEN452862.2%4.1432046.5%2.86.90.6070.8130.206
2012NOR573968.4%8.7703955.7%-1.86.90.6060.438-0.169
2011ARI452351.1%-0.9582339.7%7.86.90.6060.500-0.106
2012ATL633758.7%3.5421945.2%3.36.80.6050.8130.207
2005PIT563460.7%4.2482347.9%2.56.70.6040.6880.084
2011GNB664365.2%7.9563155.4%-1.26.70.6030.9380.335
2016NOR684566.2%8.9563257.1%-2.26.60.6020.438-0.165
2016BUF543564.8%6.3573052.6%0.36.60.6020.438-0.164
2015PIT563460.7%4.2572849.1%2.36.50.6010.6250.024
2012MIA382155.3%0.8542342.6%5.76.50.6000.438-0.163
2016NWE603863.3%6.1442352.3%0.46.50.6000.8750.275
2008DAL442659.1%2.6562646.4%3.86.40.5980.563-0.036
2005IND613760.7%4.6391948.7%1.76.30.5970.8750.278
2015SDG442863.6%4.6462350.0%1.46.10.5930.250-0.343
2010ARI371643.2%-3.7692739.1%9.76.00.5920.313-0.280
2016NYG432353.5%0.2431739.5%5.86.00.5920.6880.095
2008CAR493265.3%6.0492653.1%0.06.00.5920.7500.158
2017PHI553665.5%6.8382155.3%-0.86.00.5920.8130.221
2010NWE674262.7%6.4502754.0%-0.46.00.5920.8750.283
2015NWE614065.6%7.6422457.1%-1.75.90.5910.7500.159
2014OAK292172.4%5.6573052.6%0.35.90.5910.188-0.403
2010MIA341852.9%-0.1451840.0%5.95.80.5900.438-0.153
2014NWE673958.2%3.4462247.8%2.45.80.5900.7500.160
2014CHI473063.8%5.0713752.1%0.75.80.5890.313-0.276
2014NYG613659.0%3.6512549.0%2.15.70.5880.375-0.213
2012SEA543157.4%2.3381744.7%3.25.50.5850.6880.103
2005CHI432046.5%-2.8401332.5%8.35.40.5830.6880.104
2015STL361952.8%-0.1482041.7%5.55.40.5830.438-0.145
2007MIN352160.0%2.4472246.8%3.05.40.5830.500-0.083
2006JAX523057.7%2.4321443.8%3.05.40.5830.500-0.083
2006DEN442454.5%0.6542444.4%4.75.30.5820.563-0.019
2013MIA462656.5%1.6562646.4%3.85.30.5820.500-0.082
2010GNB533260.4%3.8311548.4%1.55.30.5820.6250.043
2011BAL492551.0%-1.0421638.1%6.35.30.5810.7500.169
2007KAN351748.6%-1.6431637.2%6.85.30.5810.250-0.331
2016ARI543564.8%6.3452555.6%-1.15.20.5800.469-0.112
2014BAL633352.4%-0.5542342.6%5.75.20.5800.6250.045
2015SEA492755.1%1.0381642.1%4.25.20.5790.6250.046
2006IND624166.1%8.1513058.8%-2.95.20.5790.7500.171
2007PHI512345.1%-4.1552036.4%9.25.10.5790.500-0.079
2008MIA452760.0%3.1472348.9%2.05.10.5780.6880.110
2017CIN432455.8%1.2562646.4%3.84.90.5760.438-0.138
2011TEN372259.5%2.3482347.9%2.54.80.5750.563-0.012
2003DEN563155.4%1.2351542.9%3.64.80.5750.6250.050
2006DAL583560.3%4.2482552.1%0.54.70.5720.563-0.010
2005NWE583763.8%6.2482756.3%-1.54.70.5720.6250.053
2004BAL402050.0%-1.3451840.0%5.94.70.5720.563-0.009
2012NYG623454.8%1.1502346.0%3.64.60.5710.563-0.009
2011CHI382052.6%-0.2562544.6%4.84.60.5700.500-0.070
2009BAL573052.6%-0.3431841.9%4.84.60.5700.563-0.008
2017CHI332060.6%2.5492449.0%2.04.50.5690.313-0.257
2012DET553360.0%3.8392051.3%0.74.50.5690.250-0.319
2017OAK342058.8%1.9482347.9%2.54.40.5680.375-0.193
2017BAL523057.7%2.4452248.9%1.94.30.5660.563-0.003
2014CIN492857.1%2.0552749.1%2.24.20.5640.6560.092
2003CLE421945.2%-3.3481837.5%7.54.20.5640.313-0.252
2006MIN421945.2%-3.3461737.0%7.44.10.5640.375-0.189
2015OAK412561.0%3.2583051.7%0.84.00.5620.438-0.125
2004NYJ432558.1%2.2412048.8%1.83.90.5610.6250.064
2003TEN603253.3%0.1411843.9%3.83.90.5600.7500.190
2010JAX462963.0%4.6573154.4%-0.73.80.5590.500-0.059
2014DEN623962.9%6.1523057.7%-2.43.70.5570.7500.193
2007OAK352160.0%2.4552850.9%1.23.60.5560.250-0.306
2008BAL512447.1%-3.1391435.9%6.73.60.5560.6880.132
2008BUF522548.1%-2.6552341.8%6.23.60.5550.438-0.118
2007HOU462860.9%3.6623353.2%-0.13.50.5540.500-0.054
2015ARI633860.3%4.5472655.3%-1.03.50.5540.8130.259
2010ATL583560.3%4.2422354.8%-0.73.50.5540.8130.259
2017SEA452555.6%1.1422047.6%2.33.40.5520.5630.010
2006PHI462656.5%1.6432148.8%1.83.40.5520.6250.073
2013KAN573357.9%2.7371951.4%0.73.40.5520.6880.136
2004KAN594067.8%8.6543463.0%-5.33.30.5510.438-0.114
2002NYJ543259.3%3.3492653.1%0.03.30.5510.5630.011
2017NOR553258.2%2.8482552.1%0.53.30.5510.6880.137
2017LAC472246.8%-3.0361336.1%6.13.20.5490.5630.014
2005JAX492959.2%3.0361952.8%0.13.10.5480.7500.202
2002JAX512854.9%0.9532649.1%2.23.10.5470.375-0.172
2015WAS493061.2%4.0492755.1%-1.03.00.5460.5630.016
2012GNB473268.1%7.0472961.7%-4.03.00.5460.6880.141
2012HOU573256.1%1.7402050.0%1.33.00.5460.7500.204
2014HOU482654.2%0.5462247.8%2.42.90.5450.5630.017
2004CAR523159.6%3.4502754.0%-0.42.90.5450.438-0.108
2002STL512854.9%0.9492449.0%2.02.90.5450.438-0.108
2004NOR472757.4%2.0603151.7%0.92.90.5450.500-0.045
2003NOR402255.0%0.7532649.1%2.22.90.5450.500-0.045
2005DEN583560.3%4.2392256.4%-1.32.90.5450.8130.268
2006KAN482960.4%3.5442454.5%-0.62.90.5440.5630.018
2007SFO291551.7%-0.4532547.2%3.22.80.5420.313-0.230
2007SEA492857.1%2.0412151.2%0.82.70.5420.6250.083
2017CAR522853.8%0.4442147.7%2.42.70.5420.6880.145
2013NYJ422150.0%-1.3492244.9%4.02.70.5420.500-0.042
2006HOU422457.1%1.7492551.0%1.02.70.5420.375-0.167
2010PIT502448.0%-2.6401640.0%5.32.70.5410.7500.209
2011ATL593152.5%-0.4472246.8%3.02.60.5400.6250.085
2008SDG653756.9%2.5532852.8%0.22.60.5400.500-0.040
2011MIN533056.6%1.8562951.8%0.82.60.5400.188-0.352
2011CLE311341.9%-3.5492040.8%6.02.60.5390.250-0.289
2010DET452964.4%5.1462758.7%-2.62.50.5390.375-0.164
2007CLE553054.5%0.8562850.0%1.82.50.5390.6250.086
2017TEN402152.5%-0.3562748.2%2.82.50.5390.5630.024
2002TAM512345.1%-4.1351234.3%6.62.50.5380.7500.212
2010NOR613150.8%-1.4452044.4%3.92.50.5380.6880.149
2015MIN442250.0%-1.4431944.2%3.82.50.5380.6880.149
2004ARI371848.6%-1.7512345.1%4.12.40.5380.375-0.163
2005ATL543157.4%2.3492653.1%0.02.30.5360.500-0.036
2015DET493469.4%8.0593762.7%-5.62.30.5360.438-0.098
2010NYG543157.4%2.3472553.2%0.02.30.5350.6250.090
2007GNB502754.0%0.4432148.8%1.82.30.5350.8130.277
2003CIN472859.6%3.0553054.5%-0.82.30.5350.500-0.035
2005KAN542851.9%-0.7452146.7%2.92.20.5340.6250.091
2010BAL512549.0%-2.1401742.5%4.32.20.5330.7500.217
2012CAR462758.7%2.6502754.0%-0.42.10.5330.438-0.095
2004JAX451942.2%-4.9471838.3%7.02.10.5320.5630.031
2008SFO522751.9%-0.6522548.1%2.62.00.5310.438-0.093
2004TAM402152.5%-0.3401947.5%2.32.00.5310.313-0.218
2002BAL381950.0%-1.2532547.2%3.22.00.5300.438-0.093
2016JAX402460.0%2.7553054.5%-0.82.00.5300.188-0.343
2007PIT553258.2%2.8382155.3%-0.82.00.5300.6250.095
2014DAL513364.7%5.9493061.2%-4.01.90.5300.7500.220
2003NYJ391948.7%-1.7522446.2%3.61.90.5290.375-0.154
2016PHI552749.1%-2.2512345.1%4.11.90.5290.438-0.091
2008ATL563155.4%1.2522751.9%0.61.90.5290.6880.159
2003NWE502244.0%-4.6461839.1%6.41.90.5290.8750.346
2011NOR754458.7%4.1392359.0%-2.31.90.5290.8130.284
2017WAS462554.3%0.6572950.9%1.31.80.5280.438-0.091
2017ATL542750.0%-1.7482245.8%3.51.80.5280.6250.097
2007IND693956.5%2.3462554.3%-0.61.80.5270.8130.285
2012TAM472859.6%3.0543055.6%-1.31.70.5260.438-0.089
2012DEN663959.1%3.9412458.5%-2.21.70.5260.8130.286
2008KAN452657.8%2.1673653.7%-0.41.70.5260.125-0.401
2014CLE492449.0%-2.0542546.3%3.71.70.5260.438-0.088
2012IND482654.2%0.5532750.9%1.21.70.5260.6880.162
2007DAL563053.6%0.2442250.0%1.41.60.5250.8130.287
2008GNB482960.4%3.5512956.9%-1.91.60.5250.375-0.150
2009CLE391743.6%-3.7572543.9%5.31.60.5240.313-0.212
2013SFO553156.4%1.8412253.7%-0.21.60.5240.7500.226
2005CIN623556.5%2.1482654.2%-0.51.60.5240.6880.163
2004CHI381642.1%-4.2542342.6%5.71.50.5230.313-0.211
2014GNB643757.8%3.0482756.3%-1.51.50.5230.7500.227
2012CIN573154.4%0.7412151.2%0.81.50.5230.6250.102
2009NYJ492449.0%-2.0331442.4%3.51.50.5230.5630.039
2012WAS533260.4%3.8523057.7%-2.41.50.5230.6250.102
2011MIA532547.2%-3.2522344.2%4.61.50.5230.375-0.148
2014ATL442761.4%3.6583356.9%-2.21.40.5220.375-0.147
2010WAS432251.2%-0.8572849.1%2.31.40.5220.375-0.147
2005OAK452146.7%-2.9592745.8%4.41.40.5220.250-0.272
2004CIN552850.9%-1.2522548.1%2.61.40.5220.500-0.022
2017DAL523159.6%3.4492857.1%-2.01.40.5220.5630.041
2016CIN542953.7%0.3492551.0%1.01.30.5210.406-0.114
2014STL442250.0%-1.4391846.2%2.71.30.5210.375-0.146
2008NYJ623353.2%0.1572950.9%1.31.30.5210.5630.042
2012PIT492755.1%1.0422252.4%0.31.30.5200.500-0.020
2006WAS422150.0%-1.3482347.9%2.51.20.5180.313-0.206
2005TAM392051.3%-0.7452248.9%1.91.20.5180.6880.169
2006PIT562850.0%-1.8452146.7%2.91.20.5180.500-0.018
2014SDG482654.2%0.5522751.9%0.61.10.5170.5630.045
2013TAM371951.4%-0.7562850.0%1.81.10.5170.250-0.267
2009TAM311651.6%-0.5502550.0%1.61.10.5170.188-0.329
2007JAX583356.9%2.2452555.6%-1.11.10.5170.6880.171
2007SDG522955.8%1.4372054.1%-0.31.00.5160.6880.172
2005DAL532852.8%-0.2381950.0%1.21.00.5160.5630.047
2006CIN523057.7%2.4522955.8%-1.41.00.5150.500-0.015
2004HOU442659.1%2.6442556.8%-1.61.00.5150.438-0.078
2002SDG493061.2%4.0492959.2%-3.01.00.5150.500-0.015
2004SEA533158.5%2.8512956.9%-1.90.90.5140.5630.048
2010SFO422047.6%-2.3552647.3%3.20.90.5140.375-0.139
2006BAL522242.3%-5.6331133.3%6.50.90.5140.8130.299
2002PHI572747.4%-3.3381642.1%4.20.90.5140.7500.236
2002HOU241041.7%-2.8522446.2%3.60.90.5140.250-0.264
2013DAL513568.6%7.9624064.5%-7.10.80.5130.500-0.013
2016GNB664060.6%4.9452862.2%-4.10.80.5130.6250.112
2015HOU452657.8%2.1392256.4%-1.30.80.5130.5630.050
2009SDG633454.0%0.5552952.7%0.20.70.5120.8130.301
2013BUF442147.7%-2.4512447.1%3.10.70.5110.375-0.136
2007BAL451942.2%-4.9522242.3%5.60.70.5110.313-0.199
2016SFO443068.2%6.6664162.1%-5.90.70.5110.125-0.386
2009CIN502550.0%-1.6401947.5%2.30.70.5110.6250.114
2010CIN552749.1%-2.2452146.7%2.90.70.5110.250-0.261
2011NYG563257.1%2.2613455.7%-1.60.70.5100.5630.052
2008CHI502856.0%1.4553054.5%-0.80.70.5100.5630.052
2006NOR532954.7%0.8412253.7%-0.20.60.5100.6250.115
2008MIN441943.2%-4.4472042.6%5.00.60.5090.6250.116
2009PIT562748.2%-2.8421945.2%3.30.60.5090.5630.054
2002IND502652.0%-0.6512651.0%1.10.50.5080.6250.117
2006STL543157.4%2.3553156.4%-1.80.50.5080.500-0.008
2012STL371951.4%-0.7532750.9%1.20.50.5080.469-0.039
2013CHI603558.3%3.1593457.6%-2.60.50.5070.500-0.007
2003CHI452248.9%-1.9572849.1%2.30.40.5060.438-0.068
2009ATL562951.8%-0.8512651.0%1.10.30.5050.5630.057
2009CAR402050.0%-1.3502550.0%1.60.30.5050.500-0.005
2004WAS442352.3%-0.4371951.4%0.70.30.5040.375-0.129
2002DAL261038.5%-3.8492244.9%4.00.20.5030.313-0.191
2013NOR573256.1%1.7462656.5%-1.60.20.5020.6880.185
2002MIN643656.3%2.0533056.6%-1.80.20.5020.375-0.127
2009OAK291241.4%-3.4653147.7%3.50.10.5020.313-0.189
2014DET472553.2%0.0492653.1%0.00.10.5010.6880.187
2005DET361850.0%-1.1532750.9%1.20.00.5010.313-0.188
2013NWE653655.4%1.5502856.0%-1.40.00.5000.7500.250
2004BUF612845.9%-4.4462043.5%4.40.00.5000.5630.062
2007CIN562748.2%-2.8562748.2%2.80.00.5000.438-0.063
2002SEA572950.9%-1.3552850.9%1.2-0.10.4990.438-0.062
2008NYG693550.7%-1.7351748.6%1.6-0.10.4990.7500.251
2017BUF442352.3%-0.4573052.6%0.3-0.10.4990.5630.064
2015TEN402665.0%4.7533362.3%-4.8-0.10.4990.188-0.311
2013STL492551.0%-1.0603151.7%0.9-0.20.4980.438-0.060
2007WAS552749.1%-2.2492449.0%2.0-0.20.4970.5630.065
2014MIN392153.8%0.3482654.2%-0.5-0.20.4970.438-0.059
2013PHI573052.6%-0.3492653.1%0.0-0.30.4960.6250.129
2007BUF341338.2%-5.1562544.6%4.8-0.30.4950.438-0.058
2006CHI502448.0%-2.6401947.5%2.3-0.30.4950.8130.317
2006MIA462043.5%-4.4361541.7%4.1-0.30.4950.375-0.120
2014ARI381642.1%-4.2411843.9%3.8-0.40.4940.6880.194
2015KAN543157.4%2.3402460.0%-2.7-0.40.4930.6880.194
2014NOR653960.0%4.5513262.7%-4.9-0.40.4930.438-0.056
2016OAK563257.1%2.2573357.9%-2.7-0.50.4930.7500.257
2010OAK482552.1%-0.5492653.1%0.0-0.50.4930.5000.007
2011CAR573357.9%2.7563358.9%-3.2-0.50.4920.375-0.117
2004STL422354.8%0.7563155.4%-1.2-0.60.4910.5000.009
2002OAK603456.7%2.1573357.9%-2.7-0.60.4910.6880.197
2006CLE391948.7%-1.7512651.0%1.1-0.60.4900.250-0.240
2014PIT552952.7%-0.2502754.0%-0.4-0.70.4900.6880.198
2012CHI462350.0%-1.4412151.2%0.8-0.70.4900.6250.135
2016CHI492551.0%-1.0593152.5%0.4-0.70.4890.188-0.302
2011SEA462247.8%-2.4391948.7%1.7-0.70.4890.438-0.051
2013IND502856.0%1.4412458.5%-2.2-0.80.4880.6880.200
2011WAS512141.2%-6.1572543.9%5.3-0.80.4870.313-0.175
2010CLE421945.2%-3.3482347.9%2.5-0.80.4870.313-0.175
2007CAR402050.0%-1.3462452.2%0.4-0.80.4870.438-0.050
2002TEN563358.9%3.2452862.2%-4.1-0.80.4870.6880.201
2016MIA472655.3%1.0512956.9%-1.9-0.90.4870.6250.138
2010TAM442352.3%-0.4482654.2%-0.5-0.90.4870.6250.138
2006ARI542546.3%-3.7582848.3%2.8-0.90.4870.313-0.174
2017NYJ331854.5%0.5522955.8%-1.4-0.90.4860.313-0.174
2014MIA683551.5%-1.1552952.7%0.2-0.90.4860.5000.014
2005MIN512345.1%-4.1532547.2%3.2-0.90.4860.5630.077
2010SEA502142.0%-5.6653046.2%4.5-1.00.4840.438-0.047
2013ARI502652.0%-0.6482654.2%-0.5-1.10.4840.6250.141
2002GNB573052.6%-0.3553054.5%-0.8-1.10.4840.7500.266
2009DEN522548.1%-2.6482450.0%1.5-1.10.4830.5000.017
2005PHI412253.7%0.2522955.8%-1.4-1.20.4820.375-0.107
2008SEA422150.0%-1.3512752.9%0.1-1.20.4810.250-0.231
2004TEN452555.6%1.1543157.4%-2.3-1.20.4810.313-0.169
2017LAR693855.1%1.3462758.7%-2.6-1.20.4810.6880.206
2014JAX321340.6%-4.0562748.2%2.8-1.20.4810.188-0.293
2009NWE653452.3%-0.5402255.0%-0.7-1.30.4800.6250.145
2004MIN583356.9%2.2633758.7%-3.5-1.30.4790.5000.021
2012ARI401640.0%-5.3452044.4%3.9-1.30.4790.313-0.167
2013OAK422559.5%2.7623759.7%-4.1-1.40.4790.250-0.229
2009DET361747.2%-2.1713752.1%0.7-1.40.4780.125-0.353
2016BAL462452.2%-0.4472655.3%-1.0-1.50.4770.5000.023
2011DEN361747.2%-2.1522751.9%0.6-1.50.4770.5000.023
2011HOU602846.7%-3.9442147.7%2.4-1.50.4770.6250.148
2009DAL502652.0%-0.6321856.3%-1.0-1.60.4760.6880.212
2015GNB522853.8%0.4492857.1%-2.0-1.60.4750.6250.150
2011PIT532750.9%-1.2311754.8%-0.5-1.70.4740.7500.276
2008JAX452555.6%1.1533158.5%-2.8-1.70.4730.313-0.161
2010CHI512345.1%-4.1422047.6%2.3-1.80.4730.6880.215
2012DAL492551.0%-1.0553054.5%-0.8-1.80.4720.5000.028
2013BAL522446.2%-3.6412048.8%1.8-1.80.4720.5000.028
2002DEN583458.6%3.2473063.8%-5.0-1.80.4720.5630.091
2017GNB422661.9%3.7463065.2%-5.6-1.90.4710.438-0.034
2016SDG623251.6%-0.9663654.5%-0.9-1.90.4710.313-0.159
2007NYG553054.5%0.8422559.5%-2.7-1.90.4710.6250.154
2013PIT532852.8%-0.2553156.4%-1.8-1.90.4700.5000.030
2006SEA422252.4%-0.3442556.8%-1.6-1.90.4700.5630.092
2009TEN392256.4%1.3563358.9%-3.2-2.00.4700.5000.030
2015BAL472348.9%-2.0472553.2%0.0-2.00.4690.313-0.157
2014WAS482347.9%-2.5482552.1%0.5-2.00.4690.250-0.219
2003BUF452146.7%-2.9452351.1%0.9-2.00.4690.375-0.094
2002CAR391948.7%-1.7392153.8%-0.3-2.00.4690.438-0.032
2016KAN552545.5%-4.2532649.1%2.2-2.10.4680.7500.282
2002NOR583153.4%0.2523057.7%-2.4-2.20.4660.5630.096
2005NYJ431944.2%-3.8522650.0%1.6-2.20.4660.250-0.216
2004GNB523057.7%2.4442863.6%-4.6-2.30.4650.6250.160
2008ARI653858.5%3.5553563.6%-5.8-2.30.4640.5630.098
2009JAX472451.1%-1.0522955.8%-1.4-2.30.4640.438-0.026
2008PHI633149.2%-2.5361952.8%0.1-2.30.4640.5940.130
2004DEN532445.3%-4.2412048.8%1.8-2.40.4630.6250.162
2003DAL462043.5%-4.4341647.1%2.1-2.40.4630.6250.162
2005GNB462247.8%-2.4472553.2%0.0-2.50.4620.250-0.212
2003PIT442045.5%-3.4452351.1%0.9-2.50.4620.375-0.087
2002ARI402255.0%0.7563358.9%-3.2-2.50.4620.313-0.149
2010SDG593355.9%1.6432762.8%-4.2-2.50.4610.5630.101
2009GNB623454.8%1.1462860.9%-3.6-2.50.4610.6880.226
2017NYG391948.7%-1.7532954.7%-0.8-2.60.4610.188-0.273
2003STL683450.0%-2.1482654.2%-0.5-2.60.4600.7500.290
2011SFO542240.7%-6.7341441.2%4.1-2.60.4600.8130.353
2006OAK351028.6%-8.6622743.5%5.9-2.70.4590.125-0.334
2016DEN472246.8%-3.0422252.4%0.3-2.70.4590.5630.103
2011SDG542953.7%0.3492959.2%-3.0-2.70.4590.5000.041
2013NYG361747.2%-2.1462554.3%-0.6-2.70.4590.438-0.021
2011JAX351748.6%-1.6432455.8%-1.2-2.70.4580.313-0.145
2011STL311238.7%-4.5522650.0%1.6-2.80.4560.125-0.331
2005SFO281139.3%-3.9643351.6%1.0-2.90.4560.250-0.206
2015DAL452044.4%-3.9492551.0%1.0-2.90.4560.250-0.206
2004MIA381847.4%-2.2422354.8%-0.7-2.90.4560.250-0.206
2003MIN553156.4%1.8593661.0%-4.6-2.90.4560.5630.107
2004PIT612845.9%-4.4331648.5%1.5-2.90.4560.9380.482
2010KAN523159.6%3.4372670.3%-6.3-3.00.4540.6250.171
2017TAM532649.1%-2.2532954.7%-0.8-3.00.4540.313-0.141
2010DEN522955.8%1.4523261.5%-4.4-3.00.4540.250-0.204
2005BAL421638.1%-6.3421945.2%3.3-3.00.4540.375-0.079
2012JAX361644.4%-3.1663553.0%0.1-3.10.4530.125-0.328
2006NYJ482245.8%-3.5462452.2%0.4-3.10.4530.6250.172
2003CAR431841.9%-4.8412048.8%1.8-3.10.4530.6880.235
2011DAL512549.0%-2.1492755.1%-1.0-3.10.4530.5000.047
2016TAM542851.9%-0.7502958.0%-2.4-3.10.4520.5630.111
2006CAR321546.9%-2.0432455.8%-1.2-3.20.4510.5000.049
2008WAS482347.9%-2.5422354.8%-0.7-3.20.4510.5000.049
2017DET462656.5%1.6553461.8%-4.8-3.20.4500.5630.112
2014SEA603151.7%-0.9372259.5%-2.3-3.20.4500.7500.300
2015MIA432353.5%0.2503060.0%-3.4-3.30.4490.375-0.074
2008DEN553054.5%0.8603660.0%-4.1-3.30.4490.5000.051
2003ATL462452.2%-0.4663857.6%-2.9-3.40.4480.313-0.136
2006ATL472042.6%-5.0502550.0%1.6-3.40.4480.438-0.010
2013TEN492857.1%2.0503264.0%-5.4-3.50.4470.438-0.009
2012MIN522853.8%0.4513160.8%-3.9-3.50.4460.6250.179
2003JAX452044.4%-3.9442352.3%0.4-3.50.4460.313-0.133
2006BUF351542.9%-3.6452453.3%-0.1-3.70.4430.438-0.006
2014BUF512243.1%-5.1442250.0%1.4-3.70.4430.5630.120
2010DAL472859.6%3.0533566.0%-6.8-3.80.4410.375-0.066
2010HOU533362.3%4.8594067.8%-8.6-3.80.4410.375-0.066
2011OAK472451.1%-1.0513058.8%-2.9-3.90.4400.5000.060
2004DET431944.2%-3.8452453.3%-0.1-3.90.4390.375-0.064
2011TAM381950.0%-1.2704057.1%-2.8-4.00.4380.250-0.188
2015ATL532954.7%0.8533362.3%-4.8-4.00.4380.5000.062
2009KAN381847.4%-2.2533056.6%-1.8-4.00.4380.250-0.188
2005NOR421638.1%-6.3572849.1%2.3-4.00.4380.188-0.250
2003BAL502142.0%-5.6331648.5%1.5-4.00.4380.6250.187
2014TAM392153.8%0.3523261.5%-4.4-4.10.4370.125-0.312
2012SFO552850.9%-1.2362261.1%-2.9-4.10.4370.7190.282
2011PHI663451.5%-1.1472859.6%-3.0-4.10.4370.5000.063
2016MIN502346.0%-3.6442454.5%-0.6-4.20.4360.5000.064
2012NYJ472348.9%-2.0412458.5%-2.2-4.20.4360.375-0.061
2015BUF381950.0%-1.2452760.0%-3.1-4.30.4340.5000.066
2013ATL522751.9%-0.6573459.6%-3.7-4.30.4330.250-0.183
2015JAX542953.7%0.3573561.4%-4.7-4.40.4320.313-0.120
2007DEN512549.0%-2.1543157.4%-2.3-4.40.4320.4380.005
2010CAR331030.3%-7.5663248.5%3.1-4.50.4310.125-0.306
2008CLE381436.8%-6.2542750.0%1.7-4.50.4310.250-0.181
2002CIN421945.2%-3.3583255.2%-1.2-4.50.4310.125-0.306
2014PHI592949.2%-2.4432558.1%-2.2-4.50.4310.6250.194
2009PHI522548.1%-2.6512956.9%-1.9-4.50.4300.6880.257
2006SFO482041.7%-5.5623251.6%0.9-4.60.4300.4380.008
2017HOU422252.4%-0.3543361.1%-4.3-4.60.4290.250-0.179
2015DEN442147.7%-2.4372259.5%-2.3-4.70.4270.7500.323
2007CHI441840.9%-5.4522751.9%0.6-4.70.4270.4380.011
2017PIT633250.8%-1.5392461.5%-3.3-4.80.4270.8130.386
2009HOU633352.4%-0.5372464.9%-4.3-4.80.4260.5630.137
2015IND492653.1%0.0533362.3%-4.8-4.90.4250.5000.075
2010BUF371951.4%-0.7543361.1%-4.3-5.00.4240.250-0.174
2016HOU441840.9%-5.4442352.3%0.4-5.00.4230.5630.140
2015NYG542444.4%-4.7522853.8%-0.4-5.10.4220.375-0.047
2004ATL512752.9%-0.1493163.3%-5.0-5.10.4220.6880.265
2017MIA382052.6%-0.2513262.7%-4.9-5.10.4220.375-0.047
2003WAS452453.3%0.1583662.1%-5.2-5.10.4220.313-0.109
2017IND401640.0%-5.3512752.9%0.1-5.20.4210.250-0.171
2006TAM371643.2%-3.7482756.3%-1.5-5.20.4210.250-0.171
2005CLE391128.2%-9.7502244.0%4.6-5.20.4210.375-0.046
2014TEN391948.7%-1.7633758.7%-3.5-5.20.4190.125-0.294
2016ATL633961.9%5.5554072.7%-10.8-5.30.4190.6880.268
2015NOR583560.3%4.2654467.7%-9.5-5.30.4190.4380.019
2016SEA562646.4%-3.8462656.5%-1.6-5.30.4180.6560.238
2014IND603355.0%1.1503366.0%-6.4-5.30.4180.6880.269
2012PHI502244.0%-4.6553054.5%-0.8-5.30.4180.250-0.168
2002NWE492653.1%0.0543463.0%-5.3-5.30.4180.5630.145
2013SDG593050.8%-1.4452862.2%-4.1-5.40.4160.5630.146
2008CIN331545.5%-2.5492959.2%-3.0-5.50.4150.281-0.134
2005NYG592745.8%-4.4432455.8%-1.2-5.50.4150.6880.272
2005MIA522140.4%-6.6512651.0%1.1-5.50.4150.5630.148
2012CLE391743.6%-3.7533056.6%-1.8-5.60.4140.313-0.102
2013CLE361952.8%-0.1503264.0%-5.4-5.60.4140.250-0.164
2012OAK421842.9%-4.3543055.6%-1.3-5.60.4130.250-0.163
2004CLE411946.3%-2.8533158.5%-2.8-5.60.4130.250-0.163
2002PIT612845.9%-4.4412356.1%-1.2-5.60.4130.6560.243
2015CHI502448.0%-2.6452760.0%-3.1-5.70.4130.375-0.038
2006NYG512752.9%-0.1463065.2%-5.6-5.70.4130.5000.087
2003OAK341544.1%-3.1553258.2%-2.8-5.80.4100.250-0.160
2007ATL431739.5%-5.8472553.2%0.0-5.90.4100.250-0.160
2004SFO412048.8%-1.8603660.0%-4.1-5.90.4090.125-0.284
2010MIN462043.5%-4.4462656.5%-1.6-6.00.4080.375-0.033
2013MIN482552.1%-0.5633961.9%-5.5-6.00.4070.344-0.063
2006DET451840.0%-5.9603253.3%-0.1-6.00.4070.188-0.220
2002SFO562748.2%-2.8523159.6%-3.4-6.10.4060.6250.219
2005STL512447.1%-3.1623658.1%-3.1-6.20.4050.375-0.030
2003IND623251.6%-0.9412765.9%-5.2-6.20.4050.7500.345
2006TEN381744.7%-3.2623658.1%-3.1-6.20.4040.5000.096
2013GNB653350.8%-1.5573561.4%-4.7-6.30.4040.5310.128
2011CIN512345.1%-4.1412458.5%-2.2-6.30.4030.5630.160
2015TAM512752.9%-0.1563664.3%-6.2-6.30.4020.375-0.027
2015PHI432455.8%1.2614065.6%-7.6-6.40.4010.4380.037
2007STL391743.6%-3.7573357.9%-2.7-6.40.4010.188-0.213
2008DET311961.3%2.5644367.2%-9.0-6.50.4000.000-0.400
2017KAN502142.0%-5.6512854.9%-0.9-6.50.4000.6250.225
2003SFO622946.8%-3.9442659.1%-2.6-6.60.3990.4380.039
2013WAS502652.0%-0.6603863.3%-6.1-6.70.3970.188-0.210
2005TEN462247.8%-2.4563460.7%-4.2-6.70.3970.250-0.147
2017SFO512447.1%-3.1573459.6%-3.7-6.80.3950.375-0.020
2011BUF532852.8%-0.2593864.4%-6.6-6.80.3950.375-0.020
2007TAM462043.5%-4.4352160.0%-2.4-6.80.3950.5630.168
2003NYG471838.3%-7.0492653.1%0.0-6.90.3930.250-0.143
2008OAK371540.5%-4.7543157.4%-2.3-7.00.3930.313-0.080
2002NYG592237.3%-9.4442147.7%2.4-7.00.3930.6250.232
2015SFO391743.6%-3.7543259.3%-3.3-7.00.3920.313-0.079
2007MIA392051.3%-0.7523465.4%-6.4-7.10.3910.063-0.328
2012TEN361850.0%-1.1583763.8%-6.2-7.30.3870.375-0.012
2016DET482654.2%0.5533667.9%-7.8-7.30.3870.5630.176
2016CLE442454.5%0.6604066.7%-8.1-7.50.3850.063-0.322
2002ATL602846.7%-3.9442761.4%-3.6-7.50.3840.5940.209
2014CAR472246.8%-3.0462963.0%-4.6-7.50.3840.4690.085
2008NWE653350.8%-1.5453066.7%-6.1-7.60.3830.6880.305
2016WAS612845.9%-4.4543259.3%-3.3-7.70.3810.5310.150
2013HOU402050.0%-1.3483266.7%-6.5-7.70.3810.125-0.256
2005HOU371643.2%-3.7603660.0%-4.1-7.80.3800.125-0.255
2010STL562035.7%-9.8452248.9%1.9-7.80.3790.4380.058
2014SFO441943.2%-4.4442761.4%-3.6-8.00.3770.5000.123
2011KAN361233.3%-7.1512854.9%-0.9-8.00.3760.4380.061
2017ARI482041.7%-5.5462758.7%-2.6-8.10.3760.5000.124
2013JAX411843.9%-3.8653960.0%-4.5-8.20.3730.250-0.123
2002BUF583153.4%0.2503570.0%-8.4-8.30.3730.5000.127
2017CLE391948.7%-1.7463167.4%-6.6-8.30.3720.000-0.372
2009SEA481939.6%-6.5553156.4%-1.8-8.30.3720.313-0.060
2004DAL402152.5%-0.3453271.1%-8.1-8.30.3720.3750.003
2007DET502550.0%-1.6644164.1%-7.0-8.60.3680.4380.069
2009BUF381231.6%-8.2502754.0%-0.4-8.60.3670.3750.008
2008TAM562239.3%-7.8362055.6%-0.9-8.60.3670.5630.195
2017DEN481939.6%-6.5412458.5%-2.2-8.70.3660.313-0.053
2011IND381642.1%-4.2573561.4%-4.7-8.90.3630.125-0.238
2006GNB491632.7%-10.0452351.1%0.9-9.10.3590.5000.141
2003DET381847.4%-2.2433069.8%-7.2-9.30.3560.313-0.044
2008HOU612845.9%-4.4473063.8%-5.0-9.40.3550.5000.145
2012KAN371027.0%-9.7643453.1%0.0-9.70.3510.125-0.226
2012SDG472246.8%-3.0402870.0%-6.7-9.70.3500.4380.087
2010NYJ502040.0%-6.6432660.5%-3.2-9.70.3500.6880.337
2007NYJ491836.7%-8.0402357.5%-1.7-9.80.3490.250-0.099
2002DET431841.9%-4.8643960.9%-5.0-9.80.3480.188-0.161
2003ARI431841.9%-4.8603761.7%-5.1-10.00.3470.250-0.097
2010PHI583153.4%0.2433376.7%-10.2-10.00.3460.6250.279
2015CLE471838.3%-7.0623658.1%-3.1-10.00.3460.188-0.158
2012BUF482450.0%-1.5553869.1%-8.8-10.30.3420.3750.033
2009CHI512447.1%-3.1563766.1%-7.2-10.30.3410.4380.097
2003SDG462247.8%-2.4503570.0%-8.4-10.90.3330.250-0.083
2014NYJ471736.2%-8.0492959.2%-3.0-10.90.3320.250-0.082
2008STL291034.5%-5.4533464.2%-5.8-11.20.3270.125-0.202
2016LAR341647.1%-2.1523771.2%-9.4-11.40.3240.250-0.074
2016NYJ541935.2%-9.7512956.9%-1.9-11.60.3210.313-0.009
2009STL341132.4%-7.1593661.0%-4.6-11.70.3200.063-0.257
2009NYG562748.2%-2.8624267.7%-9.1-11.80.3180.5000.182
2007TEN552036.4%-9.2402460.0%-2.7-12.00.3160.6250.309
2005ARI461328.3%-11.4442454.5%-0.6-12.10.3140.313-0.002
2004NYG542648.1%-2.7503672.0%-9.4-12.10.3130.3750.062
2004OAK412048.8%-1.8564173.2%-11.2-13.00.2990.3130.013
2005BUF491734.7%-9.0523363.5%-5.4-14.40.2780.3130.034

The biggest overachiever in terms of winning percentage relative to red zone success was the 2004 Steelers. Pittsburgh went 15-1 but was below-average in the red zone! That’s pretty tough to do, with the Steelers offense producing 4.4 fewer touchdowns than expected.  Pittsburgh led the NFL in points allowed and yards allowed, so this was a defensive-driven team, but this was also extremely talented offense.

Alan Faneca and Jeff Hartings both were first-team All-Pros, while a third offensive linemen (LT Marvel Smith) joined them in the Pro Bowl.   A rookie Ben Roethlisberger was the quarterback, and Hines Ward and Plaxico Burress were in the primes of their careers (Ward made the Pro Bowl, while Burress led the NFL in one advanced statistic).  At running back, Jerome Bettis and Duce Staley shared duties effectively enough to help the Steelers finish second in rushing yards, and first among all teams in rushing yards by running backs.  And the Steelers employed blocking fullback Dan Kreider and blocking TE Jerame Tuman to great success.

But still, Pittsburgh was one of the worst red zone offenses in the NFL.  A year later, though, the Steelers would be one of the best.

{ 1 comment }