≡ Menu

Who Is The Most Jeff Fisher Coach of All-Time?

It’s easy to make fun of Jeff Fisher, who has a reputation for being the very definition of mediocre. A search for “Jeff Fisher 7-9” on Twitter will send you down the rabbit hole. But do the numbers back it up? Is Fisher as average as it gets?

He has won 6 or 7 games in his last five seasons, and went 8-8 in the season before that. In 10 of his 20 full seasons as a head coach, he’s won 7 or 8 games. But Fisher did go 13-3 three times, and won double digit games three other times. So how do we measure how “Jeff Fisher” a coach is?

The key, I think, is being average. Mike Mularkey has a 4-21 record over the last 10 years. He went 2-14 with the Blaine Gabbert/Maurice Jones-Drew/Justin Blackmon Jaguars in 2012, and then 2-7 as the interim head coach for the Titans last year. We don’t want to count that as being “Jeff Fisher-like.”

So I came up with a formula to measure how far from .500 each coach was in each season, and gave more weight to extreme seasons. You can check this footnote for the fine print.1

As it turns out, Fisher was the 2nd most Jeff Fisher coach of the 50 men who have coached the most games. The least Jeff Fisher coach was Paul Brown, followed by George Seifert and Bill Belichick.

But the most Jeff Fisher coach? Any guesses? Here are some hints.

  • Like Fisher, this coach has exactly 20 career full seasons as an NFL head coach.
  • Fisher had three seasons with 13+ wins; this coach finished between 4-12 and 12-4 in 19 of 20 seasons.
  • This coach went 6-10 an NFL record five times. In fact, Mike Ditka (three 6-10 seasons) is the only other head coach with more than two 6-10 seasons.

Give up? Why it’s Tom Coughlin, of course.  The graph below shows the 50 head coaches who have coached the most pro football games in history.  On the X-Axis is number of games; the Y-Axis displays the results of the methodology described above (which is so abstract a thing that I don’t even want to name it).  The key, though, is the best-fit line.  And no coach is farther from the line than Coughlin, with Fisher just behind him:

coughlin fisherSince Fisher and Coughlin have both coached for 20 full seasons (ignoring the six-game interim stint at the start of Fisher’s career), we can compare them without any tricky formula. Let’s just compare how many wins each coach was from 8 in each season. I will present this two ways: both squaring the difference (to give more credit to extreme seasons) and without.

CoachYearTmWinsDiff From 8 WinsDiff Squared
Coughlin1999jax14636
Fisher2008oti13525
Fisher2000oti13525
Fisher1999oti13525
Fisher2005oti4-416
Coughlin1995jax4-416
Coughlin2008nyg12416
Fisher2003oti12416
Fisher2004oti5-39
Coughlin2005nyg1139
Fisher2002oti1139
Coughlin1998jax1139
Coughlin1997jax1139
Coughlin2015nyg6-24
Coughlin2014nyg6-24
Fisher2014ram6-24
Fisher2010oti6-24
Coughlin2004nyg6-24
Coughlin2002jax6-24
Coughlin2001jax6-24
Coughlin2010nyg1024
Coughlin2007nyg1024
Fisher2007oti1024
Coughlin2013nyg7-11
Coughlin2000jax7-11
Fisher2015ram7-11
Fisher2013ram7-11
Fisher2001oti7-11
Fisher1995oti7-11
Coughlin2012nyg911
Coughlin2011nyg911
Coughlin1996jax911
Fisher2012ram7.5-0.50.25
Coughlin2009nyg800
Coughlin2006nyg800
Fisher2009oti800
Fisher2006oti800
Fisher1998oti800
Fisher1997oti800
Fisher1996oti800
FisherTotal39.5141.25
CoughlinTotal42128

As you can see, Fisher ends up with a higher number, which means his seasons were more extreme. However, that changes if we don’t square the differences. Fisher does have more seasons right at .500, but he also has those three 13-3 seasons. Ultimately, it’s those that make him look slightly less Jeff Fisher-like than Coughlin. I think two 6-10 seasons is more Jeff Fisher-like than an 8-8 season and a 4-12 season, which is why I chose to square the differences. But your mileage my vary.

Tom Coughlin, of course, is not going to be remembered in the same way that Fisher was. But he did finish between 6-10 and 10-6 in 70% of his seasons. Coughlin’s legacy will go down as being one of the best post-season coaches ever. When I ran the numbers three years ago, Coughlin had exceeded playoff expectations by a greater amount than all but one other coach in NFL history. Fortunately for Coughlin, he hasn’t made the playoffs since, so those numbers have not changed.

  1. 1) Calculate each head coach’s winning percentage in each season. For example, in 2015, Fisher’s team went 7-9, for a 0.4375 winning percentage.

    2) Subtract that winning percentage from 0.500, and square the difference, to give more weight to extreme seasons. That produces a result of 0.004. Obviously an 8-8 season would produce a 0; a 10-6 season would yield 0.016.

    3) Then, weight each season by the number of games played (to account for coaches who had partial seasons).

    4) Then, get a career grade by summing the (games-weighted) result from each year.

    5) Then, I took the 50 head coaches with the most career games, and created a best-fit formula to project the career differential based on games played.

    6) Finally, subtract the expected result from the actual result to see how “Jeff Fisher” each coach is. []

  • Josh Sanford

    It seems clear to me that some coaches have a skill set that does not show up in W-L… that is the ability to keep a job without winning much. In other words, they are likable. Or believe-in-able. I have thought that most owners were too quick to fire a coach. You might hate your coach, but you also have to go hire someone who you think will do better.

  • Pingback: It’s All Orange, Fat Man: 06/17/16 | Thin Air()

  • I thought of Chuck Knox immediately. He just seems to have had an entire career between 7-9 and 9-7. I honestly had forgotten about his first stint with the Rams, during which his worst season was 10-4. That pretty much eliminates him. He did at one point go five straight years of either 7-9 or 9-7 in Seattle, though he also somehow managed not to go 8-8 at all.

    Coughlin makes sense after hearing his name, though. Without looking at the specifics, I would have said that he probably only had one standout team each direction (’95 for bad, ’99 for good) while the entire rest of his career was in the 6-11 wins range. It FELT more volatile because of the way it seemed that for five or six years we had a four-week period of hearing that he was about to be fired followed by six weeks of calls for him to go into the Hall of Fame before he even retires.

    • sacramento gold miners

      Chuck Knox was an excellent Head Coach in the NFL. Similar to Marty Schottenheimer and Jim Mora in the sense he usually favored a ground-oriented attack. Knox turned around Los Angeles, Buffalo, and Seattle, but could never quite reach the Super Bowl. The term “Ground Chuck”, was used to describe his offensive philosophy.

    • Richie

      Yep, Knox was my guess as well.

  • Anders

    This is the reason why I think Coughlin is not a HoF coach (and Eli for that matter is not a HoF QB), way too many average seasons.

  • Ryan

    Chase, can u please post a table of most jeff fisher like, my initial guess was dan reeves, looks like he was close!

  • AgronomyBrad

    It would be interesting to see this stat run for teams, too. For instance, It seemed like the Seahawks of the Early 2000s were perpetually stuck at.500

  • Richie

    I love that the 2 most Fischer-like coaches have careers that have completely overlapped (until 2016).

    That’s pretty weird of itself. 2 coaches who began in the same season, each changing teams one time, and both coaching for exactly 20 years.