A few of those guys had two big seasons. The dropoff may be dramatic after that, but the second-best season is too good for them to turn up on this list. Larry Johnson’s 2006 is also on that list of the 50 greatest VBD seasons above. Vick had another season in ’06 that was better than ’10 in fantasy terms (though they were close enough that Neil’s scoring system might affect that). Terry Allen had some receiving value in ’92 that at least somewhat offsets the difference in rushing TDs. Joe Morris had a big 1985 as well as ’86.

DeAngelo Williams is definitely going to be a strong contender for near the top of the list, though, and I would not have thought about him!

Perhaps Michael Vick 2010?

Other than that, I'm thinking Brad Johnson 1999, John Riggins 1983, Randall Cunningham 1998 (don't know if that counts in terms of total career, but counts given his years surrounding it), Larry Johnson 2005, Joe Morris 1986, DeAngelo Williams 2008, Terry Allen 1996, Torry Holt 2003, Fred Taylor 1998.