Here’s the issue I have regarding Don Hutson – Was he really that much better, or did he benefit from the circumstances he played under more than most? Remeber, back then teams didn’t really play “pass defense”, nor did they shift coverages, nor did they double or triple cover players. He also played on a team that threw the ball far more than the average team (his 1942 season GB threw around 100 more passes than the league average). I have no doubt he was the best WR of his era, but I think it might be a bit of a stretch to put him up so high on the all time list. I’ve seen highlights, but nothing on film shows him as being much more than faster than the defender

Interesting but unsurprising. The Giants have been known for lackluster WRs for basically their entire existence