Posted the initial model for the HOF Monitor, if you’re still interested.

http://nflsgreatest.co.nf/2014/05/hall-of-fame-monitor-defense/

I read the BBR link a bunch of times trying to find proper analogs in the NFL. Like PFR counts AP1, but AP2 should count for something, right? But then how many AP2s equal an AP1, and how many AP1s equal an MVP. So much room for subjectivity.

I went with some black and grey ink tests, like 5 points for leading the league in certain things and 2 points for being in the top 3.

1.5 points for a Pro Bowl
3 for AP2
5 for AP1
7.5 for OPOY
10 for MVP
20 for all decade team
1 for each playoff win
7.5 for a SB loss
20 for a SB win (Aikman had to get in the HOF somehow)
15 for a “legendary” season, like Marino 84, Warner 99, Young 94…whatever. This is super subjective. for instance, do you count Brady’s 2010 or just his 2007?

I also have compiling benchmarks, but they are a little different. Half a point for each:
25 completions over average
500 yards over average
10 TDs over average
10 INTs below average
1000 ANY over average
Where numbers are calculated similar to the way Chase does RANY.
There is also something to be said for holding records, but then you get into which records are important and which aren’t. Plus, Bill James is probably smarter than I am.